Okay. Welcome to the let me mute. Welcome to the San FranciscoPlanning Commission hybrid hearing for thursday, july 14, 22. In person can remote hearings require everyones attention and our patience if you are joining remote and are not speak mute your microphone. To enable Public Participation sfgovtv is broadcasting and strolling live and will receive Public Comment. Comments during Public Comment are available by calling 4156550001 and entering access code 2486 862 0895 well take Public Comment from those in city hall first and open remote line. Speak clearly and slowly if you are care to state your name for the record. Each person will be allowed up to 3 minutes you will hear a chime indicating your time is almost up. I will announce your time is up and take the next person to speak. For call nothing to submit testimony when we reach the item you are entered in speak press star 3 to be added to the queue. When you hear your line is unmuted that is your indication to speak. Best practice call from a quiet location. Speak clearly and slowly and mute the volume on television or computer. In city hall, lineup on the screen side of the room. Please silence mobile belle device. I like to take roll. President tanner. Hee. Commissioner Vice President moore. Here. Commissioner diamond. Here. Commissioner fung. Here. Commissioner imperial here koppel. Hee yoochlt and commissioner ruiz. First is consideration of items proposed telephonance item 1 at 1 street a discretionary review is proposed for continuance to august 25 of 22. Item 22019022830 clement street home sf authorization condition to september first of 22. Further commissioners under the regular calendar we are in receipt of request for item 10 case 202200390 for neighborhood mixed use planning Code Amendment to be continued to august 25 of 22. And foiblely i am pleased inform you that under review item 15766 duncan a review has been with drawn. I should we are open up Public Comment for any of the items that are proposed for continuance. Again if you are call nothing remote you need to press star 3 and from those persons in chamber need to come forward. No questions to speak from any member. Public comment is closed and continuance is before you, commissioners. Commissioner imperial. Move to continue second. Thank you, commissioners on this motion to continue items proposed commissioner ruiz. Why aye diamond. Aye commissioner fung. Aye. Commissionering imperial. Aye. Commissioner koppel. Aye. Commissioner moore. Aye and president tanner. Aye. That passes 70. And place this under your consent calendar. All matters constitute a consent are considered to be routine by planning and may be acted upon by a vote of the commission. No separate discussion unless a member of the commission or public or staff requests. Item 3, 2110 chestnut a cu. Item 4. 3908, 24th street k rushgs authorization and item 54400, 17th street a conditional use authorization. Open up Public Comment to allow anyone request that any of these 3 conch cent items pulled off of consent. Again if you are in the chambers come forward if you are call nothing press star 3. No requests to speak, Public Comment on your consent is closed. And it is now before you. Commissioner imperial. Move to approve. Second. Thank you, commissioners on this motion to approve items under consent commissioner ruiz. Why aye diamond. Aye commissionering fung. Aye. Commissioner imperial aye commissioner koppel. Aye commissioner moore. Aye. And president tanner. Aye. That passes unanimously. Under commission matters consideration of Adoption Draft minutes for your june 23 and june 30 of 22 hearings. We should open up Public Comment. Members in the chambers in forward. And for those call nothing you need to press star 3 to be acided to the queue. For the minutes. Hayes valley regarding the minutes for june 30, im prizeed see a Public Commentroused a single word. May be that happens all the time it was a surprise after i considered the publics made. A single word over material concerns that people expressed park at grounds level which is a violation of the market octavia plan. Winds the first building the west wind will hit that building and cause impacts on period of time and bicyclists. The loss of the plaza and art space over 50 . Of the public space lost. The agreements about the below market rate location amount and that those were changed. People also expressed concern about the failure to address deliveries and tnc pick xup drop offense. So, i dont see those in the reflected in the minutes. They are occurrence. Thank you. Last call for Public Comment on the minutes. No requests to speak, Public Comment months is closed. And they are before you, commissioners. I will responded to the last Public Commenter that our requirement is to provide an indication what was said. We dont transcribe Public Comment verbatim. In fact, attending shun shine Ordinance Task force another cest minutes was brought up and they were told not to do it verbatim, which is odd. In any case we dont stranz skrab the testimony verbatim. Is there a motion to adopt the minutes . Commissioner koppel. Motion to adopt for june 23 and second on that motion to adopt the minutes commissioner ruiz. Aye. Diamond. Aye commissioner fung. Aye. Commissioner imperial. Aye y. Commissionering koppel. Aye commissioner moore yoochl aye. And president tanner. That motion passes unanimously 7zero. We will place us under item 7 commission commentses and questions. Thank you commissioners i will start us off with our land acknowledgment. The Planning Commission we are on home land of the Ramaytush Ohlone the original inhab tants. As stewards of the land and with traditions the recommend ram never lost nor forgotten responsibilities as the care takeers and for all peoples reside in their traditional translator. As guests we recognize we beg your pardon from living and working on their home lands. Wish to pay respects acknowledging the eldand relatives of the recommend Ram Community and by affirming their rights as first peoples. I want to start off today by thanking members of the Planning Department who, yesterday, on tuesday helped host project genesis for young folks learning about the develop the process from everything from construction, financing, architecture the government side. I want to give a rounds of applause and thank you to all the staff who shared their career what they do now. The students enjoy today and i know sometime its can be hard with quiet teens to know what is happen nothing their brains. The end they warmed up and i think we have folks who will apply for internships. I want to thank the department and thank jacqueline kiez and julianne who helped to get everything together and are also stewarding other interns and programless the department is good to see that providing many of the young people with exposure to when we do in planning and potential careers they could have. Ir will open up to other commissioners who may have comments. Not seeing anything. Back to you. No audio. Intern and plan are 1s we hired 7. If you dont mind standing up so the commission can see who you are. Again. These are high school interrence, College Interns and some offure your planner rons. Thank you for taking on the work this you are doing and you can sit. I will explain [laughter] you dont have to stand the whole time. 15 College Interns and 13 High School Interns we sent around talking about where they are from. We got a great representation both on college inturns. Woe got one from San Francisco state and uc berkeley and ucla. As well as back east and nyu and cornel i dropped out of. Our high school program. Balboa, lincoln high school. Local. And so it is a great representation. We had over 18 huh human letters of interest for our college program. A huge in demands. You know our inturns are paired with plan exerts wing on projects. Just to call out a couple, ad u out reach. Multifamily housing, small multifamily strategies. Working on Housing Element. Forplex. Public art history irk context. To name a now. They are engage in the specific projects. Our high school is continuing partnership with opportunity for all. The second year we are doing that and want to thank former commissioner chan who helped get this going. Final presentations will be in august. You will be invited and will be welcomed your participation in that. I wanted thank you for your support. Thank you all for being here today and thank you tina tammy for all her work in put thanksgiving together. As well as [inaudible] who have been working as well. Thank you. Welcome we are excited have you here had i had my first job in government i this h to go to every Council Meeting for a year. Hopeful low you learn a lot watch figure you have questions reach out. Let your planner know happy to give you anything you might need and glad to have you here helping our department and learning more about planning. Commissioners review of past eventses at the bhoord of supervisors and appeals the Historic Preservation did not meet yesterday. Good afternoon aaron star manager of legislative affairs. First on the land use agenda was the landmark designation resolution for st. James church. This is only an initiation of land mark the item needs to go before the board for a vote. The st. James church is significant as a work by master architect julie morgan and this would be the first landmark in the neighborhood it was recommended to the full board. Next the mirs autouse housing density ordinance this week staff presented sought to over view the ordinance and the amendments made. Also to address the questions raised at the last hearing how this bill interacts with the code and loo a Feasibility Analysis was done on inclusionary rates staffs responsibles the city in the process of reconvening the tax so a full review of all of our city rates can be reevaluated based on market conditions. From the data we have. The conditions are not favorable to Housing Construction reported this commission, we are not on pace to meet our 10 i dont remember average on housing applications or start this is year. Staff noted that this ordinance brings the cites eligible on far with other rezoned areas where density gives a chance of development. This was not sufficient for the committee they wanted an analysis of increasing inclusionary before psz thanksgiving on to the full board. Preston supports the ordinance in concement. There were 13 Public Comments regarding the ordinance with 10 in support and 3 in opposition in support node for additional housing the impacts of current structure and removing red tape for service station conversions. In opposition the personals of affordability and loss of blue collar jocks peskin removed the reference from cars to casas he saw it was a problem and recommended the name change. Supervisor melgar did not take issue with the name and fine with re. The committee voted replace with autouse housing density not on the literation but is in english. Supervisor preston moved duplicate the file and remove the housing density and keeping the deletion of the cu requirement. Both file it is were conditioned the call of the chair. Mile per hours charging location ordinance this was at the last time this was here supervisors voted add amendments that would remove fleet charging as an accessory use and amended require cu for fleet charge nothing all zoning districts. Conditioned the item the amendments needed to be draft third degree week the item had to be continued because of amendments not siendz. It was continued for a week. The full board this week 3 ordinances passed the seconded read including the supervisor peskin Group Housing special use district the mirs affordable code enforce am ordinance and supervisor mandelmans foreplex ordinance. And thats all i have for you today. Thank you. Have a question from commissioner imperial. I do have a question in terms of the not to mr. Star but to dpreshthd [inaudible] about the Group Housing education. Group housing legislation is this something that will come to the Planning Commission for us to be informed as in terms of details i dont think im aware of that. That one we heard. Right. You heard 2 Group Housing ordinances proposed by supervisor peskin one changed the definition of Group Housing so they had more common open space and no private and was exclude it from china town and from the upon tenderloin. Okay. Thank you. We can sends out a summary from the board. Ir cant recall if there were amendments after you heard it. Yea. We do a new code sum row we can sends that when it is is out. Thank you this week was the sud part . Definition for Group Housing passed it might be effective. Or close to yea. Thank you. The board of appeals did not meet last night. I see commissioner moore. Sorry a slight delay i had a question for mr. Star. Does the adjustment of district boundaries affect this in any form or shape . Which legislation are you speak of. Group housing sud. Mow the Group Housing sud is based on its bounds easier in the ordinance. Does not corespond to district bound easier. I think in response to director [inaudible] will be helpful to see a summary with the boundaries that mr. Star is describing would be helpful. Thank you. Okay. Commissioners the board of appeals did not meet last night. But did meet on july 6 and one item of enter the proposed project was to add 3 ad u1555 oak street and heard by you as a discretionary rerowel in march of 21. While the commission was sympathetic to tenants concerns and the parking needs, the Commission Voted unanimously to not take approve the permit as proposed the dr paled to the board of appeals and while they also sympathized with the 10 analysiss and the appellates issues, they focused on the projects or the properties violation history with dbi and voted unanimously to deny the appeal and approve the project as proposed. Commissioners. We can move on to general Public Comments at this time. Members of the public may address on items of interest that are within the jurisdiction of the Commission Sept agenda items agenda items your tune will be foordzed when the item is reached in the meeting. Each measure may address the commission terror up to 3 minutes when speakers exceed the 15 limit it may be moved to the end of the agenda good afternoon. Georgia i sudden an e mail last night about hai will talk about today and going back to june 30 before your break i hope you had a good time i sent you i gave a hand out now available at the submitted the hearing supports documents for june 30. So hay want to talk about is that project when i locked at it on the [inaudible] there was nothing. No information. Nothing. So far i did a Public Records request and that was helpful but all i found were the 3nopdrs issue in summer of 2015 and the first one said. Give me demo [inaudible] nothing and this is july 2015. 7 years after section 317 had been instituted after you had code impeptation documents and staff hand outs [inaudible] not like something no one knew b. Bite second nopdr in august the planner is asking for the correct [inaudible] i want to read. Your demolition information indicates that no portion of the front elevation will be removed part of project upon even though tltdz under go a transformation. Ure look at the hand out i gaveow june 30 you will see, yea major transformation. So. No demo [inaudible] in the request. I went to the fourth floor of your new building dbi records department. No audio. Ir would lieshg to suggest the Planning Commission ask and expect from the Planning Department that you would be fully informed about the history of any site. And the permits or agreements made and appeals made and you should have all of that at your finger tips when you talk about issuing a new permit but a series of permit bunkham no construction. Also, there has been talk about permits being held indefinitely. There should be a term limit on how long a permit can be held without construction starting. Concern about people getting permits and slipping the property with the permit with the entitlement. So they00 autothings you should know about if agreements about Affordable Housing. If there was an appeal and resolution. The terms should carry forward. Eir considerations in the past. Which might change depending upon location of the building of the properties developed. Public space. Things that are we in the public want to have the institutional memory bring forward. Thank you. This is sue hester im coming planning not to approve but too continue the item on the calendar that project you were told after the hearing was closed. Had an eir and no reference to the eir for the public or the commission to review that as part of the record. And so rather an e mail to the Commission First of july. Does not correct the issue at 6 30 when you had your hearing. Second issue on that project was that it was a project that had gone through an approval in 2017. And when it wents to the board of supervisors on appeal on the Environmental Review, there was an negotiation wi