We do expect commissioner johnson to arrive shortly and commissioner bobby wilson that to be continuance items one ab fulsome conditional use authorization and the Zoning Administrator will opine on the variance for indefinite continuance and further under the regular calendar item 8 potrero zoning map staff asked for a continuance to the i didnt get all under the discretionary review authorization circuses we received confirm that item 17 a the discretionary review has been withdrawn as a result, the defer will take up the matter during the first recess. No others items proposed for continuance. Okay. Thank you any Public Comment on this item . Proposed for continuance. Good afternoon Commission Jim counsel to the Property Owner on potrero and ask the item be heard as quickly as possible if not today this is the correction of an error in the zoning height map on a second Story Building that covers the lot it existed for the last 50 years and thely down zoned to open space despite the plan documents show the property in a 40 feet involvement on error that were asking that be corrected you know again, the building occupies the full property and been there 50 years i know your calendar is booked up and make sure it is heard as quickly as possible and filled the application last oversight were concerned about moving forward thank you. Okay. Thank you very much additional Public Comment on the continuance items. Specifically i asked about the potrero street item he didnt know what is recalendar im concerned that increasing the heights right at the freeway exit and having a demonstration will jeopardy the farm that is there since is 80s and probably before the san jose im not knowing the history that well but the reason the farm exists and the school exists there is a bunch of rich people complaining and trying to get rid of it i think you need to think about for no reason to make at the seller rich i understand youre trying to correct some deal that didnt glow have not eastern neighborhoods i also wanted to correct a lot about the eastern neighborhoods that is why weaves appealed the beast on bryant it is is we cant do anythings and all the pdr is oh, well lost if were nothing changing the fooermz ever beast on bryant but for the potrero hill street thank you you can consider what i said thank you. So my name is my name is silvia johnson. This zoning issues could be corrected you know no Strings Attached a level on the ground to be organized and if we can create a system like this and zone issues this will not be problems that we have it has this issue and going on for too long for this organization not to be on resell and on this part zones makes more sense in our World History we need this discussion of our people in our movies districts and family because they have missed the point of arts and the administration and we dont see any kind of issues the death is on the native side this issue that comes to and our tv processes and theyre not seeing that point this is on their leveling of childrens and with the killings and the progress of making shoes where why a lot of those things that are and not working in economics in electronics we heard these things to be you know put to the progresses of recreating and with the phones and every you know equipment that do miracle damage to our processing and the question you put you start running in there thats a medical its not the reason why and i think the system. Thank you, maam, your time is up. Is there any additional Public Comment . For the items proposed for continuance not seeing any, Public Comment is closed. Commissioner wu just on that item on potrero we want further discussion with the rec and park as pointed out has the Community Garden next door i want to remind everyone this is a clerical error from the eastern neighborhoods plan but the request for changing it from open space to m u o o to raise the height limit staff is not recommending the change in the height limit thats to clarify that was our position but the that note correct. I want to correct that actually that is mixed income residential as part of eastern neighborhoods inadvertently zoned to o s as parts of eastern neighborhoods so yeah, it was not changed in the zoning. It is the september 8th the appropriate date and september 8th is fine. Okay. For that ill move to continue tempo one indefinitely and item 8 september 8. Second. Commissioner antonini i believe there was comment with that that item one you spoke about, sir so why is it indefinitely continued. Oh, 8 okay. Im confused i thought there was some comments about item number one. No, it was item 8. I get it no problem. Director rahaim. Oh, no, im sorry had was done. Commissioner moore. Weve received a couple of interesting emails from the gardeners at the farm if you want a copy they were quite interesting. There is a motion that has been seconded to continue items as proposed commissioner antonini commissioner johnson excuse me commissioner moore commissioner wu commissioner Vice President richards and commissioner president fong so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 5 to zero Zoning Administrator, what say you . Continue 1b indefinitely. Commissioners under our consent calendar on broadway this is a conditional use authorization commissioners and staff as well as a number of speaker cards has requested this pulled off of content and take this up in the beginning of the calendar. First item please. Commissioner moore. I was going to ask to move it off content. Item 3 consideration of draft minutes for july 4th 14. Any Public Comment on the draft minutes. Are those comments specifically to the minutes. First, the policy for that and thank you. Any is there any additional Public Comment on the draft minutes not seeing any, Public Comment is closed. And commissioner wu. Move to approve draft minutes. Second. Second. Thank you, commissioners on that motion to adopt the minutes commissioner antonini commissioner moore commissioner wu commissioner Vice President richards and commissioner president fong so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously and passes United Parcel service on commissioners questions or comments. Commissioner antonini in the chronicle on tuesday an unfortunate story about albert sam. On Market Street that has been in existence foyer one and one years and painstaking staking repaired and made to work has been infrequently vandalized with graffiti and needless destruction this is terrible i connected to land use about the activation of streets often we say the businesses are not activating the streets their you know employees are not coming out a bunch of reasons one of the biggest reasons on some of the streets people have not feel safe when there is violent activities concurring frequently the kinds of destruction of the clock and i think we have to move away from the culture of nonpunishment because i think we ask for problems and we ended up getting them because the word is out if one is caught they wont be held account for their actions and if theyre caught the punishment is modest the attitude none gets hurt not a Violent Crime therefore not to do much they have a different attitude in san diego a vandal between ages 12 and 16 had caused over one thousands of damage and they documented it they caught him and told his parents, you know, they had to make amends for that and cover the costs and they refused to do so the city and county put a lien on their house and that changed the attitude in san diego they dont have a lot of problems with graffiti because of the teeth in their laws we need to take that sort of attitude in San Francisco we want to have vibrant and safe and attractive streets we keep repairing those treasures that are historical and continuing are strird by vandals and the same thing with childrens mraurtsdz with spend valuable tax dollars and make them pay for what we do id like to see that has a way to help us to make our streets things that people can enjoy once again i think that concluded commissioners comments. Let me reset any machine. Commissioner Vice President richards. Hi were having because under the discussion please dislocation me a lot of projects that result in decisions dwelling units and the policy issues i keep on bringing up over and over we need to look at the lens the demolition of rental units and ava term we need to figure out and density we have 2 of those today coming up i went back to the housing unit and a lot of policies we need to Pay Attention when we approve those projects one discourage the policy 2. 1 retaining the safety and microscopes and without jeopardizing discourage the sound housing unless an increase no Affordable Housing were doortodoor hours and creating large unit and going abused policy 2. 6 discourage the housing for commercial use and shortterm rentals well have those issues not able to be rented easily, etc. To i think were on to that one obviously 3 protect the affordability of the residential units and preserve the rental units to meet the city Affordable Housing needs so when we get those decisions we need to understand whether or not were taking rentcontrolled units off the market and if it we are weve pruftd a project on lombard street and girard of the two units and got marketrate housing to help we are were in a better position consider what were getting in return and the affordability of the stock by the we need to see what moderate opportunities a 78 thousand square foot one thousand dollars dollars a square foot i digit doubt it a smaller unit well be doortodoor and someone can buy a starter home and the last one policy 3. 4 preserve the types of older ownership units im imagining we see the redefinition of section 317 were potentially having more under what we consider demo i understand that is the case i want to remind myself and the rest of the commission looking at those policies through all the projects through the lens of these policies and the element and take a look at it there are demos we approved san bruno a small cottage but the result no integrity and improved 4 units that make sense not a hard and fast rule but to make sure we dont take case by case but the second quick items in airbnb third annual report and result was basically they said that airbnb is not accruing the housing crisis it is exacerbating it, it is a good way to look at that once we sort this out with whether or not to have real enforcement on airbnb but fourth the impact and everyone is guessing late the the San FranciscoBusiness Times talk about details this the traffic what it does to the economy it is a balance between jobs housing transportation and other things if we keep on adding housing no way to get around the city or bay area it is causing nor problems we need to figure out and an mta with a Planning Commission it is was a good meeting we started to talk about those issues and another good reading in the San Francisco article as commissioners, if theres nothing further, well move on to directors announcements. Commissioners, i have no new reports. Review of the past events of the board of supervisors and the Historic Preservation commission did not meet yesterday. Hi arnold for the Planning Department there was no planning items that was at that land use but the full Board Hearing we the planning fees ordinance passed it findings second reading and the dwelling units sponsored by supervisor farrell, supervisor wiener and commissioner peskin passed its second reading and the second one passed it First Reading also at the board the appeal of Planning Commission certification of the final eir for 16th street it proposes three hundred and 19 units and 25 thousand square feet of retail and open space and a large lot with a lump berry yard in the lower potrero hill it contains a Brick Office Building and others buildings not to be roursdz the appellant raised the height and pdr loss and traffic and Historic Resources the biggest source of contention the support by the appellants terms the metal shed alternative that will rain the metal shed forces pdr and reduce the count to 4 hundred and 77 that was continued and rejected for a number of reasons for the reason it reduced the count by over 200 the appellant focused focused on the financial feasibility they were contesting the issues and not the Environmental ImpactEnvironmental Review not to appeal the large project authorization the project was code compliant and at the end the board of supervisors voted 9 to one with supervisor peskin opposing to uphold the certification of the eir and in a cautionary for supervisors supervisor cowen had to be recused because of comments they made regarding the volunteer Community Benefits that the sponsor was providing she asked he give more and the sponsor offend up 800,000 the City Attorney remembered the board the ceqa and only be considering issues pertinent to that after that supervisor cohen supervisor cowen to avoid any taunted and the board of supervisors asked about negotiating with the developer and repeated such conversation be shouldnt be part of ceqa a poodle board voted to recuse her and uphold the eir certification and there were no introductions this week. Thank you, thank you. And the board of appeals met a couple of items first, the board of supervisors did confirm the reappointment of commissioner rick swigs and commissioner honda for a 4year termed commissioner fung is the current Vice President and two items that were decided open to the commission both relate to ongoing efforts to retain pdr and make sure those uses are enforced first a letter of determination on bryant tan dopey found it the second story had been illegally been converted to office space and provided a that time his office to office the permitted was listing the proposed office as evidence of an ongoing leg office of property never a permitted from the previous industrial use to office space that authorized the change of use but the board felt count permitted history was sufficient to confirm legal office space one of the facts we felt this supported our decision that had been used during the 90s and theyre not allowed since 901990 but by sf weekly and under the planning code this is an allowed use office is not but the board felt this was legal offices in the building and overturned my depreciation we had another notice of violation that was corey teague issued it was for illegal conversion of the pdr previously a Contractors Office to General Office use in mci but within the area subject to the moratorium in place since september or october of 2014 and this use was established in 2015 picture i think we have a clear and strong case and the boards amazing upheld our determination this is one of the sites that has an Application Pending for a large project and some have been in the central soma and both were in central soma last night so wanted to make you aware of that thank you. Thank you commissioner Vice President richards. What was the votes on the one they did not uphold. It was 4 to one with commissioner adams commissioner lazarus voting in favor of our determination. Thank you. Commissioners item 7 case pennsylvania avenue an informational presentation and David Winning slow on december 3rd, 2017, the Planning Commission approved the proposed project on 22 and pennsylvania avenue per Planning Commission motion 19523 as part of approval the commission added a condition of approval to better address the typography of the surrounding neighborhood since the public hearing the Department Staff undertook a design process with the project architect steve perry new owners represented julian Planning Commission and representatives from the dog Patch Neighborhood Association dna representative in particular and the potrero boosters based on this Design Review the Property Owner project sponsor has revised the project as follows dwelling units the revised project increases from 20051 to im sorry 200 and 57 the revised mix includes one and 44 one bedrooms, one two bedrooms and 13 three bedrooms open space the revised project increases the amount of open space from 23 hundred plus to thirty thousand plus square feet of open space as pdr the revised project reduces the amount of pdr from 45 thousand to 22 thousand plus square feet offstreet parking it reduces from 200 and 13 to one and 65 and massing the revised project incorporated a 55 break and opens on the courtyard and the height of the project has been revised the revised project reduces the overall height and incorporates roof lines better distinguished portions relative to the tap graph and neighborhood pattern the materials of the project have been revised to incorporate a wider variety of materials that distinguish the building relative to the typography id like to im going to turn it over to t