Business . Do we have Public Comment on item number eight . Seeing none, Public Comment is closed. Next item please. Sfgov tv could you please show our slide . As is our custom, the office of Small Business is your one stop shop for permits, for find out how to do business in the city and county of San Francisco. It is free. So contact the office of Small Business. Item number nine adjournment he was we have a motion to adjourn . So moved. Second. All those in favor say, aye. [chorus of ayes. ] good afternoon let you call the tuesday, april 25, 2017, of the sfpuc to order madam secretary. Commissioner president commissioner courtney and commissioner caen and commissioner vietor are expected shortly we have quorum commissioners you have the minutes of the april 11th meeting any additions or correction. So moved. And any Public Comment on the minutes seeing none. All in favor, say i. I. All in favor, say i. Theiness are approved general Public Comment address the commission on matters that are within the commissions jurisdiction and are not on todays agenda. I have one speaker request from mr. Da costa. Commissioners welcome. In 199 of you all created the San FranciscoPublic Utilities commission by a mayor named willie brown so many of you are know a lot about how that was created and whats the purpose of this commission. Yesterday, i was paying attention to the deliberation at the Ethics Commission and this city and more room 200 as done great disservice to our city and it so happens that one of the 10 californias reaches out to the San FranciscoPublic UtilitiesCommission Im not going to name names i use my First Amendment rights to mention the names but it is shocking that in the year 2017 the sfpuc the commissioners, other sponsors who have to regulate look the other way so i attended a board of supervisors meeting i think about i missed the last one i missed your meeting the last one 3 weeks ago two advocates were pissed off with the board of supervisors because theyre at the board of supervisors including one item that is legislated to the sfpuc millions of dollars are extended because of no Due Diligence simply you need a checklist if you have the checklist before you and go by the checklist youll not make such mistakes it is being made injecting for people at home dont dr. Time to come here and do want to come here the people how will tree address they having to be educated on issues i i dont want to come here i see that on television but what im going to say is this go before the board of supervisors. Talking about the Ethics Commission and those deliberations but im going to try to use what in the federal system the rico act for the deliberations here thank you very much. Thank you is there any additional Public Comment . Seeing none, Public Comment is closed. Commissioners you have communication that has been provided to you and also to the public any questions or comments on that communication any Public Comment on the communication items okay. Seeing none well move on to other Commission Business commissioners . And then move on to the quarterly general manager completely. First item id like to call up an update on the cleanpowe f cleanpowersf. Welcome. Thank you good afternoon barbara hale i have two items to report on for cleanpowersf enforcement and some other mishmash of other sponsors activities on the enforcement were successfully serving our customers about 80 thousand accounts enrolled our opt out is 3. 3 percent overall we have received more updates to supergreen since we last spoke it increased from 2000 plus customers Human Resources supergreen 2. 1 percent of Customer Base is pretty good our tatter is 5 percent so 2. 9 and continuing in the may enrollment activities we had intent to enroll one thousand plus customers that is three hundred and 85 that signed up ahead of time want to be in supergreen 6 hundred and 97. To be in green and auto rolling the customers were serving our he noivengsz have gone out 2. 2 percent opting out out and special workshops that are targeted for the Net Energy Metered customers have more be complicated bills were tagging a drilled down and held the first of two workshops on april 20th at hayes valley clubhouse people state and my clients spent half an hour answering questions a number of people that signed up for sfpuc that was good the next is april 29th at the eureka Valencia Rec Center if you want to know about the snepz program in terms of other activities we had a number of all the out of Office Meeting met with San FranciscoState University wanted to go over he our views on none bypassable charges where we have alignment and we are hearing that pg e and the two other utilities will will be making a filing at the cpuc today to change the message for recovery those above market coverage to the cpuc and called the portfolio adjustment mechanism the pam so stay tuned well looking that carefully that will be a big item that well be engaged in we also participated at the hearing in sacramento on sp senator bradfords bill would have required our integrated Resource Plan our plans how to serve our load to be reviewed and approved at the cpuc so we had expressed concern and opposition to that bill and joined with cal and were successful in getting senator bradford to remove that in the bill have not seen it in print but progressing 2409s legislative process expect to see it in print soon and well breathe a say of relief and received new data from pg e that describes our customers you know our folks that are enrolled including the folks that are enrolled so we get that update annually and were factoring that update into the poolroom analysis for the gross plan and bringing that to you the full plan not just the presentation as a communication item for the next commission he meeting and also bring a couple of agenda items i want to briefly talk about those bringing the bawsca time extension to the next Commission Meeting the business practice policy and in particular the resetting of renewable goals to 50 percent by 2020 that was talked about mayor ed lee made a nice announcement on earth day i hope you saw the press it was annoyed to see us providing those benefits for San Francisco with that, ill close and ask if there is any questions. Commissioner. Another lafco joint meeting it seems like it modest makes sense for the supervisors if were seeing on mou. We dont have one calendar ill be happy to work with the Commission Secretary and with the lafco executive director to establish that if this is what the commission wants. Through the chair i feel perhaps im not sure we want to talk about what is on the agenda but seems like with cleanpowersf rolling out San Francisco government Audit Oversight Commission citywide the Late Development to get on the on the same page. Lets look at the agenda and do a joint meeting or structure that meeting in a way it is simile formation an easier way to look at that. Okay. Thank you. Thank you and for Public Comment on this item eric brooks. Good afternoon, commissioners eric brooks sf green party our city sf clean energy advocates. So first on specific things in the report yes sb 618 had a major problem but still another problem in sb 618 but staff is aware of we need to push on the author of that bill it is that still has language in it similar to language that was attempted to be put in the Big Clean Energy bill a few years ago that talks about Cost Shifting from to existing pg e customers based on building new renewables and having new renewables plans that is opening of the door for pg e to come up with more excuses so we need to participation it that bill and expecting that bill will be brought back towards the end of the session with amendments that make it bad again, we need to stay on top that i if hear staff mentioned if you devolve me pg e is also proposing something that was proposed several years ago when san joaquin tried to launch their bond the programs need to set aside in case of failure not 100,000 as now but tens of Million Dollars and over one hundred millions if they adopt that that policy is pushed by the moply and if they adopt that policy that will be a death for the choices in california and might effect us so if they keep on heading in that direction and on cleanpowersf in general want to reiterate what were saying at the last meeting weve made a lot of progress but the fact were not lined up to enroll all the customers by 2018 the fact that we are project by project 2020 to get to 50 percent basic green product everyone is doing that and the fact we have it project moving forward because our brothers and sisters in labor were assured well do a local buy out and putting people to origin with the build out that kind of job creation and getting us on track to stop antarctica and the iceland from metaling we need a job and build out plan by 2018. Along those lines thank you mr. Brooks and to commissioner vietors request when you start to talk about the issues weve made this progress when you got into them you can dive deep into the the build outs and the candidates made to the workforce i dont know we can have a line item with lafco and really drill down as far as we want to go ill i want to put that out there and say probably have to be a joined meeting with that board. Thank you and mr. Da costa. Way back in the year 2000 we first started having our meeting linked to the community 2002 we attended many meetings in sacramento in todays world i dont think that any progressive person forward thinking person who doesnt want clean solo that we want to embrace it what i find difficult is why you commissioners dont have a birds eye view of that never once do you all mention the rico act and how hydro electrical is come to be and how it is used today with the Clean Energy Even though the word clean is used this energy that sfpuc is providing is not really clean and i dont want to go into that today it is not dirty but not, clean what i want to talk about connected to the point about our infrastructure recently 90 thousand customers were impacted in a blackout how does that impact what sfpuc is providing and the details of it if you want to learn more about that ill sit down and discuss that with you, we had that problem at the presidio that substation failing and catching on fire whatever now in the marketing some of the speakers stated we havent reached a benchmark and the novices in that area and maybe we can tweak our system and finally dealing with a monster at pg e id like a tally of all the times pg e and you all have gone to bat meaning a lawsuit and thats choose one hundred how many pg e has won and how many you have won thank you very much im not going on to the board of supervisors. Additional Public Comment. Thank you jed if 350 sf i guess i want to start by pointing out something that happened this past week the Bay Area Water Supply Conservation Agency set out a carbon free 50 in the bayview and 085 control measures theyll take over to push in that direction that is something weve been Hidden Valley involved in for four or five years it is called spare the aircool assignment and again, the air district it finding the regulatory air agencies part of that will be regulation for them and spreading best practices around from jurisdictions all over the bay and again, setting high standards based on things happening in the bay area and using this district to spread that information and the standards as rapidly and expeditiously to get us to that goal i wish i had the grafted but theyll be short of 2020 extraordinarily short in 2030 and short in 2050 given everything weve read about in the paper and giving us a feeling of superiority over the disaster in the country we need to lgbt and look at the data and look at how far we to go the air district recognized we have that theyre looking everything both in the authority and also in power given that ill highlight for you that cleanpowersf and moving to 100 Percent Renewable Energy is the sooner we can do that the sooner to focus on decartoonish the sproi the sooner we can focus on fully electrifying transportation those things can happen until we replace the foul and if we have Community Choice programs in other jurisdictions that are already more renewable than we are we need to match that and theyll need to match us well be basically meeting the highest standards that are feasible in the bay area to be where we need to go to that end really, really encourage it staff and the commission to the a lot into rolling the rest of the decide into by the end of 2018 we heard in lafco that is feasible were taking a two year pause in from the 15 percent and looking at the rest of city and given where we need to get to move as quickly as possible thank you very much. And official Public Comment. Hi good afternoon. Im melissa a conservatism coordinator with the sierra club and echo two two speakers were talking about i want to urge urge the commission to support a faster gross timeline and recommended to local development of local resources we need a citywide build out plan for this and this will definitely accelerate our energy goal so asking to for you to support improperly San Francisco customers by 2018 and making the basic Green Service available also thank you. Thank you. Yeah. Welcome. Good afternoon. My name is elaine with 350 San Francisco. Org one of the things that we do is myself and volunteers from the community go out on sunday streets and street fairs and other things and sign people up for supergreen and i would urge you all to go beyond the 5 percent supergreen and 50 percent of Renewable Energy you can do better and people in the community theyre behind you i think i understand the reasons for being a little bit conservative and not moving faster i think San Francisco is the place so you know lets move on and let me say step back and think had is the lynch pin for everything we need to do 100 Percent Renewable Energy then have electrical vehicles and plug them in their 100 percent renewable when you change out your house from gas heat and gas water heat and you change that to protect thats 100 percent renewable and any industrial processes in the sfifksz become 100 percent renewable thats the vision we need to go fast ill encourage you to continue this but move up the pace and go for 100 percent renewable no reason not to if not enough on the market Start Building up you built San Francisco already thank you. Thank you. Yes, sir. My name is david im speaking as a resident of San Francisco for climatic change i im sorry oh, do you want me to repeat what i said anyways, the reason i want to speak because of my concern of climatic change i want to see cleanpowersf implemented as quickly as possible thank you. Thank you good afternoon commissioners brewing president of hate asbury not going to repeat by the way, to booster that in our the neighborhood weve promoted cleanpowersf to all the members to enroll earlier but still want to know when the full enrollment will happen that is possible weve seen it coming on with point communities and other districts i think that is feasible we can do it ill support with my colleagues that we do our best to enroll everybody by 2018 thank you. Great. Jason fried, executive director. Once again thank you to the staff they worked with cal cpuc to get the change that no longer makes it did bill that once was i know there are concerns but not as it was and the staff leadership was vital in that concurring and get proper credit for that and not planning on talking about it butt joint meeting ill be happy to bring that but make sure the mou is not waiting for a joint meeting steps in the process that needs that to be approved before the end of fiscal year so doing that at the next meeting will be important to move forward correctly please keep that moving forward and ill be happy to work with our staff to figure out a joint schedule but tuesday is the board of supervisors meeting but ill be happy to make that happen and finally as the other folks said moving forward this as quickly as possible it important and looking forward to working with all of you to make sure that happens and in terms of scheduling a joint meeting i think if you can work with between our staff substantive agenda. Ill be happy to and make sure that is worthwhile. Commissioner courtney it is a defied to have that done and also commissioner vietor is right new commissioners you only recognize one the commissioners from the last time we met it is good to get that joint back together and working towards the final push for cleanpowersf citywide and i dont mean to go to go to sfgovtv. Org back slash and enroll today. Thank you. Is there any additional Pu