We really need to investigate the balance versus potential failure and or lack of positive Program Outcomes what us in this presentation that is artie happened. That is very heartening. We look for to talking with staff about more details. I just wanted to point out to make it clear that, the pci a is going up. And up our rates i just want to make sure that thatll make our rates is higher than that. Thank your staff are doing a tremendous metalwork a very tough job but they been doing a lot of it would very changing situations. A few things that i want to bring up. A ppa process i would say the pricing is the best but that is what was needed to be done in the beginning. I think it was well worth for them to do. We should be looking at that model and also the tax credits will go away from the federal level as a fallback which is not as good as the tax credit is now. We have some options that will save us in San Francisco. The other thing is talking about the policies and procedures that you have for the first phase. I agree that we should be looking at all those things. You might want to look at the different costs. Its not like longterm that you want to have but it can give you some money quickly to say were going to do it takes a couple years will go to the process. I think its well worth the energy of what that is and how it looks like. The quicker you expand the quicker you can get more leverage in your rate structure and having more money to do that buildout. This will take some time to actual build and develop the system. Any other Public Comments . Thank you all very much and thank you for the presentation. Item 13 . Am item 13 approved amendment number two. Good afternoon. Im the Environmental Justice and landuse manager. Just a quick context for todays amendment that before you. This is a continuation of a project that we started in partnership with supervisor around two years ago. Were trying to engage residents and ratepayers were there at that is in front of their homes to show that small actions like removing a little bit of concrete total on the ring to soak and can have benefits. This again is an amendment to extend the existing grant for an additional year and i will provide just a little bit of context around the accomplishments. Working with the Supervisors Office we have removed over 6000 ft. Of impervious paved over concrete. Replace it with vibrant stormwater front your gardens. Thats around 75,000 gallons of storm water removed from our system. The amendment that before you will help extend this program for another year and let us work with another 20 residents in district for. With that, i will take any questions. When you say were removing the concrete what you mean . That is a volunteerbased effort. They work with the Property Owner they cut the concrete and is a voluntary effort, everybody comes on help and bring in the soil and plant the sidewalk gardens and the maintenance of those front yards is on the Property Owner. The cutting the concrete breaking it down and all that is being done by friends of the urban force . They do some subcontractors but its handling through friends of the urban force. I am just a comment on reluctant keeping the fact that we been having these conversations about the nonprofits and the roles and more specifically when youre talking about actually doing construction work, the work thats covered bar agreement meant and performed by the men of women that already work for the commission but for men and women that work for summer contractors under certain standards because everyone so busy we just keep missing opportunity and opportunity. They were going to gauge into this there needs to be some additional linkages. And what im talking about are the human beings. The ones that we have for example going through programs at the Human Services agencies. And in the friends of the urban foreigners want to have two, they should be looked at for an opportunity to have a job with a nonprofit. Before we continue im going to say that i really cant support it at this point in time. Until we continue to flush out the missing pieces. I feel with men and women every day or looking for an opportunity. I understand that there are and we talked about getting back to you on all the nonprofit things that we are interact with. I think some of the challenge that were facing is that the labor is sort of hitting directly title. For example the scene property, if you lease it out who is actually managing the property . We are just listening . When we look at the situation we just want to break the square of a sidewalk and plant trees or something else. We dont really think about the labor component because were talking about how much . M this would be for 80,000 of which the concrete Cutting Services is a very small percentage. I do agree that we need to have a more holistic look at all of the touch points. One of the things is put all the things that were doing as a touch. Directly, indirectly with the labor market so that you have a full flavor of everything that were doing and how they interact and youre right, it could be an opportunity to leverage all the things were doing not only in this area but other areas. I greatly appreciate your comments. I want to be really, really crystal clear. Its not for me as for leverage and not for me about union and wage scales. The labor standard piece does. People care and he gets a conversation going because of the investment they were married making as a city the committee workforce that is a linkage that i think we can all agree on. It were not linking some of these entities because we are profiting it out. On this one piece i think that we all invest in those young men and women that committee workforce piece. And theres just not enough there kind of not put together in the right way and we dont have the leverage. If we have one great guy whose timing out with Human Service and agency they were just missing the opportunity. I hope to be clear. I think youre clear in every opportunity that we dont take advantage is a missed opportunity. We would love to sit down and chat with you about these type of opportunities. Also this is the last time that this particular grant can be amended. And again its trying to keep that were going. A lot of the volunteers and this is based on volunteer committee efforts. I would urge the commission to consider approving this amendment while we give ourselves the time to have this conversation. This program has been so successful that i expect future opportunities as well and right now just hoping to keep the current work going. Commissioner . I would like to thank you for the comments and i agree. I would like to support what proportion proposed here there is momentum right now to the young men in orlando who help educate and help us put things on the ground. He came through a program. I dont abuse your study Cancer Program and he found gainful career. Its a fantastic opportunity. I would like to suggest porch allow this and move forward while we look for components to engage in the labor concrete cutting. The actual the muscle of the work done by residence. I would like to throw my support behind this. Its appropriate for us to have this dialogue. I am not going to ask that you dont move it forward. I appreciate your comments as well and i think that the Workforce Development conversation is very important, not only now but in this context and in every context. As a representative from the environmental Seating Committee i look at this differently as well. I see it as a pulling up as m h much. So understand your concerns i would still like to put a motion on the table to move this item forward. I will second. Can i think we can probably do both. By moving, i think im committed before i send it to have a conversation to see how we can take advantage of the opportunity. We need to take advantage of these opportunities. Commissioner courtney maybe we can talk offline and use that as leverage to take advantage of this opportunity. Im confident that we will have a conversation. We have a lot of stuff to go. Thank you. Public comments . Good afternoon commissioner. The program. This program is one of the most Popular Program and we would like to see this continue. Thank you everyone. Thank you. Any other Public Comments . We have a motion and a second all those in favor say i. Opposed . Its a 3one vote a1 vote and i. We will be moving into executive session. Would you please read the items that will be having a close session on . Item 16 is dedication as plaintiff 17s conference will negotiator. This is price and terms of payment. Will not hear item 18 through 2 22. And item 23 is a threat to Public Services cities. Thank you do have any Public Comment on the items to be heard in close session . C9 may have a motion so that we can assert client moved to assert and second. All those in favor San Francisco is known worldwide for its atmospheric waterfront where spectacular views are by piers and sight and sounds are xhanl changing we come to the here for exercise relax ball games entertainment, recreation market, exhilaration a wide variety of contributions easily enjoyed look up the bay the waterfront is boosting for activities boosting over 25 visitors every year the port of San Francisco manages 7 may have Million Dollars of waterfront from hyde street and Fishermans Wharf to the cargo terminals and name shoreline the architecture like pier 70 and the Ferry Building is here for the embarcadero and a National Treasure the port also supports 10 different Maritime Industries alongside with the recreational attractions making San Francisco one of the most viable working waterfronts in the world but did you think that our waterfront faces serious challenges if earthquake to damage the seawall and the embarcadero roadway rising seawalls will cause flooding at high tides and Major Repairs to a safe many of the piers the port is at a critically turnl point time to plan for the future of San Franciscos waterfront this year the port is updating its marts plan the Plan Working Group to invite a wide variety of poichdz from the city and bayview and other advisory teams to share their expertise if intense and Maritime Operations the waterfront Land Use Plan has guided the use and development of the lanes for the last 20 years major physical changes take place along the waterfront and now is the time to update the waterfront plan to continue improvements that will keep our waterfront vibrate, public and resilient the Biggest Challenges facing the waterfront are out the site an aging seawall along the embarcadero roadway and seawalls that will rise by 21 hundred to provide and productivity of tides seawall is built over weak soils and mud the next earthquake will cause it to settle several feet without the urgent repairs that will damage the promenade and other things weve been fortunate over the last hundred years less than one foot of seawall over the next hundred years Scientists Say well have 6 feet of seawall rise imagine the pier 30 32 will be floated, the embarcadero will be flooded our Transportation System is fog to be heavy impacts unfortunately, the port didnt have the Financial Resources to repair all the deteriorating piers let alone the adaptations for Sea Level Rise. It is clear that the port cant pay for the seawall reinforcement or deal with the Sea Level Rise on its own needs to raise money to take care of the properties at take care of the maintenance on the properties no way absent anti funding the issues of Sea Level Rise or the schematic conditions of seawall can be development. As studies talk about the seawall challenges the working group is look at the issues please come share our ideas about recreation, pier activities, shoreline habitat, Historic Preservation and transportation issues and viral protection. We know this planning process will not have one question and one answer we need the diversity of the opinions how people feel about San Francisco waterfront and want to hear all the opinions. The challenges call for Big Decisions now is the time to explore now and Creative Ideas to protect and preserve San Francisco waterfront. Now is the time to get involved to help to shape the future of our waterfront. We need the debate please come forward and engage in the process. This is your waterfront and this is your opportunity to get involved be part of solution help San Francisco create the waterfront we want for the future. This is really to dream big and i think about what our waterfront looked like for all san franciscans today and generations to come. Get involved with the planning process that will set the fraction for what is coming at the port. Find for in upgrading dates on the ports website. ship blowing horn in distances okay good morning, colleagues and welcome to the first timma meeting of 2017 very exciting my pleasure and privilege to lead this board that includes Treasure Island i want to recognize and thank supervisor avalos and supervisor campos who served on timma committee with me over the past year we accomplished quite a bit in 2016 and for the first time last year adopted on initial set of tool policies and congestion management policies to shape a total program that support robust and very transit on the isle for the residents and workers while the Town Hall Level will be worked out we accomplished perimeters likes population direction of travel and the shape of the discount and at the exemption policy i time to recognize the many residents of Treasure Island that worked with us and concept the recommendations this address town hall burdens and for the low income resident by directing the transportation affordability witness told you free in the early years of the program and the county trait barriers for the low income travelers 2017 will condition to be busy as we design this Transportation Program and the island ferry surface expanded bus service and on island shuttle and car and bike you shuttle and entering into meta and funding from the state and regional grants in fact this is readily an Initiative Time and opportunity as we develop this new neighborhood for San Francisco we imagine what a transportation heavy and transit first time neighborhood truly can look like speaking of grants i want to congratulate our staff with sfmta and uc berkley won a 6 million granted in the u. S. Go department of transportation to support town hall and economic shuttles only the island i want to recognize, of course, our director tilly chang, Deputy Director eric and michelle with that grant and matching fund will a town hall system and be able to work with sfmta related parking system with the mtc to bring the components together i look forward to working with all of you on the Treasure IslandManagement Program in the coming year thank you and mr. Clerk, call the next item. Well start with the role. Off role commissioner breed absent a commissioner cohen is absent commissioner farrell present. Commissioner fewer commissioner kim commissioner peskin commissioner ronen commissioner safai commissioner sheehy commissioner tang commissioner yee. We we have quorum. Thank you mr. Clerk and im sorry for going out of order this is time for the colleagues to get to the womens press conference next item. Call two and three, chairs 3 and those are informational items. Ms. Tilly chang want to thank chair kim for her leadership that was a busy year and as mentioned as the pa with the Yerba Buena Island the westbound ramps was a huge accomplishment to continue on the grant award i was landline to join with colleagues mayor ed lee and director rahaim into the sfmta to meet with secretary fox two weeks ago to receive the grants that chairman shared from the department of transportation for the deems of the town hall with the vehicle shutters that was mentioned in addition our staff works with the city and ripening staff from oakland and our own Mayors Office in on the advocatvolkswagon program in tho we supported two applications four is 2 million i look forward to meeting with all of you to lay out to the opportunities and receive the input on this opportunity as well as all the opportunities around the Treasure Island mobility management this is truly an opportunity for us to be a laboratory for the Sustainable Development locally we were disappointed is not able to secure the Museum Location we work hard with the Planning Department and that work will continue as we support the tida to further develop opportunities for this site o