Surprise! The Mushroom from The Masked Singerhad us all fooled this whole time. Pretty much no one correctly guessed his true identity, including the judges. Nicole Scherzinger does get some props for coming to the correct answer at the 11th hour during her final guess — and then Robin Thicke just copied her. But this contestant deserves a lot of credit for keeping the fans and judges alike in the dark for so long. The Mushroom was the runner-up for season 4, only unable to beat the Sun (aka LeAnn Rimes). But second place is nothing to sneeze at, and the person under the mask was just happ...