A sophomoric argument resurfaces [With Comment by John]
A sophomoric argument resurfaces [With Comment by John] As college students, John and I both subscribed to the philosophical doctrine of determinism. We differed, though, on what implications, if any, the doctrine had for the issue of income distribution. I believed that because the traits that result in wealth are determined by causes beyond our control — the genetics lottery, for example — wealth is undeserved. Therefore, inequality is unjust and should be abolished John understood that my conclusion didn’t follow from our premise. Even if high incomes are undeserved in some philosop...