CSPAN3 Supreme July 2, 2024
First, the cruel and unusual punime clause governs which punishments are permitted. Not what conduct can be prohibited. Second, no precedent spos the ninth circuit rule. Instead they misread robinson to bar any punishment for involuntary conduct linked to a status. But robinson tells on tt states cannot outlaw the status of drug addiction. It made clear they can prohibit conduct like drug use could this court should not rew robinson six decadesat third, the ninth circuits approach has proven woable. The eighth amendment does not tell courts who is involuntarily homeless, what slt is adequate, ...