CSPAN3 Supreme July 2, 2024
Punishment clause governs which punishments are permitted. Not what conctan be prohibited. Second, n precedent supports the ninth circuit rule. Instead they misread robinson to bar any punishment for involuntary conduct lketo a status. But robinlls only that states cannot outlaw the status of drug addiction. It made clear they can phibit conduct like drug use could this court should not rewrite robinson six decades later thir the ninth circuits approachroven unworkable. The eighth amendment does not tell courts o is involuntarily homesswhat shelter is adequate, or wme, place and manner relatio...