Live Breaking News & Updates on Vanessa Munro

Stay updated with breaking news from Vanessa munro. Get real-time updates on events, politics, business, and more. Visit us for reliable news and exclusive interviews.

Natasha Radmehr: Abolishing the not proven verdict would be the first step to better justice


IN 2013, a woman known as Miss M was raped while on a night-out in Fife. Two years later, when her case was taken to a High Court trial, the jury reached a verdict of not proven. Recounting how she felt when this news was delivered, Miss M said: It was an insult to the trauma I had been through and to the tenacity I had shown over the last two years … the not proven verdict felt like I had been given a life sentence.”
Scotland is highly unusual in allowing juries to reach a not proven verdict in criminal trials. Dubbed “that bastard verdict” by Sir Walter Scott, it is often perceived as an acquittal laced with a spicy caveat: we actually think you did it, but the evidence isn’t quite there. Not surprisingly, it’s a verdict reached disproportionately in rape and attempted rape cases where open-and-shut evidence is notoriously difficult to obtain. Victims are left with a lack of closure, a mistrust of the justice system and a sense of shame; if only they’d tried ....

United Kingdom , Lady Dorrian , Sandy Brindley , Vanessa Munro , Nicola Sturgeon , Rape Crisis , First Minister Nicola Sturgeon , Scottish Greens , Scottish Government , Rape Crisis Scotland , Lord Justice Clerk Lady Dorrian , ஒன்றுபட்டது கிஂக்டம் , பெண் டோரியன் , மணல் பிரிண்ட்லி , வனேசா மன்ரோ , நிகோலா ஸ்டர்ஜன் , கற்பழிப்பு நெருக்கடி , முதல் அமைச்சர் நிகோலா ஸ்டர்ஜன் , ஸ்காட்டிஷ் கீரைகள் , ஸ்காட்டிஷ் அரசு , கற்பழிப்பு நெருக்கடி ஸ்காட்லாந்து , ஆண்டவர் நீதி குமாஸ்தா பெண் டோரியன் ,