Replies(3) A Shelter Island woman was charged with kidnapping her six-month-old baby, police said. (Shutterstock) LONG ISLAND, NY — A Shelter Island woman was arrested in Delaware and charged with kidnapping her six-month-old daughter, who lives with her father in Hampton Bays, police said. According to Southampton Town Police, the infant had been missing since Tuesday; on Thursday, her father reported the child missing and said he believed she was with her mother, Sarah Payne, 34, and was possibly in Wilmington, Delaware. The baby had been removed from Payne's custody by Suffolk County's c...