republican party. she could not broaden her appeal. i said on this show if she doesn't broaden it, she will fizzle out. she didn't broaden her appeal and that's where she is. rick perry has not been able to expand himself beyond the right wing of the republican party. >> do you think he's done? >> oh, he's done. >> he needs to work on himself the next debate. >> he can't up do the damage -- he cannot undo the damage that's been done to him. >> he can undo it by a good performance in the next debate. >> he can't have a good performance. that's not who he is. >> he's a comeback kid, then you can say the texas kid came back but right now it doesn't look good for him. >> still interesting. boris epstein, karen hunter, thanks to both of you. not only are the anti-creek protests growing, new york could see the biggest and most organized of these common stragsz from all across the country. but now big labor is also joining in. why? we've got the president of the united steel workers of america live right here in a couple of minutes. the ntsb is trying to figure