Heard, at least 30 rounds by some estimates. Killing editor his bodyguard and eight others. Charlie hebdo has been very very satirical in their approach to religion. With a long history and controversial history. The offices have been fire bombed several years ago because of satirical issues it featured the muslim prophet mo ham made. The french president Francois Hollande said nobody can believe they can act like this and get away with it. It is 4 00 a. M. In france and an intense manhunt is under way at this hour for the terrorists who killed 12 people and injured 11 at the paris headquarters of the french satire mgz Charlie Hebdo or charlie weekly. The attackers headed east right after the attack and this is the latest video from the scene of a Police Operation under way in the french east of paris. Heavily armed police entered an apartment that french media reports belongs to one of the suspects. Just a short time ago, French Police said the youngest suspect, an 1yearold hamid hamid moraud has turned himself in and theyre still searching for two brothers. Sayed kuatchi and sharif kuatchi in their early 30s. They wore masks and carried assault rifles. The attacks lasted less than ten minutes. People climbed on to the roofs of buildings to make sure they were getting away from the shooting down below. [ gun firing ] witnesses say they yelled allah akbar during the attack. A witness caught that scene on video. [ gun fire ] that completely blurred figure you saw on the screen was the Police Officer being shot. The people who decide what you are allowed to see on american tell advice have decided you should not be able to see that Police Officer clearly. I dont know how those decisions are made. A witness who encountered the escaping gunman says they yelled, you can tell the media that its al qaeda in yemen. Joining me now from paris is nbc news Foreign Correspondent bill kneel neely. What is the latest there . Reporter the ironic thing is the policeman who was shot at point blank range was a french muslim policeman. Whats absolutely clear tonight is the French Police know exactly who theyre looking for. They have released in the last couple of hours photographs of those two brothers the kouachi brothers and they have said these men are armed and extremely dangerous and theyre asking the French Public for their help. We know one was jailed for terrorist offenses ten years ago. Jailed for 18 months. And we think the other brother was in syria and returned in august of last year having done something in syria, we dont know what. But from the look of those videos, these are two gunmen who are quite at ease with weapons, the way they hold the weapons. If you saw one of the stills there were 15 gunshots in very very close proximity to one another, as if the person doing the firing had been very steady. They do things very calmly. And this is what eyewitnesses report, that these were two calm almost trained professional, if you like gunmen. But of course, to say professional of a horror like this is not quite right. And police have also issued now the names of all of the victims. The people who are in that editorial meeting were of a certain age. One of the cartoonists was 80 years old. I have one of his books on my bookshelves at home. He is a very very well known political cartoonist. Another was 78. And he was given frances highest award, highest civilian honor. So these were very well respected, very well known men and women who were killed in the most brutal fashion. But it does not seem that the French Police know exactly who theyre hunting. The manhunt very much on. What do they know about how long the suspects have lived in france . Were they born in france . It appears they were. They seem to be of french algerian extraction but they were born in paris, at least thats what we hear from some antiterrorism experts. The French Police have not given details biographies. Also remember, reports that one of them have returned last year from syria. French police estimate that around 300 french nationals are in either syria or iraq at the moment fighting for isis. So this is a big problem in france in germany. And of course these suspects would be anywhere at the moment. They were heading north of here at speed along motorways. They could be in belgium by now. Its not just a french issue. This is a Northern European manhunt. Bill neely, thank you for staying late and joining us on this incredible day. Thank you very much. Joining me now from washington s nbc news justice correspondent pete williams. What are we learning in washington from the fbi and from the defense and intelligence sources who are looking at this . Well a couple of things. Number one is as soon as the french authorities got the names the u. S. Was going back and looking to see if there was any possible connection between this attack and people in the u. S. And they say tonight, they havent found any, that theyve been looking at their databases and dont see at this point any contact between the suspects in france and people in the u. S. Thats thing one. Thing two is whenever you have an event like this, the Intelligence Community takes the amount of material its been collected, they sort of hit the pause button and look back before the event to see if they can find things that in retrospect would indicate some kind of warning for this attack. And they say that they cannot. So its an all handson deck affair to try to help the french to make sure there are no other attacks in the offing. A couple of other points here theres been a decision not to raise the Terror Threat level in the u. S. Over the year that has sort of evolved in the early days of the Terror Threat level. It was kind of raised based on sort of general jitters. Now the policy is the threat level isnt raised unless theres some specific intelligence indicating theres an attack plabnned on the u. S. A couple of other go ahead, pete, go ahead. As is typical when you have rapidly unfolding events you get a lot of contradictory information. Its still not entirely clear what the french authorities believe these three people did. It seems clear the two older ones were involved in the shootings, but whats the role of the third suspect. At one point today to indicate the confusion here at one point, one french official said there had been an arrest and that was retracted. Earlier tonight, two senior u. S. Counterterrorism officials told nbc news that one of the suspects had been killed and the two were in custody. But now they say the information that was the basis of that account couldnt be confirmed. And from what we know now, that appears to be wrong. Its just been a day like that. Pete williams thank you very much for staying with us. Thank you, pete. You bet. Tonight, france raised its terror alert to the highest level. The sign yor terrorist able list at flash point Global Partners and jim cavanaugh. Whats your reading of the evidence so far . There has been a number of confusing details emerging whether from french authorities or american counterterrorism officials. They indicated that at some point, one of the attackers was killed. At another point, that he was arrested. A third point that he handed himself in. So theres a lot of speculation. But we know that based on all the details that have come out, the two individuals, the two brothers remain at large. And that one of them might have travelled to syria last year and that he might have returned unnoticed. One thing they said toby standers is tell the press that its al qaeda in yemen. Well reportedly, right, because we cannot completely ascertain thats exactly whats said. But lets retract back to march of 2013 when they had a hit list. And one of the names on that hit list was i think we have this will hit list. There it is. One of the names on there the editor of the newspaper. Along with people they eave been after for years. Theyve been featured in inspire magazines first issue that included the names of other cartoonists who also depicted profess mohammed. Jim cavanaugh, what do you make of what youve seen on video about the way they handled these weapons, the weapons they were using. How would you obtain weapons like that in paris . I think it would be a little bit difficult to get them just normally in paris. The l the tactical vests that one of the actors was wearing. I think the way they acted looked to me like one or both had been in a conflict area. They carried these rifles comfortably. Not highly trained military like of a western nation. They werent that kind of people. They didnt move like that. But they moved as people that had been in conflict before. They werent scared away by Police Officers who came in bicycles or vehicles. They knew they were going to win that fight with rifles. But theyre bumbling as well. They went to the wrong door. The one guy lost his shoe. You know highly trained military operatives would tie their shoes. They would have the right door. You know they jim, as youre saying that we just saw the video of one having to stop and pick up his shoe as hes getting in the car. Right, right. Jim, we also have a report indicating that in that black car that were seeing in the video, one of them left an id by mistake. And thats part of how he got tracked down. Right, exactly. You know shades of the pakistani terrorist in times square who bumbled the bomb. He made this contraption that wouldnt detonate and left hisses in the car. This is where these guys sort of fit, it looks like in that in the realm of theyre not one crazy lone wolf actor like hassan in ft. Hood who acts alone, radicalized on the web. And theyre not dispatched by core al qaeda like 9 1 1. Theyre in the middle somewhere. Contacts maybe in syria or north africa. Maybe a little selfradicalized or contact radicalized. A little wolf back but theyre very, very deadly. When i saw this manhunt developing today, the French Police are superb at this kind of work. It is very very hard to escape their chase in france. Well yes. The french authorities are actually extremely capable, except that you cant really protect everybody. In any country, really, you can not protect everybody. In the case of the attack in france today, the target was pretty much a soft target. Even if there was some security out there, you know a couple of guards and a couple of policemen cannot prevent heavily armed gunmen the armed policeman guarding them was the first person killed as they approached. Exactly. They would high caliber guns that could kill dozens of people in a couple of minutes. What does that tell us though, about frances gun policy . I think thats a discussion for another time but its important to look at how did they obtain their weapons. Who provided them . Who helped them . You know, going back in their communication trail, how were they able did they communicate with people individuals outside the country . Did they indeed travel . Did they communicate with commanders of fighters on the ground . The fact that they got the location wrong indicates that someone else gave them the location information. It looks like they had maybe never been there before. Thats a possibility or maybe just working off the address. And not knowing exactly what thanks for helping analyze this for us tonight. Really appreciate it. Coming up president obama responds to todays murders in paris. And one of the brave editors who decided to publish the cartoons that provoked those murders in paris today. I was not expecting to get a ford. We went around the country talking to people who made the switch to ford. It felt nicer than my bmw. Good gas mileage. Ecoboost makes a four cylinder engine feel like a six cylinder. My dad went and turned in his lexus and got the exact same car as me. He had to have it. Im very happy with my escape. I dont know if ill ever not buy a ford. Make the switch to americas favorite brand. Check out special offers on ford escape at ford. Com or see your local ford dealer. That was the france press news room in washington, d. C. Today holding the je suis charlie, i am charlie signs. But are you really charlie . Can you be charlie . If you do not dare show the cartoons that got 12 people murdered in paris today. That is why those people were executed. Cartoons. Cartoons that included depictions of the founder of islam. The killers said we have avenged the prophet. They said that. Those were their words. The can i recalls dependent want those cartoons to be seen by anyone, and they are not the only ones. Most major news organizations in america will not show those cartoons. Some perform the selfcensorship right before your eyes by showing a photoof the editor of that magazine holding up the magazine, but then cropping the photo so you cant see what all the fuss was about. You cant see why that man holding that magazine was murdered today. I will not be presumptuous enough to hold up a sign, a card that says je suis charlie and i will not be able to show you the cartoons that got some very brave People Killed today. But i will be joined later by one of the brave american editors who has decided to republish all of those cartoons that led to the murderous madness in paris today. In the internet of things, every device can be connected, to your company, your customers and all your data. Cyberedge from aig is more than insurance. Its Proactive Technology and specialists to help keep you ahead of the curve. Claims specialists and advisors to protect you as cyber risks evolve. Cyberedge to help you change the internet of risk into the internet of opportunity. Youre only young once. Unless you have a subaru. announcer the subaru xv crosstrek. Symmetrical allwheel drive plus 34 mpg. Love. Its what makes a subaru a subaru. Ive lost all my friends today. They were not vicious people. They just wanted us to live happily. They were people who wanted to play a humor to play a role in their lives. That was all. That was all. I just cant comprehend it. The editorial director of Charlie Hebdo once said i would rather die standing than live on my knees. He died standing today for the principle of freedom of expression, he was 47 years old, not married. He had no children which he cited as one of the reasons he felt free to risk his life making jokes about the founder of islam. Two years ago, he told the l. A. Times, im more likely to get run over by a bicycle in paris than get assassinated. He also told the times if one person is injured or killed it doesnt mean all of france will be put on its knees. Its not islam attacking france. Its one person attacking another person. Thats all. Bernard maris, an economist was apparently visiting the Magazine Office today when he was killed. He was a frequent contributor to the magazine writing on the name uncle bernard. He was 68 years old. Tonight, frinch police reench Police Released the name of the other victims, jaun cabut, a cartoonist who was called one of the giants of the genre. He was 76 years old. Bernard verlhac has been drawing cartoon since he was 13 years old. He once said the best cartoons give rise to laughter thought and set off a certain kind of shame. He was 50 years old. Georges wolinski was an 80yearold cartoonist. In 2011 he said my job is to look for ideas. I spent all my life looking for ideas, like a pig looks for truffles. The l. A. Times says wolinskis drawing, quote, encompassed a wide range of subjects but smeshlized in contemporary sexual mor rayes with a focus on women and current affairs. He said i want to be cremated. I told my wife you will throw my ashes in the toilet that way i will see your ass every day. Today, his daughter posted this photo of his office. Joining me now is the White House Correspondent for the french network. I want to mention some of the other names that have just been released by French Police. Michel renault, he was a guest there. A special protection service, that may have been the person who was guarding the office who was killed first. And then ahmed maribet, a Police Officer apparently himself muslim. Laura, tell us about this magazine and its place in french media. This is a very special magazine for the french. All the men who worked there are dead today wanted to do journalism and they wanted to do serious journalism but they also wanted to make people smile about real issues. France is completely traumatized by what happened. Its the journalists which has been killed today, the french people cannot understand why theres so much horror Terrorism Strike against journalism. And people really wanted to change the world and will live in freedom, freedom of the press, freedom of speech freedom to do whatever you want and say whatever you want. Laura, we see thousands of people in france today, in Paris Holding up the sign je suis charlie. Was that the feeling . I suspect it wasnt the feeling about the magazine before today. Its the feeling that something has changed in france. I know in the United States you see france as a beautiful country with woman, wine french, this is completely over. After today, its more over than ever. France is facing a very difficult crisis about its identity identity, about terrorism, about very serious issues about the far right, which is rising about Muslim Population which does not have job, which doesnt know how to do. Young people who are going to iraq, to syria, and are coming back to france to strike the french society. In the United States you have 9 11. In france today, a lot of people were saying it was again of 9 11 for the press, but also about freedom against freedom and against democracy. Laura, what is your guess about what will be happenlinging in france over the next couple of weeks in terms of a political reaction and a societal reaction to this . I think were going to see for the moment a lot of people united. Again, this is a shock so youre going to see like tonight thousands of french people demonstrating. You know that french love to demonstrate. Theyre going to stand side by side to show to the world that the french people do not want terrorism in the street. Then youre going to have a lot of political questions. Francois hollande the french president does not have good ratings at this moment. Its between 15 and 20 . The far right is rising in the past months. People have a lot of anxiety about the Muslim Population, as i said before how they are going to be integrity. And how this country is going to face terrorism. So theres going to be an amount of grief, but how are we going to resolve this crisis . Whats going to happen next. And what are we going to do about terrorism and the fight against terrorists. Laura, im very sorry about the attack that your country suffered today. And thank you very much for joining us tonight. I really appreciate it. Youre welcome. Coming up how the American Press has responded to these murders today. A former editor at the onion will join me. And ezra klein is here to talk about what his website has dared to do today. How can power consumption in china impact wool exports from new zealand, textile production in spain, and the use of medical technology in the u. S. . At t. Rowe price we understand the connections of a complex, global economy. Its just one reason over 70 of our mutual funds beat their 10year lipper average. T. Rowe price. Invest with confidence. Request a prospectus or summary prospectus with investment information, risks, fees and expenses to read and consider carefully before investing. Not all toothbrushes are created equal, oralb toothbrushes are engineered with end rounded bristles so brushing doesnt scratch gums and angled perfectly to remove 90 of plaque for a healthier smile. Trust the brand more dentists and hygienists use. Oralb. Welcome to the most social car weve ever designed. The allnew nissan murano. Nissan. Innovation that excites. Does a freshly printed presentation fill you with optimism . Then you might be gearcentric. Right now, all printers are on sale. Plus great deals on hp ink and toner. Office depot officemax. Gear up for great. I take prilosec otc each morning for my frequent heartburn. Because it gives me. Zero heartburn prilosec otc. The number 1 doctorrecommended frequent heartburn medicine for 9 straight years. One pill each morning. 24 hours. Zero heartburn. In my world, wall isnt a street. Return on investment isnt the only return im looking forward to. For some every dollar is earned with sweat, sacrifice, courage. Which is why usaa is honored to help our members with everything from investing for retirement to saving for college. Our commitment to current and former military members and their families is without equal. Start investing with as little as fifty dollars. In november 201 1, the Charlie Hebdo offices were fire bombed after a cartoon of mohammed was on the cover. The editor stood up in front of his blownup offices holding up the cartoon that provoked the bombing. Most major news organizations in this country including this network, the Associated Press and the New York Times decided not to show any of the cartoons that led to todays murders. But cartoons can be seen on lieng atline at vox. Com, huffington post, and bloomberg. It was confirmed to the last word that newspaper will publish a cartoon from Charlie Hebdo on tomorrows editorial page. It will be the same cartoon that provoked the bombing in 2011. It depicts ho maam head ss mohammed with caps that says 100 lashes if youre not dying of laughter. Ezra, you decided to republish all of these cartoons today. How did you decide to do that. I would like to tell you it was a big decision and we had a big meeting. The changes and the risks and the questions, but honestly i spoke to my editor i saw the post before it went up. It never occurred to any of us not to publish it. Our job is to explain this news story. When you cant explain without showing what this magazine pug lished and wrote about. I talked to my editor to make sure i wasnt missing a link in the chain. But i do want to make one point here. I dont really agree that this was about the cartoons and the way people are saying it is. I dont think this is about the cartoons any more than a rape is about what a victim is wearing or a murder is about the street the person is walking down. Many people see these cartoons, many people do not go on mass killing sprees. This was at the lunacy of the murderers who did it. If they hadnt gone to the offices of this magazine, they might have blown up a bus, they might have gone on a different kind of killing spree. But i think that saying its about the cartoon is a little bit within their frame. These are people who wanted to kill. You saw that when they shot a policeman point blank. These were killers. I think there was an excuse here about cartoons but i dont believe that was at the root of it. Well a motive in gram investigations, the first place the police go is they ask the people who did it why they did it. They told us very clearly today why they did it. They said they were avenging the prophet. So i get your point, ezra. I dont see why my judgment should override what the killers actually told us. But this was a tough one for you. Im going to read something you wrote today as a former editor of the onion. 12 people were murdered at the offices of Charlie Hebdo apparently for doing the very thing the onion does, satire. But they did one thing the onion hasnt done. They actually included images of mohammed mohammed. Yeah. As far as my recollection goes there hasnt balanced budget a time when the onion has run an image of mohammed especially not for any inflammatory reasons. So i do think that there is a kind of fine line that has to be walked, which is sensitivity to the cultural preferences of your readership or anybody in the world versus the freedom to publish anything you see fit in a free society. So there while the onion has poked a lot of fun and called out radical islam, i dont remember a time when it has run an image of mohammed. Not for any particular reason beyond that i just dont recall it having come up. Did you have any i mean the way you described running these car troons seems very simple and clear. And i get it. But im wondering if at vox you considered any sensitivity issues as joe just referenced about these cartoons. I think thats a real issue. I think we should all be aggressive about affirming peoples rights to publish these cartoons. But the thing about free speech is what makes it what is so great about it is you dont also have to enforce all of it right . In free speech there is an implicit endorsement often by the state. In free speech there isnt. To me, these cartoons had a category change around today, right . A week ago, a month ago, two months ago, i might not have a published them outside of a news story. I think a lot of them arguably were in bad taste. But today they became a news story. And the point about publish them was not to rile leaders up not to poke fun at a religion or make a political point, it was to try to explain what happened in that incredibly horrible crime in paris. Once they made that transition being what they were to being part of the core of this incredible International Terrible story, that made the decision a lot easier. I dont think at that point the act of publishing the message of publishing them was about the message they cared. It was about doing the job we felt we needed to do to explain to readers what was going on. Its going to be fascinating, ezra and joe, to see what happens after you at vox have put these up. Puffing post has put them up. Washington post is going to have one in the print edition of the yup tomorrow. And thats going to be a big moment because every other time in the last several years that anyone has run any kind of image of this kind anywhere in the world, denmark france, wherever you are, there has always been some kind of protest reaction. Including some very very large protest reactions around the world at different times. And joe, you have to wonder, whats coming next here. I dont know whats coming next. I think ezra put it really well. I was flipping through, as it were, the imnjs on vox today, and it never occurred to me that vox would have been one of the soul publications to print them. The tragedy here is that theyre images. Theyre cartoons, you know . I dont think they have to mean anything. And i think centering so much of our discussion on what is the response going to be is this okay, is it not, given that there are very real safety concerns illustrated graphically and who blie and violently today, i think by centering our dissuggestion solely on that gives them much more power than they need to have. I think if we allow ourselves to dwell on this fear then the message that these three killers were trying to send that i dont believe they sent on behalf of islam has a whole is given much more strength than it deserves. Well ezra to some extent theres a certain amount of the mission is accomplished. When most news organizes in america absolutely refuse to show these cartoons in anyway. That was the objective of the murderers today. You saw different eder tos tweeting and writing about anything that is really real the fear of safety. How do you balance what you think you need to do for your audience or in your i deemism as a member of free press and your fear of depriving the families of your employees of a father or mother. But i think more people have send these immechanicals today ever than would have in the absence of this act. And i think theres been an encouraging affirmation of a free press here. And i hope internationally. Thank you very much for joining us tonight. Coming up we will go back to france for a live report on the man manhunt that is under way right now. Curling up in bed with a Favorite Book is nice. But i think women would rather curl up with their favorite man. But heres the thing about half of men over 40 have some degree of erectile dysfunction. Well, viagra helps guys with ed get and keep an erection. And remember, you only take it when you need it. Ask your doctor if your heart is healthy enough for sex. Do not take viagra if you take nitrates for chest pain; it may cause an unsafe drop in blood pressure. Side effects include headache, flushing, upset stomach and abnormal vision. To avoid longterm injury, seek immediate medical help for an erection lasting more than four hours. Stop taking viagra and call your doctor right away if you experience a sudden decrease or loss in vision or hearing. Ask your doctor about viagra. [ fishing rod casting line, marching band playing ] [ male announcer ] the rhythm of life. [ whistle blowing ] where do you hear that beat . Campbells healthy request soup lets you hear it in your heart. [ basketball bouncing ] heart healthy. Great taste. [ mm. ] [ tapping ] sounds good. Campbells healthy request. Mm mm good. ® the schelp then the spill. Now the scrub and the second guess. Finally, the rewash. Or you can make it easy and do the pop with tide pods. The first 3 in 1 laundry pack. It cleans, brightens, and removes stains in one step. Tide pods one step to an amazing clean. The United States journalists from around the world were among those who gathered at the newseum in washington, d. C. And in new york city at 7 00 p. M. Eastern, hundreds came to new york citys union Square Holding signs and pens aloft. Well be back with more on the live coverage of the hunt for the two killers still at large in france. Good job still running in the morning . Yeah. Getting your vegetables every day . When i can. [ bop ] [ male announcer ] couldve had a v8. Two full servings of vegetables for only 50 delicious calories. Ive had a lot of hondas. We went around the country talking to people who made the switch to ford. I loved the look of the fusion. We test drove it. I was like this is my car. Allwheel drive is amazing. I felt so secure. You can do it, emmie ecoboost is when you can take a four cylinder and make it feel like a six cylinder. I was really surprised. I drove the fusion. And i never went back. Make the switch to americas favorite brand. Check out special offers on ford fusion at ford. Com or see your local ford dealer. She inspires you. No question about that. But your erectile dysfunction that could be a question of blood flow. Cialis tadalafil for daily use helps you be Ready Anytime the moments right. You can be more confident in your ability to be ready. And the same cialis is the only daily ed tablet approved to treat ed and symptoms of bph, like needing to go frequently or urgently. Tell your doctor about all your medical conditions and medicines, and ask if your heart is healthy enough for sex. Do not take cialis if you take nitrates for chest pain as it may cause an unsafe drop in blood pressure. Do not drink alcohol in excess. Side effects may include headache, upset stomach, delayed backache or muscle ache. To avoid long term injury, get medical help right away for an erection lasting more than four hours. If you have any sudden decrease or loss in hearing or vision or any allergic reactions like rash, hives, swelling of the lips tongue or throat or difficulty breathing or swallowing, stop taking cialis and get medical help right away. Ask your doctor about cialis for daily use and a free 30tablet trial. Check it out im sending a tweet. Tweet thats not how it works, grandpa. You think i am out of touch. I saved 15 percent on Car Insurance in just 15 minutes. You couldve saved money in half that time with esurance. wings flapping ah, a reply. Im trending 15 minutes for a quote is old news. Start with a quote from esurance and you could save money on Car Insurance in half the time. Welcome to the modern world. Esurance. Backed by allstate. Click or call. [bassist] two late nights in tucson. Blew an amp. But good nights. Sure,musics why we do this,but its still our business. We spend days booking gigs then weve gotta put in the miles to get there. But its not without its perks. Like seeing our album sales go through the roof enough to finally start paying megs little brother i mean,our new tour managerwith real,actual money. We run on quickbooks. Tha ts how we own it. [coughing] dave, im sorry to interrupt. I gotta take a sick day tomorrow. Dads dont take sick days, dads take nyquil. The nighttime, sniffling sneezing, coughing aching, fever, best sleep with a cold medicine. This is about freedom of speech and freedom of the press. But one thing that im very confident about is the values we share with the french people. A universal people in Free Expression that cant be silence with senseless violence. Joining me now is steve clemens, and msnbc contributor, steve the john kerry and the president gave these kind of pro forma statements. Whats going on backstage in washington, particularly now at the nsa. This is when those big silos of data, communication data including french communication data that Edward Snowden revealed theyre collecting could be valuable to the french pop i think you nailed it lawrence. I can guarantee you behind the scenes, we are looking at every bit of associational intelligence that we can find on those that have been identified as the alleged killers in this. Looking for every relationship they have, every phone call theyve made what they spent money on where theyve traveled to. And putting a map together of the digital profile of these individuals. Im sure were working with them. I mentioned when the minister of flans was here he talked about frances concerns that they were seeing increased connections and efforts between different fragmented groups in africa and in europe to try to connect with isis. So that was an example of the kind of sharing that was already going on government to government. But im sure that were doing the kinds of things you nailed in your comment. Stooe, i suspect at the end of this story, we may never know just how much of an contribution is made by american intelligence, if any, to solving this or bringing more details to how it all happened. Well i think, you know the character of the u. S. Intelligence establishment in most cases is to stay beneath the surface, behind the scenes and no to disclose information publicly because it compromises perhaps mean methods and sometimes signals to other party what we can know. It was highly unusual, frans, when we identified north korea as a corporate in the hacking of zone sony. That almost never happens. Youre right, you dont want to disclose too easily to others out there. You want to have them continue to engage in the patterns of communication that theyve gone. Thank you very much for joining us tonight. Thank you, lawrence. Coming up next a live report from france on the search for the two suspects who are still at large. son oh no. Can you fix it, dad . Yeah, i can fix that. dad i wanted a car that could handle anything. I fixed it dad thats why i got a subaru legacy. vo symmetrical allwheel drive plus 36 mpg. I gotta break more toys. vo introducing the allnew subaru legacy. Its not just a sedan. Its a subaru. So youre looking for a loan . Hows your credit . I know i have an 810 fico score, thanks to the tools and help on experian. Com. And your big idea is hot dogs shaped like hamburgers . Nope. Hamburgers shaped like hot dogs. Thats not really in our wheelhouse. You dont put it in a wheelhouse. You put it in your mouth. Get your credit swagger on. Become a member of experian credit tracker and find out your fico score powered by experian. Fico scores are used in 90 of credit decisions. [ male announcer ] approaching medicare eligibility . Dont put off checking out your Medicare Options until 65. Now is a good time to get the ball rolling. Medicare only covers about 80 of part b medical costs. The rest is up to you. Thats where aarp Medicare Supplement insurance plans insured by unitedhealthcare insurance company, come in. Like all standardized Medicare Supplement insurance plans they could help save you in outofpocket medical costs. Taking informed steps really makes a difference later. Thats what it means to go long™. Call now and request this free decision guide and explore the range of aarp Medicare Supplement plans. All plans like these let you choose any doctor or hospital that accepts medicare patients. These are the only Medicare Supplement insurance plans endorsed by aarp. Call now and request your free decision guide and start gathering the information you need to help you go long™. At this hour police in france are looking for these two brothers as suspects in the terrorist attack in paris today. The search has taken police about 100 miles northeast of paris. The latest on that search is next. Sound like a sure thing but im a bit skeptical of sure things. Whys that . Look what daddys got. Ahhhhhhhhhh growth you can count on from the bank where no branches equals great rates. Alkaseltzer plus presents the cold truth. I have a cold, with terrible chest congestion. Better take something. Ill catch up later. Awww. Truth is, theraflu severe cold doesnt treat chest congestion. Really . New alkaseltzer plus day powder rushes relief to your worst cold symptoms plus chest congestion. Oh, what a relief it is. Here we go woooo woooo and now, alkaseltzer plus has a complete line of powders to treat your worst cold symptoms. Welcome to the most social car weve ever designed. The allnew nissan murano. Nissan. Innovation that excites. Judicialewudicial official has confirmed that the two suspects are still at large in the deadly attack of the offices of the french weekly Charlie Hebdo. French authorities released photos of the two brother, 32yearold Cherif Kouachi and 34yearold said kouachi, both born in paris, considered armed and dangerous. A third suspect, 18yearold hamyd mourad surrendered to police earlier tonight. Bill neely is life in paris. What do we know about the suspect who surrendered to police . Do we know where he surrendered and why he surrendereds . Was he basically cornered at that point . We havent got confirmation he was even named initially by police. But we know the man who turned himself into the Police Station is 18 years old. He turned himself up near the belgium border. And supposedly he turned himself in because he saw his name mentioned on soeshl media and decided to go to the Police Station. But none of that has been confirmed by police. What police have confirmed, and its quite clear now, they are looking for these two brothers. One of whom was convicted ten years ago of terrorist offenses, of trying to encourage a group of men to go to iraq to fight u. S. Troops. And the other brother, we believe, who returned from syria in august of last year. Paris tonight is a city in shock at the worst terrorist attack in 54 years here. Its a city fearful because these two men, the two gunmen pictured in the videos are still on the loose. People have fearful they might strike again. People are in solidarity. Were joined by a french correspondent. Laura, what do you think the reaction will be in france to what we now know to be the fact that both of these people being searched were born in paris. These are native born frenchmen . Its not going to be surprising for the french people because they know that it happened before, it happened a few years ago with a young kid who was raised in france, went to a synagogue, murdered kids. And people are expecting this kind of attack. In the past six months politician people, reporters were describing how french people were preparing attack against journalists, jens jews, against differen symbol of democracy. So the french people are not surprised. The french people are shocked. The french people want to be now united. And the french people are going to look very closely at whats going to happen in the next hours. How the people are going to be arrested. What the French Police is going to be. Is there going to be a battle between the French Police and the two guys. Are they going to surrendered . Are they going to fight against the cops. A lot of questions at this moment. French is resilient and french people at this moment just want to show to the world how they are united in the fight against terrorists. Bill neely in paris, thank you very much for joining me tonight. Youre welcome. Chris hayes now continues our live coverage. Tonight on all in an attack in paris leaves 12 dead gunmen open fire on the offices of the satirical magazine Charlie Hebdo. Tonight as the french fill the streets in protest, the latest in paris on the hunt for the gunman. What we know about what this magazine and these cartoonists were targeted again and again and what this attack means for free speech around the world. All in starts right now. Good evening from new york. Im chris hayes. Following an attack on a french satirical magazine in which 12 people were killed, French Police have issued an appeal in search of the two suspects. They are two brothers in their 30s. French police are calling on anyone with information t