Transcripts For MSNBCW The Last Word With Lawrence ODonnell 20170502

That President Trump wants and not a single penny for the trump wall. And after a negotiating defeat like that, President Trump said today that he, he could have negotiated a way the civil war. You knew damn well i was a snake before you took me in. Its clear that for our president , the Campaign Never really ends. They are gathered together for the white house Correspondents Dinner without the president. I think because he cant take a joke. Media outlets like cnn and msnbc are fake news. Fake news. I just wish someone had told me that all you have to say is fake news over and over again, you know . President brush, i never thought i would pray for the day that you were president again. Lets rate the medias 100 days should. We do that . They are a disgrace. The president goes after us because were a easier target than kim jong un. Nobody is safe. Were probably not safe over here. Its one long stream of consciousness. Why was there the civil war . Why could that one have not been worked out . This is crazy that the United States has this ignorance. Its crazy. I want to know your opinions. Youre the president of the United States. Thats enough. Thank you. Thank you very much. President trump now thinks that choe have negotiated away the civil war. This is the same president who failed with his first big bill in congress, repealing and replacing obamacare. No president has done that, failed to pass his first major agenda item. And none of those recent president s, who were able to pass their first big agenda item ever said that we could have been spared the civil war with better negotiating. Today at the White House Press briefing, sean spicer was asked to clear up the confusion about whether everyone with preexisting conditions will be guaranteed Health Insurance under a new Trump Health Care plan written by the most conservative members of the house of representatives. It is a plan that makes it optional for states to coffer preexisting conditions. Yesterday in the television interview, President Trump left it unclear as to whether he would change that part of the bill and make it mandatory instead of optional. So sean spicer was asked about that today. Was he referring to something he wants to push to include in the bill . Was he talking about the language that is already in there . I think both in the sense that mcarthur meadows amendment to ensure existing conditions continue to be covered. But obviously as this bill hopefully passes the house this week or whenever it does and then goes through the senate and the house, this is an issue that is important to him. He was asked whether the president supports the current language of the bill, which does not make the coverage of preexisting conditions mandatory, or does he support trying to push that language into the bill . Which is it . Sean spicer says i think both. It cant be both. Thats what makes governing so hard. To govern is to choose. And the choices are never easy. And if you choose to make coverage of preexisting conditions optional for the states, then you will pick up some more of those extreme conservative members of the house of representatives. But you will surely lose other members of the house. And if you push to include in the bill the coverage of preexisting conditions as a mandatory guarantee, then you will lose those conservative members. I want to make it optional. No. It cant be both ways. You cant have both. So no. Sean spicer doesnt have an answer to the question. He doesnt have an answer to the governing choice that the president wants to make on this. And that governing choice is stunningly simple. Just tiny. Tiny. Compared to the issue that drove us into the civil war, donald trump is the first republican president who doesnt lavish praise on Abraham Lincoln. It seems that donald trump may have only recently discovered that Abraham Lincoln was a republican. Here he is in march, reading a teleprompter about Abraham Lincoln to a room full of professional republican politicians, all of whom know that Abraham Lincoln was a republican. President trump seems to be learning that Abraham Lincoln was a republican from his teleprompter. As president , lincoln signed the law that built the first transcontinental railroad, uniting our country from ocean to ocean. Great president. Most people dont even know he was a republican, right . Does anyone know . A lot of people dont know that. We have to build that up a little bit more. Lets take an ad. Lets use one of those pacs. Pretty insulting to that audience to ask them if they knew that Abraham Lincoln was republican. That fact appeared earlier in the president s teleprompter. And then he had this kind of delayed surprise reaction to it. It was a National Republican Congressional Committee event. They know. Everyone in that room knows that Abraham Lincoln was republican. Donald trumps favorite president wasnt a republican. But President Trump believes if his favorite president had been president in 1861 instead of Abraham Lincoln, we wouldnt have had a civil war. I mean, had Andrew Jackson been a little bit later, you wouldnt have had the civil war. He was he was a very tough person, but he had a big heart. And he was he was really angry that he saw what was happening with regard to the civil war. He said there is no reason for this. Andrew jackson didnt see what was happening with regard to the civil war. He was a southern slave owning president from tennessee 24 years before the civil war. He died 16 years before the civil war. White supremacists and many southern politicians who are not white supremacists, but remain bitter about the civil war dont like Abraham Lincoln, and they do like Andrew Jackson. Steve bannon is a big Andrew Jackson fan. And now doubt turned President Trump into an Andrew Jackson fan. In order for President Trump to negotiate away the civil war, he would have to know why the civil war was fought. Jon meacham who wrote the definitive biography of Andrew Jackson said to the New York Times today the expansion of slavery caused the civil war. And you cant get around that. So what does trump mean . Would he have let slavery exist but not expand . Thats the counterfactual question you have to ask. So in the next trump interview yes, only hope that the interviewer will ask President Trump how he would have avoided the civil war. How much slavery would President Trump have been willing to allow in the New Territories of the United States . Thats another version of todays question, easier question of are you for making coverage of preexisting conditions mandatory or optional . The governing outcome is always in the details. Always. So as jon meacham is insisting, you cannot say you would have negotiated away the civil war without telling us exactly how, exactly how you would do that, without telling us what your position would have been on allowing slaves in the territories, and how that would have convinced the south not to commit treason and not secede from the you know and wage war against the United States of america. The civil war shamed the south for two reasons. First, because the confederacy lost the war. And second, decades later and a century later, when slavery was no longer even remotely morally justifiable, the south was shamed by the reason that it fought the civil war slavery. And so southerners 100 years later changed the reason. In the 1950s, segregationists started calling the civil war the war of northern aggression because they could not admit that the south was fighting the war to preserve and protect the institution of slavery. The south could not have been clearer about it at the time. They put it in writing. Mississippi called the, quote, the institution of slavery the greatest material interest of the world. Louisiana said they were fighting the war because of their, quote, determination to preserve african slavery. Texas politicians have always footnoted their policies as coming directly from god. And so texas justified the confederacy this way. The servitude of the african race as existing in these states is mutually beneficial to both bond and free and is abundantly authorized and justified by the experience of mankind and the revealed will of the all mighty creator as recognized by all christian nations. President trump thinks a better president than Abraham Lincoln, a president like, say, Andrew Jackson could have negotiated with texas. Over slavery and over the divine word of god as it pertains to slavery. Or maybe he doesnt think that. Because perhaps President Trump thinks the civil war was not about slavery. Perhaps he thinks it was all about northern aggression. All Abraham Lincolns fault. Were going to have to wait for the followup interview on what the president meant. And that is the question of the day. What did the president mean . North korea is wondering what the president meant tonight. When the president said, unlike any other president before him, that it would be an honor, his word, an honor to meet with the murderous dictator of north korea kim jong un. If youre wondering what kim jong un has to do in order to have a meeting with the president of the United States, the answer is we dont know because the president wont say. We dont know what he means. That means kim jong un doesnt know what he has to do to get a meeting with the president of the United States. And so we enter the second 100 days of the Trump Presidency with a preexisting condition. No one knows what the president means. Will the president sign the Health Care Bill that allows states to make coverage of preexisting conditions optional . No one knows. How does the dictator of north korea have to change his behavior to get a meeting with the president of the United States . No one knows. Least of all, kim jong un. And how would President Trump, who has been unable to negotiate the passage of a Health Care Bill with his own party in congress, how would that president have been able to negotiate a way the civil war. Joining us now, washington columnist for the boston globe. She is with the Pointer Institute for media studies. Also with us charlie sykes, editorinchief of right wisconsin and an msnbc contributor. Indira, the press briefing every day involves a series of questions to essentially what did the president mean when he said or what does the president mean and where does he stand, and every day as sean spicer offers no more clarification of wherever the president had left the confusion point. Well, in this case where youre talking about trumps position on authoritarian leaders, this is something where President Trump has been pretty consistent even since he was candidate trump. He has been consistent in the words he used about himself. Remember at the rnc, at the Republican Convention when his big line was i alone can fix it. Which is not the kind of a line you would have heard from Ronald Reagan or george h. W. Bush or other wellknown republicans. Its the kind of line you would hear more from a suharto or a fidel or some other authoritarian leader. So i thought it was very striking during the campaign, one of the most interesting polls was one out of the university of massachusetts that showed that the single most clarifying reason people were likely to vote for trump in the primaries was not income, race, religion or anything like, that it was actually whether they had a more aauthoritarian mindset. So i think that goes some way to explaining the president s warmth towards, for example, sisi of egypt and the things that he sa about duterte of the phippines and kim jong un. That one is quite surprising, i have to say. And i bet there are some people within the Trump Administration who are knocking on his door and wanting him to resay that a different way perhaps tomorrow. I want to go to Something Else the president said yesterday. And charlie, i think this is going to come as a surprise to a lot of your republican wisconsin friends about the president. He said that hes willing to give up certain things in trade negotiation with china in order to get their cooperation with north korea. He never mentioned this during the campaign when he was talking about how tough he was going to be with china. He never said, you know, maybe ill go easy on them on trade in exchange for Something Else. Lets listen to this. And if i can use trade as a method to get china, because i happen to think that china does have reasonably good powers over north korea. Now maybe not, you know, ultimate, but pretty good powers. Now if china can help us with north korea and can solve that problem, thats worth making not as good a trade deal for the United States. Excuse me, right . Charlie, its worth making not as good a trade deal for the United States. Its almost as if he is making it up as he goes along. Almost. What a dumb time to be alive. In one day i think weve achieved peak trump ignorance and incoherence at the same time. And part of it is that you have a president who obviously is functioning without any fixed principles. He will blow which way the wind blows on personality. And obviously his knowledge of the details of public policy, whether its health care or trade policy is limited. And of course hes more than willing to share his ignorance about history as well. I mean, this is exactly what America Needs right now, right . To relitigate the 1830s. And indira, the truth is that the way these negotiations are done generally with most countries, with trade and with issues like helping us out in another Foreign Policy arena that. Tend to be very separate things. There tends not to be an overlap. But if there is in a country like china, thats completely understandable. He is right now. He is actually right that it is understandable that if china is invaluablebly helpful on north korea, that might soften a United States position in some spot in trade relations with china. But thats not a level of complexity he ever admitted to a voter who he promised to label china a currency manipulator and beat them up on trade. Yes, youre right, lawrence. It is absolutely true that we always make deals with foreign countries. And we give a little on this. And they give us a little on this. And then we give them a little on Something Else. And it was common, for example, under the obama administration, russia helped the United States with the Northern Distribution Network to get supplies into afghanistan to resupply the u. S. afghan effort at a time when we couldnt good through pakistan, and we were softer on russia on some other things. We were softer all the time. Its not something that candidate trump ever talked about or admitted to. And it surprised me that trade would be an area he is willing to give on since that was one of his areas during the campaign. He caved on the wall this week. Think about it. In the last week he caved on the wall. And now he is caving on trade. Those were the two most consistent themes of the entire campaign. A quick one, charlie, before we go. Donald trump has said less about Abraham Lincoln than any other republican politician ive ever listened to. Its not something ive really noticed until today. And i kind of went back in my brain and said wait a minute, here where is all the praise of Abraham Lincoln. Is that a steve bannon calculation . Yes. And also, there is a strain of conservatism. The paleo conservatives who have always been somewhat hostile. They think of lincoln as being a Big Government sort of tyrannical figure. But that was always kind of a fringe element on the right. And i think you can tell that Donald Trumps been spending some time in that particular swamp. Because most republicans are going to be talking about Abraham Lincoln, not how a genocidal figure like Andrew Jackson would be so much smarter and tougher than that lincoln, that dummy who got sexual abuse a civil war. Charlie sykes gets the last word in this segment. Charlie sykes and indira lakshman, thank you for join us. What people are saying, is he sane . If youve tried every pill on the shelf to treat your tough nasal allergies. Listen up. Unlike pills that dont treat congestion, clarispray covers 100 percent of your nasal allergy symptoms. Clarispray. From the makers of claritin. We cantwhy . Y here terrible toilet paper ill never get clean way ahead of you. avo charmin ultra strong. It cleans better. Its four times stronger and you can use less. Enjoy the go with charmin. Introducing new depend real fit briefs. Now more breathable than ever. In situations like this, theres no time for distractions. Its not enough to think im ready. I need to know im ready. No matter what lies ahead. Get a free sample at depend. Com what people are saying, is he sane . I have no idea. I can tell you this. And a lot of people dont like when i say it. But he was a young man of 26 or 27 when he took over from his father, when his father died. He is dealing with obviously very tough people. In particular the generals and others. And at a very young age, he was able to assume power. A lot of people im sure tried to take that power away, whether it was his uncle or anybody else. And he was able to do it. So obviously hes a pretty smart cookie. burke at farmers, weve seen almost everything, so we know how to cover almost anything. Even a coupe soup. [woman] so beautiful. [man] beautiful just like you. [woman] oh, why thank you. [burke] and we covered it, november sixth, twothousandnine. Talk to farmers. We know a thing or two because weve seen a thing or two. We are farmers. Bumpadum, bumbumbumbum theres nothing more than my vacation. Me so when i need to book a hotel room, i want someone that makes it easy to find what i want. Booking. Com gets it. They offer free cancellation if my plans change. Visit booking. Com. Booking. Yeah. Find fast relief behind the counter allergies with nasal congestion . With claritind. [ upbeat music ] strut past that aisle for the allergy relief that starts working in as little as 30 minutes and contains the best oral decongestant. Live claritin clear, with claritind. Today the president declared north korea the biggest foreign threat facing the United States. Nobody is safe. Who is safe . The guys got nuclear weapons. Id like to say theyre very safe. These are great, brave soldiers. These are great troops. And they know the situation. We have 28,000 troops on the line. And theyre right there. Nobody is safe. Were probably not safe over here. If he gets the longrange missiles, were not safe either. The president refused to specify how he would handle north korea. I dont like drawing red lines. But i act if i have to act. What would it take . Would it take a Missile Launch into south korea, conventional or nuclear . Ive been pretty wellknown for saying nothing when it comes to the military. Joining us now, gordon chang, columnist for the daily beast and author of Nuclear Showdown north korea taking on the world. And also jim walsh, massachusetts institutes of Technology Security program and one of the handful who have traveled to north korea for talk with officials. And jim walsh, i want to go to the technical capacity first of all. The president there saying were probably not safe here. What could he mean by that . And because were seeing these missile tests just, you know, not even get close to leaving north korean airspace very much. He is talking about whether north korea has an icbm, something they could launch from north korea that would reach the United States. Now my own view is overestimates the threat and underestimates it at the same time, which sounds crazy. It overestimates it because i think they are quite some time from this. Weve had predictions they would have this capability. The prediction dates have come and gone. We dont have the wait for this to be a real deal. The president rightly points out. We have thousands of troops in south korea. Thousands more in japan. I think north korea could probably get a weapon to both of those places. If they incinerated 28,000 american troops in south korea, i think thats a big deal. So it is a threat. And we dont have to obsess about the icbm to take this seriously. Its serious right now. Well, lets listen to what the president said in this interview with Bloomberg News today. He said it would be appropriate for me to meet with him. I would absolutely be honored to do it if its under the right circumstances, but i would do that. And gordon, he doesnt say what the right circumstances are. No. And clearly at this point, he wouldnt be able to do that. I think the right circumstances are once he gets kim in the right position where kim feels he has no choice but to give up his weapons there has to be sanctions first and kim may be more amenable. But the point right here saying he would be honored to meet kim, this really is wrong. What does that communicate to both the South Koreans and the North Koreans . The North Koreans, it legitimizes their ruler. To the South Koreans, its a real problem. It help ones of the candidates in the may 9th election. That candidate is very antiamerican, very antiu. S. Alliance. So trump should not be saying things to help people who dont like us. And also in that thursday reuters interview, he said two things that helped the moon jaein, the antiu. S. Candidate. He said the South Koreans should way 1 billion for the antimissile system and threatened to terminate the u. S. South korea free trade agreement. Those are things which undermine u. S. Interests at this time. And then he had to reverse himself on those of those things . Yes, he does. Let me push back on my good friend gordon chang. I agree with him his critique about the things about south korea. Thats the wrong thing to say about an ally. And then earlier said i dont stand by any of my statements. Again, adversaries and allies are listening. Thats not a good agreement. But weve had sanctions. Lots and lots and lots of sanctions. What do we have in a north korea that builds more missiles and test morse nuclear weapons. If we wait until the very end to have a negotiation, that will never happen. I think there is a possibility here that we could have some talks, and that would lead a freeze. And believe me, i would take a freeze over them building their capability and being able to reach the United States. And yes, it was sort of awkward to say the least to say all those nice things about kim jong un. But a guy who has been to north korea, been to iran, had meetings with awful people, you dont lead into if meeting by saying youre a murderous regime, i hate you. If were trying to prevent a nuclear war, then were going to have to say some things that make conversation possible. I say hold your friends close. Your enemies closer. We should be talking to them. This is a dangerous situation. We could get a war that no one wants because of miscalculation. My complaint with trump is not that. My complaint is the messages and signals are all over the place. Every day its a different message. Well, jim, i think i can agree with a lot of what you have to say. And then i think we get into exactly what is the language of dealing with north korea. And do you say its an honor, gordon, to meet with him . Do you call him a smart cookie . Do you need any of that language here . No, you dont. Even if we thought that having sitting down with the North Koreans now was a good thing, and you know, thats arguable. We tried freezes before. We have done all that and it doesnt work. But the point is you dont need to say these things about what really is the worst despot in the world question. Have good diplomacy with the North Koreans without actually reg jit mizing a regime that doesnt like is. Gordon chang and jim walsh, thank you both for joining us tonight. We really appreciate it. Thank you. Thank you. Coming up, Michael Moore has a question for donald trump, and we have questions for Michael Moore. Thats next. microphone feedback listen up, heart disease. You too, unnecessary er visits. And hey, unmanaged depression, dont get too comfortable. Were talking to you, cost inefficiencies and data without insights. And fragmented care stop getting in the way of patient recovery and pay attention. Every single one of you is on our list. For those who wont rest until the world is healthier, neither will we. Optum. How well gets done. Whoa,i just had to push one button to join. Its like im in the office with you, even though im here. Its almost like the Virtual Reality of business communications. No, its reality. Intuitive one touch Video Conferencing is a reality. And now its included at no additional cost with vonage business. Call now and see why 3,000 companies a month are switching to vonage. Business grade. People friendly. Lwhos the lucky lady . Im going to the bank, to discuss a mortgage. Ugh, see, you need a loan, you put on a suit, you go crawling to the bank. This is how i dress to get a mortgage. I just go to lendingtree. I calculate how much home i can afford. I get multiple offers to compare side by side. And the best part is. The banks come crawling to me. Everything you need to get a better mortgage. Clothing optional. Lendingtree, when banks compete, you win. Okay . Awkward. This afternoon, republican congressman billy long in missouri announced he would vote against the new House Republican attempt to repeal and replace obamacare. Quote, i have always stated that one of the few good things about obamacare is that people with preexisting conditions would be covered. The mcarthur agreement strips away any agreements. Saying President Trump did call congressman long today, and they discussed his position for being a no vote on the ahca. Congressman long wants preexisting conditions covered, and thats why he wont support this bill. The president tried to confuse a Television Interviewer yesterday about what exactly is in that bill. Sean spicer tried to confuse White House Press corps today about what exactly is in that bill. Apparently the president could not confuse congressman billy long what is in the bill that he has read. Joining us now, Michael Moore, an Academy Awardwinning filmmaker who announced today that he is going to broadway. He will star in a oneman show on broadway this summer called the terms of my surrender. Michael, its your broadway debut, first of all. It, yes. Thats a big deal. Yes. And youre going to go to broadway. Yes. To surrender to President Trump because hes gutting it right on health care. What are the issues youre surrendering on. No, no. No need to go because you already know i have given it up. I think the terms of my surrender are slightly different. The show is its a piece of satire that ive written. And ive always wanted to do something live on the stage. And i thought actually, ive been on a bit of a creative tear since, well, last summer when i saw the train wreck that was coming. And ive been doing a lot of writing. And approaching this from various fronts. So the first salvo is going to be i want to do something here in this city, frankly. The Global Headquarters of corporate america, wall street, the epicenter of the media. And the home of that great bastion of free expression, the american theater. You will your script adjust to things that happen in the course of, say, sean spicers day . Yes, yes. It is scripted. But if we need to bring in chocolate cake on any given night, well be able to do that, yes. Today was so fascinating. You saw sean spicer which we played earlier in the show trying to pretend that it was very clear what the president s position is on preexisting conditions in this new bill. Well, there he was on the phone today with a republican congressman who is saying im voting against it because it doesnt guarantee coverage of preexisting conditions. Apparently that congressmans very clear about whats in it. Yes. Trump doesnt understand that literacy is still alive and well in this country. People can still read. And this particular congressman from missouri knows what theyre planning to do, because he read it. You dont have to go much deeper than that. But, again, part of the propaganda machine, which again, we like to laugh about here, but actually its not very funny, because they think theyre getting away with it with tens of millions of people if they just Say Something enough, often enough and just repeat the lie, enough people will believe it. Well, that is working for most of the people who have already voted for donald trump. Yes. And for no one else. Right. But because trump ran an election that ended up being benefitted, he benefitted from the fact he was appointed by the electoral college, it doesnt matter what the majority of americans think right now. What is the good news is we are the majority, myself and my fellow americans who didnt vote for him. And we have raised a ruckus on so many issues in these first few months that i think weve kept him very busy. And people are attacking this on all fronts. I came on your show right after the election. I said we have to operate on four fronts here. Well need citizen mass action. Weve seen that, right . We need our lawyers to go to court and get injunctions. Weve had that. We need to run people who can win next year. We need to take back the house of representatives. And if we keep our democratic senators, it means we only need to remove three republican senators next year we need to do that. And the final thing that i have pushed is we need an army of satire. We need everybody to use their sense of humor and their comedy to bring him down. Because his skin is so thin, he gets so upset at, you know, all Melissa Mccarthy has to do is keep appearing and alec baldwin on snl and, you know, basically, i and others, we formed this larger group of discombobulating him with humor, ridicule, satire, to we want him up at three income the morning tweeting. The more he is doing that, thats the less he is doing to hurt the country. He does appear to pay more attention to you and alec baldwin and Melissa Mccarthy and everybody at snl than he does to even the constituents of republican congressman billy long, who have impressed upon this republican congressman you cant vote for this. And so youre right about the number of fronts that need to be manned here. The thing is too, like you just said that, and we just admitted. I Just Announced what the strategy is. Yes. It will still work. Lets say he is watching right now. I think over at fox during this hour, there just a test pattern. So he has flipped over here and heard the strategy that is still he cant control himself because there is a disorder afoot here. And we want to keep him busy with that disorder. Not busy in the way where he is launching more tomahawk missiles necessarily, but to where he just is chasing his tail. Its our version of wagging the dog essentially. When you go to broadway, you will be it seems to me preaching to the converted to a great extent as opposed to your documentary where you took the cameras, went right out into the heart of trump land, which was a completely different world to talk to. Talk about the advantages of each one of those audiences. Well, who says im note making a documentary . Oh. Listen. I said im on a creative tear, all right. This is salvo number one. Why broadway . Because people on my side of the political fence need to start reaching the people who go to see cats and the line king. So im planting my flag in a place where Middle America shows up. In the summer, thats true. And thats why im doing flit the summer. And we need we need we need to sponsor nascar things. We need to see Climate Change things on the hoods of chevys that are racing around the track, you know. We need i did consider the ice capades or disney on ice perhaps. Im just saying im being funny, but im not. Because i really do believe that we need to reach people where theyre at. 8 million obama voters voted for trump. I probably cant convince the vast majority on the way on the right. But i think we can hold our hands out to the 8 million obama voters that voted for trump. Remember, it was just 10,000 visits in michigan, 2,000 votes per precinct that we lost. Well can do this. And going on broadway is one way im going to attempt to reach out to Middle Americans. And the pricing of the seats, i got the producers to come there for like 25 bucks. And discounts for trump voters. If trump voters want to come, i will probably actually buy their ticket. Jun 20th or july 20th . It starts on july 28th. Only for 12 weeks. And next time i come back on, well go back to our show tunes that we used to do. Boy. You were singing during the commercial. I would invite you to sing us out, but were in a big hurry. Michael moore, thank you very much for joining us. Thank you. Coming up, sean hannity says it might be the end of fox news as we know it. He is very worried about whats happened there today. Im so frustrated. I just want to find a used car without getting ripped off. You could start your search at the allnew carfax. Com that might help. Show me the carfax. Now the car you want and the history you need are easy to find. Show me used trucks with one owner. Pretty cool. [laughs] ah. Ahem. Show me the carfax. Start your used car search and get free carfax reports at the allnew carfax. Com. Theres nothing more than my vacation. Me so when i need to book a hotel room, i want someone that makes it easy to find what i want. Booking. Com gets it. They offer free cancellation if my plans change. Visit booking. Com. Booking. Yeah. This clean was like pow everything well . My teeth are glowing. They are so white. Step 1 cleans. Step 2 whitens. Crest [hd]. 6x cleaning , 6x whitening a i would switch to crest [hd] over what i was using before. Before fibromyalgia, i was a doer. I was active. Then the chronic, widespread pain drained my energy. My doctor said moving more helps ease fibromyalgia pain. She also prescribed lyrica. Fibromyalgia is thought to be the result of overactive nerves. Lyrica is believed to calm these nerves. Woman for some, lyrica can significantly relieve fibromyalgia pain and improve function, so i feel better. Lyrica may cause serious allergic reactions or suicidal thoughts or actions. Tell your doctor right away if you have these, new or worsening depression, or unusual changes in mood or behavior. Or swelling, trouble breathing, rash, hives, blisters, muscle pain with fever, tired feeling, or blurry vision. Common side effects are dizziness, sleepiness, weight gain and swelling of hands, legs and feet. Dont drink alcohol while taking lyrica. Dont drive or use machinery until you know how lyrica affects you. Those who have had a drug or alcohol problem may be more likely to misuse lyrica. With less pain, i can be more active. Ask your doctor about lyrica. When this guy got a flat tire in the middle of the night, so he got home safe. Yeah, my dad says our insurance doesnt have that. What . you can leave worry behind when liberty stands with you™. Liberty mutual insurance. Introducing new depend silhouette briefs. Featuring a comfortable sleek fit. As a dancer, ive learned you cant have any doubts. Because looking good on stage is one thing. But real confidence comes from feeling good out there. Get a free sample at depend. Com. Another day, another big shakeup at fox news. Less than two weeks after bill oreilly was force outstanding out of fox news, bill shine is out as fox news copresident. Suzanne scott will be the new president of programing for the Fox News Channel. Last week when reports hinted that bill shine could be the next to go, sean hannity tweeted i pray this is not true, because if it is, thats the total end of the Fox News Channel as we know it. Now as politico reports, many fox insiders said the network remains a wash with speculation about hannitys future in the wake of shines resignation. Joining us now haddas gold. Haddas, sean hannity tweeted something last week saying somebody high up and inside Fox News Channel is trying to get an innocent person fired. This he gives this bill shine situation an intrigue that, you know, becomes incredibly powerful if it also involves some link to sean hannity. Exactly. Sean hannity and bill shine go back a long ways. In the mid90s it was sean hannity who recommended bill shine to roger ailes to bring him to fox news. He was Sean Hannitys producer for some time. Shine is pretty well liked within the network. His departure today while not completely unexpected because of those tweets that sean hannity sent, and a lot of people saw that as sean hannity very close to bill shine, that he knew something was happening, its still shaking up the network. Its another big change for the network that has had a year of tumult. What are you reporting that women at fox news felt about bill shine . Bill shine was named in a couple of lawsuits as somebody who was aware of Sexual Harassment allegations and either didnt do anything about them, or in some cases some women are actually alleging that he in some way helped sweep them under the rug. So there was a feeling at fox news that if the murdochs were so committed to changing the culture, why were so many of these people still in power . And a lot of them are still there as well, despite the fact that bill shine is gone there are other people who have been named in other lawsuits who are still executives at fox news to this day. A lot of people at the network are still wondering is there more to come . This isnt the end of it possibly. Hadas gold, thank you very much for joining us tonight. We really appreciate it. Thank you. Coming up, lisa bloom who brought some of the most important lawsuits against fox news that started this whole turmoil going a few weeks ago. , with help from our advisor, we made it through many market swings. Sure we could travel, take it easy. But weve never been the type to just sit back. Not when weve got so much more to give when you have the right financial advisor, life can be brilliant. Ameriprise it can seem like triggers pop up everywhere. Luckily theres powerful, 24hour, nondrowsy claritin. It provides relief of symptoms that can be triggered by over 200 different allergens. Live claritin clear. Like finding new ways to be taken care of. Home, car, Life Insurance obviously, ohhh. But with added touches you cant get everywhere else, like claim free rewards. Or safe driving bonus checks. Oh yes. Even a claim satisfaction guaranteeeeeeeeeee in means Protection Plus unique extras only from an expert allstate agent. Its good to be in, good hands. If you have moderate to severe Rheumatoid Arthritis like me, and youre talking to your rheumatologist about a medication. This is humira. This is humira helping to relieve my pain. And protect my joints from further damage. Humira has been clinically studied for over 18 years. Humira works by targeting and helping to. Block a specific source. Of inflammation that contributes to ra symptoms. Its proven to help relieve pain and. Stop further joint damage in many adults. Humira can lower your ability to fight infections, including tuberculosis. Serious, sometimes fatal infections and cancers, including lymphoma, have happened, as have blood, liver, and nervous system problems, serious allergic reactions, and new or worsening heart failure. Before treatment, get tested for tb. Tell your doctor if youve been to areas. Where certain fungal infections are common and if youve had tb, hepatitis b, are prone to infections, or have flulike symptoms or sores. Dont start humira if you have an infection. Talk to your doctor and visit humira. Com this is humira at work. At lincoln, were all about making things simpler for you. Like, imagine having your vehicle serviced. From the comfort of your own home. Introducing complimentary lincoln pickup and delivery servicing. Because the most important luxury of all. Is time. Pickup and delivery servicing on the entire family of lincoln luxury vehicles including a complimentary lincoln loaner. I know bill shine is a behind the scenes figure but for your viewers its hard to overstate his centrality to fox news. He was roger ailess right hand man for years. He was in all of those meetings, intimately aware of roger ailess culture. The fact that he was not aware of this misogyny and Sexual Harassment to many is unbelievable. Joining us lisa bloom, she represents women who accused bill oreilly of Sexual Harassment. Lisa, talk about the importance of people in the management chain willing held responsible for these things. Because this is the first instance of that. Roger ailes was both management and he was one of the harassers. But bill shine has never been accused of harassing anyone. He is being let go at this point because of his involvement in what became the culture of allowing these things to happen, apparently. Thats right. Hes accused over and over again of being an enabler. Instead of doing his job when women complained about Sexual Harassment, which would have been to do a prompt, thorough investigation, protect the victim, punish the perpetrator instead he has been accused repeatedly of simply protecting the guys at the top, sigh lenszing the women by paying them money and then driving them out of the country the company. As an enabler he is partly responsible according to these accusations for what went on at fox news. I think its very appropriate he is gone now. He is gone now because of the public pressure and the heat thats been put on fox news. One theoryb why bill shine might be kept, fox news is under a federal investigation, u. S. Attorneys office in the Southern District here in manhattan, about what they were doing with the money that paid these settlements and how they reported that money, and possibly other thing. And there was speculation that as a company fox would not want an executive like bill shine cut loose and available as a witness. Well, thats true. But also, lawrence, keep in mind that 21st century fox, the Parent Company of fox news s trying to buy sky tv in the uk, a multiple billion dollar deal. I have sent a letter to the regulator there saying this company does not meet their deisntsy standards because they dont respect womens rights in the work place. I think part of the reason why they got rid of bill oreilly and part of the reason why they have now gotten rid of bill shine is they want to present a clean image to the regulator so they can make the billions they hope to make. Lisa one of the reports from gabe sherman indicates that Suzanne Scott who is going to be the first woman in charge of running fox news, she was in charge of enforcing roger ailes mini skirt dress code for women, apparently, according to gabes reporting. Yes, there is also their inhouse vp and general counsellor who has been accused of being an enabler. There are race discrimination cases pending. 12 or 14 people actually filed race discrimination cases and diane brandy is named in those cases. Having known about race discrimination at fox news for many years and not doing anything about it. I think there is more House Cleaning to do over there. Lease audio bloom once again thank you for joining us for this conversation. Appreciate your time. Thanks lawrence. Coming up, trump versus trump, on china and american jobs. Its how well you mow fast. Woooh its not how fast you mow. Its how well you mow fast its not how fast you mow. Its how well you mow fast. Theyre not just words to mow by, theyre words to live by. The John Deere Ztrak z345r with the accel deep deck to mow faster, better. Take a test drive and save up to 250 dollars on select john deere residential ztrak mowers. vo more dper rollres for mom bounty is more absorbent, so the roll can last 50 longer than the leading ordinary brand. So you get more life per roll. Bounty the quicker picker upper its time for you and your boys to get out of town. laughing left foot. Right foot. Left foot. Stop. Twitch your eyes so they think youre crazy. If you walk the walk you talk the talk. Its what you do. If you want to save fifteen percent or more on Car Insurance you switch to geico. Hide the eyes. Its what you do. Show em real slow. A lot of people up there cant get jobs. They cant guilty jobs. Because there are no jobs. Because china has our jobs. There are no jobs, because china has our jobs. That was candidate donald trump. And here is President Trump today. If i can use trade as a method to get china because i happen to think that china does have reasonably good powers over north korea. Now, maybe not, you know, ultimate, but pretty good powers. Now, if china can help us with north korea and can solve that problem, thats worth making not as good a trade deal for the United States. Excuse me, right . There are no jobs because china has our jobs. And then we want to make not as good a trade deal for the United States, letting china keep all those jobs . Worth mentioning during the campaign. That is the last word. The 11th hour with Brian Williams starts now. That is the last word. The 11th hour with Brian Williams starts now. Tonight, President Trump says nobodys safe because of north korea. He also said today he would be honored to meet with kim jongun, having called him a pretty smart cookie. Plus an admitted killer at the center of a human rights outrage is invited to the white house. So the question was rais today at White House Briefing about the kinds of men who appeal to donald trump. And the president goes deep on a History Lesson about our seventh president , Andrew Jackson. Problem is, it didnt match any known history. So tonight, Andrew Jacksons Pulitzer Prize winning biographer is with us to clear it up. The 11th hour begins now