permanent but the middle class is not. it's tax relief for companies and rich people. the premise from the white house and republicans on the hill is if you can really get the economy growing strongly with tax cuts for companies, then that is going to benefit everybody. that's their operating assumption. but the joint community of taxation looked at the tax changes under the senate bill and found by the year 2027 the lowest earning americans will see their taxes rising the most. so in the beginning it's tax cuts for everybody and then that starts to peter out. if you look at the rich chart going over to rich people, they still have their tax cuts. that's at the core you are hearing from senator brown and others, it's not a vehicle to help income equality, it's a vehicle to help companies. >> that, of course, is in the senate. if you are looking at the house bill you are learning more after