one person who saw this loss of the white working class voters early on was former united states senator moynihan of new york who wrote in 1968 right after bobby kennedy was killed n a word the people of south boston should be on our minds as those of roxbury or bedford stiv es ant. they've been abandoned. four years later moynihan talked about catholic voters. he said the white working class should be a base on which to build not to abandon. even in the high office of vice president, joe biden born in scranton hasn't either. as my old boss tip o'neill used to say, he hasn't forgotten where he came from. he knows and shares the sentiments of those ordinary people who feel they've been abandoned by the democratic party they themselves built. and that's "hardball" for now. thanks for being with us. "all in with chris hayes" starts