Gator that killed dog caught, euthanized in Winter Garden Trappers catch gator that attacked dog An alligator trapper is warning people and pets to stay away from bodies of water after a woman's dog was attacked and killed by one. The gator responsible in the attack was captured and killed off of the West Orange Trail in Winter Garden. WINTER GARDEN, Fla. - An alligator trapper is warning people and pets to stay away from bodies of water after a woman's dog was attacked and killed by one. The gator responsible for the attack was captured and killed off of the West Orange Trail in Winter Garden.