Transcripts For MSNBC The 11th Hour With Stephanie Ruhle 20240913

Stuart stevens gets tonights last word. The 11th Hour with Stephanie Ruhle starts now. Tonight, the day after the debate, president ial hopefuls meet again, hours after the fiery faceoff. Where the race goes from here. Plus, why a baseless Conspiracy Theory about migrants eating pets in springfield, ohio, found its way to the president ial debate. We will speak directly to a local officials. Then he is the only democrat to face to j. D. Vance. Tim ryan is here with a device for the Harris Campaign as the 11th Hour gets underway on this wednesday night. Good evening once again. I am Stephanie Ruhle and we are now 55 days away from the election, but Today Campaigning was temporarily set aside as candidates joined together with the country and marking 23 years since the 9 11 terror attacks. 10 hours after facing off against one another in an intense debate, Vp Kamala Harris and Donald Trump greeted one another and shook hands. At the solemn commemoration at Ground Zero in new York City. Harris, trump, and j. D. Vance spent the day attending events in new york, washington and pennsylvania. While governor Tim Walz was in minnesota where he honored 9 11 victims with a day of service, helping volunteers pack meals for food banks. Tomorrow everyone is back out campaigning and we will see how last Nights Debate changed the national conversation. My Colleague Peter Alexander has more on that. Reporter for 90 minutes, harris delivered on her strategy to try to provoke outbursts from the former president , mocking his rallies. What you will notice is people start leaving his rallies early out of exhaustion and boredom. Reporter trump repeatedly taking the bait. She said people start leaving. People dont go to her rallies. Reporter harris pressing him on his refusal to accept the election results. Donald trump was fired by 81 Million people. Clearly he is having a difficult time processing that. Reporter and in a dramatic moment, slamming him for praising the repeal of roe v. Wade. You want to talk about this is what people wanted . Pregnant women suffering from a miscarriage, being denied care in an Emergency Room because Healthcare Providers are afraid they might go to jail and she is bleeding out in a car in the Parking Lot . She didnt want that. Reporter though harris did not specify if she supports restrictions on abortion. Trump targeted harris for her record on the economy. Ive never seen a worse time. People cant buy Cereal Or Bacon or eggs or anything else. Reporter and on the border. They destroyed the fabric of our country. Millions of people let in. With that lets get smarter with the help of our panel tonight. Peter baker joins us, chief white House Correspondent for the new york times. And Michael Steele is here, former chairman of the Republican National Committee and former Lieutenant Governor of maryland, but you know him as the cohost of the weekend, right here on msnbc. Peter, i turn to you first because you are at Ground Zero with president biden as well as the vp, Donald Trump, j. D. Vance. What was it like to see Kamala Harris and Donald Trump together. The only thing separating them was no Mike Bloomberg standing between them, 12 hours after an absolutely brutal debate. There was something surreal about it, right . They spent an hour and a half on stage, savaging Each Other. Calling Each Other a Disgrace And Weekend horrible and all of these insulting things and there they were the next day, basically as you say, 12, 10 hours later, standing in the same tent at 9 11. It was actually bloomberg who reached out to touch Kamala Harris to get her to turn around, to draw her into shake Donald Trumps hand and they did have a seemingly friendly handshake. In Fact Trump seems to have said something pleasant to her and even patted her hand. And you know they got along fine. It is a reminder, i think, not of how politics used to be, where there used to be respect across the aisle. Instead i think it is a reminder of how important 9 11 still is. This moment that forces politicians who really dont like Each Other very much to at least pretend they are part of the same country, the same nation, the same, you know, society at least for an hour. It is something that New Yorkers are so proud of, The Way we come together, but it is something when Mike Bloomberg is the one asking you to be polite. That is a rare day. Michael, lets talk about 9 11. A devastating day for our country, especially New Yorkers and on that day Donald Trump made a point of saying that his building became the tallest in new York City after the World Trade Center fell. Not only was that a grotesque thing to say, it was also a lie along with the other lie that he told that thousands of muslims were standing on roofs of buildings in new jersey, celebrating the attacks. That is who Donald Trump was 23 years ago today, so why is anyone surprised that 23 years, Last Night on the Debate Stage he lied for 90 minutes straight that is who he is. That is who he is and who he was 23 years ago and who he is today. Look, Donald Trump has never been sensitive to the moment. He did not understand the gravity of 9 11. He did not process it. What he did process is now he has the tallest building in new york. That is what he processed. The other thing he processed, you know, was Conspiracy Theories that muslims, you know, keeping with this vein of antimuslim hatred that tried to emerge on the heels of 9 11, but for the guidance and soft words actually of president bush, to remind us who we are in a moment like this. He would have gone down that Rabbit Hole and tried to perpetuate those lies about muslims, stirring up anti muslim hate among white people. That is basically that is his mo, so it does not surprise me that he is standing on a stage 23 years later with a black woman that is running for president , parroting the same things and nor should the rest of us be surprised, especially the media that has covered him for 23 years. Especially in the last nine years. So i wish the media would stop acting surprised when Donald Trump behaves a certain way, because you have been covering that for as long as he has been on the stage and i think that is something that a lot of americans, as you look at this moment, are trying to pull themselves away from, this sort of, oh my god, you know, look at Donald Trump again. We are tired of it and there is a level of exhaustion that a lot of americans have, which has opened up this moment for Kamala Harris The Way it has. She just said, youve got to be tired by now, because i know i am. So lets go this way. Lets go forward. In 2016 one could make the argument for a lot of americans he was a new face, a new voice. People liked The Way he spoke directly, but now in 2024, people know exactly who Donald Trump is. There are no surprises. Molly, one of the most notable tweets of the night, i will share it with our audience. If harris wants to win, she needs to train her face not to respond. It feeds into a female stereotype and more importantly at risks offending undecided voters. What a harebrained, what a harebrained idea you had, frank. Are you kidding me, molly . Are you kidding me . Yes this is a stereotype if you are living in 1982. I dont like to commit media on media violence, but in this case i did troll him and say this is totally misogynistic. It is stupid. It is also very stupid and it is not what happened at all. I think that is the most interesting thing. She actually got the power. She used the power. I read today this Sarah Longwell Piece in the atlantic about how a lot of on the fence voters were saying she looked president ial and i read some other on the fence voters were saying that they related when she was laughing. So i do think it was just something from another century and look, there are these sort of hot Take Punditry things and some are misogynistic and the idea that she cant have normal facial expressions is one of them. She really won the game of tv Last Night. She couldve had a lot of totally normal outraged and fired up responses, but she showed incredible discipline. Like a silent assassin letting him spin himself like a top. And look, she did a ton of research and a ton of prep and you could tell because she sort of knew what would get him and stepped back and let him do it and that was sort of, she has been very good at kind of proving the doubters wrong. He didnt prep. It was Tulsi Gabbard and Laura Loomer who prepped them. Im going to leave that they are. Peter, we are hearing Team Trump go on and on about how unfair it was because he got fact checked more than Kamala Harris did, but heres the thing, of course he did. Donald trump spent the entire night repeating wellknown lies and the Fact Checks were basic. It is not aggressive to say im sorry, sir, nobody is Eating Animals or killing babies. Yeah, if there is more Fact Checking it is because there were more alleged facts to check. No question about it, he laid out a whole lot of things that were obviously completely false or fictional. One of my favorites is when he says that everybody in the country, liberals and conservatives, democrats and republicans, wanted roe v. Wade overturned so the Abortion Issue could go back to the states. That is obviously not even true. 60 were opposed to overturning roe v. Wade, but he said this repeatedly now as if it were true and somehow does not seem to be daunted when People Fact check him and as you rightly say, they eating Dogs Episode is something i think we will remember most about Last Night. Not just because it wasnt true, but because it seems so farcical and absurd. Look, the moderators got criticized the last time around when trump faced Joe Biden for not doing more realtime Fact Checking. Im sympathetic. It is really hard to do that in the moment. If you stop every single sentence that a politician says, particularly like Donald Trump who says wait there is more context and this is something you did not say. There is a balance to be had between allowing a debate to go forward and allowing the other person in the debate to challenge, you know, factual assertions and not allowing complete falsehoods to be, you know, put on the air and that is a tough balance for any moderator. I think the moderators Last Night did a good job. If anybody is going to be mad about Donald Trump repeating these dog stories, he should be mad at foxnews and j. D. Vance for feeding him this puppy chow. He said it on tv, he learned it from watching his favorite tv personalities. Michael you think at The End of the night, at The End of the day any votes changed Last Night . Before the debate we talked about the undecided voters who said they did not know of her and had not seen her. Last night she put on a show and so did he. Generally i would say probably just a little bit at the margins, perhaps around the corner, you know. Someone said i think im going to vote differently. That was not this debate. I think this debate did have more than a marginal impact on voters. I think it was apparent in some of the overnight reaction and responses from Focus Groups as well as Spot Polls that were taken. When you are showing 60 of the people watching the debate said that she, Kamala Harris, one, yeah, and when a lot of those voters are, you know, sort of undecided, centerright, independent voters. Who have largely been on the fence because of hesitation around Joe Biden and now feel a little bit more engaged and leaning into this conversation for the presidency. I think it did and i think she acquitted herself as a president should and that was important because going into this one of the things i was very interested in seeing how she would manage was her prosecutorial instincts against her president Ial Mantel and she was able to hold that president Ial Mantel in front of the american people while she spanked that behind a little bit along The Way as a prosecutor and i appreciated that. I appreciated that because that is what she needed to do and i think a lot of voters responded to that. I think peter in his reporting and others, you know, could probably sense that there was something different about this. Not to put peter on the spot, but something different about this debate as opposed to some of the others, that the voters were receiving this differently than they had bush and gore or, you know, the first Biden And Trump debate. I should correct myself. We know Laura Loomer was there. She traveled with Donald Trump and was in the spin room. We do not know that she prepped him. Tulsi gabbard gets that credit. Lets talk about Taylor Swift. This morning Donald Trump said she would probably pay for her endorsement in the marketplace. She will lose scores of fans. Going to lose business. I heard that from rightwing pundits, but i want to remind our audience that Taylor Swift endorsed Joe Biden four years ago. Since then her tour raked in more than 1 billion. It is the highest grossing concert ever. She had the Topselling Album of the year. Three of the last four years. While you and i are sitting here she is across the street at radio city, probably taking home all the Video Music awards. What you make of this endorsement and the backlash that her fans who are republicans will no longer be swifties . Theyre going to shake her off. Donald trump loves a threat, he loves to threaten people and conservatives love a boycott. Hold on. Liberals are no strangers to the boycotts. For sure, but remember boycotts, political boycotts look, i am not too worried about Taylor Swift. I think shes going to be just fine, but it is important. You know trump really has this binary where you are for him or against him and if you are for him than he wants to bestow upon you and if you are against him then debate usually dont matter, this one might. We can say the same about celebrity endorsements. They usually dont matter. Could taylor be different . Look to the amount of people. Thousands of registered to vote between Last Night and today. On her instagram she said and here is how to register to vote. In fact there were searches, am i registered to vote in texas . She is a huge driver of Get Out The Vote and by The Way, conservative radio host, i mean there was a celebrity, remember. Rush limbaugh was the biggest get out the Vote Driver when he was still alive, so you know she is not a political person, but her music is, in some ways, very emotional for a lot of these people and so and musicians, rock stars, artist, have been political forever, this is nothing new. I introduce you to bob dylan. Thank you all for starting us off this evening. When we return it is not just his election lines, he is doubling down on another debug claim. Donald trump brought it up and i will bring it up again. This ridiculous claim that immigrants are stealing and eating pets in ohio. We will get the facts straight with someone who is actually there. And later, stoking fears about migrants is not new for trumps vp pick. It is how j. D. Vance edged out a win in his ohio Senate Race and we will speak about it with his former opponent. The 11th Hour just getting underway on what i will call a pretty important wednesday night. Ght. Rinvoq works differently and its a oncedaily pill. When symptoms tried to take control, i got rapid relief with rinvoq. Check. When flares tried to slow me down, i got lasting Steroidfree Remission with rinvoq. Check. And when my doctor saw damage, rinvoq helped visibly reduce damage of the intestinal lining. Check. Rapid symptom relief. Lasting, Steroidfree Remission. And visibly reduced damage. Check, check and check. Rinvoq can lower your ability to fight infections, including tb. Serious infections and blood clots, some fatal; cancers, including lymphoma and skin; heart attack, stroke, and gi tears occurred. People 50 and older with a Heart Disease Risk factor have an increased risk of death. Serious allergic reactions can occur. Tell your doctor if you are or may become pregnant. Put uc and crohns in check and keep them there with rinvoq. Ask your gastroenterologist about rinvoq. And learn how abbvie can help you save. An alternative to pills, voltaren is a clinically proven Arthritis Pain Relief gel, which penetrates deep to target the source of pain with nonsteroidal antiinflammatory medicine directly at the source. Voltaren, the joy of movement. When did i Call Leaffilter . When i saw my gutters overflowing onto my porch. Leaffilter is a permanent gutter solution, so, you never have to worry about costly damage from clogged gutters again. Its the easiest call you can make. Call 833. Leaf. Filter today, or visit leaffilter. Com. Craig here pays too much for verizon wireless. I so he sublet half his Real Estate office. [ Bird Squawks loudly ] to a pet shop. Megs moving company uses tmobile. So she scaled down her fleet to save money. And dons paying so much for at t, hes been waiting to update his equipment theres a smarter way to save. Comcast business mobile. You could save up to 70 on your wireless bill. So you dont have to compromise. Powering smarter savings. Powering possibilities. Among the many things we heard from Donald Trump during the debate with Kamala Harris was a baseless lie about haitian immigrants in springfield, ohio. These are the people that she and biden let into our country. In springfield they are eating the dogs. The people that came in, they are eating the cats. They are eating the pets of the people that live there and this is what is happened in our country and it is a shame. Know it is not. That was former president Donald Trump spreading a Conspiracy Theory he learned from Social Media in front of tens of millions of americans. The truth matters on the show and i want to make this absolutely clear. None of what you live learned from the former president is true. I want to bring in an expert on this subject. Thank you so much for being here, commissioner. The governor of your state, mike dewine, has said this is not true. Can you tell us in your official capacity, have you seen any evidence of these claims . Pets being stolen, killed, and eaten . Absolutely none. I have spoken with Springfield Td and the sheriffs office. We have had concerned calls come into the Dispatch Center and they have been followed up on and have not been substantiated. What was your reaction Last Night . You like many other americans were watching the debate and what was your reaction when you heard Donald Trump talk about springfield and spread this lie . We do have real issues in springfield, ohio and immigration is a real issue, so i am glad that our potential president is talking about it and bringing light to it, but the issues in springfield that are really related to a big surge of haitian refugees coming to our community, most of them are actually here illegally. Local leaders in our community are focused on issues that matter, which are ensuring that people are driving with proper licenses. Secondly, funding to alleviate the pressure we are feeling from the infrastructure, when we have 20,000 more people working in the same infrastructure. It just is not work anymore and finally we work on cultural assimilation and helping people overcome some of these gaps and barriers that we are seeing between our traditional Springfield And Clark county residents and those who are new to our community. Why do you have this large group of immigrants, mostly from haiti . It is my understanding that they came here several years ago for jobs and an expensive housing. We have a low cost of living in comparison to the rest of the united states. They came for jobs and were brought by Temp Agencies that had opportunities to place them in positions here, because we did have available jobs. One haitian Community Leader in springfield spoke to my colleague. I want to share what he said about how these lies have impacted his community. Some of them asking me, even yesterday i had a Friend Calling and asking if he has to leave because he is scared for his life. Another friend told me that it seems that he would have had some family coming to visit him, but it seems that he is not welcome in columbus or dayton, because it is not safe right now for him in springfield. These are hardworking immigrants who are here illegally, doing jobs, being part of the community. What is your reaction to what he just said . There are real concerns for those who live here and for haitian immigrants who have come here as well. One thing that i dont have concerns about his safety. Haitian immigrants are not a Law Enforcement Problem in our community. They are much more likely to be victims of crimes than to be perpetrators of crimes. So i do have concerns mostly about what this is doing to the image of our community. I have concerns about what it will do potentially to Business Investment and others who might come to visit because we have a lot of great things in the community that we want people to come here for. President trump has been to our community and i know he is aware of that and Senator Vance has been good to Ohio And Springfield and we want to encourage them to come and see All Of Us for themselves. Can i ask before you go, if you did not have those migrants filling those jobs, what would it do to the economy in springfield if none of them came or they were subject to a Mass Deportation . Because these are refugees, the Deportation Conversation is somewhat moot, because they are here on temporary refugee status. So they are not here on an illegal status, so i dont know why there would be any kind of Mass Deportation, but as far as the economy is concerned we have available jobs. We did need workers, so that was a match of the time people were brought here to fill temporary jobs. Unfortunately we have been saturated and infrastructure is that Max Capacity and we are looking for ways to deal with that at this time, so we are looking for additional funding. The state has been generous with funding for healthcare and training. Those are the important things we want to stay focused on. Thank you so much for joining us tonight. Getting to the truth and making sure our viewers understand what is happening is crucially important to us. I really appreciate it tonight. Thank you. Nobody is eating cats. When we come back our next guest has a lot of experience running against the gops immigrant fearmongering. Tim ryan shares his advice for beating Trump And Vance in november when the 11th Hour continues. Continues. Ding vraylar to an antidepressant is clinically proven to help relieve overall depression symptoms better than an antidepressant alone. And in vraylar clinical studies, most saw no substantial impact on weight. Elderly dementia patients have increased risk of death or stroke. Report unusual changes in behavior or suicidal thoughts. Antidepressants can increase these in children and young adults. Report fever, stiff muscles, or confusion, as these may be lifethreatening, or uncontrolled muscle movements, which may be permanent. High blood sugar, which can lead to coma or death, weight gain, and high cholesterol may occur. Movement Dysfunction And Restlessness are common side effects. Stomach and sleep issues, dizziness, increased appetite, and fatigue are also common. Side effects may not appear for several weeks. I didnt have to change my treatment. I just gave it a lift. Ask about vraylar and learn how abbvie could help you save. While the Trump Team elevates Conspiracy Theories about immigrants, it is worth remembering that two years ago j. D. Vance won his Senate Race by stoking fears about migrants in the state of ohio. As Tim Walz gets ready to debate trumps Running Mate in less than a month, our next guest is the only democrat to face vance and he has some insight. Tim ryan joins me now. He founded the organization, we the people. You get some credit because you are the first prominent democrat to call for Joe Biden to step aside and for Kamala Harris to run for president. You got a lot of heat for it at the time. I remembered. And last Night America got to see the Kamala Harris that you told us about. How are you feeling now . I feel great. She was awesome. I feel great for the country, i feel great for the party. When you have talent, like any business almost, but if you have talent you have smart sand you are generally wanting to learn. You are going to grow in whatever job you get into, even if at the time it may be over your head. She had the 2020 election where she would say i did not run a great race. She became vp. She kept growing and learning and i was like, what are we doing . This is the one that should take the mantle and Last Night was so fun to watch. The only thing better was Fox News after, watching the meltdown. I was not watching Fox News and im not sure why you were. I get a lot of entertainment from that. You wouldve got a lot of that here, too. The vp debate, you have debated j. D. Vance. He is mysterious. When you think about a guy like Tim Walz, he is someone you might think would run for office. A huge likability factor. J. D. Vance has almost none. Similar to ron desantis, yet both are in office. What is the key to running against this guy . Showing the personality, talking straight. J. D. Can get into very theoretical, highminded conversations to try to explain the insanity of immigrants Eating Dogs or whatever. You can see him Last Night on some of the shows. That is the lowest level possible. It is low but he tries to get into some level of nuance and i think Walzs Strength will be the coach. Explanations normal people can understand. The key will be dont let j. D. Vance get away with a bunch of this because he will try to say i never said that, thats not what i meant. He will try to wiggle out of some of these things that he said and i think that walz is the perfect person to call him out on it. What do you think about this Conspiracy Theory . You know springfield ohio and i just spoke to the county commissioner, president. It is totally acceptable to say that we have a ton of migrants who have come to this area, more than we can handle and weve got a problem. That is except the bull. How does a conspiracy like this start . People are stealing, killing, and Eating Animals. You know where springfield is. You know who lives there. What went through your mind . How does the spread so fast . The analysis is like the White Supremacist groups and extreme groups online started to amplify it and it is all about scaring people and they think that is the best way to do it. People in ohio are normal people. They may vote more conservative depending on the election thats normal. They are pretty normal people and Theres Nothing wrong with that. The idea is immigration is complicated. There is No One who will say this is easy and i thought what trump did Last Night put him in a lane in so many ways, but on the extremism, Eating Dogs and cats and all that craziness. If this is so complicated, if we need immigrants, if they work really hard like a lot of the ceos have said. I would hire 30 more haitians because they work so hard. But we cant have too many. There needs to be a process, you cant just come in and skip the line. That is a complicated conversation. Who is the leader running right now that can bring us together and say lets have this complicated conversation . Lets Add Meat lets admit it is complicated. That is where kamala will create space between trump. Thats not what he is doing. His fearmongering has gone so far that he has upset in Ohio Family that faced enough grief and tragedy. The father of a young boy killed in a Car Crash is demanding an apology from j. D. Vance and Donald Trump after they cited this young Boys Death as a reason to stop haitian immigration. Watch this. J. D. Vance and Donald Trump, they have spoken my Sons Name and used his death for political gain. This needs to stop now. They can vomit all the hate they want about illegal immigrants, the Border Crisis and even untrue claims about fluffy pets being ravaged and eaten by community members. However, they are not allowed, nor have they ever been allowed to mention Aiden Clark from springfield, ohio. I will listen to them one more time to hear their apologies. That is not normal. That is a father who is extraordinary. His son was killed in an accident. It is heartbreaking to watch, because anybody who has kids puts themselves in that situation, but what it really illustrates is there is nobody who cant be used by Donald Trump and j. D. Vance to score political points. No grieving family. No complicated immigration situation. No woman who has a complicated pregnancy. Those are all pawns in the game and i think that is the exhaustion that america sees right now and i think they are going to reject that, because it is not american, it is not human, it is not kind, it is not compassionate and that is what you see and it is sad to watch because when the show is over and the story subsides, they will never be the same and you watched two politicians use them. It is also not a game. Tim, it is always a pleasure to see you. Always a pleasure. I like how they make them in ohio. When we returned, from tariffs to inflation, Donald Trump and Kamala Harris sparred over economic pitches to voters. We will get into how the Business World reacted. I can tell you one thing, the guys who support trump didnt seem to want to take my call today. We will talk about that when the 11th Hour continues. Ghosting me. i wish i had someone like evan when i started. Somebody just got their first Debit Card Ice cream on you . Ooo, tacos i got you. Wait hold on, dont you owe me money . What . your money is a part of your community, so your bank should be too. Like, chase oh, why leaffilter . Its well designed, efficient, i appreciate that. Leaffilters technology keeps debris out of your gutters for good, guaranteed. What more could you ask for . Call 833. Leaf. Filter today, or visit leaffilter. Com. Today we got another sign that inflation may be cooling down the u. S. Inflation rate is now at 2. 5 . The lowest we have seen since february of 2021. That comes as the fed is expecting to cut Interest Rates later this month. The economy, of course, why did they not talk about the economy. Turn up the volume it was the first question at last Nights Debate and no surprise they clashed over their plans and how they are going to help voters, watch this. Donald trump has no plan for you. And when you look at his economic plan it is all about Tax Breaks for the richest people. What the Warton School has said, Donald Trumps plan would explode the deficit. I went to the Warton School of finance and many of the professors, top professors think my plan is a brilliant plan, a great plan, a plan that will bring up our worth, our value as a country. Do you believe americans can afford higher prices because of tariffs . They will not have higher prices. Who will have higher prices is china and all of the countries ripping us off for years. I intend to create an opportunity economy. Investing in small businesses, in new families, in what we can do around protecting seniors. He loves the word many. It needs to be the drinking, many, many. We need to discuss it, two friends of mine. Editor of the financial times and former Wall Street Banker turned journalist, peter, there is good news on inflation. Things still cost a lot, right . The average thing you want to buy is still 20 higher than where it was a few years ago. Car insurance, homeowners insurance, crippling. That is why it is a hard question. The first Question Harris got asked. Are you better off . It is hard to say yes because it is complicated despite all of this good news what is going to change that . I dont think there is enough time, frankly. It was, the weakest bit of her debate the first question as you said, first 10 or 15 minutes i thought it was the weakest response, because it is tough for her. Even though inflation is coming down it hits the Working Class voters the most. Not just car insurance, groceries, we have done polling for the last year. It is eggs, meat, those are the things people are complaining about. I think it is too late. What she needed to do, she did it by The End of the day is change the subject. I dont happening the economy is a winner for her even though inflation two months before inflation. It might not be a winner for her it could potentially been a winner for trump but did not. His plan is tariffs but it will worsen inflation, bill. I dont understand. We need tariffs because i learned during covid we dont make chips here. Yes, that is why we put together the 53 Billion Chips App it was a potential weakness for her but trump made it weaker for himself. And sites going to warton and many professors, a tariff is a tax on the american people. The american people are going to pay that tariff, not china, not the people who he is slapping the tax on. So, it is a combination of his inability to actually understand economics. He is talking about reducing taxes, you know, the corporate Income Tax from 21, already incredibly low, did that in his first term, i think it was a big mistake. Now lower to 15. He will cut off taxes on tips, okay. Fine, taxes on social security, okay, fine. But then somehow at the same time he is reducing taxes everywhere, he is also going to finally focus on the national debt . No one is. That is kind of my question. But why does he is a he is going to . Why does he pretend he will focus on it when he raised the national debt 8 Trillion . Did you just ask peter and i why trump . We only have 10 minutes to go. We can not help you with that. Do the american people not care about the deficit, and trumps will balloon it and harris will raise it they said they did. At some point the markets will care about the deficit. I spent six years in europe, at some point the market says your levels are so high we will not fund you or high rates and that is bad for everyone. Suddenly my Mortgage Rate goes up and Credit Card rates go up. At some point the markets will say i will not fund the american government and No One, this used to be a republican issue, right . This is the key party issue. Yes. Oh, no, peter. You are forgetting. We used to know. It is all gone. You are forgetting at some point the markets will react but the key is at some point we live in a world of shortism. Lawmakers do not think it will happen on their watch. Do you think Last Night her performance changed Anybodys Mind . Elon musk. And talking about her performance exceeding most peoples expectations. What i remember learning from my sources over the last two weeks we dont know her. We dont know how she could lead. She had a commanding performance Last Night. My sources were not taking my calls today. How about you . Well, look, i think you got 20 who are just totally in the tank for trump no matter what he says or does if it is for their own political aspirations or wallet or they are plenty rich already and dont need another Tax Cut or the extension of the trump Tax Cuts, that is 20 of Wall Street. If you are super, super rich one thing you dont have under your tree is power, and Donald Trump will give it to you this christmas. Oh, please. [ laughter ] next. But then, 80 of Wall Street, the Rank And File are democrats. I think they were really excited and happy about her performance. I agree with you. I am hearing the same thing. Also this fencesitters the middle ground. On Wall Street i dont think there are anymore they did not like biden, they did not like biden because lets be honest his administration the fcc, now, i think he was pushing them even though they were holding their nose to trump. Harris have a record in northern california. He is antibusiness no regulation, he is st. Business he is antibusiness and regulation look at the economy for four years. Maybe the last two democratic president s, Barack Obama and clinton i would say his record is much tougher On Business than either of those. Well, Barack Obama was very tough On Business, Wall Street did not like Barack Obama. The economy, our economy is one of the strongest in the world coming out of covid and the Stock Market which i know lots of people on Wall Street really like, okay, it is at an all time high and it continues to gain strength even in the face of rising Interest Rates which i have to say frankly it was about time that Interest Rates were risen because they were held low for 13 years and thank goodness they are allowed to be more yes, everybody is going to the Punch Bowl and having a great safety net. I know we dont have time. It does not have to be be Labor Or Business and good night to both of you when we come back or snobs and good night to both of you when we come back. We have to talk about one of the darkest mosts in history. Still uniting us after 23 years. We will take a moment to pause, love and remember September 11 love and remember September 11 you know whats brilliant . Boring. Think about it. Boring is the unsung catalyst for bold. What straps bold to a rocket and hurtles it into space . Boring does. Boring makes vacations happen, early retirements possible, and startups start up. Because its smart, dependable, and steady. All words you want from your bank. For nearly 160 years, Pnc Bank has been brilliantly boring so you can be happily fulfilled. Which is pretty unboring if you think about it. Thursday Night Football on prime. Its on. Ready to have some fun . Its buffalo versus miami, as Thursday Night football is back. Afc East Division rivals battle it out, in a highpowered Offensive Showdown you wont want to miss. What a catch its Josh Allen and the bills, unreal versus tua and the dolphins. Stream Thursday Night football. Only on prime. man these men of means with their silver spoons. What will become of them when they discover robinhood gold allows others to earn their very liberal rates on idle cash . They would descend into chaos. Ed gutters. Call leaffilter today. And never clean out clogged gutters again. Leaffilters technology keeps debris out of your gutters for good. Guaranteed. Call 833. Leaf. Filter today, or visit leaffilter. Com. Guaranteed. This one is for you. This one requires a big deep breath. The last thing before we go tonight. We are remembering to never forget. Today marks 23 years since the September 11 Terrorist attacks. Memorials were held today in new York City, shanksesville, pennsylvania and at the pentagon. Here are some of the services. [singing] seven crewmembers fought as one that morning preventing flight 93 from reaching the united states capitol. Saving an untold number of people. We honor their actions as a display of unity, courage and defiance. Every day we serve in the only surviving buildings struck by Al Qaida on September 11. We carrys powerful sense of service. We are the united states of america. We do not bend to