Now closed, a beloved Birmingham oyster dive and burger bar looks toward the future Updated Feb 06, 2021; Facebook Share The night before their last day of dining room service on New Year’s Eve, the staff at Fancy’s on 5th weren’t focused on planning a grand New Year’s Eve toast, nor had they even planned a special celebratory menu. The plan that night would be “dinner as usual,” restaurant owners Paget Pizitz and Harriet Reis told AL.com in an interview the evening before New Year’s Eve. “We’re not doing anything special for New Year’s Eve other than what we do every day, which is tremendously special,” Pizitz said in late December.