The Anti Self-Care Hero We Need This Week Mamamia Out Loud ADVERTISEMENT Before she got her part as Brooke in One Tree Hill, Sophia Bush had to audition three times. The first time Bush auditioned for the role, she was rejected for not being "sexy enough". When she auditioned for a second time, she was rejected for being "too sexy". After finally landing the part following a third audition, Bush appeared in more episodes in the series than any other cast member. A Michael Jordan connection. As much of One Tree Hill's plot centred on basketball, it's no surprise that the show has a connection to basketball legend Michael Jordan.