Schlichter CHICAGO – U.S. Seventh Circuit appellate judges granted Apple immediate relief from Chief District Judge Nancy Rosenstengel’s order remanding privacy invasion claims to St. Clair County circuit court. On Jan. 22, they vacated the order and directed her to reconsider it in light of Townley v. Clearview, an opinion they issued on Jan. 14. They have issued six opinions on privacy of biometric information in two years, all on the jurisdictional question of standing to sue. A concurring judge found he couldn’t extract a rule from that line and wished the Supreme Court would repair its precedent. Under Article III of the Constitution, persons lack standing in federal court when asserting an interest or claiming an injury that all members of the public share.