People sitting in the waiting area all stood up at one time and turned and started running. It was chaos. It was mass chaos. Among the victims a 28yearold father of three yoind the police force a year ago. His fellow officers lining the streets saluting their fallen comrade. This guy was shooting. That poor woman that got off an elevator and nothing to do with nothing. All those officers that responded were heroes and they saved a lot of lives. We just dont know how much damage he was prepared to do. Bill mike tobin on scene this morning. The gunman identified as 32yearold juan lopez had a relationship with one of the victims. They had a conflict in the parking lot. Witnesses say at one point lopez was standing over her firing at close range and he continued into the hospital. Officer Samuel Jimenez new to the force. Three children at home received a call for an officer in need of help. Arrived on the scene and came under fire shortly after that. When they pulled up they heard the gunshots and they did what the heroic officers always do, they ran toward that gunfire. So they werent assigned to that particular call but they went because thats what we do. 25yearold, a pharmacist as the superintendent mentioned just got off the elevator and probably never knew what hit her when she was shot. The gunman was shot. Unclear if he was shot by police or turned the gun on himself. According to some radio traffic last night he had threatened to kill himself. Bill the first officer to die in the line of duty in chicago this year, right . Unfortunately it is fought. Chicago police are still mourning the death of commander paul bauer killed a few blocks from here last february. A foot chase with a man who lived there and the homeless man opened fire on the officer. The second officer killed. The mayor said it tears at the soul of the city. Bill a tough story from chicago. Three minutes past. Sandra breaking news on the border crisis. Obamaappointed federal judge ruling against President Trumps ban on asylum for immigrants who cross the border illegally as the Homeland SecurityDepartment Says more than 5 uncriminals have been traveling with the Migrant Caravan. Garrett teny is live from the white house now. What is the white house saying about this . So far neither the white house or department of Homeland Security have talked about the ruling. Were keeping a close eye on the president s twitter feed where he likes to weigh in this time of day. The aclu and center for Constitutional Rights sued the administration almost immediately after President Trump issued his proclamation on november 9 which prevented immigrants caught crossing the border illegally from being able to then claim asylum. In his ruling the federal judge said the president did not have the authority to change our asylum laws writing congress is clearly commanded in the immigration and naturalization act that any alien who arrives in the United States irrespective of their status may apply for asylum. Whether or not at a designated port of arrival. Whatever the scope of the president s authority he may not rewrite the immigration laws to impose a condition that congress has expressly forbidden. Thats important to note. This ruling is a temporary restraining order. This fight is not over. Both sides will come before the court to present their full arguments a month from now. Sandra the white house is also pushing back on reports about ivanka trumps use of a personal email. What are we learning . The Washington Post reported that she used a personal email address to conduct government business sending hundreds of emails last year using a private email account she shares with her husband, jared. She reportedly did this throughout much of last year before she was briefed on the rules. Youll remember on the campaign trail candidate trump was highly critical of Hillary Clintons use of a private email server. Critics are using that pointing to his daughters practices to call him a hypocrite. A spokesperson for ivanka says there are big differences saying to address misinformation being pedaled about mrs. Trumps personal email. She didnt create a private server in her house or office and the account was never transferred or house at trump organization, no emails were ever deleted. The spokesperson said ivanka explained her email use to white House Counsel and to congressional leaders last year after she was given this update on what these rules were and how she could follow them. Sandra thank you. Bill good to have you back, alan dershowitz. I feel like im going to law school today. Lets get through three of them. Ivanka trumps attorneys argue its not apples to apples. What do you make of that . I think its hypocrisy on parade. Each side uses whatever arguments they can to help and bolster their partisan position. Everybody uses private emails. We now have a list of probably a dozen people in public life who have used emails apparently ivanka trump used the emails only for scheduling purposes. There was no classified material. The emails are all preserved. Also owe a noon issue. Its partisan bickering. We should not be criminalizing the use of private emails either for Hillary Clinton on ivanka trump. Bill we need a better system. See if that happens. Democrats are arguing you need Senate Approval or whitaker to be the acting a. G. The white house says he is in a temporary position and by law can serve for up to 210 days. Even after that point you can argue whether he stays on longer. What do you make of that argument . I think you have to give the president some discretion to fill vacancies. He cant fill a vacancy pefrmly the day it occurs. Justice Thurgood Marshall when he was appointed for the court of appeals served as an interim judge for months before his appointment was confirmed. He had not been confirmed and he was serving as a judge. Throughout history from the founding weve had interim appointments. I agree that if the interim appointment goes on for a long period of time or if major irreversible decisions get made by a nonconfirmed interim appointee that can raise some constitutional questions. This lawsuit itself is much too broad in its scope challenging the very concept of an interim appointment for a nonconfirmed person. Bill let me read you what theyre arguing. Installing Matthew Whitaker defies constitutional law. Any viewer of School House Rock would recognize it. Americans prize the system of checks and balances. Im just a bill on capitol hill. School of rock. Well, i think i was in the school of harvard and not the school of rock for 50 years and never heard anybody complain about interim appointments. It is such a partisan attack. If this were a democrat president who made an interim appointment we wouldnt hear these senators complaining. It is completely partisan. Now, they have a point if it comes to serving for a long period of time but i suspect the president is anxious to make a Permanent Appointment and it will be up to the senate. If the senate takes a long, long time confirming as they have sometimes, then the interim appointment will last longer. Thats in the nature of things. And the constitution certainly doesnt preclude a president from making a shortterm temporary interim appointment. Bill topic three on immigration. You know this is red hot right now. A judge apparently agreeing with a democratic argument that you do not have to legally enter a port of entry in the United States in order to claim asylum. I think this law can be interpreted sometimes for different people from Different Countries from overseas. How do you see it, professor . I think he has the better of the argument, the judge does, on the statutory interpretation. There is nothing in the statute that suggests that the president has the authority to overrule congress. Now, all he has done is given an interim injunction and so im not sure how many people will be affected. Ultimately he has to make a final decision but you have to look at the statute. The president s authority is not a Constitutional Authority. It is limited by statute. If the statute permits Asylum Seekers to seek asylum even if they come in illegally, that statutory rule has to prevail. If the president doesnt like that rule he should go to congress and have Congress Change it. Bill to follow up on that reading from the associated press. President trump used the same powers it writes he used last year to impose a travel ban upheld by the u. S. Supreme court. I dont agree. I think its a different power. The president has Constitutional Authority to decide people cant come in from particular countries. Thats within his statutory authority. Thats part of the statute that authorizes the president to make those decisions. But there is no comparable provision in the asylum statute authorizing the president to make decisions changing the nature of asylum. It is a complicated and interesting statutory interpretation that could go either way. I think a judge to get an injunction temporarily is probably the right judicial decision to make. Well see what happens when the case goes to final resolution. It may get all the way up to the higher courts. Bill good stuff. Thank you for coming back today. Enjoy your thanksgiving. Well see where the arguments go. Next hour much more on this. Jonathan turley is our headliner. The question is top of the next hour whether or not turley agrees with dershowitz. Well find out next hour on that coming up. Sandra many different interpretations. After two recounts and countsless controversy florida finally making it official. Right now Election Officials are certifying the winners of the states most contentious Midterm Elections. More on the big announcement. Zbr President Trumps Approval Rating hitting a new high when it comes to the economy. Pulling off something his presented cess predecessors could not. Sandra heavy rain could promise relief from the Deadly California Wildfires but officials are bracing for a whole new set of dangers. Well have a live report from the ground straight ahead. Its scary, the fires, it was right behind us. Im trying to stay as strong as i can for them. It is really hard to do it. I really just want to break down and find a new place but it is really hard. This food truck is our baby. And like any baby, its loud, stressful and draining. And we love it. I refuse to let migraine keep me from saying. I am here. Aimovig, a preventive treatment for migraine in adults, reduces the number of monthly migraine days. For some, that number can be cut in half or more. The most common side effects are pain, redness or swelling at the injection site and constipation. Talk to your doctor about aimovig. And be there more. Bill polling numbers giving President Trump a bump when it comes to handling the economy. 53 , up from 50 if august. A if you high for the president. Art laffer, former reagan he we could be down 400 points in 15 minutes on the dow. What is this administration doing right on the economy and what accounts for 53 . Done almost everything right. The tax bill is spectacular, deregulation is wonderful. Paul as the head of the fed is terrific. You dont get better advisors that kudlow and mnuchin. What trump is trying to do is a work in progress on trade but it is where we were with reagan. If you remember in august of 1982, you were too young. But we hit the bottom of the stock market. It was really still very low in november but all the policies were in place came january 1, 1983 all of them took effect. The same thing is happening here. Trump doesnt have to do anything more for the economy. The economy bring it on. Bill rosecolored glasses from nashville, tennessee from art laffer. Reading from gallup, trumps last two ratings on handling the economy, 53 , are well above the average of 45 on the economic approval measure across president s from reagan through obama. He is reaching back in the 80s. You have the fed out there, art, you have the battle with china on tariffs. A lot of that is manmade. They are manmade in many ways. We have the problem with the fed as well. Remember paul vol ker dropped the Interest Rates dramatically. 21 1 2 prime Interest Rate when we came into office. The rates were dropping because of tight money. Everyone was worried the fed was going way too far and too tight. All the same head winds occurred with us. We lost the Midterm Elections in november of 1982 badly to the democrats. Reagans approvals were very low and then we had this boom, january 1st, 1983 to june 30th, 1984. We grew by 12 at an 8 annual rate in real gdp. Amazing. By november of 1984, we had won reelection by beating mondale 49 to 50. A landslide. Reagans world. All the deck has been set. All i can say to anyone is bring it on. Just sit, hold tight and you will see whether this stuff works. Bill here is what i read after the midterms. No new tax cut package that will pass or happen. So what is the best arrow in the quiver . The tax bill itself. These things take time. Weve dropped the highest rate from 35 to 21 . We dropped the personal income from 37. Passthrough cuts. 100 expenseing. They are all in place. Look at the gdp numbers and employment numbers. Theyre coming true. It takes time, bill. What well see is the next two years we have plenty of time to see whether it works. If it doesnt well get shell acted. If it does well win a landslide in 2020. Bill you wonder if the economy is in shape without the tariff battle. I know what you are talking about gdp. Some are wondering if the 4 or 3. 5 is the occasional spike and the 2 is the norm established over the last 8 or 10 years. Thats what they say. Amazing how the spike comes after we pass the bill. Well see whether its just a passing fancy or whether its real. I believe that the economy is set for Enormous Growth over the next two or three years and i think it will happen and if im wrong, im wrong. Ive been wrong before and im much better at forecasting the past than the future but im very comfortable with the position President Trump is it. Bill good to see you. Have a great turkey day. Bill thank you, art, talk to you. Sandra 16 House Democrats are vowing to vote against nancy pelosi for speaker of the house. Our ateam will take that one up and theyre on deck. Were awaiting the u. S. s official report on the murder of saudi columnist Jamal Khashoggi. Well tell you what the white house is now saying. The president said it is a complete tragedy. Looking for answers and directed everybody to get the answers including the secretary of state almost immediately following the murder. If youre waiting patiently for a liver transplant, it could cost you your life. Its time to get out of line with upmc. At upmc, livingdonor transplants put you first. So you dont die waiting. Upmc does more livingdonor liver transplants than any other center in the nation. Find out more and get out of line today. This is moving day with the best inhome wifi experience and millions of wifi hotspots to help you stay connected. And this is moving day with Reliable Service appointments in a twohour window so youre up and running in no time. Show me decorating shows. This is staying connected with xfinity to make moving. Simple. Easy. Awesome. Stay connected while you move with the best wifi experience and twohour appointment windows. Click, call or visit a store today. Bill Stormy DanielsAttorney Michael Avenatti responding to reports that an actress filed a restraining order against him days after avenatti was detained by police on Domestic Violence charges. He responded to all of it in a tweet saying ive never abused a woman or committed Domestic Violence. He said its bogus and fabricated. Im a target and will be exonerated. It was not immediately clear if the actress was the same woman who accused him of Domestic Violence a week ago. Sandra fox news alert on the deadly fires in northern california. Rescue crews working against the clock sifting through debris and rubble searching for any victims before heavy rains move in. Now new threats of flash flooding and massive mudslides. 82 people confirmed dead statewide. 700 still unaccounted for. Meanwhile survivors are returning to their homes or whats left of them. It is just two really nice houses well built by me and thats the only thing sticking up is the melted refrigerator. I dont have enough time left on the planet to ever have it again and thats pretty hard to take. Sandra were live in chico, california. Claudia. Good morning, sandra, thousands of fire evacuees are waking up at shelters like this one in chico. This morning were at the east Avenue Church and donated supplies helping 200 people who for now are living in the gym here. These folks are getting medical attention and trying to stave off an outbreak of norovirus going around. Two more sets of human remains increasing the deaths from the camp fire to at least 79. The number of those unaccounted for has dropped to 700. Search crews warn some people may never be found due to the intensity of the flames. With evacuation orders now being lifted in some areas around paradise residents are returning to sift through the rubble of what used to be their home. The states insurance commissioner says the losses are staggering. In 2017 from all the california fires there was 12. 6 billion in insured losses. Th