Senate confirmation running an agency as politically electric as the epa is. They dont want to get four confirmations for four slots, and before major election season, scrambling to have a cabinet that is functioning, trying to keep the seats warm. Part of the reason he has been able to hang on as long as he has. As the shoe drops, there will be more pruit stories, it will make it tough to last as long as he has. Emelba marcos here. He said this on air force one on thursday. I think scott has been a fantastic job. I think he is a fantastic person. They lost scott pruit. They feel strongly about him and love scott pruit. Coal and energy. Reuters, 25 more Industry Leaders than advocates. Add that to coal representatives. Yes, i think that certainly, the politics of trump trying to revive the dying coal and Energy Industry plays into this. What is more important is what he said about scott pruits effectiveness. The advocate shows how ineffective he has been. A lot of his actions tied up in the courts, the repeal of obamas clean power plant, and the withdraw from the accord, that he pushed the president to do, cant be done until the day before the 2020 election. He hasnt done a lot to damage the environment y he has threatened to do so. Put a lot of balls in the air. I definitely dont think that he is as effective as the president seems to understand. Then, there is the interview he did on fox with ed henry. By many expert watchers such as the three of you, could have gone better. This president watches these sorts of interviews and makes big evaluations on his team based on those performances. If the performance wasnt good, that is another reason why mr. Pruit may not be there that long. The president does watch these performances, one thing that filled other Trump Officials is flying too close to the sun. Getting too much attention and seeking the limelight, which President Trump likes to preserve for himself. One thing is how similar scott pruit is to the arc of price. Who was felled by ethics scandals, it start wide one, and kemt getting bigger and bigger, the white house went to defending him, to ultimately, he was fired. I think the president takes this stuff seriously. He is caught between a conservative base that very much likes scott pruit. And his work product, the way the white house put it likes the fact that he is moving forward with a deregulation agenda, as various reporters have raised. The senate calendar, is jam packed with executive and judicial nominees, an epa chief that can get in a 51vote Republican Senate will be a difficult proposition. That is what betsy was talking about, too. That is the question, with republicans starting to come out and say, this isnt good. Gaudy, from south carolina, the u. S. Autohouse oversight chairman, how much energy is there behind the lets see how we can correct this pruit problem from the right . How much energy on the right is there . On the right in movement. Conservative circle, despite all the headlines we have seen, there is broad deepseeded support for pruit. I am not talking about voters, but conservative elite, the people who run organizations, the people who plan rallies, put together events, some of those movers and shakers, the cpack, they like his conservative, right wing, when it comes to environmental issues, upwards of 100 conservative movement people, prominent folks who run others and are involved, signed a letter supporting pruit. The president is getting phone calls, outside of the white house, saying stand by your man, scott pruit is only under attack, but there is a leftish Conspiracy Theory to try to take scott pruit down. There is a countering force, the staff in the white house themselves. They are frustrated with pruit. Less than forth right about stories coming out about him. And the facts related to the scandal that is have emerged. The question is, which force at the end of the day, is the most impactful . The folks on the right in the white house frustrated by pruit. Or the conservative movers who see him as one of their own. 15 second, a new development, jonathan swans reporting on john kelly, chief of staff. Blowing up, unhappy, muttering or saying underneath his breath he may or may not quit. Your reaction . I think that there is a lot of motivation on his part to leak that a lot of outrage in this white house. I take it with a grape of salt unless he is it willy willing to do it. President trump is his chief of staff and Communications Director all in one. The purpose of that job is to set up everybody, including the president of the United States follows, donald trump does not do that. Kelly has threatened or suggested he wanted to quit. I would take it with a grain of salt. Thank you so much for trying to get all of that into the seven minutes at the top of the hour. Good to hang out with you. New details this hour on breaking news from germany. Police in the city of munster ruling out terrorism in this incident, a van blowed into a crowd, leaving three dead. 30 injured. Police say the deceased suspect was a germanborn citizen. As for a motive. The man was suicidal. Looking for mental illness, and any ties he may have to a right wing extremist group. Who threatened Stormy Daniels . Her lawyer said there is a thug who scared her to keep silent. And what could help her case. After careful consideration of your application, it is with great pleasure that we offer our congratulations on your acceptance. Through the Tuition Assistance program, every day mcdonalds helps more people go to college. Its part of our commitment to being americas best first job. When this guy got a flat tire in the middle of the night, so he got home safe. Yeah, my dad says our insurance doesnt have that. What . you can leave worry behind when liberty stands with you™. Liberty mutual insurance. Afi sure had a lot on my mind. My 30year marriage. My 3month old business. Plus. What if this happened again . I was given warfarin in the hospital, but wondered, was this the best treatment for me . So i made a point to talk to my doctor. He told me about eliquis. Eliquis treats dvt and pe blood clots and reduces the risk of them happening again. Not only does eliquis treat dvt and pe blood clots. Eliquis also had significantly less major bleeding than the standard treatment. Eliquis had both. And that turned around my thinking. Dont stop eliquis unless your doctor tells you to. Eliquis can cause serious and in rare cases fatal bleeding. Dont take eliquis if you have an artificial heart valve or abnormal bleeding. If you had a spinal injection while on eliquis call your doctor right away if you have tingling, numbness, or muscle weakness. While taking eliquis, you may bruise more easily. And it may take longer than usual for bleeding to stop. Seek immediate medical care for sudden signs of bleeding, like unusual bruising. Eliquis may increase your bleeding risk if you take certain medicines. Tell your doctor about all planned medical or dental procedures. Eliquis treats dvt and pe blood clots. Plus had less major bleeding. Both made eliquis right for me. Ask your doctor if switching to eliquis is right for you. Stormy daniels attorneys attorney is taking a victory lap right now, following the president s first public remarks about his client. Up until a few days ago, he showed great restraint and discipline. We knew that was never going to last. Low and behold he cracked and made statementos air force one. We dont think there is any question, there is no agreement. This latest back and forth, the president broke his surveillance and knew nothing about his attorneys 130,000 alleged hush money payment to daniels. Today, a major announcement in the coming days regarding the efforts of the person they claimed daniels. Well, cohen said he used his own personal funds to make the pay out to daniels, neither the trump or Trump Campaign was involved. He dies threatening daniels. Here to talk about this, Jennifer Rubin opinion writer for the washington post. And jennifer, what do you make of what he said, a victory lap, if you will, expect more to come. And the president finally saying something. If you watch the tape, which you have probably many times, he didnt seem comfortable answering that question. Right, i think it was interesting that he seemed to almost be taken off guard. He has studiously avoided commenting at all on the topic. It was interesting that he refused to xhenlt on the last question the reporter asked, that was, is there an slush fund for the hush money. That is something that many of us are interested to find out. Was this a oneshot deal or has trump had many women s there a pool of money that Michael Cohen has presided over. As far as the promise of information on the threat, michael avonatti is a good public lawyer. Good at getting in under the president s skin. And presenting the videotape as if we were going to get Video Evidence of the affair, for the 60 minutes interview. Lets see what he has to say. If there is kexz to the Trump Organization that is extremely serious. At this point, he is doing a good job keeping his client in the news and keeping trump on the defensive. Screaming from the mountain tops, in this case. There is a question about the slush fund. Where did the money come from. There is, according to a memo obtained by cnn earlier this week, regarding a payment from First Republic bank. Where did the money come from, what is the history . There is clear data behind every payment that flows from one place to another. Add that to the pot here. Nobody believes that Michael Cohen paid personally for this. If there was an Illegal Campaign contribution from trump enterprises, from another place we dont know about it. It is an illegal contribution. If it came from trump business enterprises, that is where the problem is here. Again. The other thing i want to make a point in says, President Trump, yes, he did comment on this for the first time yesterday it is one thing if he lies to reporters and the media, saying i dont know where the payment came from. It is another thing if he is lying under oath in deposition. Is he going to get to depose trump. Thank you. U. S. And china. How the tariffs could affect the u. S. Consumer. Welcome back to msnbc live. As trade tensions with china rock the markets, steel and aluminum, it was canada, the top exporter of steel and aluminum to the u. S. Hit the hardest. The president granted exemptions. Largely targeted china. China responded with tariffs on 3 billion on goods, that is expected to trickle down to consumers. And the u. S. Announced 50 billion on chinese goods, and china announced 50 billion in tariff, keeping the shoving match alive. Some farmers expressed fears about the Financial Impact of the tariffs, many are economically vulner able. The trump mmpgz said it was considered 100 billion on chinese experts, no words on what products would be targeted. China said it will fight as any cost. For now, u. S. Stocks are taking a dive, the dow, s p and nasdaq, all red. Ambassador, thank you for being with us. When you look at what is going back and forth here, one has to ask, on the other side, who is ping in china, what does he want out of this. When you see his reactions to president s call for more tariffs, what are you seeing it . China is going to retaliate. China cannot be viewed as backing down or appearing weak. They have gained stature internally and internationally. They will hit back hard. Unfortunately, in a trade war, both sides will lose. Consumers and workers. It will be especially hard on American Consumers and American Companies. When you look at what he may do next, he is an individual that can implement tariffs as he chooses, basically, the United States is different. Although the president does have the ability, because of National Security to implement the tariffs, congress can pass legislation to stop this ability. It is different there, in china. We will have to wait to see what the Trump Administration is imposing, in subject of the tariffs, a surcharge or tax on chinese goods coming into the United States. Able to give back, they dont have to buy american products, if they levee tariffs on soy beans, they. With respect, if we want to not buy shoes at macys or nordstroms, what is our choice . Buy 500 shoes made in italy . All microwaves are only made in china. What choice do we have . Eat the cost, pay more out of their pocket, which means less money for vacations, retirement, buying an automobile, or saving for college education. Why did china target soy beans . Looking at the back and forth. If the United States, if there is improvement for opportunity on center, is tht right way to go about it. With the negotiations this is largely done behind the shiny bright spaces we are discussing now, trade. They know that soy beans, are grown by the supporters of the Trump Administration. Hitting hard, agriculture. Backers of the president. And pressure on the Trump Administration. I come from the state of washington, Eastern Washington is have they openly discussed the dismay of what tariffs will do to their backers of President Trump. China does not have to buy american soy bean, brazil has hey surplus. They can buy from brazil. The ta rives wont hurt the chinese economy. They can find substitutes. Tariffs on goods coming from china, that American Consumers will have to pay. There arent many substitutes. American consumers will have to pay more, and many are used by American Companies in manufacturing, and building. Their final product will be more expensive. Marking it hard to sell in competition with canada, germany or australia or uk. Whether they try to sell it here or overseas. Former commerce sect lock, thank you for stopping by. You have been talking about this for weeks, i should say. N now. Right now, two leaders are saying this. If you do this i am going to do this. There has been an argument this is part of a fully thought out strategy. I dont think wall street believes that like myself, dont believe it is tackical, it is quite impulsive. That is three times the economic harm his own administration leveed on the u. S. , that is in violation of world trade rules, i dont think the president cares about that. When you publicly humiliate an asian leader, it is more forceful than if you have a negotiation. They came in in private negotiations, heavy handed to start. That set the tone. You are an expert of market, you saw the three arrows going down, babounsed back up. By the end of the week. Yes. How real is this . It is there is a possibility relations deteriorate with canada and mexico. And nafta. And some fear the u. S. May pull out. The far left leading candidate in mexico, if he won the president ial election in july, building become adversarial. One word answer, no wins in a trade war. Who wins more in this back and forth here . I saw one paper said that we would lose 1. 3 gdp, the rest of the world would suffer, everybody loses it could mean global recession. The high priest of this sort of stuff. President trump is sending members of the National Guard to secure the border. Who is funding all of this . Only invisalign® clear aligners are made with smarttrack® material to precisely move your teeth to your best smile. See how invisalign® treatment can shape your smile up to 50 faster today at invisalign. Com could Michaela Deprince use the chase mobile app to pay practically anyone, at any bank, all while performing the grandest grand jete . She could. But in real life she pays her sister, for that sweater she stained. phone buzzes chase. Make more of whats yours. Texas is the first state to call for tighter security. 250 National Guard personnel, headed for the mexico u. S. Border, tweeting, we are sealing up our sournl border, the people of our great country want safety and security. It has been a disaster on this very important issue. Mary jennings combat veteran and democratic candidate for congress in texas. Mj, what do you make of this call for 4,000 National Guard working along with Border Patrol agents . Hi, richard. I think it is disturbing on a couple of levels, many pointed to the fact that it is a waste of resources. There is not an army intending us harm. It is manufacture a humanitarian issue. I was called up for a number of missions, hurricane relief, three towers in afghanistan. It is largely will people with full time jobs and families. We stand ready to answer the nations call. What we expect in return, in that willingness to leave our lives behind is that those decisions are made in critical situations, where there is no other option. How does from your understanding in talking from other National Guard personnel, how does the National Guard coordinate with Border Patrol and ice with a presence there. Three years on the task force in california. I think that military works well with lawsuit. We always are uneasy, when there is demilitarization on american soil. I think there is a hes tanzy to, especially going into something that is openended the way this s i have heard things from National Guard troops there until a wall is built, that has not been funded. We are sick of being called up for suspicious missions with openended time lines. You are running for congress, are you one of the 309 women running, alltime record in our great country. Tell me what your view is on the National Guard politically, what you would like