There is a number of interesting things here and think there are quite interesting for dbi, particularly at page 592. Dbi requirements. Dbi would require that the detail geotechnical reportthis is not 301 mission, this is transbay. Report address the potential settlement of impact of excavation dewater. The report include determination bl a Lateral Movement and settlement survey of adjacent streets during construction. If a Monitoring Survey were recommended department of public works require a special inspector be retained. It goes onif you can wait one second mr. Brigs. Mr. Hui, relative to dbi requirements in the eir for transbay, do you know who in your department is in charge of that . I wasnt involved at all. I think it [inaudible] presumably this requirement is ongoing right now. I think [inaudible] hired their own consultant. I only doing the plan check in charge of the plan check for them. So, the watering is not in my area of expertise. I appreciate your candor, mr. Tomthis is Pretty Amazing and deputy City Attorney gibbener in so far this is the subject of years of litigation, let me just read what it says page 590. Ground settlement could result from eccavation of subservice parking oreb basement level from construction and heave during installation of pime squz long term dewatering. These potential effects are described below followed be department of building inspection procedures in place to insure unstables conditions do note result. This is mitigation section of the eir. They didnt get the memo. That is abendantly claer. The head of the department never hurbd of this. It says they are responsible for monitoring the groundwaterdewaltering. As a matter of fact, when dewatering happens, a permit has to be obtained from the puc to discharge the water into the citys waste water system for which uc gets reports and the eir says they will get reports and found the dewatering report for 350 mission and says here we reviewed your application for a banch waste water permit and says to discharge 5 million gallons of water and requires reports. Interestly enough rks the puc charges them for putting that water in the waste water system. Same with 101 first street. What i cant find and found correspondence is the dewatering records for the building of the Salesforce Tower at transbay. What i have been able to find is a series of emails that indicate that the monthly reports have not been forthcoming for some 15 months. I see emails from brian coon to the contractor saying that they meter broken and going on for a long time. I dont think mr. Brigser are you in a position to answer this . Do you know anything about that . I am looking at the same corresponds nss. As far as i know we dont have it data but requested it. But as the permitting agency, when i read the permitatize says if you dont get what you want you can cancel the permit. Dbi has certain rights. Given that all this is happening right now in the realtime and building is continuing to sink you think that somebody somewhere in this government other than a member of the legislative branch of government or supervisor breed and i have the ability to ask you lots of questions, we dont have the ability to tell you what to do, but somebody needs to get this thing under control. There are all these moving pieces whether it is lateral or dewatering. Here are the documents that say dbi is charged with looking at the dewatering comprehensively and yet dbi doesnt know that. I guess we have to get transbay in here too. Anyway, if you can follow up on that and do what you should be doing that would be helpful. Point well taken, and any members the public who like to testify on item 5 . Please come forward, maam. Some day well get to the bottom of this. Go ahead. Hello supervisors peskin and others. My name is Janet Campbell a architect trained at georgia tech and mba in real estate and have 38 years of experience in architectural and real estate development. I came to shed loithd on what i have seen over the past 17 years within the planning and building and other departments. In 49 states the lines of responsibility to produce plans is not allowed. Architects Structural Engineer and contractorerize notd allowed to practice each other profession. They use a standard orphdue care particular to their profession for the life, safety and welfare the public including financial with regards to those who hold loans on such properties. In all such places in california an earthquake country those lines have been blurred. Architects and engineer can practice each others professions. Further, while the license laws are clear who can and cannot practice architectural and engineering, time and again we see paper napkin like drawings taken in against license law jz approved oner commercial space or residential propertys with multiple units. Against the law and in multiple departments. Why in the hell does this hap snn we see [inaudible] expediteers who discuss properties with planning and building and other personnel representing clients against license laws. We see restaurants biltd biment without plans and appropriate permits and contractors crowing in emails how they got her done. The afect is brutal on a number of my clients. Because of illegal units at least twof my clients are stuck in a round hell based the biing prices through clueless realsters with mortjudges on the income. Hin one case approved and bought by my clients been to directors hearing and lean against their property and unable to sell or refinance. Another client found her self represented by a expediter who represented the landlord rchlt sijeed a commercial lease prior to hiring me and when i go go to into the project found no way to accom daitd a exist. She losti prevented a number oaf other clients fraup similar mistakes, if they get to me soon enough. I have a list of items that i have given you that could be changed. Thank you mrs. Campbell and in receipt of your written statement and gave a copy to had clerk so will be a part the official proceedings of this committee. Thank you for your comments. Any other members here for Public Comment . Seeing none, well close Public Comment. Supervisor breed. Without objection we will continue this item to call of the chair. Thank you all very much for coming and before i see my doctor who just walked in, would anybodywe got a quick closed litigation session before supervisor breed has to split. Deputy City Attorney gibbener. Mr. Chair, if i may we do need to call the item 6 through aithd settlement of lawsuit filed by First National insurance for 405 thousand. 7, is ordinance setment of lawsuit fideitem 8 settlement filed by bhr opraigds for 169, 263, 18 i dont think we need to go into closed session, so if is there a member of the public who would like to comment on 6 through 8 . Seeing none my doctor doesnt want to comment. Public comment is closed and without objection we send the ord nnsss and one resolution to full board with recommendation without objection and no more business before this panel and we are adjourned. Welcome all of im more and more reign the ceo of had been coat in the city of San Francisco and ill be your mc today calling names im super proud to be an equation part to sfmade to help keep homes in San Francisco i served as the president and ceo of goodwill in San Francisco one of sfmade long standing work patrons before that i came to know and love sfmade work when i feels regional Vice President of the foods the leading measures of heath foods for kids in the bay area and reaching millions of kids across the United States everyday calling names so with xooichlt and appreciation of the value of having a strong moufr that or manufacturing that creates worldclass products and thousand of jobs for us in the bay area an honor to be our host for today, this is an exciting culmination of work we sfmade in partnership with the San Francisco surfacing and fremont and oakland to highlight 89 facilities and talk about ways to be work more diligently look around were in a building with bones were built from manufactured and manufacturing is programs for the future as part of the work at pier 70 thank you forest city for providing 2, 3, 4 space today as i look out i see dozens of Community Partners whove made this possible from government leaders to nonprofits panders to our media sponsors the San Francisco businesses a private sector partners that is an few minutes ago and releasing and technology and so many of the manufacturing that themselves together you represent the eco system in the bay area that can drive a powerful Manufacturing Sector in doing so create a platform for more inclusive and equitable economy to start our program im so pleased to bring to the stage one felt presenting sponsors the Vice President of Community Service for pg e. clapping. the Vice President of Customer Service for the operations for local customers and Customer Service and Customer Relations in addition oversees Customer Account management and other sales as well as nonproducts and Services Welcome deb. clapping. hi, everyone id like to echo more and more reigns comments and welcome and thank you for supporting sfmade states of regional manufacturers in our world event im honored to be part of todays program and excited to continue the collaborative effort to support the bay area in the development of manufacturing jobs in california as more and more reign alluded to my role of Vice President of pg e has given me the unique opportunity to see the contribution of the bay area Manufacturing Sector bags or beer and tesla electrical cars bay area manufactured are not only making but making a difference by drinking jobs, resources and innovation to our Community Since the 1970s pg e has worked to help Companies Save money by saving energy per Capital Energy consumption staying flat and increased by 50 percent in the rest of the country we know that companies that save energy that translates into more turned out for businesses and their future committees down the road pg e working closely with all of our customers to design and implement Energy Efficiency programs and policies that allow businesses to do more with less Energy Saving money and helping to protect the environment we help local businesses mediated the Energy Challenges maximizing the return on their Energy Investment thats why we believe so strongly in the Bay Area Urban Manufacturing Initiative linking together san jose San Francisco oakland and fremont that will be a critical driver of the future of the bay area manufacturing and the jobs it provides in our business when the Community Thrives and grows our companies has opportunity to thriving and good grow along with that we dont succeed unless you succeed pg e is proud to creating a more sustainable through local manufacturing i look forward to seeing all the great things that sfmade will bring to the by way of with that, i thank you for your suppo support. clapping. thank you deb and not were not able to bring all the bay area manufactured were excited to see what is happening in manufacturing and the leaders that are shaping it take a look at this so my vision for this region is a recentury equitable thriving region we have to have all types of jobs all types of people we have to have an inclusive equitable economy we have all sorts of opportunities we will not concealing chief this vision unless we grow and support our Manufacturing Sector when were all thinking about how to make sure that our diverse populations get a chance at sharing prosperity in the region it cant be solely a discussion about the Technology Industry it has to be about what people not once you enter into the diversity you understand there are different groups and countries a lot of them of immigrant but fantastic people that understand how to make things the bay area urban manufacturing is the next step in the evolution of our Regional Manufacturing system theyll harness the collective pour across the regional each working to help manufacturing start grow and stay in their communities. Employers a recognizing the proximity between manufacturing and seeing a lot of this in manufacturers trying to take advantage of that. You know fremont is not unique in the sense many all the employers want a well educated workforce ive seen first hand the College Changes the curriculum they partner with the larger employers and basically is a what do you need our skills our students need to make sure they can work in Great Companies like you. With manufacturing it is to the best of my knowledge the workforce training is critical and that didnt happen in one decide but across the entire region. We are interimmigrant region so i really enjoyed working with my mayor in a fremont and san jose and San Francisco we rails when is if job balance and transportation and infrastructure and just making sure that our reason as a whole is competitive on the International Scale we have to Work Together. I know that is important to know how connected we are several companies have a factory in one city and corporate in other places and in another city not seeing the aide boundaries you and i see validated. You think there is a reputation in the world ive had people come off of their planes from china what do you make here he want to buy there theres a sense of high quality it is a reflection of the, fact that our reputation is as San Francisco in the bay area is world recondones our innovation and quality there are many challenges for every city in a transmittal it make sense for us as we hear about companies from by the way, braid for us to be engaged with one another and important to Work Together we are offering the best in the bay area to employ our residents. Were in together join the bay area urban manufacturing and help us create a more equitable and Prosperous Bay area clapping. next im very exciting to welcome to the stage bob the director of City Community development and inclusive finance. Bob leads the partnership with the global and National Organization in support of inclusive finance and Community Development through Economic Empowerment focusing on assessable finance financial coaching and sf this and Neighborhood Revitalization sees to College Education and Small Business micro development with the citys micro finance and corporations and municipality working across the citys groups to expand access to Financial Services city was sfmade first institutional partner in 2012 and consisting been one of the lead partners manufacturing of accelerate programs as a presenting sponsor and incredibly amazing guy i i know you e bring you bob proud to support the region. clapping. i left it on my desk and can you hand media that Times Partnership hello, everyone it is a pleased to be here fantastic location thank you. This wonderful venue we was taking with adam from new york and thinking brooklyn would be jealous of the potential to develop here in San Francisco i wish you a lot of luck the city is involved in supporting sfmade and the whole urban Manufacturing Movement for some years and it is an exciting movement i know many of us watched the elections so alcohol know the loss of manufacturing job is not only one of lost jobs give you a political issue and within that concerns many, many of our community and how we replacing manufacturing jobs and not likely to be replaced in the forms they were like Ben Rosenfield steel supporting the navy arts but what can can be think internal work of many difference from small to Medium Enterprises the engines are growing and the way weve seen stunt and this region not just in the bay but we as a new yorker he speak about the bay area i speak about what city but we have four mayors offices an area that many of us look at the bay area will think of is h as progressive and entrepreneurial and this is what is so important that is a period of change were we worried many of us in terms of jobs and loss and creation this is a success that many of the entrepreneurs bring to our city is exciting for the jokes you create and exciting for the job recreation but for the stimulus you bring to the city and the ability to le