CSPAN Lamone V. Benisek Oral Argument July 14, 2024
Reverse and vacate for three reasons. The First Amendment retaliation test that was adopted fails to provide a manageable standard because it does not give courts and legislators the means to distinguish between excessive political consideration and those that have been deemed constitutionally acceptable. Was this a political consideration . I dont think it is, your honor. This is the norm where states receive one party receives more than 60 of the vote and congressional elections. If that is right in your defense is not really we cant tell the difference between and nonexcessive. To doly need...