தண்டனை வழிகாட்டல் News Today : Breaking News, Live Updates & Top Stories | Vimarsana

Stay updated with breaking news from தண்டனை வழிகாட்டல். Get real-time updates on events, politics, business, and more. Visit us for reliable news and exclusive interviews.

Top News In தண்டனை வழிகாட்டல் Today - Breaking & Trending Today

Sentencing Law and Policy: Split Eleventh Circuit panel rejects equal protection challenge to illegal reentry guideline


Yesterday the Eleventh Circuit handed down an interesting split panel opinion in
US v. Osorto, No. 19-11408 (11th Cir. April 20, 2021) (available here). These paragraphs from the start of the majority opinion provides a flavor for the issues and the court s holding:
Defendant-Appellant Juan Carlos Osorto was convicted of illegal reentry after the 2016 Guidelines went into effect.  Because he had committed other offenses both before his original deportation and after it, but before his current illegal-reentry offense, he received offense-level increases under both subsections 2L1.2(b)(2) and (3).  He now challenges both subsections as violations of, among other things, his equal-protection rights.  Osorto (and the Dissent) argue that these guidelines, which apply to only illegal-reentry offenses, discriminate against noncitizens by counting their prior convictions twice once in the offense level and a second time in the Guidelines’ criminal-history calculation. Mean ....

United States , Juan Carlos Osorto , Sentencing Commission , Eleventh Circuit , Appellant Juan Carlos Osorto , Judge Martin , Sentencing Guideline , Fifth Amendment , Due Process Clause , ஒன்றுபட்டது மாநிலங்களில் , தண்டனை தரகு , பதினொன்றாவது சுற்று , நீதிபதி மார்டின் , தண்டனை வழிகாட்டல் , ஐந்தாவது திருத்தம் , காரணமாக ப்ரோஸெஸ் உட்கூறு ,