Or should we get on with building the rail trail?
A new company, Northern Rivers Rail Ltd, has been established in an effort to get the Casino to Murwillumbah rail line reopened for trains.
They will host their first public meeting this week.
But the issue of what our rail corridor should be used for continues to divide our community.
On The Northern Star's Facebook page, readers were vocal with their opinions.
On the pro-train side, Doug Moses wrote: "I remember travelling from Murwillumbah on that train back in 1958. Train was ancient, carriage letting rain in everywhere, but the country scenery was beautiful, making it a thoroughly enjoyable journey. Wish the proposal well."