Transcripts For MSNBCW Andrea Mitchell Reports 20160114

Hewlett packard enterprise. Is youyou may be muddling through allergies. Lode . Try zyrtec®d to powerfully clear your blocked nose and relieve your other allergy symptoms. So, you can breathe easier all day. Zyrtec®d. At the pharmacy counter. Right now on Andrea Mitchell reports trump versus cruz. The frontrunners not very subtle dig at ted cruzs finances hours before their big showdown in charleston. I know nothing about it, but i hear its a very big thing. I hope he solves it. I think hes a nice guy. I hope he gets it solved. I just hope thats not a big problem for him. Those loans have been disclosed over and over and over again on multiple filings but all the information has been public and transparent for many years and thats the end of that. Changing the subject. Bernie sanders knew ad on wall street reform after Hillary Clinton hammered him on health care. Like me, no. Will they begin to play by the rules of our president . You Better Believe it. An msnbc exclusive. A man on death row for ten years finally set free, now in a big interview he opens up to msnbcs craig melvin. There are friends of yours that over that time period, you became friends and next thing you know they have been executed. That hurts. Good day. Im Andrea Mitchell in washington. With friends like these, who needs enemies . When donald trump isnt killing ted cruz with kindness, hes trying to sink the texas senators chances in iowa by keeping stories critical of cruz alive and putting doubt into the minds of cruzs conservative supporters. Joining me ahead of tonights big Republican Debate, nbcs Hallie Jackson and katy tur both in north charleston, South Carolina. Hallie, first to you. Lets talk about the problem that ted cruz has over this Goldman Sachs loan and how it conflicts with his own narrative of who he is and what hes trying to communicate to conservative iowa voters. Reporter right. This idea that hes this populist tea party crusader, this warrior, who rails against the big banks yet is taking loans from Goldman Sachs, citibank, loans he did disclose on his personal Financial Disclosures but not filed with the s. E. C. Something as you played ted cruz calls an inadvertent mistake, the campaign saying it is checking to see how to rectify this. The bottom line, this is something that yet again is knocking ted cruz off his message. Do you think he wants to be talking about this . No. Do you think he wants to be talking about the birther issue and other attacks from donald trump . No. He wants to be hitting his own message of constitutional conserco conservativism and instead hes trying to push back against this story that contradicts frankly or potentially could for voters his narrative. Of course, when we talk about donald trump and how he goes after people, nobody knows this better than you, katy, how has trump played this and tried to put cruz off his game given how closely tied they are in this polling in iowa . Reporter well, he doesnt stop talking about it. Thats his plan all along, to distract, distract, distract, keep the focus off donald trump and on to ted cruz, making voters question everything about him, question whether hes i believable to run for president , question whether or not the canadian birth is a real problem, question this loan and what it means to his back story. If he keeps raising these issues, he keeps trying to sow the seed of doubt within voters mind, paint him as somebody who is not necessarily a sure bet to win the general election if he faces Hillary Clinton or Bernie Sanders, that he is the one that will be a sure bet. He doesnt have these problems, doesnt have these issues. He will be the one that will be able to come out the victor. Ted cruz, who knows. He might not be able to even be eligible for president. This is the way trump responded to ted cruzs attacks that trump had quote, new york values. Does that seem like criticism to you . Do you embrace new york values . I embrace. Look, in new york we took a big hit with the world trade center. Worst thing ever. Worst attack ever in the United States. Worse than pearl harbor because they attacked civilians, they attacked people having breakfast and frankly, you know, if you would have been there and if you would have lived through that like i did with new york people, the way they handled that attack was one of the most incredible things that anybody has ever seen. When people want to knock new york, first of all, you shouldnt be doing it because you have a massive population there, but when you want to knock new york, you got to go through me. Really interesting to see this matchup. To both of you, hallie first, what do you expect tonight when they are standing side by side on the debate stage . Reporter yeah. Listen, i think that over the last week, we have been talking about the fact that this political bromance between the two has been crumbling. That said, i do think if the opportunity presents itself you will see ted cruz go after donald trump and reup this line of attack he has been testing out this week, this idea that donald trump has these new york values as you heard him respond there, this idea that donald trump is tied to Hillary Clinton supporters. That said, if trump stays back and doesnt come at cruz and if theres not an opportunity or moment that presents itself, i dont know that ted cruz will necessarily turn the barrels on donald trump unprompted. Katy, what are the chances trump wont go after him . Reporter well, trump has always said hes a counterpuncher, hes not going to be the one that attacks first. So we are going to see if he decides to do Something Different tonight and go after him. Of course, they are neck and neck in the polls in iowa and they do need to break away from each other, but theres an inherent risk involved that donald trump goes after ted cruz too hard, he might alienate some voters who are crossover voters between trump and ted cruz. Thanks to both much yoof you. We will be watching. Joining me for our daily fix, Washington Post editorial columnist ruth marcus, wall street journal Political Editor jean cummings. How big a problem is it for ted cruz to be acknowledging a Goldman Sachs loan, goldman and others saying it wasnt at a favorable rate but it was not disclosed in a timely way when it was supposed to be to the federal Election Commission and so he had to do an amendment on that, and it does undercut his whole narrative, i mortgaged everything in order to run for the senate, i put everything on the line. On the line with the backing of Goldman Sachs. We both used to cover money and politics and reality is, this is a transgression. Its a technical transgression. Its not fatal but its not the greatest time in the world for ted cruz to be talking about this and any time you are saying ted cruz and Goldman Sachs in the same sentence, its not the kind of campaign that he wants to be running right now. How many iowa voters, caucus goers, would have even known that his wife works for goldman . Absolutely. That, he doesnt want the association with the big bank being highlighted this close to the caucus time, and also, i think the other piece of this where it undercuts his narrative in terms of, you know, he was so committed to his candidacy and the causes of the tea party and the grassroots that he attracts that he was willing to risk his familys financial ruin in order to get to the senate to fight for what they believe in, and that isnt exactly correct, that really hurts, too. In fact, its not correct at all. Thats not who he is. Lets talk about the democrats. New Des Moines Register poll, bloomberg poll, showing neck and neck in iowa and its not so much that Hillary Clinton is or that Bernie Sanders is gaining. Its that Hillary Clinton is losing among the undecideds. More people are not sure. So her support is softer than people might have imagined. Her support is softer and its not going in the direction that they want, and the response from the Clinton Campaign of course will be that they always expected the race to tighten but the fact is, this is at least to me right now, a little bit of a mystery which is what exactly is going on, what is making these voters who were once inclined in her direction have second thoughts. I dont have a view on that yet. Shes been hammering him for days on the unspecific numbers, the lack of any kind of numbers in his health care, Single Payer Health care plan. I want to get to the details of that in a moment but hes now counterattacked trying to change the subject clearly with the toughest ad and arguably the first really negative ad of the campaign, something he said he wouldnt do. This on wall street reform today. There are two democratic visions for regulating wall street. One says its okay to take millions from big banks, then tell them what to do. My plan, break up the big banks, close the tax loopholes and make them pay their fair share. Then we can expand health care to all and provide universal college education. Will they like me . No. Will they begin to play by the rules if im president . You Better Believe it. Jeanne, thats a very effective ad for Bernie Sanders and it doesnt mention obviously her counterpoint which would be that her wall street plan, her wall street reform plan has gotten a lot of praise for going after the shadow banks that many say were really involved in the crash. That said, hes got credibility on this issue. He does. Because hes been running on it forever. Its how he launched his campaign. Hes very credible on the issue and what is also effective, i think, about that ad is that its not an attack ad. He is promotting his plan. He is promoting his candidacy. By reference, does it speak that im better than her . Sure. But its not an attack ad in the traditional sense. And he doesnt name her and i think that makes that ad a lot more effective. He doesnt need to name her because Everybody Knows who exactly he is talking about. Briefly, this is so complicated, but on health care, on the numbers, the lack of numbers and what the Clinton Campaign is saying about his single payer proposal. Sure. Theres two issues here. The Clinton Campaigns argument is this is his biggest proposal by far. He needs to explain to us exactly how hes going to pay for it and specifically whether thats going to mean that middle income taxpayers see their rates rise. The Sanders Campaign has indicated that theyre not going to be forthcoming with those details. I think thats a perfectly legitimate question for her to ask. At the same time, if you look at some of the evidence and studies on single payer, they do argue that for the most part, middle income taxpayers will not be hurt once you take away, sorry to wonk out here, once you take away their need to pay for premiums, that will make up for some of the increase in taxes they might have. So a really interesting substantive debate but you cant have it without the numbers to back it up. Bottom line, he says without knowing exactly what his plan would be, you cant be specific. Other experts have said it could cost as much as 15 trillion to 18 trillion over ten years. Its relevant that the Bernie Sanders campaign in the summer said we are going to come out with the numbers and didnt. Then they said they would have them before the iowa caucuses. Now they say they wont. Thats another reason that its a soft target for Hillary Clinton because hes not delivering in a way that he had already promised he would. We have to leave it there. We have a lot more to talk about because we can now announce the official candidate lineup for the nbc news democratic primary debate this sunday in South Carolina. On the stage, sunday night, Hillary Clinton, Bernie Sanders and Martin Omalley have all qualified for the debate based on the latest polling with omalley barely making that cut. But he will be there. Tune in to nbc news for special debate coverage 9 00 eastern on sunday. Moderated by lester holt. Im honored to be able to announce that i will be joining lester at the table in this final democratic debate before the iowa caucus. Please join us then. Up next, the senator sits out. We will talk to rand paul about why he is boycotting the Republican Debate tonight. Everyones lookin red carpet ready. My man, lemme guess who youre wearing. Toenail fungus . Whaaat . . Fight it with jublia. Jublia is a prescription medicine. Used to treat toenail fungus. Use jublia as instructed by your doctor. Jublia is workin it most common side effects include. Ingrown toenail, application site redness,. Itching, swelling, burning. Or stinging, blisters, and pain. Oh fight it with jublia now thats a red carpet moment ask your doctor if jublia is right for you. Visit our website for savings on larger size. At ally bank, no branches equals great rates. Its a fact. Kind of like working from home equals not working. Numbers look pretty good, hows it on your end dave . Oh, the numbers look so good. Dave, daves on it. When a moment turns romantic why pause to take a pill . Or stop to find a bathroom . Cialis for daily use is approved to treat both erectile dysfunction and the urinary symptoms of bph, like needing to go frequently, day or night. Tell your doctor about all your medical conditions and medicines, and ask if your heart is healthy enough for sex. Do not take cialis if you take nitrates for chest pain, as it may cause an unsafe drop in blood pressure. Do not drink alcohol in excess. Side effects may include headache, upset stomach, delayed backache or muscle ache. To avoid longterm injury, get medical help right away for an erection lasting more than four hours. If you have any sudden decrease or loss in hearing or vision, or any symptoms of an allergic reaction, stop taking cialis and get medical help right away. Ask your doctor about cialis and a 200 savings card hey pal . You ready . Can you pick me up at 6 30 . Ah. boy im here im here cop too late. I was gone for five minutes ugh move it. Youre killing me. You know what, dad . Im good. dad it may be quite a while before hes ready, but our Subaru Legacy will be waiting for him. vo the longestlasting midsize sedan in its class. The twentysixteen Subaru Legacy. Its not just a sedan. Its a subaru. The new Bernie Sanders ad that we just showed is his toughest campaign ad yet, taking aim at Hillary Clinton as a new Des Moines Register bloomberg poll shows him closing in on clinton in iowa. Im joined by the secretary of agriculture, tom vilsack, the former governor of iowa and a strong clinton supporter. Mr. Secretary, welcome. Good to be with you. Lets talk about iowa, because why is bernie doing so well, why are people not flocking to him, but as we see in these poll numbers, that people are becoming less certain about their support for Hillary Clinton . The reality is we always anticipated this is going to be a close race and its been a great campaign, substantive campaign, certainly contrasts nicely with whats going on on the other side. Hillary is doing all the right things and at the end of the day, i think the key here is organization. Theres no question who has the Stronger Organization to deliver the people the caucus. The poll is instructive because it indicates that bernie is basically topped out. He hasnt moved at all since march. So its not about bernies support. I think its about making sure that we continue to reach out to hillarys supporters, reassure them that her plans are the best and in fact, that shes tough enough to win. Whats not or whats missing in this campaign is the fact in order to govern, in order to do anything, you have to win. You have to be tough enough to win. She has been vetted. Bernie has not been. In our own poll this week, he had better numbers against any of the republicans than she did. He is more electable in a general election, according to what people think now. Andrea, there has not been a negative ad directed at Bernie Sanders yet. Hillary clinton has withstood pressure over the course of her incredible career. I can guarantee you that there will be plenty of negative advertising that will redefine Bernie Sanders. At this point in time, im proud of the election and the race these folks are running because its substantive. Hillary has better plans, i think shes indicated where the moneys going to come from to pay for her plans. That is something Bernie Sanders has not done. I think its a fatal mistake on his part not laying out precisely how hes going to pay for college, how hes going to pay for a hlt caealth care for. And until he does that people in iowa will be skeptical of those plans. Why should people in iowa, corn growers, as the agriculture secretary, get this special ethanol mandate now that oil prices are below 30 a barrel . Its much different. There are a multitude of reasons. Cleaner air is the result producing ethanol is very environmentally costly according to members of the house and senate who tried to take it away. We have recently done studies about this. I think basically the folks are working on old information. Its much more efficient than oil production. Number two, it supports nearly 400,000 jobs. Number three, it stabilizes prices and four, it reduces our reliance on foreign oil. Its basically an opportunity for us to reduce our trade deficit. Number five, it reduces the cost of gasoline at the pump anywhere from 25 cents to 1 a gallon depending how high gas prices are. There are multiple benefits to the country from this industry and basically, what this does, it essentially establishes a threshold for the industry to meet. We are now not only meeting that threshold but also beginning to export this fuel to china and to places all over the world so its going to continue to grow and continue to support jobs here at home. And its going to continue to reduce our reliance on foreign oil. I would rather have our farmers get the benefit and our workers get the benefit rather than folks in the middle east. I want to ask you about your poverty initiatives because as agriculture secretary, you have been, as long as i have known you, really concerned about rural poverty and how the High Percentage of poverty that resides in rural areas. One out of four American Children live in a home thats at or below the poverty level. So this president has been moved by that statistic and has instructed me as the chair of the Rural Council to address it. We are looking at creative solutions, Integrative Solutions and comprehensive solutions trying to make sure we bring information and services to families, not just to children and not just to mom and dad but to the entire family, better worker training for mom and dad, better child care availability, Better Services for youngsters. Thats why its important to have universal free prek, why its important to have the Affordable Care act so kids are covered there. Are a lot of benefits that have accrued. We are going to begin to see that break come down. We are seeing the Unemployment Rate come down in Rural America as a result of the record amount of job growth we have seen in the last 70 months. So we are going to continue to work on it. Thats another reason why you need Industries Like the renewable fuel industry and expand that not just to fuel and energy but to chemicals so that you bring manufacturing back to rural communities. Thats whats happening in america today. Its going to continue to expand dramatically as a result of the president s activities. Secretary vilsack, thank you so much. Thank you. Now speaking of iowa, kentucky senator and republican president ial candidate rand paul joins me now with iowa, of course, the first voting. Thank you for being with us. Youre not going to be on the stage tonight in the Republican Debate. You have opted out of the undercard. Tell me why. I think its a mistake with only about three weeks to go in the election to let anyone designate your campaign as not being a contender. We just made the decision that the media shouldnt get to decide this and the parties shouldnt get to decide this. Besides, the most recent polls out of iowa have me definitely in contention and above and ahead of a couple people they did include on the debate stage. We think the decisionmaking was arbitrary and capricious and we just werent willing to take it, frankly. One of the things you have done in trying to pressure the Republican Party and fox business, the other debate sponsors, to put you on the main stage is you were on the air with alex jones, the conservative talk show host. Let me play a little bit of that. I wanted my audience to get you in that debate. The best thing would be to call the Republican National committee and tell Reince Priebus that they need to allow all voices to be heard in the debate and that its not fair to exclude me from the debate. Do you have any problem with going on, i guess you didnt, with alex jones, a conspiracy theorist who said that sandy hook didnt happen, 9 11 didnt happen . Why would you go on the air with someone of his with his background . I think i have been pretty ecumenical. I go on air with people from the far right and the far left. This morning im on msnbc which is not a conservative network or not thought to be a conservative network so i dont think anybody accuses me of being afraid of going on with the right or the left. The job of a candidate is try to get your message out. Get it out to anyone who is listening and try to change the direction of the country. What do you think of this matchup between ted cruz and donald trump . Ted cruz now, the New York Times disclosing that he had a loan from Goldman Sachs, not a favorable rate, they all claim, but it wasnt disclosed properly to the f ergsec. He did that subsequently, apparently. Does it matter . I think what will end up being more important and voters will probably judge to be more important is that ted cruz didnt show up and didnt think enough of auditing the Federal Reserve to actually show up and support me in that battle this week in the senate. I think thats affecting him more probably than the loan will be. But well see. Voters still havent decided yet. And what about nikki haley and her response to the state of the union . Theres a lot of criticism from the conservative side of the party, she was praised by Establishment Republicans but slammed by others, including donald trump, for what she said obviously shots that she took against trump and other voices in the party, as well as in the media. I think donald trump would be a disaster for the Republican Party. I have spent the last two years trying to say we need to be a bigger party, more inclusive, more diverse, rich, poor, white, black. I have been really trying to expand the notion of our party and i think donald trump is trying to narrow that and there is a certain anger that appears to be directed toward different ethnic groups that i think is a mistake. Our party i think actually needs to do much more than we have done to be a bigger party. I think donald trump would take us back a generation or two and i think would absolutely destroy the party. So im doing everything i can to make sure that hes not the nominee. What if he is . Well, we can only hope. I think that he isnt but i think we make a mistake because we have so much time now to talk about politics, that we really think that we are going to predecide things. Nothing is really known until people go to vote february 1st, even the polling in all likelihood probably has no validity in what will happen on february 1st. I agree with you there. I think until people have voted and we have seen how volatile it is. Getting back to trump, what if he is collecting delegates and what if it turns out that way, what if the pollings correct and hes the nominee. What do you do . I faced this same dilemma when i ran for the u. S. Senate. I was the underdog. The establishment had their candidate. But everybody, my opponents as well as myself promised to support the nominee. Thats how Party Politics works, so your party can beat the other party. While i want to be the nominee, i pledge that i will support who will be the nominee. Thats the only way the party can draw together because you need everybody in the end to beat the other party. So i think its a hypothetical obviously thats uncomfortable because we are vying in a very heated battle right now to see who will be the nominee and i dont want donald trump to be the nominee. But i think its an unfair question in the sense that we arent there yet. Lets ask it once we get there. I think you will find probably the same answer that most people will support the nominee. And is there any chance that you can be on that debate stage . I dont know what your conversations are. What are you doing today to try to fix this or what is your counterprogramming . We have pointed out to the Republican Party and to the network that if you look at the polls that have come out, that we should be included. The most recent poll by the Des Moines Register thought to be one of the most accurate polls out there has me by myself in fifth place, and this would averaged in with the others that they were looking at, would actually have me in the debate. So we think to quibble about tenths of points really is unscientific. The polls have a margin of error often of two or three points, sometimes four points, and so really, its unscientific and biased and really does a lot towards instead of growing the Republican Party, it looks like they want to shrink the Republican Party if they want to push the liberty vote, the libertarian leaning voters out of the party. These voters can go other places. They sometimes vote for Third Party Candidates and so i dont know. We think its a mistake that they made. We hope they will try to correct it. What are you going to be doing tonight if you are not on that stage . Well, we are going to be reaching out to our two Million People on facebook and others, we are going to be having a Teletown Hall at randpaul. Com. If anybody wants to ask me directly a question, go to our facebook and become part of the Teletown Hall tonight. Rand paul, senator, thank you very much for being with us. Thank you. Coming up, terror at a starbucks in jakarta. Was it isis . We get the latest just ahead. With my colleagues, a second bomb went off, another suicide bomb. Run this business. But i really love it. Im on the move all day long. And sometimes, i just dont eat the way i should. So i drink boost® to get the nutrition that im missing. Boost complete nutritional drink has 26 essential vitamins and minerals, including calcium and vitamin d to support strong bones and 10 grams of protein to help maintain muscle. All with a great taste. I dont plan on slowing down any time soon. Stay strong. Stay active with boost®. Arent moving in the right direction,bers it can be a burden. But what if you could wake up to lower blood sugar . Imagine loving your numbers. Discover oncedaily invokana®. With over 6 million prescriptions and counting, its the 1 prescribed sglt2 inhibitor that works to lower a1c. Invokana® is used along with diet and exercise to significantly lower blood sugar in adults with type 2 diabetes. Its a oncedaily pill that works around the clock. Heres how invokana® reduces the amount of sugar allowed back in to the body through the kidneys and sends some sugar out through the process of urination. And while its not for weight loss, it may help you lose weight. Invokana® can cause important side effects, including dehydration, which may cause you to feel dizzy, faint, lightheaded, or weak, especially when you stand up. Other side effects may include kidney problems, genital yeast infections, urinary tract infections, changes in urination, high potassium in the blood, increases in cholesterol, or risk of bone fracture. Do not take invokana® if you have severe kidney problems or are on dialysis. Stop taking and call your doctor right away if you experience symptoms such as rash, swelling, or difficulty breathing or swallowing. Tell your doctor about any medical conditions, medications you are taking, and if you have kidney or liver problems. Using invokana® with a sulfonylurea or insulin may increase risk of low blood sugar. Imagine life with a lower a1c. Are you loving your numbers . Theres only one invokana®. Ask your doctor about it by name. In new york state, we believe tomorrow starts today. All across the state the economy is growing, with creative new business incentives, the lowest taxes in decades, and university partnerships, attracting the talent and companies of tomorrow. Like in utica, where a new kind of workforce is being trained. And in albany, the nanotechnology capital of the world. Let us help grow your companys tomorrow, today at business. Ny. Gov starts with arthritisg pain and a choice. This is sheldon, take tylenol or take aleve,. The 1 recommended pain reliever by orthopedic doctors. Just two aleve can keep pain away all day. Back to the news. Isis has now officially claimed responsibility for a deadly attack on indonesias capital of jakarta earlier today. Multiple attackers assaulting the city center with grenades and guns, leaving seven people dead, two civilians and five of the attackers themselves. For the details, im joined by msnbc Foreign Correspondent Ayman Mohyeldin in new york. This is the first time we have seen a claim of isis for something happening this far in asia. Yeah, absolutely. Certainly in indonesia. This is considered by many experts who have been following this and certainly seeing where isis attacks have been in the past, the First Official claim of responsibility for an attack inside indonesia, indonesia being the Worlds Largest muslim population. Long past of militant groups operating there, including al qaeda which carried out a very deadly attack back in 2002. We will get to that. But todays attack was brazen. It took place in the heart of jakarta, involved several individuals, according to police, by some estimates as many as five individuals, including suicide bombs, small arms fire as well as grenades. It seemed that the plan, the intent of the plan was try to wreak havoc in the heart of jakarta right in the area busy with workers, busy with westerners as well. It wasnt too far away from the president ial palace, the u. S. Embassys in the vicinity as well as the u. N. Offices in indonesia. We know the target outside of a starbucks popular among local residents there. So some are saying its very similar to the attack we saw in paris where the intent was to start in one area and then spread that terror, spread that fear, in various parts. Indonesian police and security were able to get there quickly and that led to a standoff and led to a shootout in which at least two people were killed. Two innocent civilians were killed in addition to the several attackers that were involved in this. Ayman mohyeldin, thank you so much. Coming up next, battleground South Carolina. Governor haley ignited a new battle in the republican civil war ahead of tonights debate. Youre watching Andrea Mitchell reports. Eteria noise flourish spray noise flourish spray noises school bell sigh flourish spray noise share the joy of real cream. Share the joy of real cream. flourish spray noise . With reddiwip. You have to feel healthy. On the outside. At your core. Trubiotics a probiotic from one a day naturally helps support both your digestive and immune health by combining. Two types of good bacteria. Trubiotics. Be true to your health. I am totally blind. I lost my sight in afghanistan. If youre totally blind, you may also be struggling with non24. Calling 8448442424. Or visit my24info. Com. Light piano today i saw a giant. It had no arms, but it welcomed me. crow cawing it had no heart, but it was alive. train wheels on tracks it had no mouth, but it spoke to me. It said, rocky mountaineer all aboard amazing. cell phone rings where are you . Well the squirrels are back in the attic. Mom . Your dad wont call an exterminator. Can i call you back, mom . He says its personal this time. If youre a mom, you call at the worst time. Its what you do. If you want to save fifteen percent or more on car insurance, you switch to geico. Its what you do. Where are you . Its very loud there. Are you taking a zumba class . The battle lines have been drawn ahead of tonights big Republican Debate in South Carolina. Donald trump hinting hell make ted cruzs citizenship an issue. Cruz hitting trump for having socalled new york values. Now of course, the issue of the Goldman Sachs loan. Joining me is South Carolina congressman and former governor, marc sanford, joining me from charleston. Thank you very much, congressman. Lets talk about ted cruz, donald trump. These are the top two candidates. Where do you come down on the way they have been battling back and forth . This is the nature of the end of the scrimmage. As you get closer and closer to votes being cast, elbows begin to fly more and more. I think you will probably see some of that tonight and you will see it certainly in the days leading up to iowa, New Hampshire and South Carolina. Is it good or bad for the party . It is what it is. You can go back to the days of people caning each other in the senate chambers. There has always been a rough and tumble component to american politics. And its the powerful contrast you said thshis, you said this. At times the process gets a bit messy. The old saying is if you like sausage, dont watch it being made. That back and forth hopefully allows voters at the end of the day to glean the truth. Is there merit or not to trumps charges with regard to cruz on citizenship. I dont think so but ultimately thats for the voters to decide. What about nikki haley, the governor of South Carolina, of course gave the republican response and was sharply critical, certainly critical of president obama with ybut sharp critical of her own party and is taking heat for that, for the loud voices. Let me play a little for you. During anxious times, it can be tempting to follow the siren call of the angriest voices. We must resist that temptation. No one who is willing to work hard, abide by our laws and love our traditions should ever feel unwelcome in this country. Now, the next morning she told matt lauer that she was referring to donald trump as well as some other voices, including voices in the media, when she spoke about the noise and loud voices. Do you agree with her . I do. I think that theres merit to what shes saying. What shes saying goes up against two forces that i think are really at an Inflection Point in our country. One is people fear some components of globalization. They fear the way they compete against seven billion people around planet earth and its easy in political terms to find somebody else to blame and oftentimes, thats blamed on the new guy in town or the new gal in town. So you have that force going on. And the other is a force that plays as you well know, andrea, in the media which is if it bleeds, it leads. Too often, media goes for the negative story, not the uplifting story. Degrading comment will be covered much more than an uplifting compliment. So you have those two things combined together and you get on the tail end of a campaign with election right around the corner, again, people throw out some things so we shouldnt go that way. I hope we dont. I think the governor was right in what she suggested. But thats probably not the nature of the way the end of campaigns come down. To your point, ann coulter and others, ann coulter tweeting out within minutes that Governor Haley should be deported. Is that constructive, that kind of invective . I was just going to say, me, as guilty of this as anybody in the world of politics or anybody in civilian life. No, i dont think thats constructive. She was born in orangeburg, South Carolina. She has much of a claim to United States citizenship as ann coulter does. Thank you very much, congressman from South Carolina. We will all be down there by tomorrow and seeing you, we hope, in the next couple of days. Coming up next, from death row to free man. At least temporarily. An msnbc exclusive report on a texas man who has always insisted he was innocent. And new evidence that set him free. Our cosmetics line was a hit. The orders were rushing in. I could feel our deadlines racing towards us. We didnt need a loan. We needed shortterm funding fast. Building 18 homes in 4 ½ months . That was a leap. But i knew i could rely on American Express to help me buy those building materials. Amex helped me buy the inventory i needed. Our amex helped us fill the orders. Just like that. Another step on the journey. Will you be ready when growth presents itself . Realize your buying power at open. Com i tabut with my back paines, i couldnt sleep and get up in time. Then i found aleve pm. Aleve pm is the only one to combine a safe sleep aid plus the 12 hour pain relieving strength of aleve. Im back. Aleve pm for a better am. Why fit in when you were born to stand out. The 2016 Nissan Altima has arrived. Im mary ellen, and i quit smoking with chantix. I have smoked for thirty years and by taking chantix, i was able to quit in three months. And that was amazing. Along with support, Chantix Varenicline is proven to help people quit smoking. It absolutely reduced my urge to smoke. Some people had changes in behavior, thinking or mood, hostility, agitation, depressed mood and suicidal thoughts or actions while taking or after stopping chantix. Some had seizures while taking chantix. If you have any of these, stop chantix and call your doctor right away. Tell your doctor about any history of Mental Health problems, which could get worse or of seizures. Dont take chantix if youve had a serious allergic or skin reaction to it. If you have these, stop chantix and call your doctor right away as some can be lifethreatening. Tell your doctor if you have heart or blood vessel problems, or develop new or worse symptoms. Get medical help right away if you have symptoms of a heart attack or stroke. Decrease alcohol use while taking chantix. Use caution when driving or operating machinery. Most common side effect is nausea. I cant believe i did it. I quit smoking. Ask your doctor if chantix is right for you. Welcome back. Now to a harrowing story of a man recently freed from death row. Alfred Dewayne Brown was released from a texas prison last summer. He spent a decade on death row for a crime he says de not commit. Msnbcs craig melvin has been following the story. You spent a lot of time with him including last night. He was here watching a basketball game. Heres the thing. He insisted he was not even at the scene of the crime. He was convicted in 2005 in a high profile case in the killing of a Houston Police officer. The officers name was charles clark. Along with a cashier as well. There was no forensic evidence, there was no surveillance footage, either he said he was at his girlfriends apartment and actually called to check on her when he saw the coverage of the killings on television. Proof of that call would have been an alibi. Problem was, no one could find a record of the call back then. He was convicted, he was sentenced to death row, and he spent his days right there in that tiny cell, 23 hours every day. Then in 2007, he got a new attorney. He declares that he knew in his gut after meeting him for the first time that he was innocent. In 2014, they discovered the missing phone record. It was buried in a box of papers in a Police Detectives garage there in houston. There has still been no plausible explanation about precisely how it got there. This is what the texas court of criminal appeals said as it set him free last summer. Quote, based on the habeus corpus courts findings and conclusions and their own review, we hold the state withheld evidence that was both favorable and material to applicants case in violation of brady. That of course is a reference to a Supreme Court case brady v maryland that deals with exculpatory evidence and due process. Brown walked out of prison june 8th last year. And is he free and clear or is there any chance the state would try to even retry him . The d. A. At the time last summer said they did not have sufficient evidence to bring new charges. However, again, as you know, theres no statute on Capital Punishment so theoretically, yeah, if theres some sort of new evidence that emerges, he could be tried for murder but this is not something that keeps his attorney up at night. They think that he is more than likely out forever. Extraordinary. Are there other reasons he should never have been on death row . His girlfriend at the time said in their initial interview with the investigators, she said that he was there, that she got the phone call. Investigators come back, according to her, they pressure her to change her testimony, they charge her with perjury. She spends close to three months in prison or excuse me, in jail for perjury, and is only released when she changes her story. She later tells her attorney that she had to choose between him or her kids and she chose her kids. So she recanted her testimony as well. How is he spending his time . Because you said you were with him last night. This is pretty remarkable. Hes got a bucket list. He wanted to see an nba game so he went to the wizards game and saw the wizards take on the bucks, beat the bucks. He crisscrosses the country with his lawyer talking to law students about his case, about the process as well. He wants to make this his mission. He works on a horse farm down in louisiana now. He finds it very therapeutic, very cathartic to be outside. I asked him last night what the hardest part about being in prison, being on death row, what the hardest part was. Listen to what he said. The hard part about being on death row is when you be talking to a guy not knowing that he has an execution date and you get close to him, like just sharing different things, artwork, whatever it is yall be talking about and yall get close, and then the guards come knock on his door and tell him pack up. Pack up, because that would be his execution day. He had a lot of friends who ended up being executed in texas while he was on death row. Wow. Craig melvin, unbelievable story. Thank you for bringing it to us. Really appreciate it. Great to see you. Just ahead, power up. How operation hope is making sure that tech and innovation leaves no one behind. You think youre doing all you can for your heart health,. But 9 out of 10 americans. Arent getting enough important omega3s. Bayer pro ultra omega3 can help, with two times the concentration of omega3s than the leading brand. Love your heart. With bayer pro ultra omega3. Iall across the state belthe economy is growing,day. With creative new business incentives, and the lowest taxes in decades, attracting the talent and companies of tomorrow. Like in the hudson valley, with world class biotech. And on long island, where great universities are creating next generation technologies. Let us help grow your companys tomorrow, today at business. Ny. Gov we need to be ready for my names Scott Strenfel and r im a meteorologist at pg e. We make sure that our crews as well as our customers are prepared to how weather may impact their energy. So every single day were monitoring the weather, and when storm events arise our forecast get crews out ahead of the storm to minimize any outages. During storm season we want our customers to be ready and stay safe. Learn how you can be prepared at pge. Com beprepared. Together, were building a better california. Thats what i mean when i say an innovation economy. Weve got to be confident about our ability to solve any problem if we put our minds to it. That was president obama of course, this morning at Mckinley High School in baton rouge, louisiana, echoing his optimistic state of the union message. Today in atlanta, that same focus on leadership, innovation and empowerment is center stage at the 2016 Hope Global Forum. Msnbc is a media partner at this event featuring conversations with leaders like treasury secretary jack lew and Chelsea Clinton over the next two days. Joining me is the founder of operation hope, john hope bryant. Thank you very much. Its a great honor to be with you and talk to you about andrea, thank you. What can be done with public and private partnerships and what are you trying to do to include innovation and technology through all sectors, especially the young people who dont have access . Well, i think that when secretary castro said this morning he wants to have every low Income Housing complex and home wired with the internet, that was extraordinary. Its simple and you would assume it was done, but it is not. You are not connected to the internet, you cant innovate anything or even search for a job, frankly. To van jones who was here last night, he said the best way to stop a bullet is a job. So if you think about whats going on in ferguson, missouri, thats a jobless economy. Think about whats going on in baltimore, that was a jobless economy. Think about what happened in southcentral l. A. That started operation hope, the rodney king riots, jobless economy. 700 credit score communities dont riot. Only 500 credit score communities do. We have to move Credit Scores 120 points. We are doing that through our locations, an innovation, a new software to give people uplift that can measure. It also brings more gdp in the economy and the guy who made the suit, we raised his credit score 100 points, taught him to be an entrepreneur and now he has six employees and is adding to his taxes, raising his children and adding to the American Dream of Small Business creation. How do you do this town by town and city by city, get businesses engaged . It seems like such an overwhelming challenge. Is it one step at a time . It is one step at a time. I think its also scaleable. We are going to open 1,000 hope inside locations. Sun trust opened 20, committed to opening 20. First tennessee bank, largest bank of tennessee, committed to 15. We are the only nonprofit inside of a bank branch. Hyatt hotels committed to two. Whole foods, we are negotiating with them. Two hospitals in detroit, we are working with the mayor to do 100 locations in detroit, part of their revitalization effort. Coca cola just committed 1 million today to put hope inside for women and entrepreneurship for girls in public schools, very much like the school the president was at. So we need not just a ph. D. Conversation but a phdo conversation. We have to think global but you have to act local. The president needs partners Like Operation hope who are on the ground and whoever the president is next, republican or democrat, this is an American Issue because 70 of the people watching your program right now feel that like they have too much month at the end of their money. Its a completely bipartisan program. Congratulations to you and to all the people involved. We will keep on it and follow up as you proceed. Thanks so much to you. Congratulations. Thank you so much for being with us. Appreciate it. Be sure to check out the livestream on msnbc. Com to watch the 2016 Hope Global Forum today and tomorrow. That does it for this edition of Andrea Mitchell reports. Follow the show online, on facebook and twitter. Be sure to tune in tonight at 9 00 eastern for Rachel Maddows interview with Hillary Clinton. Msnbc live with Thomas Roberts is next. To folks out there whose diabetic nerve pain. Shoots and burns its way into your day, i hear you. To everyone with this pain that makes ordinary tasks extraordinarily painful, i hear you. Make sure your doctor hears you too i hear you because i was there when my dad suffered with diabetic nerve pain. If you have diabetes and burning, shooting pain in your feet or hands, dont suffer in silence step on up and ask your doctor about diabetic nerve pain. Tell em cedric sent you. I built my business with passion. But i keep it growing by making every dollar count. Thats why i have the spark cash card from capital one. I earn unlimited 2 cash back on everything i buy for my studio. And that unlimited 2 cash back from spark means thousands of dollars each year going back into my business. Thats huge for my bottom line. Whats in your wallet . Hi, everybody. Great to have you with me. Im Thomas Roberts. Tonight, the sixth republican president ial debate will be happening, just two and a half weeks before the iowa caucuses. The phrase follow the money is revealing a new controversy that could spell trouble for senator ted cruz, the iowa frontrunner. Gop rival donald trump calling the New York Times report a quote, very big thing. An investigation found that cruzs 2012 campaign failed to report low interest loans totalling up to about 1 million from two big wall street banks, Goldman Sachs and citibank. Wednesday night, senator cruz made remarks about the report, attempting to diminish any importance of it. We borrowed against the stocks and assets that we had under ordinary terms. If it was the case that they were not filed exactly as the fec requires, then we will amend the filings. Our finances are not complicated. We put in the entirety of our