Transcripts For MSNBCW Morning Joe 20201118

Repeatedly, not a second term of the Current Administration, the next administration. Whos that going to be . It could be Terry Bradshaw. Maybe Terry Bradshaw will be running the next administration . I dont know. I mean, it could be mitt romney . Its probably going to be joe biden. Its okay. Mitch, you can say it, the Biden Administration. Its okay. Donald trump cant fire you by tweet. But you know, we are getting to a point and i said at the beginning when mitch tweeted out that he tweeted out that we were going to go through the process, all the votes needed ton couto be counted, we need to count the legal votes, court challenges. I agree, thats legitimate to say, and willie, thats what we do here in the United States of america. But at this point, its a giant giuliani grift. He got laughed out of court yesterday in pennsylvania. Something went on in wayne county last night well talk about later. A lot. I mean, just talk about people literally trying to disenfranchise hundreds of thousands of voters, black voters in michigan. Theyre just theyre hurting themselves. Its hard to believe, but after all of these years, so many of these people just continue to damage their reputation more by the day, and theyre getting routed. And now again, if you want to know how bad things are going, theyve now passed their Legal Proceedings over to the grifter in chief, Rudy Giuliani, who i dont think had been into a courtroom since 1992 when he got laughed out of the federal courtroom in philadelphia yesterday. Yeah, i mean, first of all, republicans are calling this the Biden Administration in private. Some of them are calling joe biden themselves. Others are asking their democratic colleagues to pass on their congratulations to joe biden. They know where this is headed, which makes it all the worse that they are doing what they say is to give the president space, to let the Legal Process play out. But i think as of yesterday, theyre 1 for 25 in court, is the Trump Campaign. Got smacked down in the Pennsylvania Supreme Court on the question of election observers. You have the secretary of state, a republican, who President Trump endorsed in georgia, whos holding firm, under pressure from those two senators there and from the president. Theyre going about their recount, which is going to certify again that joe biden won. This is all going very badly. Its very embarrassing. But the president seems to be leaning into it. So, the question to me, joe, is how much longer do republicans let this go on . How much longer do they let him fire people who are qualified and who are doing a good job . How much more damage will they allow this man to do to the country in his remaining two months, where they finally publicly acknowledge that hes leaving and that joe biden is the president elect . And when do formerly conservative outlets that have devolved into being little more than antitrump propaganda machines, when do they start saying not for the sake of joe biden, but for the sake of america and for the sake of their own ereputations this s a spectacle, republicans are making fools of themselves . Ive been waiting for the editorial page ive been reading my entire life, the wall street journal editorial page, to write Something Like that. Id love to see the National Review do what william f. Buckley would do, what william f. Buckley would have done the day after the election, and say, its over, mr. President. Its time for that. But i will say, the wall street journal this morning took a step in that direction. And the headline is, rage against the voting machine. This is the lead editorial in the wall street journal opinion page. President trump so far has been unwilling to concede to joe biden, and his latest argument is that Voting Machines must have been rigged. Wheres the evidence . Strong claims need strong proof, not rumors and innuendo on twitter. And they finish by saying, if georgias recount doesnt find big irregularities, which its not, then these claims should be put to rest. In the george w. Bush years, the conspiratorial left focused on bibold, a maker of electronic Voting Machines. It would be a mistake for anyone on the right to go down a similar dead end. And willie, i remember back during the bush years and all the conspiracies raging on the left about george w. Bush. It was exhausting. I remember when republicans won, you know, elections, you would hear the next morning, oh, we found these ballots i mean, it was you just we, republicans, used to mock conspiracy theorists on the far left for doing the same thing that they are doing now, except, my god, they have a president who is egging them on, who is actually getting in the way of a peaceful transition, which, of course, is one of the cornerstones, one of the foundational elements of this Constitutional Republic. We have a peaceful transfer of power and weve seen it happen time and time again. Go ahead. We see it from democrats to republicans and republicans to democrats, and if trump and his cronies cant grow up, it is time for formerly conservative thought leaders that used to run formerly conservative news outlets to step up and do the right thing here. Yeah, i mean, the conspiracy theories are getting more desperate. You have Rudy Giuliani on television talking about mobsters in philly stealing votes. And then literally in the same sentence, saying, well, that sounds pretty farfetched, but thats what im hearing. Thats the legal defense. Theyre just lobbing conspiracy theories out. But to your point, its not just republicans giving the president space to go through the Legal Process. Some of them are participating in the charade. Lindsey graham is calling the secretary of state in georgia and putting pressure on him during this recount. He also said he was calling around to other secretaries of state, including the one in arizona. Well, that secretary of state quickly put out a tweet yesterday, said ive never spoken to Lindsey Graham about this, this is false, i havent talked to him. What really captured the farce, though, is that Lindsey Graham is calling around to states he doesnt represent, asking them to relook at all their ballots. And then yesterday, going on the floor of the senate and fistbumping Kamala Harris when he saw her on the floor during a vote. Yeah. So, there you go. There it is all in one place. Hes going through the charade with the president , calling around the country and fistbumping Kamala Harris yesterday. Its just hard to be shocked at this point, but as joe pointed out well, because were not shocked, right . Were not. Its the damage that theyre doing to the country that you just wonder how far do you need to go with this charade . Were going to dig deeper into all of this. Along with joe, willie and me, we have White House Reporter for the associated press, Jonathan Lamire, nbc news capitol hill correspondent and host of way too early, kasie hunt is with us. She never sleeps. And in a moment, were going to get to the latest person President Trump did fire by tweet, a top Elections Security official, simply because the official told the truth about how safe and secure the 2020 election was. But first, the story that all the dominant backdrop to all of this cases, hospitalizations, and deaths are on the rise in the u. S. As the country continues to suffer from the coronavirus pandemic. Its getting much, much worse. Yesterday, the u. S. Added over 159,000 coronavirus cases, bringing the overall total to 11. 4 million cases. Hospitals continue to run out of space and equipment as more than 73,000 people were hospitalized as of monday, an increase of over 3,000 from the day before. The average u. S. Deaths per day has also now reached over 1,100, up from just over 830 two weeks ago. The average pace is expected to climb in the coming days. It is getting so much worse, willie. It is. And the white house knows it. Nbc news has obtained a copy of the White House Coronavirus task forces latest weekly report to states that delivers an assessment of the pandemics trajectory. The report dated november 15th is jarring. It reads in part, there is now aggressive, unrelents, expanding, Broad Community spread across the country, reaching most counties without evidence of improvement, but rather, further deterioration. Current mitigation efforts are inadequate and must be increased to flatten the curve to sustain the Health System for both covid and noncovid emergencies. Heading into thanksgiving, the report warns, the upcoming holidays can amplify transmission considerably. States should expand all Health Messaging across all platforms, including sms autotexting, to warn citizens about the risks of social gatherings, advise people to avoid them, and reemphasize face coverings and social distancing. Specifically, recommend holding an event only with individuals within ones household and emphasize the risk of exposing an elderly person or someone with an underlying condition, if gathering indoors without masks. Again, thats the White House Coronavirus Task Force Weekly report. Lets bring in president of the American Medical Association, dr. Susan bailey, and chief nursing officer for the American Nurses association, debbie hatmaker. Dr. Bailey, let me begin with you. The white house assessment there is pretty stark. It tells the story. Whats your assessment of where we are right now . Things are, indeed, very grim. Doctors are concerned that our hospitals are filling up and that we really need to double down on our basic preventive measures wearing masks, washing hands, keeping six feet apart, and avoiding large, indoor gatherings. We have some vaccines and exciting things coming around the bend, but we want to be ready for them when they get here, and so we need to work as hard as we possibly can right now to slow down the number of new cases. Debbie, weve seen nurses doing interviews, trying to get the word out to show what it really looks like in these icus, what it looks like in a covid unit, many of them being overrun across the country. What can you tell us about what your nurses are seeing there on the front lines . Well, thank you, willie. And im pleased to be here this morning to represent the nations nurses. We are hearing that things are quite stark, and were very concerned that this delay in the transition is negatively impacting that. Just this week in north dakota, we heard that some facilities are running critically low on supplies and that nurses are being asked to transition and work in other units for which there hasnt been time for orientation and for adequate preparation or training for that. So, were concerned about that. And the delay in the transition only impacts that. So, it is time for the Trump Administration to begin to prepare the Biden Transition Team on those important issues around the stockpile for the necessary critical medical equipment. Were still seeing delays in ppe, inadequate supplies on ppe, and this will only get worse with the delays in the transition. So, dr. Bailey, before i get to my next question, im wondering if you could develop upon that point the actual impact of not sharing the information. Will it cost lives . We are very concerned about that. And an example. When shift change occurs in a hospital, doctors, nurses, everyone in the hospital needs to transfer information about their ill patients as quickly as possible and as completely as possible to make sure that nothing falls through the cracks in taking care of that particular patient. Well, were in that situation now on a national level, and the American Medical Association, the American Nurses association and the American Hospital association are all asking the Trump Administration to provide that morning report, that seamless transition, that information that we need to make sure that every patient is taken care of and nothing falls through the cracks. So, and dr. Bailey, a followup. The folks from the biden Coronavirus Task force are saying the first thing the president s going to do the president elect joe biden, is invoke the defense production act on things like testing and ppe and supplies. It seems like right now the state of testing is still quite marginal, difficult, not where it should be. Its either inaccurate or there are delays. You cant get immediate responses. Sometimes you wait five days, which, of course, makes treating the coronavirus and stopping the spread much more difficult. Would you agree that almost the most basic thing one can do right now is uniformly, across the country, wear a mask . The ama has recommended that everyone wear a mask for quite some time right now. And yes, there are shortages in supplies of basic testing equipment, of the chemicals that are used. Were doing lots of other tests in hospitals right now, too, as we come on flu season. A reminder, everybody get your flu shot. And it makes it more difficult, even more to get the test done. And so, theres lots of different tests out there. Theres a lot of confusion about which test to run, where to go to get it, how long youre going to get the results back, and were starting to see an increase in delays in test results because so many more are being done and supplies are short. So, dr. Hatmaker, lets end this segment. The numbers are grim. Infections have gone up. Deaths are moving back up again. But lets give our audience some reason to hope that we are actually moving in a positive direction. I saw yesterday in the New York Times a study, a widespread study talking about how immunity may actually last for, actually, years. They dont know yet. But one of the largest studies showed that. The viral load seems to be a little less intense in the fall than it was in the spring. And also, of course, therapeutics and just the way what youve learned over the past six, seven, eight months. Youve learned an awful lot about Covid Patients when they first come in that you didnt know in early march. What advances have we made . So, joe, you have pointed out, we have made advances in treatment. We are seeing lower mortalities, but we are still concerned about the case numbers and the strain that its putting on our Health Care Providers and our systems. Were very excited about what is just around the corner with vaccinatio vaccinations, but weve also heard in our surveys of nurses that they need Additional Information and education in order to be adequately prepared to do the mass vaccinations that are just ahead. And i will say, its going to be important for the Transition Team, for the new Biden Administration to receive the protocols for operation warp speed in order to prepare adequately for equitable distribution of those vaccines. Nurses and other Health Care Providers will be key in distributing and administering those vaccinations, so we need our politicians to stop politicizing this pandemic and to step up and be role models and to continue and to move ahead with the transition in order to be prepared for vaccinations and to move us past this critical surge in the pandemic. Were wasting time and were impacting lives the longer this delay continues. Well, we want to thank you both, president of the American Medical Association, dr. Susan bailey, and chief nursing officer for the American Nurses association, debbie hatmaker. Thank you both very much for being on the show this morning. Now to the head of the department of Homeland Securitys cybersecurity unit, who feared he would be fired after breaking with the president over the integrity of the election. And yesterday, it happened. President trump tweeted that chris krebs Statement Last week calling the election the most secure in American History was, quote, highly inaccurate. After re after repeating false claims about the election, the president then announced that krebs was being terminated as director of the cybersecurity and infrastructure security agency. A source tells nbc news that krebs found out about it via twitter and that he was upset because he took the work seriously. Krebs clashed with the white house over his agencys rumor control blog designed to combat false claims about Election Fraud and hacking, many of which the president and his supporters have touted. Last night, krebs tweeted, honored to serve. We did it right. Defend today. Secure tomorrow. He also retweeted a post from mark hamill, in which the actor says krebs was fired for refusing to lie. The former chairman of the Senate Intelligence committee, republican richard burr, tweeted his support of krebs, calling him a dedicated Public Servant who did a remarkable job during a challenging time. Burr commended the, quote, creative and Innovative Campaign the agency developed to promote cybersecurity and said it should serve as a model for other government agencies. So, what were thank you, senator burr. I just would like to say thank you, again, senator burr. We should point out. Once again. Thank you so much. So, Jonathan Lamire, ive had republican senators and republican Election Officials and people from the dhs quietly telling me over the last three years, dont listen to what the president says. Were quietly working behind the scenes and were doing everything we can to make sure that were going to have a safe and secure election. I even asked them to come on, because this was in the middle of people worrying for 3 1 2 years about the president s words, about the fact that the Republican Senate wasnt moving on things. But parts of the administration were working aggressively to protect this election. The 2018 election and the 2020 election. And i heard it over and over again. And heres a good example. Here we are and im sure republican senators will say, maybe even mitch will say, hey, this was after donald trump leaves this was the most secure election ever and it was the most secure election ever because people like mr. Krebs did their job. But in this silly season, the truthtellers get fired and most republicans are afraid to do what richard burr did and commend a man for doing what . Protecting democracy from russian interference. His final words in his tweet last night krebs was protect2020, which was the departments slogan this entire election. And youre right, joe, theres been an extraordinary amount of scrutiny on this agency since 2016, since the unprecedented Russian Election interference and the fears that, whether from there or other outside forces, that could happen again in the 2018 midterms, certainly, but most particularly, this year in this president ial election year. And it seems if, for the most part, that was warded off. This is an agency that both sides of the aisle has commended, said that krebs and his unit had done a terrific job, except, of course, for the president of the United States, who has been the one dealing with and dealing in these baseless conspiracy theories about voter fraud, suggesting the election was rigged, that it was illegitimate, and this is the department of Homeland Security and this unit in particular has been trying to combat these, frankly, rumors, this spurless and baseless accusations levied from the president and his allies. And this firing was, indeed, widely expected. It was just a matter of when. Weve been talking to people close to the president for days who said he had been stewing about this, that this was, frankly, an act of petulance, that its a score he can settle before heading out the door and that there should be, we were told, we should have our radars up for more in the days ahead. And it will be, as you said, senator burr did condemn this. Well see if other republicans have the courage to do so again publicly. Very few have broken with the president here, even during this interim period where he is refusing to concede and refusing to cooperate with the transition to joe biden, but this was, indeed, as one person close to the president said last night, who was not in the favor of this firing happening, suggested simply, this is a Public Servant who was doing his job and this is what he gets, dismissed by tweet. Crazy. You know, willie, willie, there are, sometimes eras come to an end and we dont take note. Babe ruth being traded from the red sox to the yankees. You know where im going with this. I know you too well, yeah. I know where this is going. I dont. What are you doing . Babe ruth being traded from the red sox to the yankees, right . It was big, yeah. No that was a big one. You know, the signature, the japanese signing, you know, the signature on the uss missouri, like, we knew that was big, but we didnt know how it would impact us, for how long. And Jonathan Lamire stepping away from the silhouettes. Its when you know this election is over. Doesnt matter what the president said. Doesnt matter what Mitch Mcconnell says. You know that now that the silhouettes have been taken down, hes getting ready for the real transition, willie. He has turned the corner. I know you so well that the first time we took jonathans shot, before he even started talking, i knew this was coming somewhere down the road. Jonathan, what happened to the silhouettes, the nation wonders this morning . All good things must come to an end, willie, and this is, indeed, a moment where we all look, we take stock, we reflect, we try to turn the page. 2021 is on the horizon. The election, as noted, is over. And this is my own way of marking it. I will fear not continue my endeavors with the silhouettes down the road. But today wow. Today, this is a new chapter for us all. Wow. Very poignant. Hey, todd . Hey, todd . The silhouette of fifis chest, the dog, the torso down to the paws . That was a gift, todd. That was a gift. I want that set here. Even i get that joke. Wedding crashers, for those of you following along at home. Now moving on. Im going to follow mikas instructions to move on. That was the most bizarre thing, though, is that lamere had a silhouette of a dogs torso. Stop. Cut off right here. It was attached that one i never got. Sort of decapitated dog. Mika said to move on, so. Kasie, sorry to keep you waiting in the five box, speaking of charades. Lets talk about chris krebs, because it wasnt just that democrats thought he was doing a good job, it was that republicans thought he was doing a good job. Mitch mcconnell repeatedly over the last several weeks and months has praised the Organization Led by chris krebs for preventing foreign interference in the election. Last night, ben sasse the republican from nebraska, said, obviously, krebs should not have been fired. He did a good job. Are these little chips along the way to getting republicans, as they see these things unfolding, as they see norms being shattered, as they see truthtellers being fired, truthtellers who they support as well is it nudging them farther along to finally saying out loud what they wont say, that donald trump lost this election . You know, willie, i dont know. They, so far, have refused to, and it doesnt you know, i had a lot of private conversations where its very obvious what everybody thinks, which is that joe biden is going to be president , and this is the same pattern that we have been reporting on, frankly, the entirety of the Trump Administration. This kind of a thing is particularly damaging, and i think one of the reasons youre seeing these statements is that there is an acknowledgement, at least, that we still need a government that functions at a high level and that chris krebs was not a political actor. He was a competent government professional who did a job that everybody needed him to do. Dont forget, all of these senators are, you know, people who need their elections to be secure, and there had been some evidence as well of Senate Campaigns facing interference or email hacking, et cetera. I mean, they are all relying on him doing his job well. And i do think its noteworthy that they have stepped out to defend him. But at the same time, the most effective way to, perhaps, put this to an end is more likely to actually come out and say something. And you know, mcconnell joe talked about mcconnell at the top of the show he said in those remarks yesterday that what they say is irrelevant to the process in terms of whos going to be president of the United States. Im not sure that they think that when their opponents talk about things like the Green New Deal or other things that they want to run their campaign ads on, that they think words are irrelevant. And its clear from the polling, from what were seeing online, from the conspiracy theories, that people are listening to what this president says, and there is a leadership vacuum that is not stepping up to oppose what he is saying. So thats kind of where were at. I dont you know, theyve been pretty clear that its going to take the certification of these states and were seeing the Trump Campaign fight on certification questions and then the Electoral College actually voting before they really acknowledge whats going on. So, theyve got like another, you know, month, month and a half of this. Oh, dear lord. Did you say that . Okay, thank you. Still ahead on morning joe, new drama surrounding senator Lindsey Graham and georgias vote count. Now a witness claims to have heard graham ask help me help me georgias secretary of state, not his state help me with the election about tossing out ballots. Could that be considered a crime . I think it is. That discussion is next. And a note its coming joes new book, saving freedom truman, the cold war, and the fight for western civilization is coming out this tuesday, november 24th. You can preorder it now. Youre watching morning joe. Well be right back. Ning joe. Well be right back. [announcer] meet the ninja foodi air fry oven. Make familysized meals fast. And because its a ninja foodi, it can do things no other oven can, like flip away. The ninja foodi air fry oven, the oven that crisps and flips away. With sweet potato fries. Eating a falafel wrap doorbell rings thanks splitsies . Oooh. You meant the food, didnt you . No uh uh, no way come on, no no nnnnono only discover has no annual fee on any card. This is the feeling of total protection now that we protect your identity, and mobile phone, as well as auto home and life youve never been in better hands allstate click or call for a quote today with priceline, you can get up to 60 off amazing hotels. And when you get a big deal. You feel like a big deal. Priceline. Every trip is a big deal. Teeth sensitivity as well as gum issues. Does it worry me . Absolutely. Sensodyne sensitivity gum gives us the dual action effect that really takes care of both our teeth sensitivity as well as our gum issues. Theres no question its something that i would recommend. Theres no question its something i decided that i wanted to go for Electrical Engineering and you need to go to college for that. If i didnt have internet in the home i would have to give up more time with my kids. Which is the main reason i left the military. Everybody wants more for their kids, but i feel like with my kids, they measurably get more than i ever got. And i get to do that. I get to provide that for them. Some of these ballots were hid yden from the democratic inspectors because they were so bad. They dont want a democrat or a republican to inspect it. Imagine that a couple hundred thousand. So, those must have been the ones they bought from the mob or something. Im kidding. Im kidding. But rudy although there is an allegation of a mobster involved, but i think its a farfetched one. There is an allegation of a mobster [ laughter ] come on again and hes getting paid to do this like he wants to get paid a lot. The giuliani grift. Like, were going to be talking he wants 20,000 a day, i think. Well talk to Michael Schmidt about that in a second. But willie, we were talking about todd last block, and i just saw the clip. You notice, important thing that i never noticed until just looked at the clip again during the break was that vince vaughn is accused of trying to todd accused vince vaughn of trying to seduce him. Yeah. And he says give me my payment back. Vaughn doesnt even try to rebut the spurious claim. He goes right past it and he said the painting was a gift, todd. The painting was a gift. I mean, thats okay, guys . Ive got to say i walked out of this movie. I think that may have been please, dont ever admit that, okay . Dont admit that you didnt watch the godfather for 50 years nope. And dont admit that you walked out of wedding crashers. And i never saw youve got mail. Is that the apex of Vince Vaughns career right there. That might have been it. The dodgeball, wedding crashers, anchorman, i think that moment might have been peak vaughn right there, yeah. Yeah. Very good in dodgeball, but that may have been peak vaughn. Maybe that or also, of course, at the start of the gulf war in 2003, he was overseas in europe and they were harassing him, and he was like, Marshall Plan, ever heard of that, fellas, the Marshall Plan . That was also a very good vince vaughn moment. Okay, this is peak embarrassment for the usa, rudy throwing everything at the wall. Its peak embarrassment for rudy and donald trump, but go ahead. No, its just embarrassing no, no, Everybody Knows its a clown show. Americans have spoken. But go ahead. Yesterday, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court rejected the Trump Campaigns claim that philadelphia violated state law by not allowing poll watchers to get closer to the counting. In a ruling likely to undermine the federal lawsuit based on the same claims, the court found that state law says watchers must be in the room, but it does not set a minimum distance away from the counting, and the court cannot impose one. Earlier in the day, Rudy Giuliani was in a federal Pennsylvania Court arguing against mailin voting, generally calling it, quote, dangerous. It was his first Court Argument in almost 30 years, according to court filings. According to the washington post, in the courtroom, giuliani, quote, fiddled with his twitter account, forgot which judge he was talking to it happens. And stumbled over the definition of the word opacity. At one point, he attempted to in fact, he turned around and he said, there is an opacity crowd in the courthouse right now, not a seat left at one point, he attempted to needle an opposing lawyer, calling him, the man who was very angry with me. I forgot his name. Oh, my god. He told the district judge that ballots were improperly cured in some counties but not in others and that but the ham was fine. And said only cities, controlled by democratic machines had problems, but under questioning by the judge, giuliani said it was not a fraud case. The parties will return to court on thursday. At least 15 election lawsuits have been denied, dismissed, or withdrawn. Lets bring in the New York Times reporter and Msnbc National Security analyst Michael Schmidt. His latest piece is titled giuliani is said to seek 20,000 a day payment for trump legal work. Wow wow lets talk about that grift, first of all, michael. Giuliani, obviously, in way over his head. But heres donald trump doing what donald trump has always done, and that is, hiring lawyers who are not up to the task at hand, thinking that hes going to save a little bit of money here, save a little bit of money there. You can talk to his lawyers that have left the case. You can talk to people in his campaign. They all say its a disaster. And since rudys now in charge, its going to end badly. But its a great grift for rudy hes making a ton of money. Yeah. I think in the trump story, the question that i always have that i never really get a satisfactory answer to is the why. And this may answer some of the why on giulianis part. Why is he pushing this so hard and why is he one of the few lawyers in trumps orbit who is willing to do this . If you notice, the names of the other folks that have represented the president in other cases, in the Mueller Investigation and such, are not attaching themselves to this. This is giuliani show. So, the question is, why is it that giuliani is pushing it so hard . And hes all over the place making all of these specious claims about voter fraud and about things that theres nothing to back up. And who has ginned the president up to this . And this may answer some of that question. Giuliani seeking 20,000 a day, dating back to election day for his work. And certainly, there appears to be no end in sight for this and there is a financial incentive for this to go on longer and longer. Now, there are other reasons why giuliani and trump may be doing this. Look, both of them think they may have criminal exposure here going forward, if trump were to leave the white house. So, there are other factors here. But as a baseline level, the longer this goes on, the more money Rudy Giuliani makes. And kasie, i know you have a question for michael, but the question, kasie, is, is donald trump going to want to be separated from money that he knows is going to get him nowhere . He knows these lawsuits are going nowhere, and hes got a choice to make today in wisconsin to cough up 7 million or 8 million to have a recount move forward that he knows is not going to be reversed, just like the georgia ones not going to be reversed. So, how much longer is he going to be paying Rudy Giuliani, who advisers have been complaining for weeks keeps ginning the president up . How much longer is he going to pay for this . And does anybody think hes going to spend 8 million, waste 8 million on a recount in wisconsin that even scott walker says will not reverse more than a couple of hundred votes . Well, i think the smart money, joe, is that, no, hes not going to pony up to pay for that, but thats kind of the deadline, the thing that i have been watching to figure out how serious are they really about this. Are they willing to pay for a recount . Because that is what they would, as you point out, have to do in wisconsin. The person who demands the recount has to pay for it. And its not cheap. And we know that donald trump, while he makes a lot of claims about what hes doing with his money, he oftentimes is making decisions that are totally different than what hes saying. I mean, charitable contributions are a pretty good example of this. But mike schmidt, i wanted to ask you about the certification question, because that seems to be part of where were moving here. There was a flap overnight in detroit in wayne county where there was a lot of confusing backandforth about whether they were going to certify vote totals there. The certification seems to be what republicans are waiting for in terms of acknowledging and saying, okay, yes, joe biden has won this election, but there seems to be some evidence that giuliani is now focusing in on that and trying to create problems and raise questions about that to try and you know, the conspiracy theorist would say, oh, this is to try to kick the election to the house of representatives, that that, we know, is a very farfetched scenario. But what do you know about what giulianis doing on that front and what hes telling the president about that . Well, its sort of the next juncture in the story, where you know, as you were saying, the republicans are waiting for it to happen to, you know, they say, finally go along and say that, you know, it looks like joe biden won. Im sort of just skeptical of that, because we have waited the entire trump story for the norms to sort of just kick in, and i dont im less convinced that theyre just going to kick in here at the end at the most dramatic part of the story. But giuliani sees that as his next best bet. He doesnt have a lot of great cards to play. But if he can undermine that process and throw anything in the gears of that, thats their only shot going forward. Its clear that these recounts and these claims of voter fraud are not going to move the needle, so thats just simply the next point where they can try and do something, and to try to continue to undermine the result here. But i think that at a broader level, you know, a lot of folks will say, well, this isnt going anywhere and it doesnt mean anything, and i think thats totally true. But at the same time, theyre taking the president s base on fox news every night or oan or news max, wherever theyre watching, and theyre dipping them in the lighter fluid of this voter fraud story for several weeks. And look, im not saying that Donald Trumps base was ever going to, like, accept joe biden as president or look at things normally, but it will only make things worse as we go forward here in the fact that this notion is being pumped out to them every night i think is something that we are going to be unspooling for many, many, many months, if not longer to come. Michael schmidt, thank you very much. We move to georgia now, where there are far more questions than answers regarding that phone call between Lindsey Graham and georgias republican secretary of state. It turns out, there was a witness to the call, a top election official to secretary Brad Raffensperger was also on the call and agreed, it sounded like the South Carolina senator was suggesting throwing out absentee ballots. When i heard this, discussions about absentee ballots and of a potentially, if there was a percentage of signatures that werent really, truly matching, is there some point where you get to say, somebody went to a courtroom, could say, lets throw out all these ballots because we have no way of knowing because the ballots are separated . And that was partially what was going on. I could see how senator graham viewed it one way and secretary raffensperger viewed it one way, but our job in this state is to follow the latch and follow the process, and thats what we do. When graham was asked about the call yesterday, he said it was ridiculous. He asked georgia officials to throw out ballots. Then he said he talked to secretaries of states in arizona and nevada about their elections as well. Only, that never happened. Both came out and said they never spoke with the senator. Eventually so, lindsey good lord, this is bad. So, lindsey was actually lying to try to cover his tracks after he had been just stop. Accused by a republican secretary of state of trying to get him to throw out legal ballots. Eventually, graham revealed he had actually talked to arizonas governor and hadnt actually spoken to anyone in nevada. Wow. Wow, this is even bad for just lying all around. Lets bring in National Political reporter for nbc news josh lederman, who has been covering this story. Josh, what can you add . Well, there could not be a worse time, mika, for republicans in georgia to be going to war with themselves, with the path to control the Senate Running right through georgia over the next two months, but thats exactly what seems to be happening here. I spent the last several days in georgia, where the republican secretary of state, Brad Raffensperger, said that hes been pushed up against a wall by his fellow republicans, making these baseless claims about systemic fraud and problems in the Georgia Election that just dont exist. Its come from President Trump. Its come from both of the republican senators, david perdue and kelly loeffler, and its come from doug collins, the congressman whos been leading the president s recount effort there. Then came word of this phone call from Lindsey Graham, who, reminder, is not a senator from georgia. Hes from a different state. Unclear why he was even calling the secretary of state there. But the secretary of state, a republican who told me he voted straight down and up the ballot for republicans this year and every year, saying he did feel pressure from Lindsey Graham to try to find as many ways as possible, basically, to get rid of legally cast ballots. Now, as you point out, Lindsey Graham says thats not true. He says, the only thing he was doing here was trying to figure out why they dont have bipartisan teams that review the signaturematching in georgia. But then it turns out, as you point out, that there was this witness to the call who says, yeah, you could interpret it differently, but that it did absolutely go down the path of discussing, lets say that you have a county, perhaps like Fulton County in georgia, where you have a lot of votes for someone like joe biden, the president elect. If you have a high rate of signatures that are coming back as a mismatch, could you just say, well, theres too much uncertainty here, lets get rid of all of the ballots for that county, which would obviously help President Trump . The answer, obviously, is no, you cant do that. A court could potentially do that under some circumstances. But the big question here, mika, is what is this going to do to republican turnout in these two Georgia Senate races . Are republicans going to be turned off by all of this infighting, by this intervention from Lindsey Graham from out of state, or are they going to hear this constant drum beat that the election cant be trusted in georgia and think, whats even the point . Well, thank you so much, josh. We really appreciate it. You know, mika, the thing is, first of all, Lindsey Graham is making this argument, that if your neighbor didnt fill out their ballot correctly, then your ballot should get thrown out. I mean, hes asking to disenfranchise thousands, tens of thousands of votes to try, again, to help donald trump illegally gain the presidency of the United States, and hes lying repeatedly, lying about the phone call, lying about the purpose of the phone call, lying about calling secretaries of state of arizona,arizona. Lying about calling the secretary of state of nevada. Covering up. Trying to cover up, many said was a call to the secretary and the secretary that could not believe it, a republican could not believe what he did. Its interesting. The secretary of state also said that donald trump cost himself the state of georgia. If you look at the numbers of the votes, by continuing to lie about mailin voting. What are the chances Lindsey Graham just did this himself like from the goodness of his heart felt he needed to call the secretary of state of georgia . What are the chances . Someone didnt ask him to make that phone call . Pretty small. The legal angle of all this. Joining us chair of constitutional law at Ohio State University and nbc news election law analyst. State attorney for Palm Beach County joins us once again. Good to have you both. So, dave, since youre a current prosecutor, let me ask you i know youve looked at the statutes in georgia and the federal statutes involving this. If what the republican secretary of state is saying is true, that Lindsey Graham called and asked him to throw out legal ballots, is that a crime . Joe it sure smells, but from a prosecutors standpoint, theres not enough evidence yet to charge him with a crime. The federal law does say it is illegal for someone under color of law to try to deprive another of their constitutional rights, including the right to vote. Under the state law of georgia it is a felony punishable of up to tree years in prison to ask someone to commit Election Fraud. Here, its a matter of interpretation. You heard the witness. I could see it one way or the other, and prosecutors hate that. Gray area gets you reasonable doubt and reasonable gets you an acquittal. Thats why we need a fuller investigation to get to the bottom of this. It will have to be the next attorney general to do so. Dont count on Rudy Guiliani. Hes con spespicuous. Should do this or id like you to do this. Thats not what we have here. He doesnt seem to have the same compassion for fighting Election Fraud alleged on his side of the political aisle. So, ned, talk about pennsylvania for a moment. We kind of walked through what happened in that Supreme Courtroom yesterday with Rudy Guiliani fumbling and stumbling around. What are the implications of that ruling in the Pennsylvania Supreme Court . Will other courts across the country take that into account as they look at the Trump Campaigns arguments . Yes, i think so. You know, the issue in the Pennsylvania Supreme Court was about observation. Right. Even the dissenting judges there said you do not throw out ballots from valid voters just because there might have been a procedure problem. Thats a clear point that everybody is making. That you try to count the vote of the voters who are eligible to vote to cast their votes. In georgia, that was in pennsylvania. If you follow that principle, all of these lawsuits are going to fail, because they are trying to overturn what is evidently the will of the voters in these various states, and the courts are not going to do that. So the lawsuits seem to be going to a dead end, because theyre just seeking relief thats inappropriate in an election case like this. Ned, something that you brought up earlier back when we didnt really know the outcome of pennsylvania, what it would be. When i think it was alita talked about segregating the ballots, and in the, i believe it was injunctive relief republicans were seeking. Separating the ballots. I asked what the impact of that would be. You said, well they may rightly make a statement about the Supreme Court stepping on the state legislatures toes legally, since the state legislature is the one thats supposed to make these rules constitutionally, but you drew the conclusion then theres no way that the Supreme Court was going to disenfranchise voters and take away their votes for simply following what pennsylvania law was then interpreted as being by the Supreme Court. That applies, though, i guess, i should say in georgia, in michigan, everywhere. These courts are simply not going to disenfranchise voters, because of political skirmishes. I think thats right, and thats why i mention the dissenting opinion in the pennsylvania case yesterday. You can make reasonable questions about the majority opinions interpretation of pennsylvania law, but in the end of the day i dont think thats going to matter. The key point is i think theres unanimity among judges. The pain point will remain the same. Have you seen any lawsuits that the Trump Administration currently has active, that the Trump Campaign currently has active that you believe has merit and could have impact on the outcome of this race . No. Not has merit. You know, the thing that concerns me about the pennsylvania suit in federal court, the one that the hearing was yesterday, is what that does to the calendar. My own view based on federal law, the electoral count act governs president s election is this belongs in state court. Not federal court, because of the really tight timetable for resolving these cases. Florida back in 2000 kind of are ran out of time to finish the recount, because of this concept of the safe harbor deadline, always five weeks after election day. The hearing yesterday was two weeks after election day. Thats, you know, 2 5 of the five wsh we fiveweek period. That doesnt leave time for the Pennsylvania Court to do all the things they might need to do. Its a very tight timetable. The federal law says state court should be the principle place for adjudicatie ining any issue involving ballots in an election. Thats the principle that should be followed here. Dave, final thoughts to you. Have you seen anything out there from the Trump Campaign that you think has merit that could impact the outcome of this race . Absolutely not. This race was over a while ago, and this whole farce is being perpetuated by people like Rudy Guiliani who has his own personal motivations. I thought it was interesting that he apparently is trying to get 20,000 a day for his legal services. After three days he would make more than most of my prosecutors make in an entire year and my prosecutors are in court all the time, unlike giuliani who has not been a practicing trial lawyer in about 30 years. That why he keeps losing badly in court. Its one thing to spread conspiracy theories to the public on his maga channels and another thing to say in court, which hes not doing because he knows hell be sanctioned if he does so. Nome keep losing like in the Pennsylvania Supreme Court but keep losing their lawyers because their law firms dont want to be a part of this sinking ship. That should tell you somebody about their arguments. Bottom line, no evidence of widespread fraud. The margin between the two candidates was wide enough amongst several states that will prevent any court, any v canvassing ward from overturning this free and fair election. Dave used and important word, mika. Sanction. Thank you both. Greatly appreciate it. Its one thing for giuliani to go in and spout out conspiracy theories but he cant allege fraud as a matter of law. Go in and say im going to argue this as a matter of law before you, because if the judge finds it to be a frivolous crime, giuliani can be sanctioned. Thats why lawyers arent going into the courtroom offering these outrageous claims for donald trump. Its one thing to say in front of the microphone inside. You go inside the courtroom and say it, you can be sanctioned and actually face repercussions as a lawyer. Thank you very much. Coming up, breaking news from pfizer about the efficacy of the vaccine theyre developing. Well talk to a member of the Biden Transition Team about that, and much more. Well be right back. Make familysized meals fast. And because its a ninja foodi, it can do things no other oven can, like flip away. The ninja foodi air fry oven, the oven that crisps and flips away. Welcome back to morning joe. It is wednesday november 18. Jonathan lemire and kasie hunt still with us and joining the conversation we have msnbc contributor Mike Barnicle. Cases, hospitalizations and deaths on the rise in the u. S. As the country continues to suffer from the coronavirus pandemic. Yesterday the u. S. Added over 159,000 coronavirus cases. Bringing the overall total to 11. 4 million cases. Hospitals continue to run out of space, and equipment, as more than 73,000 people were hospitalized as of monday, and an increase of over 3,000 people from just the day before. The average u. S. Death per day has also now reached over 1,100 a day, up from just under 830 two weeks ago. And the average pace is expected to climb in the coming days. Nbc news has obtained a copy of the White House Coronavirus task forces latest weekly report to states that be delivers an assessment of the pandemics trajectory. The report dated november 15th reads in part there is now aggressive, unrelenting, expanding, Broad Community spread across the country reaching most counties without evidence of improvement, but rather further deterioration. Current mitigation are inadequate and must be increased to flatten the curve to sustain the Health System from both covid and noncovid emergencies. Willie . Thats the state of affairs. Getting breaking news as a vax rooen that is very, very encouraging. Pfizer and its german partner biointech saying its vaccine is 95 effective and submit for Regulatory Approval to the fda in a matter of days. In a study of more than 41,000 people showing no serious side effects, and with a rate at 95 effective preventing covid19. Lets get more on this with the former head of the agency in charge of Vaccine Development at the department of health and human services, dr. Rick bright, became a whistleblower about hydroxychloroquine early on and now serves on the Coronavirus Task force for president elect joe biden. Youre getting this information as it comes across as i am. Walk us through the numbers. 95 effective with no serious side effects going for regulatory approve until a patter of days. Walk us through it. Well, good morning, and thanks for having me on. Before i get into the encouraging news i want to remind everyone across america as you wake up and hear the statistics you just mentioned on your show, make sure you wear your mask. Were going to talk about some promising and encouraging updates on the Vaccine Development and that doesnt mean theyll be available tomorrow. Its critically important you wake up and wear your mask and do everything important to slow the spread of this virus while we work on getting those vaccines out for all americans. Now to the good news. It is very encouraging that we heard an update from pfizer that their phase three clinic the study of the vaccine be shows really remarkable effectiveness. Over 95 effective. Whats really important about their data that theres talking about today is that they show this infection works even older people and even in racial groups that theyve broken out to look at the effectiveness in different ethnic or racial backgrounds and also show that cases where they did see infections or cases of the coronavirus most of those severe cases were seen in people who did not receive the vaccine. They received the prlacebo. Very encouraging news from pfizer that they completed their data analysis. Remember, we havent yet seen the data. Weve seen their press release, but they are planning to submit that information to the fda expeditiously, so the fda and scientists can review that data critically, to give the fda a recommendation on whether or not to proceed with authorization of the vaccine. Everyone trying to keep the numbers straight, remember last week pfizer came out said its vaccine was 90 effective. This is is an update after completion of phase three up to 95 effective and moderna last week with its vaccine at 94. 5 effective. So, doctor bright, what does the pace look like here . Within a matter of days submitted for approval to the fda. What could that mean in terms of how soon this might be available . Well, we still have say the of work ahead of us. So the fda has to review the data, host an external Advisory Board of scientists and clinicians with expertise reviewing the safety and efficacy data, and that will happen, im sure, pretty quickly, because i know the fda already set dates aside to be able to review data when they became available. Once that is approved, or authorized, by the fda, the cdc will also review that. The Advisory Committee on immunization practices so they can look at the vaccine and see how it is working in different age groups or populations to be able to weigh in on the recommendations on who should get the vaccine. And then its really important, because the hard stuff starts. So this is where we remember that a vaccine doesnt save your life, but vaccination does. Remember, that vaccines dont deliver themselves. We need to make sure that we have a complete Vaccine Campaign rollout. There are very limited doses of this vaccine available right now. So probably 25 million doses or so available. It takes two doses per person to achieve that sufficient immunity and protection from the virus. So we dont have much vaccine to go around. So were going to have to make some very difficult decisions on who gets the vaccine first. How to identify those individuals and how they know theyre one of those priority groups, and then we have to make sure we distribute that vaccine to the Health Care Providers who will deliver the vaccine. This is a vaccine that must be kept at extremely cold temperatures. So there is not a lot of that freezer space or that Freezer Technology even available across the United States. Especially when you think about an equitable distribution of the vaccine. We might have several of those special freezers in some large communities or large cities, such as new york, but when you move out to Rural Communities or areas that are traditionally hard to reach with vaccines, they dont have that specialized equipment, and president elect biden has made it a promise and a commitment that when we roll out the vaccine and the therapeutics, it will be done in an equitable manner making sure were reaching those people that are hard to reach. So we need to make sure that the vaccine does get to the right people. I want to emphasize that this is why it is absolutely critical that the Transition Team is able to sit down with the Current Administration today to be able to discuss the protocols of the trials, be able to discuss the technical aspects of the vaccine and rollout and distribution campaigns. We have been held at an arms pace. We have no insight to the plans for this Current Administration. We do not even have direct access to the data. So the csa delay of the ascertainment of this election is causing significant delays with this critical time point in the data and vaccine availability. Right. Okay. Dr. Bright, quickly, and if they dont cooperate with information, will that, then i mean, is it black and white . Will they then delay exitable distribution of the vaccine . It very likely can. Its not something that is trivial. We need to sit down immediately. As you imagine, we have limited doses now. More doses will become available over the next month or two and a large part of the Campaign Rollout happens after january 20th. We need to sit down now so theres no hiccups a smooth process. That no smern left out in the cold when it becomes available because we werent aware of the plans or didnt have opportunity to make the transition. Dr. Bright, thank you so much. Thank you so much, doctor. We really we really neat to get information. Appreciate it. Mike barnicle, youve been in touch with the Biden Campaign. Are they expecting any cooperation anytime soon from the Trump Campaign . And if not, how are they moving forward at this critical time . Well, joe, thats a great question, and lets stop and think right now. Just for a second. What we just heard from dr. Bright. You realize that the biggest story right now in this country isnt the tweets. Its not the court cases. Its not Rudy Guiliani. Its the damage that has already been done to our country by the inability of the Republican Party and specifically its leader, donald j. Trump to admit defeat. What happens now . Whats the Biden Campaign telling you . Are they expecting cooperation anytime soon from the Trump Campaign . Yes. Yes. They are. I think they have talked to, repeatedly, to people who have left the Trump Administration under various circumstances, either thrown out, kicked out, fired, dismissed, whatever. So theyve talked to a few people who have some knowledge of the logistical change dr. Bright just talked about but they need to open the doors to the administration to give them full information so that people in rural north dakota that we were just talking about earlier, get the vaccine equitably. Yeah. Peter baker, bring in New York Times peter baker. Peter, there are aspects of this is just more of the same. The donald trump shock opera. Its Donald Trumps government by gesture. As has been said before. Doing things that he knows arent going to have any practical impact. This seems to be, though, the exception. As joe biden said yesterday. People will die. Because of a lack of coordination from this white house, the incoming white house. What can you tell us about any any cooperation between the two . And what is the Biden Campaign doing . What is the Biden Transition Team doing right now to prepare for january the 20th, and trying to get vaccines out to as Many Americans as possible . Yeah. Look, you have plenty of people inside this current government who are ready and willing and able and eager, in fact, to begin cooperating with the incoming government if only they were allowed to. Prior to the election, when donald trump was not paying much attention to it, you saw plenty of quiet cooperation on a transition that was going to come up and much had happened, of course, the president essentially made that impossible to proceed with. Think about the consequences here. Its not just that people are going to people are dieing right now. 15,000 people or more in america have died since election day, and other than the president coming out trying to take credit for the vaccine last week, you havent heard him talk about at at all. Hasnt met with the task force or told americans, advice what to do to mitigate this current spike. Its because the white house basically gave up on controlling the virus. They told us that. Mark meadows told us that in his interview on television before the election. Theyre not even trying to control the virus putting all bets on the vaccine and therapeutics. Thats a long way off still for most americans. Most americans will not get the vaccine until spring earliest. A lot to be done between now and then as dr. Bright said. Wearing a mask is Still Critical. Other measures are Still Critical but you dont hear the leader of the country doing anything about it. Anhurng hunkered down in the white house railing about stoling election and denying reality his time is almost up and doing nothing to help the next president confront this very, very serious crisis. Another thing dr. Rick bright said the longer trump does not work with the transition the longer its going to take to get the vaccine out to people so it could go beyond next spring. Bring in Senior Writer of politico, jake sherman. Msnbc political contributor, republicans not recognizing that trump lost the election can be seen as political fear for their own hides but also could be seen at costing lives and time. For a vaccine to help this country get back on its feet. Does anybody see that on the republican side . Let me add to what peter said. Hes so right. The administration is not talking about a Coronavirus Relief package at all. There needs to be money to distribute this vaccine. Legislation, laws in place, a mechanism to inoculate our country from this horse virus and this administration, wrote this in playbook this morning. Is he even president anymore . Hes not in public, not on capitol hill, not doing any of the things he needs to do even from a bare bones level. Im in the capitol every day. I havent seen a member of the administration in talks with congress with the leadership for days, weeks, since before the election. So its just a stunning level of kind of just silence. Its like when bars go up on the tv. Its stunning. I dont know if its ever going to end, and frankly, the president is pushed along by people like Lindsey Graham, who offered 15 different excuses for why donald trump might be president. Kevin mccarthy said yesterday we dont know the results of the election but allowed its driving towards the joe biden victory. Hes in a bubble, ultimate reality so far removed from a question seems a little too obvious. Is kevin be mccarthy, says he doesnt know who won the president ial election. Has he put out any press releases or made any comments about the congressional races being over j . That republicans fared better in congressional races . Is he saying that races that he actually likes the i dont ut comes are are completed, but the ones that he doesnt are not completed yet . That he doesnt Garrett Haake asked in his press conference we were both at and he said, kind of stumbled around. This is the obvious question. Right . He had a better than expected result and willing to accept that but not willing to accept the president ial race which did not turn in his favor. These people, politicians, are not honest. The Republican Party its only way out of this, to maintain relevancy, kiss up to donald trump. Thats just where they are, and they wont answer these questions honestly. Say it with a straight face because they know and Kevin Mccarthy said this yesterday, joe, donald trump will be very active in our party in the National Discourse for years to come whether hes in the white house or not. They dont want to make his voters mad stating the obvious and the truth, which is that joe biden is the president elect. Jake, you guys have new polling out just this morning. Really interesting interesting. Shows the country is coming to grips with coronavirus. A lot of people didnt believe it, listened to donald trump or others saying it was a hoax, would magic lis disappear. Didnt have to wear a mask, all businesses open all the time. As this spreads especially to the heartland of this country new polling showing people are taking it more seriously . In almost every respect, willie. The biggest disconnect, we have a lot of polling on this. The biggest disconnect between what republicans on capitol hill are saying and what the country wants on a massive relief package. 66 , thats about as high as it gets in a poll with so many options say Coronavirus Relief should be at the top of joe bidens agenda, if, when he takes office. I mean, if you look at what Mitch Mcconnell says, what Kevin Mccarthy says, theyre nowhere near this. 67 , these numbers are not, we dont see these in polls too often and it shows that the country is ready for a new way, according to this polling and its not the way that republicans on capitol hill have been leading so far. Peter baker, Mike Barnicle has a question for you. Mike . Peter baker what do you figure or hear from your sources about the Biden Transition Team and the level of expertise that they have in trying to deal with this issue about the virus and where its going, how theyre going to get it to different places in the country . What are you hearing from people with the Biden Campaign about what the lack of access is doing to the progress that they hope to make . Yeah. Either very concerned about that. This is not an easy operation. This is a, literally a militarystyle operation that requires coordination, requires a lot of thinking and a lot of planning ahead, and the to come in on january 20th at noon and suddenly take this over without any preparation leaves them in one hand tied behind their back to say the least. You have a lot of expertise rushing to join the biden team and eager to help the biden team. Especially people frustrated by the Trump Administration over the last months. Public Health Experts almost given up or wash their hands of an administration that doesnt seem to take it as seriously at the Health Experts want them to are excited about an administration that made this a top priority and makes it clear they do trust and do plan to follow the lead advice and people who understand the field, but youre right. Waiting 60 more days before they even begin to have access to whats going on inside the government and the planning thats been done is is certainly a big concern. I think, to the biden team. No question about it. Kasie hunt, i would think this would be a legitimate question for republicans in the senate . Jump in. It always is. And they dont seem to ever necessarily want to answer our questions about it, and, you know, i think john lemire, my question for you. I know youre, behind the scenes covering the white house, talking to these officials all the time. Im up on the hill, its clear theyre most worried and focused on winning these Runoff Elections in georgia. That is the reason why we are seeing we knew they would do this for a certain amount of time, but trying to make sure they hang on to power in the senate is really driving the reluctance between now and january 5th when those runoffs happen. We know they dont want to anger a Republican Base voter and are worried about poking the bear that is donald trump in that regard. What do we know about where the president is on all of that . We know he canceled his thanksgiving trip to maralago. Seems to be bunkering down. You have said earlier on the show that we should anticipate more firings, more potential problems. Are republicans going to get what they want from the president in temples of him staying out not hurting their chances in georgia . Or does the president care at all about that goal . President trump has rarely prioritized the wellbeing of the Republican Party. Its all about his own personal Political Capital and his own ability to hang on to power. And when he would help republicans in his administration it was for those republicans to then help him in return. We certainly know he has not been shy about criticizing them as well. In terms of georgia it is unclear. Ive been talking to his advisers both in the white house and still at the campaign who say, no decision has been made yet whether the president will be involved in these georgia runoffs. To this point he has not shown any interest outside of an occasional tweet. At the moment no plans to campaign there. Although the Vice President , mike pence, is headed to georgia. The campaigns are certainly eager for him to do so believing that if the president were to show up that could indeed fire up the base, but there is a concern that this utter inaction, this now two weeks of the president more or less abandoning his job to sulk in the white house is maybe hurting them. Is going to hurt their voters, depress excitement there. That are not sure this is going to animate them like so many republicans on capitol hill believe. And peter baker, i wanted to go to you to pick up a thread kasie mentioned. Talking earlier today about the firing of christopher krebs. You know, which was widely expected, the Homeland Security official, who vouched repeatedly that this election was secure and safe, and knocked down a lot of the frankly baseless allegations the president and his allies were making. Saying that this election was illegitimate and there was rampant voter fraud when, of course, there isnt evidence of that. What are you hearing in terms of what could be the next shoe to fall . As we discussed, there has been belief that the president will be dismissing others. We saw the change at the pentagon. Now we see this. Who else should be nervous about their job security . What else do you anticipate coming from this president as he remained 40 just holed up in th white house with no Public Events on his schedule . Unless youre a blood relative, you should be nervous about your job in the white house. Benefits of being fired might enhance their credibility with the rest of the world. The president is lashing out at anybody who has not toed the party line, whatever the party line is. Doesnt want independent advice or explanation. Whether health advice, lawyers, intelligence officials. Be whether it be obviously Homeland Security official chris krebs. Obviously, we talked for a long time about chris wray, fbi director and gina haspel. Both anger theed president not agreeing with his version of reality. Chris wray said before the elexd elex election, no, theres no widespread fraud and didnt back up the president s predictions the election would be rigged. Angered the president. Hes been on the hot seat since and gina haspel resisted going along with declassification of documents that the trump team wants to make in order to prove their conspiracy theories about what the Obama Administration did or didnt do. What youve seen again and again is a pattern with this government. Anybody who says something that doesnt please the president finds their job security at risk, and should come as no surprise to anybody. I think well see more of it in the next 60 days. Peter baker and jake sherman, thank you both for your reporting. Given the fact that these vaccines are on the horizon, i think most doctors and scientists would believe that it is harmful to the American People for the trump team to hold back information and data. They dont care. They just dont care. Why are we even saying anything about it . He doesnt care. And republicans on the hill dont care, that people are dieing. They dont care that americas National Security is at risk. Well, i would suggest this is very frustrating for the doctors and be scientists on the president s team, because, you know, that is breaking their code. The people dieing in hospitals now . Thats right. How about the people waiting for this vaccine . How about the people who desperately want their businesses to get back on track and want people to feel free to get back on airplanes . To get back on trains . To get back on buses . To go back get families together. To have thanksgiving and christmas together without the fear of spreading about about next year and schools . I mean, all of this is being held up, and all of this is not going to be coordinated with the person who will be president of the United States, and whats important to know is its not a surprise that donald trump just doesnt care, and its also not a surprise that republicans on capitol hill are putting their own petty, political selfinterest ahead of the protection of their constituents and the health of millions and millions of americans. Bring in dr. Dave campbell. Hey, dr. Dave, we had in big news this morning fromvaccine. Seems were starting to hear good news every day about that and also a study yesterday suggesting that, that if you get covid, you may have immunity built up actually in some cases for years. Lets start, though, with the vaccines. Tell us whats happening, what does it mean . Well, this is definitely the good news bad news scenario. The bad news we are all looking at right now is another 60 days before we see the vaccines become available, plus the new Administration Come into place. So pfizer today has reported that their vaccine has passed through phase three clinical trial, and is 95 effective. Thats better than they told us last week where it was 90 . We have moderna, the second vaccine that has reported their effectivenesses to be at 95 . Its important to remember, joe, that this is, to my calculation, a fivestep process, where we are now seeing good news about effectiveness of two vaccines. We will start to see and were in the middle of step two where were seeing Safety Measures look pretty good. That will continue as the vaccine rolls out. They still have to, though, make the vaccine in adequate numbers. At best, were going to see 40 million Vaccine Doses Available by end of the year, if the approval happens. Its a twodose vaccine meaning 20 Million People may be inoculated by end of the year. Then we have to address distribution across the country. Freezers, both of these vaccines need deep freezers. One of them, the one from pfizer harks to be really, really cold and kept really cold. So thats step four. You have to have trucks. You have to have freezers, keep available. But step five is the biggest concern i have. We know that half of the country are skeptical about vaccines. Half of the country have been witnessing this unwillingness with the Trump Administration and others to accept truth, to accept science and move forward with that. There was a study just came out of new jersey that confirms that. So its the fifth step, the willingness to have the vaccine for people to let their children be vaccinated. Older people often look to their younger, adult family members for advice. Thats the linchpin to this whole thing, joe. We have to have the availability of the vaccine, but we have to have people willing to take it, joe. Yeah. Mike barnicle is with us, dr. Dave and has a question. Mike . Dave, this is a twostep process of both vaccines as i understand. The Moderna Vaccine and the Pfizer Vaccine. Do you know what the waiting list, the time in between the two shots is . And are the shots given by appointment or do we go, or will the people stand in line and wait for the shots . What do we know about this . We know a lot so far, mike. The Pfizer Vaccine has a threeweek window between the first dose and the second dose. The Moderna Vaccine has a fourweek window. Supposedly these will be free to the american public. I suspect that theres will be some type of a need to have an appointment made. Thats not clear to me yet how that will unfold. Plus, in the beginning, remember, this vaccine in limited doses is going to be given to those that are in the highrisk categories or Health Care Workers, frontline workers, first responders, people with Underlying Health conditions. There are 200 million of those people, mike, in the country. Teachers, food workers. We have 330 Million People. Thats 660 million doses that we need to immunize everybody. That is a stretch. We have to work really, really hard through 2021 to get everyone who is willing to be immunized, immunized with all the steps that were talking about. Wow. Morning joe chief medical correspondent dr. Dave campbell, thank you very much. And mika, i told you before about, really quick, we got a study that was in the New York Times that again its not Peer Reviewed yet but very extensive study. Oh, right. About people that get covid. Wed heard that maybe, maybe your immune for three or six months. The Study Suggests it may be even longer than that. Maybe a year or so. Let us hope. That would certainly be great news. Some hopeful news. Still ahead on morning joe, well talk to the candidate whose race will play a key role in determining which Party Controls the senate. Georgia democrat jon ossoff is standing by. Youre watching morning joe. Well be right back. Introducing a revolution in the world of pain relief new advil dual action. Advil targets pain at the source. Acetaminophen blocks pain signals. New advil dual action with acetaminophen. Tonight. Ill be eating roasted cauliflower tacos with spicy chipotle sauce. [doorbell chimes] thank you. [puck scores] oooow yeah i wasnt ready you want cheese to go with that whine . . Ive been involved in. Communications in the media for 45 years. Ive been taking prevagen on a regular basis for at least eight years. For me, the greatest benefit over the years has been that prevagen seems to help me recall things and also think more clearly. And i enthusiastically recommend prevagen. It has helped me an awful lot. Prevagen. Healthier brain. Better life. [announcer] forget about vacuuming for up to a month. Shark iq robot deep cleans and empties itself into a base you empty as little as once a month. And unlike standard robots that bounce around it cleans row by row. If its not a shark, its just a robot. Georgia is grateful for the doctors, nurses, first responders. For those who sacrifice to keep the lights on, keep us fed, keep us safe, keep us moving. From the teachers who have gone above and beyond. Nor the love and support of our families. Everybody in georgia is thankful for everyone who stepped up to get us through this year. And now its time to step up for them. To reunite our country and end this crisis. Ill work with joe biden to beat the vices, empowering medical experts to implement a National Health strategy with free testing and vaccinations. To provide immediate Financial Relief for working families and Small Businesses and an infrastructure and jobs programs that will jumpstart our economy, and when we get this done, next year its thanksgiving with the whole family. To all who have given so much this year, thank you. Im jon ossoff and i approve this message. That was the new campaign ad from Georgia Senate candidate jon ossoff who joins us now. His Runoff Election against senator david perdue is on january 5th. Jon, i take it some Campaign Strategy changes now that we know the outcome of the election and youve been looking ahead to a Biden Administration. What other changes or strategy shifts are you putting forward right now, and, also, i guess there wont be a debate . Hey, mika. Good morning and thank you for having me. We sort of wanted to give folks a respite from the endless barrage of typical political ads and just take stock of where we are as a state and a country, and where we need to go from here. And as i was sitting with my team talking about what we wanted to say to the people we were just discussing that so many families are having this shared experience right now. Of preparing for thanksgiving, but being unable to spend it with the people we love, and we sort of wanted to offer just almost a blessing, a moment of gratitude for everybody who has helped us through this very, very difficult time, even though were so divided politically, i think we share as a people a sense of gratitude for the everyday heroes who have made this year bearable, who have helped so many survive, helped so many through this difficult time, and we really have to chart a course out of this crisis. I mean, i heard yall discussing the continued road blocks that are being put in the way of an orderly transition in washington, when there are hundreds of thousands of lives in the balance and millions of jobs in the balance. Its totally unacceptable and the American People deserve better. Jon, willie geist. Good to have you on the show this morning. You know, all eyes only the state of georgia right now, from Mitch Mcconnell, up to the president of the United States and democrats, of course, putting all eggs in this basket, as you say, so important for control of the senate. In the first round you lost by about 90,000 votes. You trailed, excuse me, didnt lose, but trailed by 90,000 votes. How do you make up that difference in a runoff . How do you get that much turnout and swing that many votes ins space of less than two months here . Willie, thanks for the question. Well, it was the closest u. S. Senate race in the country. And this is all about turnout, and enthusiasm, and energy, and getting georgians back out to the polls. And we are already running the most ambitious Voter Registration and get out the vote effort in American History here. And what im working so hard to communicate to the people of this state is that in order for this new administration to succeed in fighting this virus, in delivering rapid economic and Financial Relief to working families and Small Businesses and investing in economic recovery, biden and harris are going to need to be able to govern, and if weve got two, four, six years of just endless gridlock and obstructionism in washington, theyre not going to be able to enact legislation necessaries to get out of this crisis. Stakes are high, were letting people know that and getting out in the community very, very fast and strong to inform people of the upcoming election with early voting beginning on december 14th for this january 5th duel u. S. Senate runoff. Jonathan lemire is here from the a. P. With a question. Jon . Hi, jon, we just outlined how high the stakes are. And republicans dont know if President Trump will play a visible role. Travel to georgia to do any campaigning. Can you tell us, though, what might be in the works on the other side, for your party. Visits perhaps from president elect joe biden, Vice President elect Kamala Harris and former First Lady Michelle Obama and past president barack obama, and Michelle Obama did not make any inperson Campaign Appearances during the general election . Yeah. Reverend warnock, democratic candidate in the other senate runoff, remember, everybody, we have two Senate Runoffs in a single state for Senate Control here in georgia and reverend warnock and i were campaigning with president obama in the final weeks of the general election. I would welcome, of course, all of those folks to get down here, if the president elect and the Vice President elect have time, of course, they need to prioritize the transition and in preparing to take charge in a moment like this. Love to get them here, president obama and Michelle Obama if she wants to come down. Bottom line, its about enthusiasm and making sure the people are aware of these upcoming elections. Everything we can do to raise awareness and inspire people to get out to the polls, we need to. Jon ossoff, thank you for being on the show this morning. Well be watching. Thank you. Go to michigan now. The wayne county board of canvassers unanimously certified its vote count hours after republicans on the board blocked approval of Election Results. The board, composed of two democrats and two republicans initially deadlocked after republicans claimed irregularities in the poll books of certain detroit precincts. But the gop members reversed course after a unanimous board agreement to ask the secretary of state to contact an independent audit. Two gop poll watchers filed suit earlier in the day with the same audit request after the Michigan Court of appeals refused their petition to stop certification of the countys vote based on fraud claims. Washington post reporter robert costa tweeted last night that according to Rudy Guiliani, the Trump Campaign knows that he cant catch up, want to try to force it to the house. Lets bring in professor at Princeton University eddie glaude junior and nbc news and msnbc contributor shawna thomas, and i mean, shawna, in wayne county specifically, what is happening here . Because it could be defined as basically trying to disenfranchise a great deal of black voters . Well, i think also we can be somewhat heartened by people spoke out. People complained. People, citizens. Yeah. Actually showed up and said, i dont agree with this, and this is problematic, and i dont want my vote to be disenfranchised, and, you know, the republicans on that committee, on that, you know, 22, democrats and republicans evenly split committee, backed down and certified the election and certified at least their results that no one seems to actually really be questioning. So thats positive. I think the other thing, and, its that it points to the need for being part of your communitys politics. It points to the need for at that level, the city, the county level, understanding how your government works, and being willing to stand up and and make them accountable for it. Now, i did a little bit of research. That small group is appointed by a larger group, but if that larger group comes back and appoints the same two republicans, or even the same two democrats, shouldofyou should be aware of that, be able to stand up and say, i dont agree with this. So i think the system is still kind of falling apart and were sort of watching it fall apart or watching maybe statistic people try to destroy the system right now, but if the public wants to take action, it is possible to take action on a lower level and speak up, and we saw that, and i think that is at the very least a good thing. Eddie glaude, your thoughts . Well, first i want to echo what shawna said, the democratic process when its enacted by everyday ordinary people can be effective. But we have to describe that effort over and against what were seeing. This is whats happening in plain and open sight. Right . That is, that we have actors who are deliberately trying to undermine the democratic process. We have the Republican Party in michigan. We have republican appointees on this board. We have giuliani and the president explicitly making efforts to destabilize, to delegitimate, right, our democratic process and we need to understand that for what it is. That these people noble t only not care about the 15,000plus who died since the election, they dont care about democracy. Black and brown voters disproportionately impacted in wayne county because of it. Speaking of people speaking out, republicans in arizona appear to be split over the integrity of the election there. The state Republican Party wants a judge to postpone certifying Election Results from Maricopa County until an audit can be done, but the republican chairman mayor coier copyoieyore ta county says there is no dysfunction. Tile to dial back the rhetoric, rumors and the false claims. Biden flipped Maricopa County winning more than 50 of the vote. The county wants to certify results by end of the week. A judge is expected to hear arguments today in the arizona Republican Partys lawsuit to delay that certification. Mike barnicle . Mika, you know, id like to ask shawna and eddie to join in on this, and its not really a question. Its a thought that i have, and im wondering if im alone here. This morning. Thinking it. It is this the president of the United States quit. Quit on his job. We have a daily danger to our democracy that i have never witnessed in my life prior to this. Every single day theres a cauldron of vitriol and damage poured out of the white house, and the Republican Party about our country, and about the process we call voting. So im wondering if either of you, both of you, all of you, you know, have thought about the ramifications of this, and do you share my concern that somewhere out in this big, sprawling land of ours, somewhere there is the potential danger of a deranged individual taking things just a little too seriously and this could end up really, really terribly bad . Shawna . I mean, speaking personally, and not based on reporting. Yeah. Yeah. Im worried about that. I was worried about that before the election. I was worried about what would happen in the days after the election, no matter which side actually won. I mean, this is the reason why, you know, states had the National Guard on standby. This is the reason why the downtown d. C. , where i used to live, was boarded up. This is the reason why fifth avenue was boarded up. People were actually worried about that level of unrest as well as specifically could this start something related to race, especially in the streets . And i i dont think that fear is unique to me as a black person. I dont think that fear would be unique to anyone. I dont think that fear is necessarily unique to many white people out th, but that is exactly what i am worried about each day. That is exactly why, you know, you stockpile toilet paper hous worried will i be able to leave my home if someone does take this idea that the democratic process did not get carried out correctly too far. So, eddie, ill let you tackle that larger question. On the michigan story, donald trump is losing michigan by 146,000 votes. Its not close. So the idea that these two canvassers, these two republican canvassers wanted to throw out the votes of wayne county, of detroit, is outrageous, but we should point to the fact that people are stepping up. People are answering the challenge. People are protecting our democracy at the heights of Homeland Security when chris krebs said this is the most secure election in the history of our country. He knew he would get fire for that. Indeed, he was fired yesterday, but he told the truth. Not just the democratic canvassers but the people of wayne county on the call who heard this news rose up and the republicans had to go back and, in fact, certify that election. So, yes, we have problems, but there are also a lot of people in this country answering the bell to preserve the democracy. Absolutely, willie, but we need to understand, at least this is my view, that its not really about the success of these efforts that is the matter. One out of 25 defeats, as you mentioned earlier, its not really about them winning. Its about deepening the doubt among that hardcore 20 to 30, 40 . Deepening this sense of illegitimacy among his hardcore supporters, those folks who will not extend legitimacy to a Biden Administration and enter into the democratic process once trump transitions out. So its not about winning in this moment. Its about kind of calsfying that doubt such that it can begin to have the effect moving forward on our democracy. So i think we need to be mindful of what work its doing even as they lose. And in terms of mikes question, in terms of the white house, the madness has turned on himself. The madness is now interior. Its eating him up. And we have seen the potential for violence as sean a said. We know what happened in kenosha. We know that these folks are Walking Around with ar15s, that they plotted to kidnap the governor of michigan. We understand these forces have been activated, many have been mainstreamed. So with the doubt that i just talked about and with this willingness to act on the sense of illegitimacy that they attribute to the federal government we are on a knifes edge. We need to understand as you recognize the power of every day ordinary folk to defend our democracy in the face of it all. Eddie and shawna, thank you for being on this morning. And weve been following the overseas response to the transfer of power in america, including the reaction in ireland. In fact, nbc news chief global correspondent bill neely caught up with one of the president elect joe bidens own relatives there. He has walked on the streets here. You know, we know him as well, which is great, to talk to and stuff like that. We spent a little bit of time with him, were in the white house with him. He is one of our own. He is from here. And bill neely joins us live from dublin with more on this. Bill. Reporter yeah, good morning, mika. There are plenty of billboards and posters of joe biden all over the west of ireland, thats his ancestral home where his great, great, great grand father immigrated to the United States in the 19th century. The celebrations are not over, neither is the sense of anticipation of joe biden, the president , someone who will be not just a voice for ireland in the white house, but who will reset relations between the United States and europe. And also i think, mika, here a sense of impatience for the end of the Trump Administration and the beginning of what the Irish Foreign minister calls a much warmer, much closer relationship based on partnership and friendship, not just friction. I spoke to the foreign minister this morning, also spoke to irelands prime minister. Heres what they had to say about joe biden. A celebration. An emotional level, the fact that a man who is proud of his irish hair stage, great, great, greatgrandparents coming from ireland, the most irish of president s since john f. Kennedy. There is that sense one of our own has made it to the top in the United States. I think that we will see a warmer and closer relationship thats based on partnership rather than friction across the atlantic coming from a biden presidency, and i can assure you that the European Union and political leaders here will reciprocate to ensure that that relationship improves dramatically and quickly so that we can Work Together to solve problems together. Reporter and not just here in dublin, but in london, in paris, and in berlin everyone anticipating that on january 20th, or shortly afterwards, the United States will rejoin the paris climate accord, rejoin the world health organization, and in the words of the Irish Foreign minister, will begin speaking the kind of language the world wants to hear, in particular standing up for democracy. The values of democracy in an increasingly authoritarian world. So, mika, its not just culturally or in terms of his heritage and irish roots that ireland is looking forward to a biden presidency. Its those very, very well geopolitical issues. Nbcs bill neely. Thank you so much. And still ahead, Mitch Mcconnell inches closer towards acknowledging joe bidens election win, but he still is parsing his words. Plus, the president fires a top Election Security official for telling the truth about Election Security. Morning joe is coming right back. Ning joe is coming right back oh humans. Listen to what every strain. Every twistoof and every backache is telling you you cannot do this. Pain says you cant. Advil says you can. children laughing music swells dog barking music fades exhales experience the power of sanctuary at the lincoln wish list sales event. Sign and drive off in a new lincoln with zero down, zero due at signing, and a complimentary first months payment. When panhe doesnt justs mmake a pizza. He uses fresh, clean ingredients to make a masterpiece. Taste our delicious new flatbread pizzas today. Panera. Is now a good time enough, crohns. For adults with moderate to severe crohns or ulcerative colitis, stelara® can provide relief, and is the only approved medication to reduce inflammation on and below the surface of the intestine in uc. You, getting on that flight . Back off, uc. Stelara® may increase your risk of infections, some serious, and cancer. Before treatment, get tested for tb. Tell your doctor if you have an infection, flulike symptoms, sores, new skin growths, have had cancer, or if you need a vaccine. Rpls, a rare, potentially fatal brain condition, may be possible. Some serious allergic reactions and lung inflammation can occur. Lasting remission can start with stelara®. If youve been financially impacted by covid19, janssen may be able to help. Whoa . Someone please help of course. Youre tenacious, ill give you that [heavy breathing] product not yet rated. But you can work out anything wowith comcast business. W. Get fast, reliable, and secure internet on the nations largest gig speed network. Flexible tools like wifi you control. Voice solutions that connect you from anywhere. And expert advice here, here, or even here. Be fast. Be flexible. Bounce forward with comcast business. Get started with a powerful internet and voice solution for just 64. 90 a month. Plus, for a limited time, ask how to get a 500 prepaid card when you upgrade. Switch today. In all of these president ial elections we go through this process. There is a way to deal with disputes. Its called the courts, and the courts and the various states are dealing with whatever disputes there are, whatever evidence may be provided, and we are going to have an orderly transfer from this administration to the next one. What we all say about it, frankly, is irrelevant. All tv will happen right on time and we will swear in the next administration on january 20th. Note the use of the word next administration, not a second term, but the Current Administration, the next administration. Who is that going to be . At least it could be Terry Bradshaw. Maybe he will be running the next administration. I dont know. I mean, could be mitt romney. Its probably going to be joe biden. Its okay, mitch. You can say it. The Biden Administration. Its okay. Donald trump cant fire you by tweet. But, you know, we are getting to a point, and i said at the beginning when mitch tweeted out that he tweeted out we were going through the process, the votes need to be counted, do the court challenges, i agreed. Thats totally fine to say, thats legitimate to say. Willie, thats what we do here in the United States of america. But at this point its a giant giuliani grift. He got laved out of court yesterday in pennsylvania. Something went to in wayne county last night. We will talk about that later. A lot. I mean, just talk about people literally trying to disenfranchise hundreds of thousan thousands of voters, black voters, in michigan. They are just, they are hurting themselves. Its hard to believe, but after all of these years, so many of these people just continue to damage their reputation more by the day. They are getting routed. And now again, if you want to know how bad things are going, theyve now passed their Legal Proceedings over to the grifter in chief, Rudy Giuliani, who i dont think had been into a courtroom since 1992 when he got laughed out of the federal courtroom in philadelphia yesterday. Yeah, i mean, first of all, republicans are calling this the Biden Administration in private. Some of them are calling joe biden themselves. Others are asking their democratic colleagues to pass on congratulations to joe biden. They know where this is headed which makes it all the worse that they are doing what they say is to give the president space, let the Legal Process play out. But i think as of yesterday they are 1 for 25 in court is the Trump Campaign. Smacked down in the Pennsylvania Supreme Court on the question of election observers. You have the secretary of state, a republican, who President Trump endorsed in georgia, who is holding firm under pressure from the two senators there and from the president. They are going about their recount, which is going to certify again that joe biden won. This is all going very badly. The president seems to be leaning into it. The question, joe, is how much longer do republicans let this go on . How much longer do they let him fire people who are qualified and doing a good job . How much more damage will they allow this man to do the country in his remaining two months where they finally publicly acknowledge that he is leaving and that joe biden is the president elect . And when do formerly conservative outlets that have devolved to being i wilittle mo than trump propaganda machines, when do they start saying, not for the sake of joe biden, but for the sake of america and for the sake of their own reputations, this is a spectacle. Republicans are making fools of themselves. I have been waiting for the editorial page i have been reading my entire life, the wall street journal editorial page to write Something Like that. I would love to see the National Review do what william f. Buckley would have done the day after the election and say its over, mr. President. Its time for that. I will say the wall street journal this morning took a step in that direction, and the headline is rage against the voting machine. This is the lead editorial in the wall street journal opinion page. President trump so far has been unwilling to concede to joe biden and the latest argument is the Voting Machines must have been rigged. Where is the evidence . Strong claims need strong proof. Not rumors and innuendo on twitter. And they finish by saying, if georgias recount doesnt find big irregularities, these claims should be put to rest. In the george w. Bush years the conspiratorial left focused on die bold, ache matter of electronic Voting Machines. It would be a mistake for anyone on the right to go down a similar dead end. Willie, i remember back during duri the bush years and all the conspiracies raging on the left about george w. Bush. It was exhausting. I remember when republicans won, you know, elections. You would hear the next morning, oh, we found these ballots. I mean, it was you just we republicans used to mock conspiracy theorists on the far left for doing the same thing that they are doing now, except, my god, they have a president who is egging them on, who is actually getting in the way of a peaceful transition, which, of course, is one of the cornerstones, one of the foundational elements of this Constitutional Republic we have. The peaceful transfer of power. We have seen it happen time and time again. Saw it happen go ahead. If trump and his cronies cant grow up, it is time for formerly conservative thought leaders that used to run formerly conservative news outlets to step up and do the right thing here. Yeah, i mean, the conspiracy theories are getting more desperate. You have Rudy Giuliani on television talking about mobsters in philly stealing votes and then literally in the same sentence saying that sounds farfetched but thats what im hearing. Thats the littegal offense. They are lobbing conspiracy theories out. Some of them are participating in the charade. Lindsey graham is calling the secretary of state in georgia and putting pressure on him during this recount. He also said he was calling around to other secretaries of state, including the one in arizona. Well, that secretary of state quickly put out a tweet yesterday said i have never spoken to Lindsey Graham about this. This is false. I havent talked to him. What captured the farce is Lindsey Graham is calling around to states he doesnt represent asking them to look at ballots and yesterday going on the floor of the senate and fistbumping Kamala Harris when he saw her on the floor during a vote. There you go. There it is all in one place. He is going through the charade with the president , calling around the country, and fistbumping Kamala Harris yesterday. Its just hard to be shocked at this point. Well, because we are not shocked, right . Were not. Its the damage that they are doing to the country that you wonder how far do you need to go with this charade. And it all comes on the backdrop of a surging pandemic. Doctors and nurses are overwhelmed and well talk to two leading advocates about what front line workers need the most right now. Youre watching morning joe. Well be right back. Well be ri. children laughing music swells music fades exhales experience the power of sanctuary at the lincoln wish list sales event. Sign and drive off in a new lincoln with zero down, zero due at signing, and a complimentary first months payment. Is now a good time enough, crohns. For adults with moderate to severe crohns or ulcerative colitis, stelara® can provide relief, and is the only approved medication to reduce inflammation on and below the surface of the intestine in uc. You, getting on that flight . Back off, uc. Stelara® may increase your risk of infections, some serious, and cancer. Before treatment, get tested for tb. Tell your doctor if you have an infection, flulike symptoms, sores, new skin growths, have had cancer, or if you need a vaccine. Rpls, a rare, potentially fatal brain condition, may be possible. Some serious allergic reactions and lung inflammation can occur. Lasting remission can start with stelara®. If youve been financially impacted by covid19, janssen may be able to help. Yesterday, the u. S. Added over 159,000 coronavirus cases bringing the overall total to 11. 4 million cases. Hospitals continue to run out of space, and equipment, as more than 73,000 people were hospitalized as of monday. An increase of over 3,000 from the day before. The average u. S. Deaths per day has also now reached over 1,100. Up from just under 830 two weeks ago. The average spapace is expected climb in the coming days. It is getting so much worse, willie. It is, and the white house knows it. Nbc news contained a copy of the latest weekly report from the white house to states that delivers an assessment of the pandemics trajectory. The report dated november 15 is jarring. It reads in part, there is now aggressive unrelenting expanding Broad Community spread across the country reaching most counties without evidence of improvement, but rather further deterioration. Current mitigation efforts are inadequate and must be increased to flatten the curve to sustain the Health System for both covid and noncovid emergencies. Heading into thanksgiving, the report warns, the upcoming holidays can amplify transmission considerably. States should continue to expand public Health Messaging across all media platforms, including sms auto texting to warn citizens about the risks of social gatherings, advise people to avoid them and reemphasize face coverings and social distancing, specifically recommend holding an event only with individuals within ones household and emphasize the risk of exposing an elderly person or someone with an underlying condition if gathering indoors without masks. Thats the White House Coronavirus Task Force Weekly report. Lets bring in president of the American Medical Association susan bailey, and chief nursing officer for the American Nurses Association Debbie hat maker. Dr. Bailey, let me begin with you. The white house assessment there is pretty stark. It tells the story. Whats your assessment of where we are right now . Things are indeed very grim. Doctors are concerned that our hospitals are filling up and that we really need to double down on our basic preventative measures. Wearing masks, washing hands, keeping six feet apart, and avoiding large indoor gatherings. We have some vaccines, exciting things coming around the bend, but we want to be ready for them when they get here. So we need to work as hard as we possibly can right now to slow down the number of new cases. Debbie, we have seen nurses doing interviews, trying to get the word out to show what it really looks like in these icus, what it looks like in a covid unit, many overrun across the country. What can you tell us about what your nurses are seeing on the front lines . Thank you. I am pleased to be here to represent the nations nurses. We are hearing that things are quite stark and we are very concerned that this delay in the transition is negatively impacting that. Just this week in north dakota, we heard that some facilities are running critically low on supplies and that nurses are being asked to transition and work in other units for which there hasnt been time for orientation and for adequate preparation or training for that. So, were concerned about that, and the delay in the transition only impacts that. So it is time for the Trump Administration to begin to prepare the Biden Transition Team on those important issues around the stockpile for the necessary critical medical equipment. We are still seeing delays in ppe, inadequate supplies on ppe, and this will only get worse with the delays in the transition. So, dr. Bailey, before i get to my next question, i am wondering if you could develop upon that point. The actual impact of not sharing the information, will it cost lives . We are very concerned about that, and an example. When shift change occurs in a hospital, doctors, nurses, everyone in the hospital needs to transfer information about their ill patients as quickly as possible and as completely as possible to make sure that nothing falls through the cracks in taking care of that particular patient. Well, we are in that situation now on a national level, and the American Medical Association, the American Nurses association and the American Hospital association are all asking the Trump Administration to provide that morning report, that seamless transition, that information that we need to make sure that every patient is taken care of and nothing falls through the cracks. So, and dr. Bailey, a followup. The folks from the biden Coronavirus Task force are saying the first thing the president s going to do, the president elect joe biden, is invoke the defense production act on things like testing and ppe and supplies. It seems like right now the state of testing is still quite marginal, difficult, not where it should be. Its either inaccurate or there are delays, you cant get immediate responses, sometimes you wait five days, which, of course, makes treating the coronavirus and stopping the spread much more difficult. Would you agree that almost the most basic thing one can do right now is uniformly across the country wear a mask . The ama has recommended that everyone wear a mask for quite some time right now. And, yes, there are shortages in supplies, of basic testing equipment, of the chemicals that are used. We are doing lots of other tests in hospitals right now, too, as we come on flu season. Reminder, everybody get your flu shot. And that makes it more difficult even more to get the test done. And so there is lots of different tests out there. There is a lot of confusion about which test to run, where to go to get it, how long you are going to get the results back, and we are starting to see an increase in delays in test results because so many more are being done and supplies are short. We want to thank you both. President of the American Medical Association, susan bailey, and chief nursing officer for the American Nurses association, debbie hat maker. Thank you for being on the show this morning. Coming up, donald trump fires the head of election cybersecurity after that official debunked the president s conspiracy theories. The disturbing yet totally Predictable Development next on morning joe. Xt on morning joe. Were cheersin the merrymakers, the givers and not takers, and the home decorators. To those that got us through spring, summer, and fall, were cheersin for all at dunkin. Share some cheersin with friends via the dunkin app. America runs on dunkin friends via the dunkin app. You can crush ice, make nismoothies, and do even more. Chop salsas, spoon thick smoothie bowls, even power through dough, and never stall. The ninja foodi power pitcher. Rethink what a blender can do. A new buick . For me . To james, from james. Thats just what i wanted. Is this a new buick . I secret santaed myself. I shouldnt have. But i have been very good this year. Wow wow wow this year, turn black friday into buick friday all month long. Now during buick friday, pay no interest for 84 months on most 2020 buick suv models. Pay no interest for 84 months introducing the iphone 12 pro with 5g. Now at tmobile, unleash the 5g power of the epic iphone 12 pro in more places. Get 2 iphone 12 pro max 2 lines of unlimited 5g for just 100. Only at tmobile. Keeping your oysters growing while keeping your business growing has you swamped. you need to hire i need indeed indeed you do. The moment you sponsor a job on indeed you get a shortlist of quality candidates from a resume data base so you can start hiring right away. Claim your seventyfivedollar credit when you post your first job at indeed. Com promo tturning downhe temperature, dad. Ow. Thunk, lock the doors. Locking doors. Thunk, dim the lights. Dimming lights. [ croaking ] goodnight, honey. Goodnight. [ laughs ] thats my leg. Aw pft, pft. Evolve your home security. Get the peace of mind, safety and convenience of xfinity home. And dont forget to catch the croods, a new age in theaters thanksgiving. Rated pg. Now to the head of the department of Homeland Securitys cybersecurity unit who feared he would be fired after breaking with the president over the integrity of the election, and yesterday it happened. President trump tweeted that chris krebs Statement Last week calling the election the most secure in American History was, quote, highly inaccurate. After repeating false claims about the election, the president then announced that krebs was being terminated as director of the cybersecurity and infrastructure security agency. A source tells nbc news that krebs found out about it via twitter and that he was upset because he took the work seriously. Krebs clashed with the white house over his agency rumor control blog designed to combat false claims about Election Fraud and hacking. Many of which the president and his supporters have touted. Last night krebs tweeted, honored to serve, we did it right. Defend today. Secure tomorrow. He also retweeted a post from mark hamill in which the actor says krebs was fired for refusing to lie. The former chairman of the Senate Intelligence committee, republican richard burr, tweeted his support of krebs calling him a dedicated Public Servant who did a remarkable job during a challenging time. He commended the creative and Innovative Campaign the agency developed to promote cybersecurity and said it should serve as a model for other government agencies. So, what we are thank you, senator bur. I would like to say. Thank you, senator burr. Once again. Yeah, thank you so much. So, jonathan lemire, i have had republican senators and republican Election Officials and people from the dhs quietly telling me over the last three years, dont listen to what the president says. Were quietly working behind the scenes and we are doing everything we can to make sure that were going to have a safe and secure election. I even asked them to come on, because this was in the middle of people worrying for 3 1 2 years about the president s words, about the fact that the Republican Senate wasnt moving on things, but parts of the administration were working aggressively to protect this election. The 2018 election and the 2020 election. And i heard it over and over again, and heres a good example. Here we are, and i am sure republican senators will say, maybe even mitch will say, hey, after donald trump leaves, this was the most secure election ever and the most secure election ever because people like mr. Krebs did their job. But in this silly season, the Truth Tellers get fired and most republicans are afraid to do what richard burr did and commend a man for doing what . Protecting democracy from russian interference. His final words in his tweet last night, krebs, was protect 2020, which was the departments slogan. This entire election. Youre right, joe. There has been an extraordinary amount of scrutiny on this agency since 2016, since the unprecedented Russian Election interference and the fears that whether from there or other outside force that is could happen in the 2018 midterm, this year in this president ial election year. It seems as if that was warded off. This is an agency that both sides of the aisle have commended, said that krebs and his unit did a terrific job except, of course, for the president of the United States who has been the one dealing with and dealing in these baseless conspiracy theories about voter fraud, about the suggesting the election was rigged, that it was illegitimate. This is the department of Homeland Security trying to combat these, frankly, rumors, this baseless accusations. This was widely expected. It was just a matter of when. We have been talking to the people close to the president saying he had been stewing about this. Was an act of pech u lens, its a score he can settle before het heading out the door. We were told we should have our radars up for more in the days ahead. And it will be, as you said, senator burr did condemn this. We will see if other republicans have the courage to do so again publicly. Very few have broken with the president here even during this interim period where he is refusing to concede and refusing to cooperate with the transition to joe biden. But this was, indeed, as one person close to the president said last night who was not in the favor of this firing happen suggested simply this is a Public Servant doing his job and this is what he gets. Dismissed by tweet. Kasie, Mitch Mcconnell over the last several weeks and months has praised the Organization Led by chris krebs for preventing foreign interference in the election. Last night ben sasse, the republican from nebraska, said obviously krebs should not have been fired. He did a good job. Are these little chips along the way to getting republicans as they see these things unfolding, as they see norms being shattered, as they see Truth Tellers being fired, Truth Tellers who they support as well, is it nudging them farther along to infinally saying outoutsioutloud that donald trump lost this election . Willie, i dont know. They so far have refused to and it doesnt you know, i have a lot of private conversations where its very obvious what everybody thinks, which is that joe biden is going to be president , and this is the same pattern that we have been reporting on, frankly, the entirety of the Trump Administration. This kind of a thing is particularly damaging, and i think one of the reasons you are seeing these statements is that there is an acknowledgment at least that we still need a government that functions at a high level, and that chris krebs was not a political actor. He was a competent government professional who did a job that everybody needed him to do. Dont forget, all of these to senators are people who need their elections to be secure, and there had been some evidence as well of Senate Campaigns facing interference or email hacking, et cetera. I mean, they are all relying on him doing his job well. And i do think its noteworthy they have stepped out to defend him. At the same time, the most effective way to perhaps put this to an end is more likely to actually come out and say something. You know, mcconnell, joe talked about mcconnell at the top of the show. He said in those remarks yesterday that what they say is irrelevant to the process in terms of who is going to be president of the United States. I am not sure that they think when their opponents talk about things like the Green New Deal or other things that they want to run their campaign ads on that they think words are irrelevant. Its clear from the polling, from what we are seeing online, from the conspiracy theories, people are listening to what this president says and there is a leadership vacuum that is not stepping up to oppose what he is saying. So thats kind of where were at. They have been pretty clear that its going to take the certification of these states, and we are seeing the Trump Campaign fight on certification questions and the Electoral College actually voting before they really acknowledge whats going on. They have another month, month and a half of this. Coming up, north dakota is at the center of a surging pandemic. The very latest from that hardhit state straight ahead on morning joe. Tate straight ahen morning joe. Its just a little monkey. Thats not good. [ screams ] ohhh we have to save them. Whats the plan . New tribe name. Thunder sisters thunder sisters [ shouts ] [ screams ] heads up [ screams ] you can crush ice, make nismoothies, and do even more. Chop salsas, spoon thick smoothie bowls, even power through dough, and never stall. The ninja foodi power pitcher. Rethink what a blender can do. To fight wrinkles . Its what i use neutrogena®. The 1 retinol brand used most by dermatologists. Rapid wrinkle repair® visibly smooths fine lines in 1 week. Deep wrinkles in 4. So you can kiss wrinkles. And other wrinkle creams goodbye rapid wrinkle repair®. Pair with our most concentrated retinol ever for 2x the power. Neutrogena®. You can do better, steve get a freshly made footlong, from subway® you can even order on the subway® app did i just get picked off by Deion Sanders . You sure did now in the app, get a free footlong when you buy two. Because its footlong season™ Public Health measures that everyone should be adhering to, not a disjointed one state says one thing, the other state says another thing. We need to respond as a nation, not in a fragmented way. But right now it is fragmented as states and cities continue to roll out their own coronavirus restrictions. Ohio, maryland, montana, and illinois issued regulations on Business Hours and crowd sizes statewide. California governor gavin newsom issued a more stringent mask mandate requiring all residents in the state to wear a mask outdoors with limited exceptions. Iowa governor kim reynolds imposed a limited mask mandate after pushing back at the policy for months while still insisting that there is science on both sides. In south dakota, rapid city schools are planning to close and move to Virtual Learning today. Nevadas clark county, which includes las vegas, postponed plans for inperson instruction, opting to continue with Remote Learning through the end of the year. And in new orleans officials canceled the famous Mardi Gras Parade as the cap on outdoor crowds is limited to 250 people. Meanwhile, hospitals across the country are at or over capacity. Joining us now, the ceo of west River Health Services and head in North Carolina matthew shahan. Matthew, give us the status update on your hospital. Yeah, good morning. Thank you for having me on. Our hospital i think has faced like the rest of the rural hospitals in the country. We have what we would normally be dealing with during these times, but then you add on top the coronavirus pandemic and what its creating is an unsustainable model for rural health care. You know, from a staffing standpoint we only have so many people we can draw in. And those people are tired. Many times they work other jobs. They have farms and ranches at home to take care of. They are burned out already. And thats a concerning thing for us. We dont have a large labor pool and where we are sitting at we have what we have, and they are the best group of doctors, nurses, lab, radiology, and housekeeping we could find. But there are only so many of them. Thats my number one concern right now. Literally running out of doctors and nurses. Thats a pretty big concern. What about supplies and space . Yeah, supplies, i think our state did a great job leading up into this pandemic and has done a good job of delivering those supplies during this time. So were doing pretty good on supplies, i would say. Space is certainly the issue. We only have so many rooms that are negative pressure where with we can handle these types of patients. If we take them out of that controlled space, we put out the rest of the staff, put them at risk. We deliver babies here. We have to be protective of where we keep the patients because we dont have a large building. We dont have separate floors to house the patients. We have to be restrictive and careful. Unfortunately, that means it limits the number of coronavirus patients we can care for. Matthew, its willie geist. Great to have you on. There is a staggering banner on the bottom of the screen right now i had to look up twice before we came on. It says north dakota records worlds highest covid mortality rate. 18. 2 deaths per 1 Million People. So as you are here right now with a national audience, what do you all need in north dakota, and who do you need it from . I think we need to look at each other and realize that what rural has always succeeded in is taking care of each other. When a farmer goes down, their neighboring farms step up and help them get their crop out of the ground. What we need now is common sense. We need folks to wash their hands. We need them to socially distance. We need them to wear a mask when and where possible. I know its uncomfortable. I dont like wearing one all the time. How could i look my staff in the eyes if im not willing to do a simple thing to protect them and protect their patients. Honestly, daily, weekly, they are caring for their neighbors, people they have grown up with their entire lives who are in our covid unit on their death bed. I dont think i would be a very good leader if i did that. The governor did issue a statewide mask mandate a few days ago. Made sop news last week, and maybe you could help us understand this a little bit better. When the governor said that covid positive Health Care Workers, as long as they are not showing symptoms, can return and work in covid units. That took a lot of people by surprise. Is that okay with you to have covid positive Health Care Workers inside your hospitals . You know, as an organization or as the Health Care World we certainly appreciate that measure being taken, but as this organization, we have chosen to not utilize those staff. If they are covid positive, we want them home and getting better. This is a longterm disease. This is something that is going to be around for a while. We cannot risk having them come into the unit, whether they have it or not. We want them to stay away from the building so we can really limit those touch points where they could pass that on to another coworker. So while we appreciate it, at this point we havent been forced into that situation. I hope that is our absolute last measure because i dont want to have to make that cities. They were designed to make up for the shortfall in Health Care Workers. Matthew, Mike Barnicle has a question for you. Yeah, my question is, in north dakota, given such vast expanse of land and distances between farms and certainly between farms and cities, how do you cope with, how do you handle the fact that there are people who live these enormous distances from Treatment Facilities who perhaps have covid and perhaps are in danger of dying and you cant reach them wior the degree of difficuy in reaching them is such that i dont know what you do. What do you do . Thats an incredible question. My Hospital System serves 15,000 square miles. We have one hospital and six clinics. Our nearest tertiary facilities are over two hours away. We have a very Proud Community who quite often, when they are sick, it takes them to be really sick before they come to the hospital. Its just education. Its really it becomes the shortness of breath. When you have certain symptoms, we want you to come in. And its really hammering that in. We have had a long standing great relationship with the counties that we serve in north dakota and south dakota, and i think thats just the biggest thing. We have to have that trust and we hope that by now we have built that up with them, that we are going to evaluate them. We are going to figure out the best place for them to seek care. Maybe that is at home. Maybe thats at home with simple measures we can provide to them. When it comes time to get them admitted into the hospital, we hope we have a bed. If we dont, we have partners in the state which we call on. But at times lately they havent had beds. And when the people that we rely on and the hospitals that they rely on dont have beds, that really becomes a concerning effort. Those arent all Covid Patients in those beds. People still have strokes. They still have heart attacks. They still have all other issues going on right now. And seemingly more than usual. So really its just education and its collaboration between hospitals, which i can certainly say i have been really proud of my colleagues in the state and the work that we have done in the last few months to build up this network. But its clearly an unsustainable model. Its growing above what we can handle. Ceo of west River Health Services in hediger, north dakota. Matthew shahan, thank you for sharing your story. Republican senator Chuck Grassley of iowa has tested positive for coronavirus. The 87yearold announced yesterday he was under quarantine at home after learning that he had been exposed to someone with the virus. In a statement, grassley said he feels, quote, fine, and will continue to work from home. On monday, he was seen without a mask on the senate floor. The exposure caused drasgrassle h miss his first vote in the chamber since 1993. The Iowa Republican is the second oldest lawmaker in the senate. His diagnosis, along with that of 87yearold congressman don young of alaska, underscores the growing health risks on capitol hill, or what the New York Times calls a, quote, petri dish of marble and stone. Senator rick scott is in quarantine after a possible exposure, and Congressman Ed Perlmutter tested positive yesterday and its threatening to stall legislative work in washington. The two parties have been bickering over how to handle what could become a mini outbreak in the capital with ongoing debates over testing, maskwearing and a proxy Voting System where members cast votes on behalf of their colleagues. Jonathan lemire, i mean, this is again, i mean, the political, you know, right and left on this is becoming a health issue and they cant even agree on that . Well, mika, we certainly know there have been a number of coronavirus outbreaks at the white house. Now there is growing scrutiny and concern about capitol hill where senator grassley, 87 years old. His absence yesterday snapped a 27year streak of him not missing a vote. There are concerns about his health considering his age. And growing concern of others in capitol hill who may be exposed. You underscored just now, senator grassley, though he wears masks and has issued statements encouraging iowans to do the same, he has not on the senate floor. Very few do. Earlier this week he got into Heated Exchange with a republican colleague over that, encouraging a republican senator to wear a mask, which then drew the ire of senator ted cruz who accused senator brown of showboating because he would wear a mask away from others still speaking as opposed to senator brown, setting a good kpoof example for Public Health. We are seeing ramifications in the legislative world, too, as the senate looks and congress looks to perhaps act on what might be President Trump what will be President Trumps final two months in office. Even yesterday grassleys absence allowed democrats to defeat trumps pick, judy shelton, for the Federal Reserve because he and a couple other republicans were out. They were able to torpedo that selection, leaving it in doubt going forward. That is going to be something to watch here in the weeks ahead if there is an outbreak whether more of the legislation would stall. Wow. Up next, how technology is reshaping democracy. Keep it right here on morning joe. An official message from medicare. Did you try it yet . Comparing plans . Oh yeah. They sure can change year to year. I found lower premiums and lower prescription costs. And those new insulin savings hundreds of plans, 35 a month. Thatll save you money. So uh, mark . On medicare. Gov now. Open enrollment ends dec 7th. Comparing plans. Really pays. Paid for by the u. S. Department of health human services. Inflammation in your eye might be to blame. Ck, paid for by the u. S. Department looks like a great day for achy, burning eyes overthecounter eye drops typically work by lubricating your eyes and may provide temporary relief. Ha these drops probably wont touch me. Xiidra works differently, targeting inflammation that can cause dry eye disease. What is that . Xiidra, noooo it can provide lasting relief. Xiidra is the only fda approved treatment specifically for the signs and symptoms of dry eye disease. One drop in each eye, twice a day. Dont use if youre allergic to xiidra. Common side effects include eye irritation, discomfort or blurred vision when applied to the eye, and unusual taste sensation. Dont touch container tip to your eye or any surface. After using xiidra, wait 15 minutes before reinserting contacts. Got any room in your eye . Talk to an eye doctor about twicedaily xiidra. I prefer you didnt xiidra. Not today, dry eye. [announcer] meet the make familysized meals fast. And because its a ninja foodi, it can do things no other oven can, like flip away. The ninja foodi air fry oven, the oven that crisps and flips away. Here . Nah. Introducing the all new chevy trailblazer. Here . Nope. Here. When the middle of nowhere, is somewhere. The all new chevy trailblazer. Making lifes journey, just better. Welcome back to morning joe. Its 52 past the hour. The ceos of two social media giants, jack dorsey and Mark Zuckerberg yesterday testified before congress how they moderate the content on their platforms. Republican senators such as ted cruz of texas spent the bulk of their questioning drilling down on the alleged censorship of conservative youths, while democrats focused on the prevention of hate speech. Both parties agreed that the platforms have been inconsistent in how they monitor their content and decide on what is excluded when. Joining us now, jim steyr, founder and ceo of common sense media, a Nonprofit Organization dedicated to improving the lives of children and families in the digital age. Also hes the editor of the new anthology titled which side of histo history how technology is reshaping democracy and our lives and coauthor of one of the essays in the book. Start there. Shall we . I often take a look at the disinformation and try and u understand why have voters during this election season are embracing disinformation and always come back to facebook, disappearing ads, information out there out of context and i worry its had not just a dramatic impact on our democracy, but, perhaps, a prevailing impact. Would that be oversaying it . No. I think youre exactly right, mika. I mean, its incredible to see the impact that technology platforms, but particularly facebook and instagram, have had on our democracy and democratic norms and institutions and pretty amazings we are at a transformational moment as a country i think in whether or not we hold Companies Like facebook accountable. Its one of the major issues facing the incoming administration. Will they have a tech agenda that holds Tech Companies accountable for things like misinformation and hate speech on their platform . And i think youre going to see a Biden Administration do that and an incredibly good step forward. Talk a lot about section 230. This is willie geist. You would like it repealed and share that with the president of the United States. Shorthand, take a step back. What is it section 230, why is it sig kenificant part and why rid of it. Essentially a get out of jail free card for facebook and other social media platforms giving them blanket, essentially, blanket immunitiability from anything on their platform. Has to be changed from a kids and family standpoint or a misinformation, disinformation democracy standpoint. That has to be on the table. You saw in the hears yesterday congresspeeple people on both f the aisle what to reissue this. Facebook and twitter the biggest problem so far. How do you go about policing facebook with a couple billion users. A game of whackamole, defined hate speech, what is it . Where do you begin to tackle this problem just with facebook alone . Number one, rewrite the regulations. First Time Congress had to step up for the first time in more than 20 years and pass legislation that regulates that. Second, weve shamed them. We have a movement, stop hate for profit. Basically, it led to an advertising boycott over 1,000 advertisers and a lot of public shaming of the company for the fact they were openly impacting the election by providing disinformation to tens of millions of voters. I think its both legislation, public shaming and holding the leaders of the companies accountable. Absolutely imperative. Second, i think youll see antitrust cases against facebook from state attorneys general in the federal trade commission in the coming weeks and that will also have a big impact on them. We need a fullcourt press on the Tech Industry to make sure that they are on the right side of history. Right now Mark Zuckerberg and facebook are on the wrong side of history and were paying the price for that. Mike barnicle is here with a question. Hi, mike. You mentioned correctly the impact facebook and instagram have on our culture, world, voting processes and just mentioned you are part of an effort that has tried to shame facebook for what it has not done. So my question to you is what do you do when at the end of the day Mark Zuckerberg, facebook, sheryl samberg, helps run the organization with zuckerberg, what if he simply do not care what you say about them . Well i think they dont care that much, or they would have changed their behavior more by now. Number one, mike. Number two, you have to legislate and regulate this. We passed major privacy law in california in 2018 and passed a ballot to strengthen that law. Theres a chance to do state legislation on some of these issues. End of the day, congress has to get its act together and President Biden has to lead an effort to regulate these companies on accountability and they can do that. I predict here on this show that we will have section 230 reform in 2021. And i actually think well have antitrust cases against facebook as well. Do i think change is on, its coming. Thats a healthy thing. Founder and ceo of common sense media, jim steyr, working on this a long time. Thank you very much. The new book which side of history how technology is reshaping democracy and our lives. Jonathan lemire, if that prediction comes true, that will change, change social media and i think how people get news dramatically. Well, no question of that. Well see, of course, if the prediction does come true, but you were right, mika. Certainly we should note, though, press end of three hours today underscoring the crisis right now with the coronavirus pandemic. And how the president , im on my way to the white house now, continues to have no Public Events scheduled. There are worries rumors around him maybe more firings may be eminent. In this moment that calls for leadership, hes not going so, meanwhile, president elect joe biden we note will be having a roundtable with frontline home workers from his home in wilmington, delaware, as he attempts even without the official transition authorized by the Trump Administration try to show leadership during this everworsening pandemic. Getting worse. Saw the Hospital Administrator explain what it looks like inside though covid united nations. The president of the United States spending time tweeting conspiracy from voter election. Look at map. All bright red. When this pandemic first surged, hot spots around the country that needed to be contained. Were in a different place. Its running rampant, and the president tweets about himself. That does for us this morning. Stephanie ruhle picks up the coverage right now. Hi there. Im stephanie ruhle. It is wednesday, november 18th, and we have got a huge show for you this morning. Tons of news to get to. So strap in. Lets get smarter. We already know that President Trump isnt showing much interest in helping the nation address the coronavirus crisis, but now trump may be creating a new problem