>> line item 1, can we do the "pledge of allegiance". >> oh, that too. so let's do that first. >> okay, if you you can stand if you're able. for the "pledge of allegiance". >> i pledge allegiance tolt flag of the united states of america and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under god indivisible with liberty and justice for all. >> thank you, for the reminder. >> item 1, public comment. at this time, the public is able to address the commission. under police commission rules of order during public comment, are required to respond by comment but may provide a brief response. or written comments may be sent to u.s. postal service located at 1235 third street. if you would like to make public comment at this time, please press star-3. >> francisco nacosta. what i want to talk today is about emergency services. you commissioners should call in a commander who is involved with the emergency services so that, we all can get an idea what it needs to do a needs assessment. this is very variety to our city at this time because of what is happening. with the homelessness, not only with the drugs, but even with the fireworks. you can be a commission and just think that you know, you're going to be involved with policy making and running your mouth on mundane issue while the citizens of san francisco, are suffering because the quality of issues have gone to the hogs. the citizens but we need to do this on a raw footing. and that is where the military comes, not the military per se, but who has commanders, we need a commander who can do who can lead the emergency services. and work with the commissioners, not all of you but some of you all, so you really know how to run a first class city. today this is not a first class city. because people from all over the world are writing to me about it, thank you very much. >> thank you, caller. >> good evening, caller, you have two minutes. >> hello my name is cindy guzman i'm coordinateeter for the relations, i'm calling on the police commission to consider a proposed ordinance brought by a commissioner carter overstone who was introduced back in february and community groups are overwhelmingly. still has not yet. we want the commission to recognize the urgency of this. you know the fact that there are racial disparity in stops by police, the fact that if you only have 5% of the population in san francisco, the african-american about 27% out of the stops are of african-american that there is racial bias associated with these types of stops. and you know, we can also see that when we have these types of stops, that increases the chance of potential violence, on community members. shots to the body and, you know, and this was as a result, you can see that the community is very much concerned about that. and one of the things that we have a sizable community located in san francisco, one of the reasons for pretext stops could be if you have to continue from the rear view mirrors and a lot of them have. like clearviews, hanging from their rear view mirrors, but it has been used as a course stopping form to the community members. including one of my close friends that that has happened to. >> thank you, caller. good evening, caller, you have two minutes. >> hello my name is david, i'm a resident of district 1. the following is a quote from our founder if he--felicia zones, i'm going to call it what it is, anti blackness in terms of racial profiling. i've grown tired of talking to commission and to the board of supervisors, what is the urgency? if the tables were turned, i know there would be an urgency, when are you going to address the hare much and unjust statistics which is your responsibility as you took an oath to uphold the law for all san franciscoians, i'm tired, not tired of to quit but tired of beating a dead horse. we sought help from attorney general. in quote, we understand the low level traffic stops which was just discussed by the brief color starting to be discussed among officials and take flight nationwide. often disparity has been demanding via traffic stops for months. the black san franciscoian is three times as likely to be stropd for traffic stop. this is one of the worse black statistics anywhere. since the reform, the racial disparity level has gotten worse. routine traffic stops make up a large majority about two-thirds of stops. proven that they stop black people disproportionately and arrest black people even more disproportionately. it's long time to take them off their hands. would also like to understand how all matters related along the elimination as we have requested. >> thank you, caller. good evening, caller you have two minutes. >> speaker: good evening, it's chairperson and members of the commission. this is the amos brown, president of the san francisco aacp and baptist church of san francisco. i just talked as a pastor and civil rights advocacy, to pledge my support for holistic approach to the problem of crime and homelessness in the city. san francisco must be delivered from simpletic and realize that it takes all hands-on deck, loving mercy and welcome with their principals of their god. we can be better than who we are now. or we're too busy pointing fingers at the chief and at the commission. this needs to be a weighsing and if we don't know how to work together as dr. king said we're all going to perish as fools. in black community, we have over our share of lawlessness, that's because of a lack of opportunity for the most part but in addition to that, we need to be firm about policing and professional and being compassionate in our communities to do the same in all other communities. we must work together if we're going to save the city and give o our report that he deserves considering the high professionalism that he has given us in this city. >> good evening, chief, i'm avi fry. i'm here representing the aclu of northern california as a deputy director of criminal justice program and as a resident that it san francisco living in the mission district. i'm also calling to address what seems to delay in implementing stops in san francisco. on behalf of thousands of aclu khafter members in the city, we have worked tirelessly in community with other organizations and groups and it's been over a year since, an understanding was presented to the commission. it's been months since commissioner over stone presented the idea. the community is waiting to get this process under way. there is no safety justification for continuing for stops and in the meantime, the delay is resulting in real harms. it's resulting in the hafsh to the community. and into violence and even death. and so on behalf of oufr members and our organizations, i ask for a greater sense of urgency in getting this off the ground before tragedy strikes again, thank you so much. >> thank you, caller. >> good evening, caller, you have two minutes. >> speaker: good evening, commissioners, this is from the public defender's office, i have the callers call for urgency beginning the general order. that commission introduced two months ago. we still have weeks and months of working groups and town halls ahead of us, so it's dis heartening to see that we're not months away. but we do have a practical issue that i want to point out that i think the commission wants to claim quickly. seems to have disappeared from the commission website possibly because of the redesign. i'm asking that if you can make those public again so we can see the point coming from the community. thank you. >> thank you, caller. good evening, caller you have two minutes. >> leslie senior, glide is proud member of the community driven coalition to end by stops which now representatives over 60 local organizations who are united in our goal of pretech stops. some of my colleagues have called in this evening as well. i appreciate you prioritizing the addition. and we're hoping that it does proceed in a timely manner. this discussion has been formerly initialed, however we have yet to know about when the working groups will convene. i last asked the body on june 8th. we're looking to having a clear timeline and that includes a tentative list of dates and simultaneous town hall and a working group that incorporates the voices of community stakeholders and people who are impacted. because these racial disparity as said a couple of times this evening, they're persistent right now and the need to move quickly is doubly reinforced by san francisco ranks the worse in the state when it comes to black rates. so we should proceed aggressively and no approach to addressing these harms. and i ask that we initial these process soon, thank you. >> thank you, caller. good evening, caller you have two minutes. >> good evening, this is proun, kurning my son who was murdered august 13th, 2006. to this day, he has his case has not been solved. and as a moerlt i'm still looking for justice for my son. cause is coming up right around the corner. and i'm still looking for justice and helping other mothers and fathers who lost their children to homicide. as i call in for justice, and hoping that the police commission can expedite or do something for unsolved homicide. and with that, i thank you for listening to me. >> thank you, ms. brown. members of the public if you have any information on the murder of abry ana costa, you can call the hotline. thank you. >> thank you, very much next line please. >> line item 2, adoption of minutes for june 8th, 15, and 20th 2022. >> i'll make a motion. >> i'll second. >> thank you. >> second. >> on the motion, commission how do you vote. >> yes. >> benedicto yes. >> yes. >> over stone is yes. >> commissioner burn. >> commissioner burn is yes. >> commissioner ye. >> yes. >> commissioner ye is yes. >> and president. >> yes. >> president is yes. you have five yeses. >> thank you, can we go to public comment. >> at this time the public can make comment on item number 2, if you would like to comment you can press star-3 right now. no public comment. >> thank you. >> line number 3, public safety concerns providing overview of the census. chief scott. >> thank you, good evening, vice president and commission and director anderson. i'll start this week with the crime and i'll go into significant arrest and incidents. overall violent crime is over 6% homicide is down 4%. and other significant crime, robberies are up 1%. 14 robberies from this time last year. and results are up 12%. as far as property crime we are up a total of 7% over this time last year, 22372 property crimes compared to to 951. the good news is we're down burglar's 25%. that's 29,015 compared to 29086. our biggest driver is lars re. lars reis up 16,2 19. included in that category with auto burglars which we're up 8% from this time last year. 10001, compared to 9264. although we have made some progress in reducing that percentage over the last couple of months which we're going to continue to do what we can to drive that number down. in terms of our violent crime ,z our gun violence is down from last year, 121 incident last year, 103 total incident this year, difference of 15% decrease. come sides with firearms are down by 3. 17 this year compared to last year. and our non fatal shooting victims are down from 101 to 86 this year. homicide clearance rate is around 64%. year to date we did make a homicide arrest this week that i'll talk about shortly. in terms of the station break down the significant data is mission station leads the increase in homicides, they have 8 compared to 2 this time last year. they view as a decrease fromle this time last year to 4. northern is down by 1 from this time last year, park is down by 1, remains at 0. terwell is up 2 nr 020 to* 2. and tender lauren is down from 3, from 6 last year to 3 this year. as far as our guns, we have ceased a total of 5 19 total guns this year. and of that, 217 are ghost guns, 91 of ghost guns. that's about. significant incident over this last reporting period, we did have two homicides for the weekend ending 3. one is 400 block of arrest there has not been a arrest. the victim was in the street unresponsive as officers arrived they conducted life saving efforts which were unsuccessful. the victim died in the hospital from his injuriesment many heard gunshots and we are canvassed the area for private civilian cameras and we do have some information that we obtained on this case to follow-up. i'll give updates as this case progresses. the second homicide was on june 1 in the day view district at third street and khafter. the victim was lying on the ground next to him. initial statement by the vehicles prior to being identified. our video review from evidence that we collected showed that the victim was at a pizza parlor when he got into an argument with this unknown person. the person that's been identified and arrested actually, was arrested the next day. and this was some really good work by our investigators who because they know the area, know the people in the area were able to actually put this case together very quickly and arrest the suspect for murder. so that was really good work by the investigators and the patrol officers in the case. the couple of shooters that happened in july fourth, 9:59 there was a shooting. she was struck by a bullet. no suspects were seen and no arrest were made. that is under investigation. victim was a street performer was on the sidewalk when unshown suspect shattered on the foot. we do have follow-up information that we're looking into and hopefully we'll make progress in that case. shooting in the fourth, was in the 200 block of rich in the southern subject. a subject and asked to use the restroom when he was refused by the employees an argument ensued and subject left restaurant. a restaurant employee followed the subject and followed him in the street at which time a fight took place, the restaurant being shot. and wounded. the injuries are not life threatening and that case is still under investigation. no arrest has been made in this arrest. couple of significant arrest, on july 1, victim security guard on walgreens was stabbed after admonishing a suspect fortress passing in that store. the victim attempted to place the subject under the arrest. the suspect took out a knife and stabbed the victim several times. while officers were drafting a warrant, the person left his approximately and taken the custody. le and after the arrest for vandalizing pd vehicle. the victim is in stable condition and expected to survive the incident. and series of organized retail thefts. this happened over the past few months and several of them resulted throughout the area being burglarized. police are leading investigating agencies on june 18th, an american while driving the vehicles. and multiple counts for burglary and robbery and warrants out of brentwood and san francisco. the state attorney general office has expressed rate and our investigators will cult with our district attorney as well as other interested agencies and the state in this series of arrest. the very significant, we golt a number of these in the city and these were prolific suspects, those were burglar details. couple of some of the strategies, we've had an increase and shots fired in the day view and as a result we adjusted our deployment over this fourth of july holiday weekend. we increased our third corridor and increased our presence with tick post and some of the housing development in the district where we've had multiple shots fired. we plan to make adjustments as necessary. also in the ingle side additional resources were deployed. there were three incidents, the station participated in ten community event including merchant laws, meeting with community groups and planning for out coming community and police colob rated events and also to address concerns which is corridor which is a part of this policing plant for this year. so we hope that those strategies will do the couple of things and address the concerns meeting with members of the community. last thing on the investigative side is our driving. unfortunately we had no side shows over this holiday weekend. i do want to report progress with really good work being done. that's under the special operations bureau and really in collaboration with the district stations who always get resources to these events and we know about them, when we think that they're coming. this is resulted in approximately 40 vehicles that have been seized as a result of follow-up investigation. and i want to reemphasize if you come to san francisco and participate in these events, even if you're not caught, we will not give up on pursuing you to be held accountable for the danger of these events. with that, our follow-up investigators have done some really good work and approximately 40 cars have been seized. and that has resulted i think in us having some success and driving the side showdown in our city. so we'll continue to work on that. and last thing to report in terms of significant incident, there is a west of angel island. this happened on the 30th of june. our boat collided with the sale boat, the victim did not survive the injuries. the marine union was part of that and we were not able to save this person. and that is that is it for my report for this week, thank you. >> thank you, chief. i'm going to turn it over to my fellow commissioners, i don't see any questions or comments. commissioner ye. >> yes, i just want to talk about the graduating class, i want to thank for representing us in the graduation class. also i want to thank the chief and her staff for i guess, keeping us safe during the i word is parade, big celebration, pretty close to half a million people and also the pride parade which got to join as well as the chief and san francisco police staff as well. that's all i have, thank you madam chair. >> thank you. >> thank you. public comment. >> if you would like to make public comment please press star-3 now. good evening, caller you have two minutes. >> speaker: i want to talk about the walgreens on st. bruno and felton. if we do not support the wal green that is outside of security, we will lose the walgreen. this walgreen helps seniors with their medication and what we are doing is we lying on the board of supervisors. i heard a joke, it's a serious joke. they say that only the wal green shows receipts of over 100,000 in all loss of things stolen than they can have the wallgreen. this is ridiculous. the walgreen in san bruno now caters. are we going to wait until the wal green on san brun o closes? i have over 100 complaints about it. we have some offices, like office of percy, because it goes beyond the call of duty to do a good job. but we can do better. and chief of scott knows about san bruno. i accompanied him, he visited a few stores, we do business, we up lifted one another. i'm asking they contribute to the city. save the wallgreen on san bruno and felton. thank you very much. >> thank you, caller. sxao and vice president, that's the end. >> next item please. line item 4. presentation of the april and may 2022, report. director anderson. >> start talking while i was muting this time, just making a note that we're improving and getting better. good evening, we have 336 case that's we have been opened. and we have closed 263 cases so far this year. we have 237 case that's are pending and we have sustained 38 cases so far this year. we needed 11 cases this year and we have 20 cases who's investigations have extended beyond a 9-month period. this time last year, we had 28 case that's had gone that far. of those 20 cases continued open, 15 of those case right side told. we have commission has 12 pending cases and decision wz dpa and there is one case that is still pending with the chief. in terms of the weekly trend, we have not met in a while so this is a three-week summary. in the past three weeks, we received just 26 cases. and top allegations are 36% of allegations have been with allegations failing to take the required action. most of those are for allegations wanting a police report. and 14% are for alleging sfrd behaved or spoke inappropriately to the public. if you want the complete list they're on the website. in terms of the district break down, i just tried to talk about the top districts that have come in and those would be in terms of allegations that have come to dpa and the top district is, mission and again the allegations are concentrated around officers taking failing to take required action and making an appropriate comment. and that's a new search permission when which reported three weeks ago, there was only allegation that came out of mission, there were five this time. the largest second agency was outside of the police jurisdiction, one of the new things that we're doing is making sure that when people call, we're making referrals to the appropriate agencies. so it's frequently the case that people will come in and/or call into the office with complaints about ice or dea or other jurisdictions with information and my staff is trained and we make referrals and that's the second largest allegation that came in and referrals were made by our office. 64 cases were received in april. and in may 59 cased received. there were a total of 109 allegations and total 120 allegations made by the public in april. in terms of the audit, the 22, we held an opening meeting with sspd to initial the annual of compliant with a-coin 8-10. and i'll continue to give you updates with those but we started those meetings last month. in terms of out reach, we had a no your rights presentation at the family youth and family system of care providers. the attendees developed a presentation to better integrate families with systems to develop planning and implementation of city services. we also participated in the park district, richmond district and stations. we also had a conversation outlet--i'll let commissioner bendicto talk about it. but all the participants from the mediators that are trained and the work with our program within the past few weeks as well. we have no cases today in closed session. investigators is online in case any issues come up to help with today's meeting. if the public would like to get in contact with the agencies, you can find us at sf dot dpa. you can just google dp a or contact us at 415-241-7711 and we will return the calls. we have an agenda item that we worked on and i'll reserve my comments until we get to to it. i would raise the issue again, i know we said we were going to be caring that the numbers that i read off to the statistics and the numbers from internal affairs. i'm raising the flag as continue to give the information. it would be great if we had something to compare the statistics and numbers to the other agency that is responsible for discipline. that concludes my report for the evening. >> great, thank you director henderson. >> commissioner do you have any questions for director henderson? all right, seeing none, sergeant can you go to public comment. >> at this time the public is welcome to make public comment regarding line item number 4, if you would like to make public comment, please press star-3 right now. there is no public comment. >> thank you, next item please. >> line item 5, commission reports. commission reports will be discussion will be limiting to determine any of the issues raised for a future commission meeting. commissioners reports and commission announcements and schedule identified for consideration in the future commission meeting. >> thank you, i'm going to turn it over to my fellow commissioners for report and updates. i think we'll kick it off with commissioner benedicto. >> thank you. i have a number of updates for the commission and members of the public. the first one that i want today talk with is the update on the department general order draft 9.01. members of the commission have been working closely to rollout i would like to start by thinking. i know tonight you heard from guide and public defender so thank you for the continued engagement for members of the public. we're very excited to partner with dr. davis and they're going to help facilitate the out reach to the public which is going to take the form of three different methods of out reach which will begin the upcoming weeks. there will be commissioner staff with materials about this general record upcoming community events in august including national night out. that's an example of communities going. also with the tremendous commission, there will be community listening session that's will be hosted, those will begin the week with locations and dates to come. to allow us feedback from the community. additionally august will feature the start of working groups which will take into account. for members of the public who will call who are interested, that's the general schedule. process is on going, we recognize the need for urgency and are moving often and continue to thank the public for their comments on that. i also wanted to as a commissioner ye shared, that the commission spoke at class 275 graduation class. 6 were bilingual it was great to welcome them and to get to meet some of the cadets at that event. as director henderson noted, i also attended a event hosted for the first time in-person since covid. i was able to ex speak to the mediator, things were very happy to learn that the commission was represented there. and members mediation program is really a world class restorive program that provides a great way to resolve some of the disputes brought to dba, i think after--we'll work to agendize, because i think it is, it is underappreciated in a tremendous program that the dba can get. so thank you to all the mediator and to the department for the officers who agreed to participate in the program as well. and that's all for me. >> can i just say, thank you so much for participating and attending commissioner. the mediation folks and mediators themselves they pay attention to police commission and it's a big deal that you came and did the walk through and answer their questions. they know who all of you are. and they pay attention to the issues that culminate in the cases here. so i appreciate that you came, but i will probably be inviting you and the others to come back in the future as well. it was one of the things that was important to them, so thank you again. >> thank you, thank you, director henderson. also as updated position regarding the group and listening sessions will be provided on the commission website. we encourage people to continue to email us with the comments and suggestions. we receive information from the department. for members as well as the public so that's been helpful and he want to encourage people to participate that way and we'll try to make the commission website the hub for all of information regarding this dd g.o. so thank you for the update commissioner benedicto. commissioner burn, any updates? >> thank you, just two quick updates. number one, i have heard, i'm going to reach out to the captain of northern station. >> there is building and they call me and they get a crew to fix it and then it's filed again. we have what appears to be drug dealing. i indicated that i saw to discuss this issue. obviously, they are how would i say, they are satisfied right now with the increased employment in the evening shifts. they have obviously noticed an improvement. they verified that it's going to go beyond august. that's the information that was related to me. i certainly welcome that, i think it makes a difference for the lives of people in the area. that is all i have to report, thank you. >> commissioner that's correct. >> thank you very much. commissioner ye, i think you gave your report already but do you have any additional. okay. and commissioner carter overstone. okay, great. public comment, sergeant? >> if you would like to make public comment, please press star-3 now. good evening, caller you have two minutes. caller you have two minutes. >> speaker: hello i'm a governor intern for economic relations. i just wanted to say that you know, care, really that this concept has been introduced as early as february 2022 and other groups that have proposed this idea in june of 2021. so the need to move quickly, sorry. i'm sorry, i yield my time. >> thank you, caller. good evening, callers, you have two minutes. >> speaker: i want to speak on restoring justice. when i first learned about it in in 2010 when i went to new zealand and then we incorporated it here in san francisco. and the supervisor, i think his name was superman. i know we're talking in general terms of people visiting certain institutions, but we have to incorporate it in our school so just a suggestion. and this had been tied to the millions of dollars that has been given to organizations to stop hate crime, the portion of that can be utilized for restorive justice. so i would like to thank paul henderson, i would like to see him smile a little bit. i think he's a wise president who made some good comments. i appreciate what y'all do, but i have to run the boat because i've got too many people who ask me francisco do this and do that, and i say come on man, i cannot work miracles. all i can do is say something but i'm not even saying something to doing more. thank you very much. >> thank you, caller. >> vice president, that's the end of public comment. >> thank you, next item. >> line item 6. discussion to adopt, hostage and barricade suspect. le discussion and possible action. >> thank you, is anyone presenting or you just want us to vote? >> yeah, i think you vote, let me check my notes. >> we have captain simeria on the phone, sorry about that. >> thank you, i hope everybody can hear me. police commissioners, i'm captain john januarymoreno. i'm here with unit and our of all things, g.o., since 2020. this is a g.o.that was originally written in 199 had and either during that time, we worked with pta, and the police commission. to come up with a new department that appropriated g-dog and some verification. there is some additions and some areas that have been made more robust and we're happy to answer any questions or have any discussions. thank you. >> thank you, captain. i don't have any questions but i think that you can answer them at the last meeting that this was agendized and i think we also had it in closed session. do my fellow commissioners have any questions or comments or edits? okay, so can i get a vote or a motion actually? >> i'll move to adopt. >> i'll second it. >> sergeant. >> at this time public is welcomed to make any public comment on this item. if you wish to make any public comment, please press star-3 now. vice president, there is no public comment. i'll take the vote. >> thank you, sergeant. commissioner benedicto? >> yes. >> overstone. >> yes. >> commissioner burn. >> yes. >> commissioner burn is yes, commissioner ye. >> yes. >> commissioner ye is yes. and vice president. >> yes. >> vice president is yes, you have five yeses. >> thank you. >> thank you, commissioners. >> thank you. thank you for your hard work on this. sergeant. >> line item 7 public comment on all items below closed session and whether to hold item 9 in closed session, if you would like to make public comment please press star-3 right now. and there is no public comment. line item 8, vote whether to hold item 9 in closed session. action. >> i'll make a motion can i get a second. >> second. >> on the motion, commissioner benedicto how do you vote. >> yes. >> benedict ofrjt is yes. over ?nd stone. n.yes. >> commissioner burn. >> yes. >> commissioner burn is yes. >> commissioner ye. >> yes. >> and vice president. >> yes. >> vice president is yes, you have five yeses and i will take us into closed session. >> i make a motion not to disclose can i get a second. >> second. >> thank you. >> on the motion not to disclose. >> benedicto. >> yes. >> commissioner over ?nd stone. >> yes. >> commissioner burn. >> yes. >> commissioner burn is yes. commissioner ye. >> yes. >> and commissioner lie as. >> yes. >> commissioner lias, yes. >> line number 11, adjournment. >> adjourned. >> without objection. >> all right, have a great night, everyone, can you. --thank you. >> thank you all. >> all right, good afternoon everyone. i'm san francisco mayor london breed and thank you so much for joining us here today. for mia nounsment of who the next district attorney for the city and county and city of san francisco will be. i know, it comes as no surprise to a lot of you but here we are and we have i think an extraordinary women who will take the helm of the d.a.'s office, ladies and gentlemen brooke jenkins. [applause] you know san francisco has had some challenging times. we've been here before. we talk about what a resilient city we are. we lost a mayor, we have