Commissioner hwang commissioner melara commissioner president loftus you have a we have quorum and chief suhr e chief suhr is here. Welcome to the wednesday, february 3, 2016, Police Commission meeting sergeant, next item. Item one at this time, members of the public may address the commission on items of interest to the public that are within the subject matter jurisdiction of the commission except agenda items. With respect to agenda items, your opportunity to address the commission will be afforded when through Police Commission reluctance of order we are not required to respond to the public individual commissioners and occ personnel should not get into discussion and members of the public may address the commission up to 3 minutes. Thank you sergeant good evening and welcome. Madam president jim senior native born and raised the Mission District lived in San Francisco my entire life and served there that panel at one time im here to say number one madam president at your on behalf of in 2013 i filed with the occ i was redundant those are the things that stay with the officers throughout the career, however, and risk of disskwaid people i have to say the occ doesnt have the resources to do certain types of investigations so at the end of the day ii if unfortunately had a difficult time with officer simpson we have problems there was a traffic stop on this sunday i pulled over immediately as soon as it was safe to do so and an officer i think center 2089 came up to the window and said license and register and proof of insurance i had my license in my hand and didnt reach over to the comboef commencement but the person was belittle and wouldnt know why someone would do that im a former Police Commissioner, i have respected for those two risk their lives you can imagine a boy from the Black Mountain community and lastly i came here to say this well follow suit and let that officer ive spoken to his Commanding Officer i came in here to say a chief suhr in private and over the years this youre a god sent youre the encounter police chief this supply as had i lament the fact youre in this situation ive watched you the black and Brown Community and know how dedicated and committed to the citizens of this great city so, please hang in there weve got a lot more work to do as commissioners you have a huge charge with problems and unfortunately, it falls on your shoulder this is not a fulltime i worry about you well and happy new year. Next speaker good evening and welcome. Thank you my name is daniel i see that form poa president and now poa consultant gary is back the first time he was the news during the rodney king upcoming rising the police chief requested that some cops remove the offending newspapers called the bay times has showed somebody dressed in a Police Uniform with a face with a baton between their legs with a lead motion gary was one of the cops that confiscated those newspapers he should have been fired for that. That is a violation of First Amendment when you have the police confiscating material for the public consumption hills defensive not theft the papers were free should basically he was a dirty cop and now as a consultant for the poa he is a been fined by the Ethics Commission some 5,600 for illegally lobbying politicians the Police Commission pays the fine he keeps on doing this he thinks like bad cops are blow the law theyre not just the law but above the law thats what the police union does that protects cops whether homophobic or whatever so what i say to people if you want to Police Reform before you vote find out who the police union is endorsing and vote against that person lets turn support from the police union into a cadet for the political activists has anyone looked at the leadership of the police union it is mostly white and male. Thank you, sir. Next speaker. Good evening and welcome. Thank you. Good evening commissioners and chief suhr that id like to take the opportunity im a senior staff lawyer i wanted to come here and talk about San Francisco civil rights ordinance you mean we had a hearing on the 13 of january but the process cbos back much farther six or seven years ago Community Members tried to pass this 79 organizations supported this ordinance have been coming to you guys as you may know complaint backseats before the occ that raise questions whether or not the organization has followed that was filed one year ago there was a establishment and the understanding the officer has not been interviewed were concerned we hope it didnt get thrown out and i wanted to raise the report that was submitted to us was steel circular with the fbi we sent a list of questions and concerns to the sfpd last year sfpd came back and addressed each of the concerns the january 13th meeting they didnt they didnt address any of the concerns we think there needs to be a fuller hearing and get to the bottom where sfpd is using this language and what we can do to get a report that understand the adjoining complaint so we hope to working closely with all of you to get to a point where this ordinance the law of the land in San Francisco is awe hedhered t im here with any colleague i wanted to raise the concept of the illegal activity report i explained on january 13th those are reports that cbo through sfpd and are shared with the local center those reports are gathered award to the legal suspension and are often bans the biass the fewtion center release was as of the city of berkley net sfpd refuses to release the surveys from a request floor from my office the Police Department has not seen this report sf results in those received by the sfpd and the public has a Environmental Impact report right to see the racial precisely that runs reprimand rampant is not happening in sf i join and echo the comments of my colleagues. Next speaker. Good evening and welcome claude. Doctor marshall youre good i listen to you ever word you say you olden a lot of truth this mayor is a tragedy all around okay. I said to someone this will be a unique and mario woods hey ill not pass judgment but it is great a dialogue now at the end of the diplomacy i see that now people are talk well claude would you think that that i hope you get a bigger budget and more staff every time an officer discharges a weapon you need to be involved your office needs to be involved i emailed everyone but a Bigger Picture here a lot of things are happening chicago, new york all over look at florida a young africanamerican shot 3 times by sheriff people we have to look at this as i said weve got to change the cultural and chief suhr i thought about you quieting my passion overruled by better judgment you can be a catalyst of change in this Police Department i know you will we have to change the mindset of officers we can do that youre part of that we cant play the that politics clyde take out the politics we dont need the board of supervisors sticking their noses in but youve seen the political issue that is a Service Issue we have to look at that way thank you. Thank you. Next speaker. Good evening and welcome ms. Brown. Thank you. My name is Paulette Brown and im here as usual concern any son id like to use the overhead aubrey brown who was murdered august 14, 2006, to a semiautomatic cabin thirty rounds of bullets left that gun into my son you havent shown the picture yet so maybe ill start all over im looking for justice for my child and again, this is my son aubrey brown he was is it showing on sfgov . My son aubrey brown was murdered august 14, 2006, to a semiautomatic cabin i have been on the battlefield for will 9 years concerning my son a 200 and 50,000 reward ive had phenomenon 9 years none has come forth yet these are the perpetrators that were there these are the names of my son violators i was given Thomas Andrew and Anthony Carter and Anthony Hunter and marcus caterer i say the mayor the form mayors of 70 San Francisco said i know who killed her son so if you know who killed my son homing this case is not solved if he was a white boy would this case be solved are a white woman would my sons case be solved if i had money would my sons case be solved i feel the same thing as marios mother shell never get over this it doesnt matter where the bullet came from see those names those boys are still walking the street it is a shame that i have to walk and come into meetings all the time to bring awareness of my son and still no justice its been 9 years everybody 9 years and next year will be a decade 10 years how long will a mother impervious i say again, if my son was a little white boy i believe his case would be solved i say again, if i was a white woman my sons case would be solved liquor kate up here 14 i want the same justice i want the same thing thats what ill asking for i didnt get to show this last picture really quick thats my son and thats what i have left so anyone else ever mother feeling this way if they had those pictures help me anyone who is watching here at home knows anything about the murder of aubrey brown an anonymous tipline 415 5754444 thank you ms. Brown next speaker. Good evening and welcome. Hello michael i wanted to address a few points okay accountability and the Police Department is really out there the community and under discussion i have to call for this body to consider a resolution calling to strip the cops of confidentiality that protects them i have amuse complaints about 9 office of citizens complaints and the officers are showing up going into mediation and going through the process and the cops will never be named the cops have to be held accountable when the complaints with filed they are named i believe this body should consider a one paragraph resolution calling on mark len and david chiu to call on their colleagues in sacramento to change the cop protection law we have to name the cops when the complaints with filed the next matter is i filed a Sunshine Ordinance Task force complaint against this body you are not adhering to the sunshine laws that call on commissions to put on specific your agenda say a report from the chief Financial Officer and the president when we show up youve got a long list of specific things youll address that we need to know in advance you are going to address it is not okay to keep on saying chiefs report and thats it chief tells you what youre going to talk about im not buying in department of justice cops investigation of the department the d o jewelry box cops investigation for this Police Department for wrongs doing is not looking at the mario woods it is window dressing it is not a federal investigation that is going to carry legal weight chief Financial Officer youll be able to dismiss with the doj cops come back you know when i looked at the news and you chief were there with the mayor and the cops fellow utensil not be appearing before the cameras if in the real genuine federal investigation with legal exclamations the last thing mayor ed lee get out of your office and come into the community and hole forums about Police Accountability this indoor approach he said he has is not okay hes going to every nfl event need to get out to the community about the Police Department thank you. Thank you. Next speaker. Hearings oh. Yes. Of course, come on up. Well and good evening. Im david im going to try to read this the Police Shootings of mario woods left to a federal probe of sfpd but without the mandates of the civil rights investigation the cops prone by design b will tap down community out rankle with a sfpuc we must reject this outcome and San Francisco especially is workingclass communities of color will not wait quietly for a no toast cops report of half measures by officials if this Police Commission cant get its stuff together with the enforcement of policy there are those who will go ahead and persian through inform a Ballot Initiative to get the results we need to San Francisco a clear eyed recognize that sfpd is a typical Police Department with a warrior and occupation mentality of the racism and impunity despite to the contrary all the data points out to that the history the chinatown and the tax squad address huge disparity between the black and brown the texting scandal and the many white papers but the diverse firing squad gunning down mario woods while lopez and over thirty of the hundred and 3 other shots since 2000 has gone without notice commissioners, i ask you to do your jobs find the courage to reform the Police Department and push back against the intimidation by the poa and dont imagine your fate socially and politically or crazy by maintaining a lethal status quo. Thank you. Any further Public Comment. Good evening and welcome. Good evening. Im thomas i will just like to suppress a concern and the concern is i saw the paper a couple of days ago there is some internal dispute around yolanda King Williams of the poa as you may know yolanda is an outspoken africanamerican and speaks here mind around issues around race and other issues and it so moved, commissioners, that motion passes from the article she finds herself standing alone around the Police Officers association and permanent there was a letter that was sent addressing here issues sent to the 2000 officers that are part of poa as a result of that it she expressed concerns about her safety and not feeling safe im not an officer i dont know but one of the kind of phone call lower things about being a Police Officer if an officer who doesnt tow the line the other officers want them to tow possible they need assistance that assistance may not come or come a little bit late im here to ask that the chief be aware of this and help her secure her safety if there is an issue and that the commission be aware of this possibility so she can feel save doing what shes doing as well as the other officers also in terms of what i read about the poa is they can be pretty stern theyve been recorded to bull supervisors theyve been reported seeing in other places turning their backs on mayors the chief may have to walk a thin line of supporting and an officer or a group of officers but i hope it we all put here safety and her ability to do her job as one of the premiums for the department thank you. Thank you, mr. Simpson. Is there any additional Public Comment . Hearings Public Comment is closed. Sergeant, next item. Item 2 reports and announcements chiefs report and review of recent activities and just want regarding the use of force policy. Again chief. Good evening review of recent events it is busy right now in San Francisco obviously one of the big things were seeing the sister is busy with the few see something Say Something over the weekend when a citizen a matthew noticed a stolen van that was occupied by the expels from california a alerted the officers on the street and they were taken into custody and great example for anybody watching we say it is not just when you see something say smoking gun something and the officers where they needed to be the Park District and made the arresting yesterday something happened added Harrison A Chp officers walked up to talk to a man almost on the freeway the superintendant slashed the chp throat and he fled the scene i spoke to the deputy chief and the officer is doing well, he will survive the suspect was taken into custody at the wells fargo and again, a very serious incident deployed and the event surrounding the superintendent carranza go forward large crowds no serious incidents recorded again, if anybody watching if you see something Say Something we want all the events to go forward safely we also spoken to by a couple of speakers we did attend at the invitation of the department of justice cops office specifically acting as the United States attorney for the director of the cops office theyll be 0 doing a acholic beverage review the San FranciscoPolice Department this is something that we asked for and the department of justice will building this lead of review is appropriate at this time i assure the public any recommendations will be taken seriously this report comes monitored by the cops office were right now as we look to draft a use of force order for this commission and the public to review weve incorporated already many of the comments weve discussed at the meeting emphasizing safety of life for everyone and the deesclation and the Community Workshops came forward with many recommendations are being incorporated for the draft and once the draft ready for the commission to consider we believe it will also be a good idea to over to the cops office and looking at prior acholic beverage reviews like las vegas and philadelphia this is something we require our policies are open at this time that will be manage that something that the public to get it right the first time as much as possible and then do get trained to that order with all the inclusions and the cops announcements came obtain monday, i will request that we be allowed to have until next week to get you the working draft it can be cleaned up and ready for the presentations the cops office as quickly as possible that concludes my report. Questions for the chief colleagues commissioner wong two questions the first is that i heard antidotes there was increased Police Enforcement so i want to speak to that. Thats not the case officers assigned to all the districts are in their regular deployment there is a specific plan with the plan with all the highly impacted areas but i meet with jennifer the coalition and assured her was we are moving through the cold and wet time we certainly are not putting anybody out into the cold. The second question i have to ask questions asked around the chp how fast was more seriously injured but how did sfpd get that the parallels in mario woods did he surrender. No. You actively the officers recognized the superintendents description and approached him he didnt have the knife in handicap there was a significant struggle the superintendant made a significant effort to get one of the officers gun but the safety holster kept it up the knife was in his rear pocket and discharged it and came back to gather it. Other questions for the chief. Chief i said to follow up on the update of the use of force policy thank you for the update we did have this conversation in december when we laid the need to revise and we set early february he appreciate the changed in particular, the resources from the doj and also well get a fuller update on the Community Forum there was a number of pieces of input from the community i want to be sure it is in there i met with ron davis from doj and made that request they make themselves strabl immediately to review the force i see that people in San Francisco have been Telegraph Hill in this conversation and that would be great if we annoyance the efforts and allow feedback in realtime as opposed to to a report that comes 8 months later and considering the now policy to be trained open is important we get the best ideas i want to let my colleagues know that chief the doj was repetitive this is designed to be acholic beverage and given the review they want to bring the subject experts at no cost to San Francisco that understand those issues and make recommendations which i will announce when we get is that part of agenda the process moving forward and how to get Public Comment but the director davis was pleased at the public input with our use of force and after that well come back and have conversation were really endeavoring to use to process as a time to inform everyone the community why and how were doing it i think the timing is incredible that doj is offering resources particularly to this commission. Question for chief i share mr. Simpsons concerns about the article that read about Sergeant Williams i dont know if it is a Personnel Matter we can discuss but it is very, very trouble and without a response the public feels there are not responses so whatever you can say please do. Officer williams has been contacted and asked about to what degree she feels confront or u. S. Bancorp comfortable and at this time she will remain in her assignment and we had a before and after if she wanted to be put in another assignment but she needs this. And with that comes well monitor did situation and make sure that even if this happens out of normal. Absolutely. Absolutely yes. Okay so by way of update a question from 70s there was an article i think the gentleman said yeah we were referring to that. Any further questions for the chief colleagues. Thank you, chief sergeant, next item. Occ directors report and review of recent activities. Good evening director hicks and good evening commissioner president loftus and chief suhr and members of the public ill make 4 brief announcement and from any of the announcements ill be happy to agendize those items for a further report january 28th i participated in a press conference by supervisor cowen she announced a battle measure she proposed that will amend the San Francisco charter to permit the occ to look at a officer involved shooting even though a report was not filled the second announcement he attended the department of justice Cops Division press conference on february 1st, it was discussed by chief suhr i believe also by commissioner president loftus that was on the acholic beverage Reform Initiative that the Cops Department will enter into with the San FranciscoPolice Department. Following the press conference i too met with director davidson and his staff and occ members as well as we could advise the cops office how the office of citizens complaints operates and this was an initial meeting we expect there will be many more the future and finally and that was also discussed by chief suhr occ staff and i participate in the Community Meetings on the use of force and found it enlightening and particularly happy to see youth was there members of the Youth Commission they were engaging in the forums and had a particular idea they addressed that concludes any announcement. Thank you decorating any questions commissioner Vice President turman. Just to clarify supervisor cowens legislation will amend the charter it says the office of citizens complaints will be loudly to investigate all officer involved shootings as it currently stands you investigate the officer involved shootings there is an citizen complaint. Thats correct commissioner Vice President turman and moimg that amendment. Ill be happy to to agendize that for our next regular meeting our next regular meeting and give you a followup report. That would be helpful i think the rest of the commission would like to here commissioner mazzucco. Yes. Director hicks it clear to the audience and public the office of citizens complaints does show up every officer involved shooting without a complaint being filed; is that correct . Yes. Commissioner mazzucco we roll out and notified bid the Police Department and to most officer involved shootings and discharges and but we are constrained from investigating them until and unless a sentence complaint is filed. But you review the scene and see what is take place so your investigation starts down the road immediately like all the other investigations; is that correct. Thank you commissioner mazzucco for clarifying thats correct. Thank you director hicks any further questions for director hicks. Sergeant, next item. Item 2 c Commission Report and Commission President s report for the use of force and Commission Reports report on Blueribbon Panel. You recall one i think we met we talked about the desire to as quickly as possible to gain as Much Community input this but how the chief and i went to washington in january and gotten concepts that are nationally around is an thank you of life and deesclation we thought it was important we took out the concepts before the final draft it was given to us i want to thank you all for making yourselves available and attended the meeting i wanted to update the public it was on the website we had 3 use of force meetings we remember lead by the Community Partners i want to thank mo magic and the human right and the ymca and the third by that point church and reverend brown the biancas at bodecker park and but basically all the Community Partners created faith led by the young people that were the Summary Community initiative have a conversation about what the current rules are around force and what we want it to look like so i colleagues you have in your packet the notes from the meeting those are available to the public and also available on the use of force page on the website designed to be a process where we can be educated on what ideas are are out there im happy to touch on the few of the items and invite any fell commissioners to talk about their experience i cant stress enough if so not the way those meetings are normally done we got a lot of feedback there were small working groups woke up would choose to form a circle it was an Incredible Opportunity to talk about those issues i have to give gratitude to the people that took the time to give us the ideas i want to take a moment before i ask my commissioners to report on their experience to invite up mo magic that worked with us this summer to give initial policy recommendations and ask you guys to report from our prospective what were learned and i turn this over to my colleagues. First of all, thank you, commissioners and commissioner president loftus as well as chief suhr for having us up here we were very happy with the way those sessions went and took surveys afterwards most were welcome and feel welcome in those spaces they also felt very you know comfortable in the spaces with the groups they were in and felt satisfied with the session and would attend another session felt engaged the process and satisfied with the discussion afterwards these iced from the survey is sometimes colorblind and specifically some white and other races besides black that have excess experience with the Police Department not just a black issue but most of reporters that answered yes when dealing with the excess force were africanamerican and i think that is also important to note that on the same side of things most were very pleased with those sessions and would attend another one they also feel a sense of skeptical telling them moving forward thought hthought how th some of the common themes in the forums most the community feel that cit training should be universal and mandated and the officers should be extensively trained in circulation and put in plain clothes one of the things that was brought up to be effective an officer in uniform responding to countrys and someone in a Mental Health as Police Officers are trying to deescalating the situation a consideration of use of professional and maybe independent psychiatrists on call maybe External Resources from the department of Public Health or other mlk organizations officer should be trained with protective shields that that came up around the talk of shields the video of the United Kingdom that was brought up when talking about the decirculating the situation using sharpedged obtains and officers should be cared for with the confidential consultant there was brought up some officers over the years the force alone develop some things they midnight know from the situations necessary deal with and also the talk of maybe officers from coming from the military background may have a Mental Health undiagnosed and random drug tests of officers and more communication and data shairlg between the officers and keep in mind the patient policies and privacy that came up because some dealing with Mental Health issues may have a Mental Health background but from the officers cant assess that or not a ways to get points then you know they are not really prepared with the information and vanlsz training on the close quarter training in situation with sharpedged object instead of going to lethal force but figure out ways to engage in close quarters of those sharpedged object and the mental state is not purposely aggressive and talking about the youth and individual that maybe nervous and snappy at officers that was talked about officers should keep their calmness it is easy to identify San Francisco be that maybe snappy and aggressive as challenging their authority look at those with parents or alternated states slash Mental Health as a treat the video in london you see the officers treat the person with the machete as a threat to themselves themselves talk the break out sessions that the officers should consider those individuals not as a suspect but as a threat to themselves and education an Mental Health issues quickly im going to have any colleague daniela participant the Community SafetyInitiative Come up and share engage ideas. Good evening daniel and welcome thank you for having me. I want to say thank you for everyone that came out to our forum we have a few commissioners and sergeant came out and really be able to you know open Community Eyes on the use of force policy and during the summer i worked the Police Relations i have a few community that engages so ill start out with background engagement for officers so under that we have visiting the organization so the Community WantsPolice Officers to be engaged with Community Programs so that they have a sense of what the police are about and see them as someone to help them and not an enemy we have youth and teams that is School Resource officers we have a few of those with the boys and girls clubs theres a 20 minute period very a Police Officer come in and engage and discuss with the teams how the policy works nothing to be afraid of their meant to help and getting active into the School Spirit you you know when schools have their spirit days have Police Officers engage with them also, they said not bring their guns an campus i know a lot of the theres a lot of suggestions they want the Police Department to think about and you know have you know go through so they said have them come on campus but not a Lethal Weapon and gun so we had cultural competency train proportionate gun for gun and humanize themselves and relate to have them listen in certain situations that are you know very you know situations that escalate we also have community aids to deescalating that is one i thought was important you you know when Police Officers respond to a 911 call the community theres a lot of it is reels heckic we want the community to engage or ask the families themselves about the you know the person the situation and how this community can be deescalating and study the Successful Use from study of force strategies from other agencies jurisdictions and countries so in this one means they want to see policies from all over the world and country what they did that was able to work and have that implemented the sfpd and i just want to say thank you, again, for all you thank you for your time and to do the community and looking forward to the next forum this month and hope you can all be able to participate and have a you know better relationship with the community again, thank you and have a good evening. I want to emphasize the point im not sure that everyone except my mom watches the Police Commission every wednesday you all came this summer. Worked with us since then part of the streaming not a one and done thing but a rip those forums will continue to the fall and this situation happened we wanted to look at use of force you guys said lets use what we have a conversation between the community and Police Officers how to make it better so it as continuation of the work we started and i think were in a really strong position because of all the work and dan you want to Say Something. Finally to one of the last things that we wanted to mention there was a discussion i dont know at which forum but maybe looking at forming an independent commission arrest committee or council on use of force in and of itself and that council about include ideally xhaefksz from the psychologist and Community Members and experts and Police Officers and youth when dealing with use of force an additional errors United StatesPolice Department can have an Advisory Panel on the use of force and policies and lastly daniel mentioned well have another forum that is the third forum of the kind of weve been doing this is out of the Community Safety initiative and one of the suggestions the Community Youth forum so our third one, if i can get the projector up on february 8th. 18 february 18th. I got did im looking forward to the end of the summer from 5 to 7 00 p. M. At city hall room 201 and food is provided targeting the youth to get them engaged and hear their voices so if you know any youth please send them for the forum if you have youth groups those listening on tv we invite you. Thank you d anthony and damn so colleagues obviously we all of us most of us attended one, if you want to provide a report what you learned and experience share that with the commissioners we have the opportunity. Thank you commissioner president loftus. I attended a meeting on the high school along with d anthony in mo magic an attorney from the occ we have commander osullivan from the Police Department and captain from the terryville station i have to tell you we sit here as commissioners and people say why not respond we follow the rules but the community a lot of back and forth and the community is lead by the young men the people got talking about to the parents and children their teenagers about their concerns that was a valuable meeting we actually heard and had a dialogue id like to see the commission do more often we had the dialogue it was a difficult setting i learned a lot of things the good part of officers that were there immediately respond to the questions and explained what the officers do and why they do it the confusion is cleared up and talked about the use of force and the perspectives were great it comes from the youth thank you. It was a great idea. Dr. Marshall. It was a great i was at the one in bayview sorry i couldnt make the other one it is funny you give us suggestions thats what we wanted we ask for the suggestions from cops and everybody it is so refreshing, different, amazing there was a funny story i mean, ill not tell you but someone came and basically where are the commissioners are the commissioners and appointed i was there and another commission and looked me and said this is a classroom i dont want to be here theres dialogue going on that said it all to me it was great you guys were fabulous and you know it was you know thats what we want we wanted to hear how to improve things and let me say daniel and ive known you a long time you were great, great to see young people and maybe people leave young people alone and do their thing but wonderful, wonderful wonderful i just want to say thank you very much commissioner president loftus and by way of everything i heard was great incorporated i heard people im around all the time no leaders no leader youre not looking at the right place so thank you wonderful. Commissioner melara yeah, he went to the third street by that point church and so the the amazing thing and the the fact you were redirecting people that were difficult in the conversation theyre not focusing on what we were trying to do they wanted to take the conversation to the left or right not where we are what we were doing there and it was so nice to see you redirect every confusion in a compassionate way but fun and so i of the really glad you were doing that and glad you do the it i sat back and looked at it you, you did it thank you. Commissioner wong i attended it is the mission it was a have well taenltd event 50 folks that come out a Diverse Group some of the thoughts commissioner mazzucco was exactly right it was great we actually had dialogue a two or three minute comment and some of the quick thoughts i was a little bit disappointed not more officers it would be better to benefit the officers to be there im disappointed a lot of folks that came up for Public Comment were not there they needed to here the comments as opposed to the diatribe it was a great session he hope we can do it in other features we have that dialogue and not just sitting here having Public Comment. Commissioner Vice President turman. I wanted to join everyone at the third baptist a very good meeting officers out there with experiences and some retired officers were you glad to see there as well and not only were the facilitators great at reindirectly the public but redirecting the commissioners and Police Officers with the real conversations and kept a good command of the material that we were talking about and kept us on track and made that comfortable for everyone regardless of whether you were officers you know Community Member or commissioners and im grateful to you it was a great session we really need to do do more situations where smaller groups of commissioners go so we have more Community Dialogue it was very, very productive. Yes dr. Marshall. I want to underscore i couldnt commissioner president loftus said this is a continuation of what we started in the summer. You know how many times sheryl davis come here and say we dont want to lose that the good work we were unfortunate fortunate we had you guys to turn to so i just looked to it was fortunate to start that and have you ready when we were able to turn to there will be more so dont go anywhere. Thank you, dr. Marshall most of benefits of the things ill say the destruction i was in someone actually said have you seen the what doj did in philadelphia there there was a acholic beverage process that was one of the ideas i think that person is probably happy to see that happened ive got a lot of questions about tasers when that will happen and the process i also there was a lot of discussion about the direction we talked about england and scott land again, the young people you know ill call you the young people clearly im not there was you guys did a job of deesclation on the approach that we are looking at i say you have the minutes . One of the ways to continue to hold us accountable i appreciate what someone said great to have the mayor edwin lees meetings but the proof is in the pudding did it look different and the power to set it up everyone sought policy a number of pieces of paper so everyone will determining are denominator and again i dont know all the ideas will get in there we as a commission will benefit and dr. Joes point of hearing the best ideas not only from the United States department of justice and the Research Forum but the community interacting with the police force so want i wanted to lay out as we wrap up this report and you all commissioners will give our individual reports given we have the input in the Community Forum ive asked chief youre going to get the commissioners on the tenth the version the department wants to submit for further graft for the use of force and colleagues, any proposal is that we do what we did with the body camera get the stakeholders together with a Similar Group like before i want to add a young person or person and someone from the Mental Health group give them the da and the aclu and folks with the Body Worn Camera give them the feedback from the department and reasonable minds can differ not an agreement but from the department has the same process of knowing where the department agrees or disagree floating it on the policy and that policy would go to o. J. To understand where the department is and give us their independent assessment before it comes to the commission for consideration thats my proposal we need to give thought to smaller conversation about the use of force policy id like to Ask Community inputs on policies before we vote but weve learned smaller eloquence so agendize for next week ill lay out the dates for the process for that and have a more fully discussion ill leave it at that any questions on any of the items colleagues. No. Okay. All right. So sergeant, next item. Were still in commissioners report. Yes. Id like id like to invite the commissioners forgive an individual report on the Blueribbon Panel autopsy i spoke on the transpire fairness of Law Enforcement that was investigate the racial bias at the San FranciscoPolice Commission and data i cant remember the day but we were interviewed with folks but most of questions were about the disciplinary process how that worked and how we identify the priorities and Community Trust and so forth and it actually didnt go how it was to go i thought it was a two hour thing i thought juicy was there right before me and surprised to see may be limited the amount of time i was asked to speak former joe reilly spoke he clarified a lot of things i would had to clarify so came and shook my hand and said good luck the questions were fair i talked about everybody everything i knew from my times on the commission thats it. Commissioner wong. I want to report briefly and a couple of activities i attended the board of supervisors rules Committee Meeting on the use of force and i thought there were two interesting presentations i recommend to my fellow commissioners, if you get a chance to watch a presentation from julie from the Bar Association of San Francisco and she talked about a i guess theyve been visiting with the opd and she thought theyve made remarkable process with the Police Department and the process of presenting a report for our consideration and she recorded with that the opd has software that will work in conjunction with the Body Worn Cameras so you can push a button and pull up the video of the officer and have a way to monitor the Police Officers body language to look for explicit bias and trigger the bias sounds like Science Fiction but o pd is moving and ground floor if the academy i wanted to see in my opinion this is where we really need to focus a lot of the attention around rethinking how we use force and captain yee talked about changes at the academy i wanted to recommend we possible hold a future Police Commission meeting and theyll be open to have a public open house theyre changing a lot of things at the academy to follow the task force on the 21st Century Policing and things like denufl the training model using more sensitive physical techniques and one of the biggest problems with the recruits recycle every other younger person thai come in knowing how to text on their phones and incorporating that the academy there is a lot of rattled change happening which the root of a lot of our problems and the commission take into account what is happening in the academy and think about doing it and open up for Public Comment for training the officers the chief and i went Opening Statements the 22 Chinese New YearSan Francisco lunar new years kickoff and did a walk talk about the scams and those on the 30th i shock at the Chinese New Year flower event the reason i bring that up it is obstructed for a group by the alien for black lives matter they jumped in front of the program and held up signs i met with the group for about an hour and talked about their concerns and demand this is one of the groups i appreciate coming to the community shoulder or stakeholder forums this is another group theyve come before us i wish we would have a better dialogue with that group with Public Comment their smart folks they have passionate demands and ive drafted a pieced summarizing any thinking from doing a lot of thinking around the use of force it didnt address that so much action one of the prior Public Commenters talked about how the Police Department is moving towards the idea of a guardian model as opposed to a warrior model i believe it should be coming out sometime next week and finally i will say i met with sergeant Yolanda Williams and i share our concerns about possible safety issues for Sergeant Williams. Thank you commissioner dejesus. A new website out that tracks all those different Police Departments policies and go on nationality it is called Sunlight Foundation they gather the information i was looking at it i noticed the los angeles pout u put awe out an annual report and takes the three or four last years and listed them and tell you if it is going up or down and analyzed why they believe if so up and down additional up and down and look at the policy and those things need a policy change it is they have tasers there one of the things if he were or they were doing if you hold a tazer down is continues to fire and they dont have in their policy to disarm that and exercise that choice this is something if you talk about force important statistics and report and how it relates to the department i think we should also in terms of identifying you but this website is a Good Practice to look and see other people estate policies. Okay on a couple those items for a new line item any furthers reports colleagues saebt apparently item 2 d commission and identified for considerations at future Commission Meetings aforementioned. So i already cattle under my report for next week i will giveup give and a traffic ticket but be clear and scheduling of these items i would also you know. We have a thorough understand not rush there but put it on the agenda to study is it to make sure the questions are answered because when we do the report well do them and move on to the next item lets try to ill request we do this by no later than the end of mark. Chief what we are asking when i have an update on the back and forth that is happened with the Community Members i think you can agenda device it under the recent activities and let us know when you guys have had the conversation and at this point if there recent still things you think solved well hear from everyone and determine when. Ill ask for a timeframe by the end of march. For sure. The other thing so other colleagues, any items for future k the one thing ill let you know that next week on february 10th the department will be doing a presentation on the budget it is relevant for a number of reasons the Mayors Office asked to weigh in on the use of force and that conversation will happen next week well hear from the department and have a discussion at this point, i will say at this point given the level of improvement that the United States department of justice will have with us on the ideas and the fact were midway to the process my sense our feedback will only be preliminary but well share what we know well get that update next week anything further on this matter at this time ill call for Public Comment on 2a through d. Good evening. Michael again first of all, chief again, no written report and i noticed you were read from notes when making public request you owe me and the public a report i brought you 5 pamper standard report that Barbara Garcia you need to follow barbaras example ill give a copy and second tonight agenda doesnt mentioned that you leaders were going to be making a presentation that is going to be part of my vertical presentation to the Sunshine Task force if i knew from your printed agenda in advance you were going to be presenting their report back i really would have come here youve done the public and youth a disservice from omitting of time from the agenda thats the heart of my sunshine ordnance containment the third item is great reports back from the meetings but i didnt hear you talk about the Police Officers association showing up or cops showing up out of uniform it is great that you all were there and maybe some folks from the brass side of the department but where are the patrol cops showing up if it happened i didnt hear you talk about that the next item chief back to you social media not regulations ive gone through the occ process with michael and he says there is a 4 pamper craft of the social media he had to present to you healed to get to you this month in february outside estimate when it can be presented to the public after you reviewed it is in march so im here to urge you to move on it because we went through the mediation and hashed out things were not able to see his 4 page draft we really need to know what the department is going to be doing how it handles all the social media arms, if you will, online thats it ill give you barbaras report. Thank you. Next speaker. Good evening and welcome. Commissioners ray heart for San Francisco open government ive been gone for awhile ill be here on a regular basis id like to support mr. Traffic signal report im blank relating to the sunshine ordinance the ordinance titled reads the agendas items should be extensive specific so a person of average diligence to attend the meeting or seek further information and many of the agenda items are not clear at these commissioners one of the commissioners said i had no idea what that agenda was about please try to be specific so the people know and the second thing a comment on the sunshine ordinance which commissioner mazzucco may have given the wrong impression nothing it stops the board or the commission to responder to the commission any board or commission can respond to the public they choose not to if they want to respond they can next id like to say i commend the facilitators i was a facilitator myself for 20 years when i lived in hawaii taught they university of hawaii it is a difficult job and difficult position you have a small window of opportunities hebecause theyre your off Affordable Housing to the community the Community Gives trust and show up and speak up but if they dont feel something will come theyll stop coming you have a small window of opportunities the thing over the years ive watched out the general orders drag on literally for years green before something finally comes of it you dont have that you have a small window of opportunities for them if they go back and ask people to come to the malia cohens and speak up those people gets the impression youll not do anything that will shut off really quick i want doesnt end they not only talked about what was important to the citizens the community but to the officers themselves the 5 officers involved the incident i will guarantee every one of them is suffering to some degree we need to appreciate when we ask for those initiative talks about the lethal force not just concern for the citizens but for the officers that diesel with the out flow of dealing with the lethal force and lastly the thing that bother me about officer williams the juxtaposition from 9 Police Officers association that is hospital tills openly hostile to anyone that question a Police Officer at at the time including the board of supervisors. Thank you, mr. Heart. Next speaker. I want to bring up about the youth forums that is going on i went to mrs. Browns and the one in the tenderloin you know originally i thought that was going to be a rally or something about the Police Killings but when i came i saw that the youth were engaging in also bringing awareness to the use of force and it was good to see you know it gives me hope that what is going on now it is sad that happened but what is going on it gives me me hope it is connected it is liltd all connected and see the youth engaging people push them away and the youth are running their own homes and parents so that was a good thing i saw that day you know and it remembered remind me of my own son doing a presentation you know so that was a good thing and i think that should continue to go on and even those youth see me and give me a hug and their empowered now i think so you know and it doesnt matter what organization gets them where mo magic or organization they should be involved and continue to be involved ill make to more you know the Mental Health one of the youth ran with the Mental Health part and i am just finished my Mental Health license at city college so. Congratulations. I was involved in that i really think that the officers should have counseling mentally because i suffer from post traumatic so they do it all day that should be a mandated thing in that part of that session but all the things should be implemented thank you. Thank you ms. Brown. Next speaker. Good evening and welcome. Thank you ami chelsea with the Activities Group from santa fe and i apologize for not coming up earlier for general Public Comment is closed. I was two damn nervous and had to work up the never been here i am and the last 5 years theres been vandalism and one bombing, two attempted murders and 3 murders at abortions clinics was nursed was accosted theyre allowed to have hatred and violence against women less than two months after the terrorists killed an officer outside of the planned parenthood thousands of people were the walks of life to tell women that life is okay. And they had signs as prolife as pro women and one woman serving 20 years for a miss carriage i along with other activists interrupted a speaker by shouting fraud fake, liar as the speakers at at walks of life with the community substances counter protester and another held her in a choke hold we were pushed towards officers one twisted my arm i shouted she was going to break any arm other officers despite the fact we wanted to press charges and sfpd condoned the violations or violence at the rally ensley the half naktd female protesters are facing charges of disord conduct as offense words will or that will provoke an Immediate Reaction they called women murderers and somehow their shield if arrest furthermore, when is violence an acceptable action does that have to be the name of god unless you have a gun why are we facing fines has it been made illegal in San Francisco is San Francisco where the suspect is met with with a bunch of bullets the next time i hear the crisis of going to hell ill not be detained by the sfpd when i am manhandled off the premises thank you. If you do have a specific containment of officer semiautomatic if this incident there is a senior investigator from the office of citizens complaints you could raise your hand sir, that be investigate the allegations into a specific incident of police misconduct. Next speaker. Good evening and welcome. Im rebecca i came here to echo charley assess sentiments your organization is strictly nonvibrant in this protest we ask the sfpd respect you are First Amendment there is will an injustice well protest not be silent no matter how scary or dangers the police make it i have suggestions to through out there i think more female officers on the force women are born negotiators and have been shown to be less likely in excess force i also agree there Small Business mandatory council i believe that Aptitude Test should give for weight to social skills and less prowess he look forward to the modification that you guys come up with. Thank you. I building to your point were still hiring chief; right . Yes. 24 percent of Newest Academy class is female. And people can learn how to be the. Under Police Website you can apply together. Amazing women apply so there any additional Public Comment . Hearing Public Comment is closed. Saebt item 3 Public Comment on all matters pertaining to blow closed session including Public Comment on whether to hold closed session. Well have Public Comment on matters blow good evening. Im here to object you going behind closed doors about those matters youll consider 6 cases against basically bad cops in action so all the taxes talk of accountability and changes not going to mean anything when the bad cops have gone through the process youre considering disciplinary charges against them theyre not named not a simple cop is named in this document that is a real problem item e says that the sdhooef review of finding and chiefs decision to return are not return officers to duty following an into custody dedicated your considering returning officers back to the force that are somehow involved in an into custody death and as a must be ill not here what youre discussing or the officers name youve got to address the state law that protects the cops that preventive you from naming them and an open door to listen in on what youre discuss there really has to be verbal communication from this commission to our stat leveraged officials im name them mark leno and david dhoou and demanding the state law be changed that strips away the confidentiality that bad cops get youll be able to hold your entire Commission Hearings in public youll name the bad cops and be able to listen who what the chief thousands o has to say about returning those cops back to the force please open up the course about the disciplinary charges and action. Thank you, sir any Public Comment on 5 above hearing Public Comment is closed. Item 4 vote an whether or not to hold item 5 administrative code action. Colleagues do i have a motion to hold in closed loftus were back on record we have quorum vote to disclose is any or all items San Francisco code action colleagues do you have a motion not to disclose or i. Opposed . Sergeant, next line item. Item 7 adjournment action item. Colleagues. Move to. Do i have a motion. Move to adjourn. All in favor, say i. I. Motion passed were adjourned everyone good morning, everyone name is ed reiskin, director of transportation here in San Francisco. Which among other things gives me the great honor of operating our Transit System, muni which is one of the busiest Transit Systems in the country. And one that is really important for San Francisco. Its how a lot of san franciscans get to work and to school and around the city and how a lot of folks who visit the city and a lot of people who work in the city get around in the city. Its a really important part of San Francisco. We are always working for ways to make a better experience for our riders. We are really excited to be here today. Lets talk about the launch of our muni mobile and we are already seeing the benefits. Without further a do, mayor lee was planning to be here but unable to attend unfortunately but we are happy to have ben mattranga. Please join me in welcoming him. Thank you. Mayor ed lee was unable to make it but hes very excited about this. We live in a very busy city and we need a great Transit System. This is about choice, this is about giving folks more options, more choices for how to get on transit and have that customer experience. Thank you for coming out. I did today from city hall take muni mobile and have about another 60 minutes to get back to city hall. Thank you all for coming out and make sure you download the app and use it. Thank you. [ applause ] thank you, ben, as you know the mayor has coming together with city departments and to embrace innovation that is going to add value and service and this is the epitome that embraces innovation and bring positive value and there is a lot of innovation that will question whether or not that brings value and muni mobile. Great improvement benefit to our riders. We were only able to do things like the launch of muni mobile, of bringing technology and other improvements to this system when we have the leadership and support of our board of directors. Im pleased to say for this and for every other positive thing we are doing for muni, we have tremendous support and leadership and guidance and direction from our board of directors. Im very happy to have both the chairman of the board and our vicechair here to say a few words. Please join me in welcoming the chairman of the board tom nolan. Ben, i will try to cut it down to less than an hour so you can make it back on time. The board of directors is presiding over a very complex agency. We look at all kinds of ways to make the system more reliable, faster and more convenience for everybody that uses the system. There is more than 7,000 a day. This is really a great benefit for tourist and occasional users. Im very excited about this and look forward to seeing it a big success in a short time. Thank you, cheryl brinkman, vicechair of board of directors. I think this is going to be a great advantage for our riders both regular and casual. I know when i travel, thats what i look for is what is there to help me use the Transit System of the city that im visiting. I know visitors are going to flock to this. Thank you for being here. [ applause ] thank you, so, what is muni mobile . Right now we basically have two ways for people to pay for their fare on muni. We have cash and the clipper card. The clipper card has been a wonderful benefit for our riders and used well by our more frequent. Its a card that stores cash and passes. A very easy way to pay and nearly half of the people who ride muni now, nearly half of the trips are paid for with a clipper card. So its really been, when the people who use it love it and its been a great advance for regular muni riders. That said, we still have about half of the riders who are still paying cash. These are folks who are fumbling for change and dollar bills when they get on the bus or the train they are stuffing their dollar bills in the fare box which is both an inconvenience for those folks and it also takes time. The whole muni system is slowed as people are digging for change and stuffing the dollar bills and coins into fare box and there is cost for us because we have to process that cash. We have people running around emptying those fare boxes and counting the money and moving the money to the bank. There is a lot of logistics and cost associated with that. What muni mobile does is for those who dont have a clipper card and those who choose not to and maybe because they dont ride muni often enough or maybe they are visiting. What it will enable people to do is use their smartphones. Most people have a smartphone. They download an app from the Android Store or apple store. Its a free app. Its developed by globe sherpa to bring muni mobile to our riders. You will see how easily they will say what kind of rider they are, a regular fare, senior, youth, disabled fare, what kind of ticket they want and they associate it with a credit card or pay pal because not everybody has a credit card and they pay with their phone. Its a flash pass. They dont have to touch the clipper reader. Its not paper. Its on your device. Its secure. It has significant security protocols to make sure nobody is going to be able to hack into your phone. Its safe and easy for our fare inspectors or station agents or operators to see. There is animation that you will see in the demonstration that lets them know its a live ticket and not just a screen shot. It will make it that much easier for the folks who dont have clipper cards to be able to avail themselves of modern technology to make it easier for them to get on our vehicles. Its good for us but most of all great for our riders. I wanted to acknowledge that. I want to acknowledge john, our director. His folks that are trying to keep the buses and trains moving and the fair boxes maintained. So anything we can do for them to get less cash on the system is good for the system and the riders. I want to acknowledge sue, our Communications Director and her folks are working hard to make sure our riders know about this and use it well and know they have options. As ben said, the more options we can give to our riders the better. And mr. Fox, our chief performance officer. Our main driver on this project from inception to getting a beta test out which has been running the beta test for a number of weeks now to getting to the point where we are launching this today. With that, now that youve heard about it, we want to give you an opportunity to see it and the person that is best able to show it to you is the chief executive officer of globe sherp a. Again the firm that we partnered with. Please join me in we canning glen sherpa, [ applause ] thank you very much. Good morning, everyone. I will keep my remarks brief so we can jump no into a demo. I couldnt be more proud with the partnership with the mta staff to make muni mobile a reality. I want to give a shout out to the ambassadors and all of those that made this possible. We are going to make it the best that it possibly can be and we really appreciate that. Muni mobile is incredible. Its the leading technology in the capital of the world. For Us Innovation is about simplicity about buying a ticket securely and quickly at the palm of your hands with this phone. I will jump right in and show you a little bit about this. As you are watching this, i want you to think about mobile not just being here for the day but longterm. This is going to allow us to add new features in San Francisco. In the coming months you will see increased functionality like Spanish Language support, cantonese language support and enhancement for accessibility for vision impaired riders and that sort of thing. Muni mobile is more than just about buying a ticket, but about making it easy to get to the places that matter. With that, lets walk through the basic experience. I will start from the beginning. I open my transit application and i will select muni mobile. Am i in the way, by the way, is this okay from where im standing . All right. Im standing to the side. We can do this again if im in the way. Okay, all right. Basically muni mobile is as simple as buying and using a ticket. All i have to do is come into what we call a navigation drawer where i see my options laid out very clearly. By selecting buy tickets im drawn to a selection menu where i address two easy steps. I select what kind of driver i am. Im an adult and we can have reduced patrons, senior, disabled. I select regular adult and select the fare that makes sense for me. You can see we have the muni bus in rail fare all the way to bus pass fare. You notice when i select fare it pops up in the cart. Globe sherpa utilizes the cart. All i have to do is checkout. In this case i have been using pay pal. My preferred account. Thank you to pay pal for their support. I appreciate it. These guys rock. As you can see i have got my visa card and i checkout with pay pal and the app tells me its purchasing on the fly. This will go in realtime to the back office to purchase the ticket and here we are with the regular adult cable car fare. So you can see i have been purchasing quite a few throughout the day. Here is my regular cable car fare and when im ready to get on the cable car, i select that fare. It asks me are you sure . Lets do it. I use the ticket and this launches my ticket. This is the version of the digital ticket on muni mobile. Applause is welcome. Thank you. [ applause ] so whats beautiful about mobile ticketing is its fun and exciting and beautiful and add ed mentioned this is a highly secured system. As the animation shows this isnt just a picture, its a screen shot. By tapping my phone you see the color change components on the tickets. This isnt a rerecording of the animated ticket. Likewise you can see my fare at the bottom corner and a blinking expiration time stamp. We take a level approach to security to ensure this is a valid fare. Once im done, all of my tickets live in the my tickets screen of the app where i can come back and use the ticket again. If i wanted to hop on within the expiration time, i simply relaunch and there it is. The great thing about mobile ticketing is you can purchase tickets in advance so you dont have to think about it. You can store it for future use. One thing, if im talking too much, give me one of these. One feature we care about is that transit is a social experience. We know people ride together. If you click multiple riders. I can use two tickets and use them together so my friend and i can travel as a group using just my one phone. [ applause ] you will notice a lot of people have asked the question, there is a little code in the bottom right hand corner, a qr code or Quick Response code. This is a security measure that global uses to ensure high security. Payment officers will be equipped with a special device, an app that allows them to scan, decrip and see the qr code. Its a way to make sure the ticket is in fact valid. Lets go in and well show you a couple of the other features. If we go back to the navigation drawer. We have handy tool that lends us to the mta trip site. I can see the arrival time and when my bus is coming and when it will arrive. Thats the beauty. You use buy ticket, use ticket. Thats where we are. All right. So one last feature. This matters for people who want to keep track of their purchases. If you click on the bottom at my account, you see the profile here. I can manage my password. I can come into my billing information and any of those pieces but very importantly i can look at my transaction history. In the case that i can requisition my purchase with my employer, this is a great feature where i can come in and see just what i bought. Another piece and i will wrap, there is also a website for muni mobile. I will encourage everyone to visit it. On your mobile you can purchase from your home computer and it will show up on your device. For people who have fast fingers, boom, you can do it that way. I will stop there. Ed, anything else . [ cheers and applause ] its pretty impressive. I want to thank matt particularly for the 7 he spent on the muni fare that i dont think hes going to use. Thats more revenue for us. A couple things, he didnt show you the actual setting up up the account. He had his visa card, he didnt show us his number and his pay pal account. When i downloaded the app, i went to the Android Store and download td app and the entire experience took me about 15 seconds. For a teenager that maybe 10 seconds. Its really really easy to use which is phenomenal. It also works for paratransit. It shows you the type of rider you are. At the bottom is access, which is our paratransit service. It not only works for buses and trains but for paratransit fare as well. I think the multiple tickets on one screen is phenomenal. Particularly for visitors. There is a lot of visitors and parents and teenagers. If you are buying fares for the whole family. Another great feature. We are very excited about this launch. We think its going to be a great thing for our riders. I want to thank you all for getting the word out because we want our people to avail ourselves of this. Are you buying more tickets . No, my grandparents were calling me. Okay. Keep buying tickets. Thats it. I think we are going to stop there. And maybe i will ask travis to come up in case anybody has a difficult question. Thank you very much. If anybody has any questions, now is the time. Port authority you gave yourself a projection roll call director brinkman down the road deis a block away director nolan director ramos director rubke we have quorum item 3 announcements of the please silence all electronic devices. Any person responsible for disruption may be asked to leave the room. Set cell phones on vibrate, the vibration could cause an interruption in the proceedings