congratulations, judge kavanaugh, and congratulations to your family as well. let me just say a few things about the issue that has been discussed here a lot today, the issue of documents and document production. the standard historically that we use to -- to look at nominees is what is relevant and probative. i would suggest that we certainly get that from the 12 years you have served on the circuit court, on the d.c. circuit court, that considers when you look at the docket items that more than any other circuit court that the supreme court would be perhaps called to rule on. in the past senators on this panel have argued on both sides of the aisle that confirming a judge -- confirming a judge the best we can look at is his or