judge said most of the claims might be past the statute of limitations in other words too much time has passed to consider the complaints. inside these folders are the file sizes of investors are pinning their hopes on the documents could be instrumental in persuading the court to either accept or reject the notion that folks not knew about emissions cheating in the us years before informing shareholders. peers had the plaintiff's lawyer and they have killed i'm client his case to the media recently and. all the hot under german law is what's required to communications essential information to investors and the market we're firmly convinced that seat of the you should have told markets of the latest in june two thousand and eight because they would not manage to confuse the technology required in the united states to say we can't do it these of you didn't join with us and that's probably. divied of the emissions cheating scandal broke on