So many people say now, people who were quite supporting my views say now, no, no, no, afterthe 7th, thats the end. We cannot accept them. We cannot forgive them. And we dont want to hear about their. Their suffer. And one, if i may say so, gideon, one reason for that is some of the staunchest supporters of coexistence who reached out to palestinian communities, both in gaza, in the west bank, were murdered on october 7th. Thinking of the canadian israeli vivian silver, who spent most of her adult life working for peace, murdered by hamas. Did that not make any difference to you and your thinking . It affected my thinking. Like any victim of the attack in october, would it be a peacenik or a right winger, both shouldnt have been slaughtered the way they were slaughtered. And still i ask, does one attack really change all our values and all the things we in the left, or what is left of the left, that we believed in all our lives . And you know what, stephen, i want to ask you another