narrator: sherry asked fred to get something from the mailbox, knowing full well he was walking to his death. the evidence shows tim rogers hit fred in the head with some sort of object, knocking him unconscious. tim dragged fred into the woods, took one of his own shoelaces, strangled fred to death, and then made his way at 11:42, tim called sherry. that is him telling sherry, "the crime has been committed. i've done it. i'm heading back to the hotel." narrator: at 12:03, tim called sherry from the hotel. he tells her, "i'm back at the hotel. i'm cleaning up." narrator: and now, in a clear indication she was in on the plot, sherry deleted all her calls to tim before she informed neighbors that fred was missing. when they got those records, it was a definite "a-ha" moment. narrator: in october of 2010, tim rogers was convicted of first-degree murder