fossil fuels to clean energy. it would clean the air by 50% a a -- according to the plan. joe manchin's opposition to this program isn't that surprising, but a spokesman for the "new york times" says, senator manchin has clearly used his concerns to pay for doing things they're already doing. regardless of the reason, manchin's position is bound to create new headaches for the administration as democrats work to finalize this spending package. joining me now is yamiche alcindor. thank you for coming on. it's a pleasure to be with you.