Paradise can be brutal, even on birthdays. Thursday night's episode of Bachelor in Paradise picked up right where last week left off with several men namely Sean, Aaron S., John B., Will and Peter questioning where their rose could possibly come from.Sean's prayer to the Paradise gods was answered when a woman made her way down the steps. Though he was delighted to see a new lady, neither he nor anyone else on the beach recognized the woman in question.Turns out the new arrival is Sam Picc