Transcripts For CNNW New Day 20141027

Cnn, her basic human rights are being violated. We begin with cnns elizabeth cohen. So one side of the controversy says the quarantine is to protect the Public Health. Another side says these quarantines will lead to more cases of ebola. The morning the governments of new york and new jersey are offering clarification on their days old policy of the quarantine, do Health Care Workers returning from treating ebola people in africa will be quarantined for 21 days. In addition, those staying in hot zones who havent come into contact with ebola patients will be actively monitored. For nurse hitchcock, isolated for three days, the new policy has been a nightmare. I spoke with casey on the phone. I dont think most people understand what its like to be alone in a tent and to know that there is nothing wrong with you and that the decisions are being made that dont make sense. Reporter she was quarantined inside this tent after she arrived at newark, libberty national airport. She currently shows no symptoms and tested negative for ebola twice. My first and foremost obligation is to protect the people of new jersey. Reporter the mayor of new york city blasted the decision, which some say deters Health Care Workers from taking part in the fight to contain ebola abroad. This hero coming back from the front, having done the right thing, was treated with disrespect. Her lawyers are fighting for her immediate release. We believe that infringes on the constitutional liberty interests. They are imposing in in new york, new jersey and illinois. The policy was abruptly implemented friday one day after new york doctor Craig Spencer who treated patients in guinea was diagnosed ebola. Some people say we are being too cautious. Ill take that criticism. Reporter the cdc was surprised but acknowledges the state official versus the prerogative to set tighter policies. Now, critics say these quarantines are too broad. Theyre unclear some say theyre unnecessary, because few are not sick, you cant spread the disease. Its also confusing. We will get into it this morning. There are mixed messages. One very strong message is coming out of the white house. Officials there are urging states to enact ebola quarantine policies based on science, not fear. They are expressing concerns. Medical workers may be deterred from going to hot zones if they know they will face three weeks of confine. When they get back. What do we do about them . White house correspondent joins us with more. Not an easy one here. The science and the fear very much at odds. Reporter two very strong side. We see the state wanting to have mandatory quarantine instead of monitoring. In most cases, that can be done at home. Its not clear how that would deter people from helping out. Thats how the white house has been portraying its own fears surrounding this. We see five states, new york, new jersey, illinois, 52. Going above and beyond what the cdc is doing. Some of those governor, yes, including democrats rshlgs staunchly defending theiring as. New yorks Governor Cuomo is saying the white house has not pressured him to change course. The white house, though, has made its displeasure very clear, saying it is letting governors know it has concerns about the unintended consequences of policies that are quote not grounded in science. But the white house says its now going to work coming up with its own new guideline. In fact, that was the subject of a big meeting here at the white house yesterday, the president meeting with Public Health and National Security teams, apparently the white house feels those new restrictions that go into effect today requiring workers to self monitor for 21 days might not be enough. This is something we have seen several tiles now the white house changing things up when there has been a public outcry. We saw it with why done you apoint. An ebola czar . Why dont you have more travel restrictions. Now, why dont you do something more about returning Health Care Workers. Michelle co zin ski, you put your finger on the right concerning its not the science, Consistency Breeds confidence. When you dont have it, you have fear. Thank you for the reporting. Now, one of the people really drawing attention to this is that nurse under mandatory quarantine in new jersey. She returned from west africa, fighting the good fight. Now, she calls her 21day quarantine inhumane and a knee jerk reaction by politicians. She spoke by phone, she says she was initially in shock. Now shes just angry. Once i got to the hospital, they, of course, tested by blood, confirmed it was negative and i know that there have been reports of me having a fever in the airport, but i truly believe that its an instrument error him they were using the forehead scanner. I was obviously distressed and a bit upset and so my cheeks were flushed and i think there has been some evidence that that machine is not very accurate in these situations, so when i arrived in the ambulation unit, they took my temperature orally, it was completely normal. Does it remain normal . Yes, it has also been completely normal. I heard from my mother last night who called me concerned and said governor christie just said in an interview you were quote unquote obviously ill and this is so frustrating to me. First of all, i dont think hes a doctor, secondly, hes never laid eyes on my me, thirdly, i have been asymptomatic since i have been here him i feel completely strong. Emotionally completely exhausted. I have not been communicated a clear plan. My quarantine order written by the new Jersey Health commissioner. Even to this day no one told me what it means or whats the plan. For the one told me how long it will last. I dont know if im going to be retested and if so why i would be retested. Im completely asymptomatic. The test is not even accurate if you dont have symptoms. No one has communicated with me. You have put me in an isolation unit, i am not able to communicate in a scientific logical chain of events that ned to happen next. This to me is completely unacceptable. Do you understand the need of governors, be they from new jersey or new york or illinois to say, we cant take this risk that somebody is out there with a fever, will spike a fever eight or nine days after they arrive. We need to make sure that theyre in isolation until we know they are passed the danger zone. Do you understand that psyche . It is not understandable to mechl it is not based on any clear Public Health evidence. Its not the recommendation of Public Health and medical experts at this point. You know i think we have to be very careful about letting politicians make medical and Public Health decisions and all of the evidence about ebola shows if you are not symptomatic, you are not infectious. I understand people feel they are at risk. I think we can have a conversation about what mertz u further measures might look like. But i think this is an extreme that the really unacceptable. I feel like my basic human rights have been violated. All right. Here to discuss the medical and legal implications now of being quarantined, lets bring in a representative from the Infectious Disease society of america and a legal analyst and criminal defense attorney. Thank you gentleman for being with us. Doctor, what do you think of these mandatory quarantine teens of people returning from west africa . I am not in favor of them. When the government uses force to restrict individual rights like is happening with these quarantine teens, the burden of proof is on them and what we know about ebola they clearly arent, ebola is not contaminated during its restriction period. These measures wont add to anything to what is being done. These individuals are already being monitored by Public Health officials. This is being driven by politics, not my swooivens science. Heres the problem, some people are not self quarantineing, for instance, dr. Craig spencer who we know was bowling, he was riding around on the new york subway. That makes everyone feel nervous and feel as though they are somehow in jeopardy when theyre on public transportation. Let me play for you what Chris Christie, governor of funl said about why quarantines are required. The fact of the matter is i dont believe when you are dealing with something as serious as this, we can count on a voluntary system. This is governments job, if anything else, to protect the safety and health of our sids and so weve taken this action and i absolutely have no second thoughts about it. Doctor, he is basically saying self quarantine cant be trusted and weve seen examples of that. These people are getting active monitoring. They are in contact with members of the health community. They are tracked and known and given instructions on what to do. The other thing is even if dr. Spencers movements, during that time, he wasnt contagious. He wasnt a typhoid mary going around the city. There is a threat misconception going on among the public. Dan, we want to ask you about the legality of all this. Legally, can a state force somebody to stay in quarantine for 21 days . Yes. For over 100 years the Supreme Courts and other courts have upsed held the States Police power to infringe on the right of citizens to protect the Public Health, welfare and other things. Its the exact same logic that got us bicycle helmet laws, even at its extreme in the last century, cases where they would sterilize people based on their mental disabilities to avoid more cases like that. So be be not mistaken, the police power to infringe on individual liberties in times of Public Health crisis is tremendous. Its not completely without restraint, though, of course. If its unreasonable, if it goes too far, if its not tailored to the situation, then it may be unkwons institutional. But i think its because of cases over the last 20 years that have recognized individual liberties and Health Care Like the right to choose or, for example the right to refuse end of life care. Well, those have certainly developed legally. However, those cases are markedly different from the case where someone else may be affected by the decisions and we have seen if cases like tuberculosis, somebody will take them and stick them in Maricopa County jail. So its not without precedent. It happens. The States Police power as stamped with approval by the Supreme Court seems to allow it. Well, doctor, Casey Hickock, the nurse, who is now in an isolation tent in new jersey says it is unreasonable. She says she doesnt have a fever. Shes not sick. For many hours, she was sort of treated like a criminal, she says, she was denied any possibility of leaveing. Heres what the Governors Office in new jersey now says about quarantine. Let me read it to you. The protocol is clear, a new jersey resident with no symptoms who who has come into contact with someone with ebola would be subject to a mandatory quarantine order and quarantined at home, nonresidents would be transported to their homes if feasible and, if not, quarantined in new jersey. This woman is not from new jersey. Why isnt she put in an ambulance today and taken to i believe her home state is maine, why isnt she taken to be quarantined at home . Thats a question for governor christie. She doesnt pose any risk to anybody. She should be released and undergo this active under surveillance we are doing. She is right. I feel horrible that shes stuck there. Doctor, tanks so much for all information. We will be exploring it all morning if anything develops over these next three hours. We appreciate it. Let go back to chris. All right. Alisyn, we have the debate. Lets take a step back, for all the fear, the debate the need for solution we dont want to forget people at the center of it are fighting for their own lives against one of the worst viruses we know. Remember, Craig Spencer here in new york, one of the people that set off the debate now, hes still in isolation at Bellevue Hospital. Spencer remains in serious but stable condition. They do think he is starting to look better. He is experiencing the expected symptoms of the virus. Spencer has received a plasma transfusion from nancy writebol. You remember her. She contracted it if west africa and survived. Hes not out of the woods yet. We have to remember he was doing the lords work in west africa. They want to make sure people arent afraid to go because they wont be able come back or be if quarantine. We will discuss more of this coming up. Good morning to all of you at home. We begin with breaking news, prosecutors want the Death Penalty for the captain of a south korean ferry that capsized in april killing around 300 people. Many of those People High School students. A man is facing homicide charges for apparently abandoning the ship. Prosecutors want life sentences for three other crew members for their roles in that disaster. Officials say they have discovered a video recorded by the man who shot and killed a soldier if ottowa last week. They say he was driven by political and ideological motives. They say they will not release the footage. Apparently, it was made shortly before he gunned down that canadian soldier and stormed parliament. The 32yearold was shot dead by sergeant at arms kevin vic ars. In brazil, the president celebrating reelection. She won an incredibly tight race. Coming away with just over 51 of the vote after a bitter campaign, defeating the opposition candidate in a runoff. This is the tightest race brazil has seen since returning to democracy some three decades ago. I might read this a little slowly just because i can. The San Francisco giants just one win. A peer when away from their third world series title in five years. The giants inked bumgarner. That puts the giants up three games to two. They can win the title in game sick. When is that game, chris, tuesday night in kansas city . I dont know, im not paying attention. More on the world series coming up in our bleachers report. I hope its a good game. I think it has been tremendous. Super fun. All right, lets get to meteorologist indra petersen. Good morning, i have to ask, would it be dodgers if you had a choice . I will not answer that, there are a lot of dodgers fans watching. Right here. Thats what were talking about. All right. Weather wise, we are definitely looking at High Pressure on the east coast. That will start to change. We are watching a frontal boundary make it through the midwest. Going back even in through texas. Light showers will come along with it. Meaning by wednesday, we will see showers, not a lot. Though, an inch or so, heavy amounts down to the south around arkansas today. Either way, you will notice a big change. Look at these temperatures, as our system goes through, look at them drop back down, ahead of the cold front. The temperatures are climbing. It is fall, yay, we are still talking about 70s out in new york city by tomorrow. Lets take it daybyday. Not just a little bit. Almost 20 degrees above formal. Look at chicago, 77 degrees today it doesnt feel right. 20 degrees cooler down to just the 50s. All that making its way to northeast by wednesday we have rage and milder temperatures. We are talking 70s. Were doing good. Thank you. Evernight, a second teen ageer has died in the marysville, Washington State shooting. How a popular student could take such a violent turn and open fire. All right. Lets deal with whats obvious. You know people are talking about ebola. They are worried. Does that mean a quarantine is going too far or too bad for anyone who has been expoesd potentially . Tweet us with your ideas. Experts will give you the lo down coming up. Big day . Ah, the usual. Moved some new cars. Hauled a bunch of steel. Kept the supermarket shelves stocked. Made sure everyone got their latest gadgets. Whats up for the next shift . Ah, nothing much. Just keeping the lights on. laugh nice. Doing the big things that move an economy. See you tomorrow, mac. See you tomorrow, sam. Just another day at norfolk southern. I found a better deal on prescriptions. We found lower copays. And a free wellness visit. New plan. Same doctor. Im happy. Its medicare open enrollment. Have you compared plans yet . Its easy at medicare. Gov. Or you can call 1800medicare. Medicare open enrollment. Youll never know unless you go. I did it. You can too. A single ember that escapes from a wildfire can travel more than a mile. That single ember can ignite and destroy your home or even your community you cant control where that ember will land only what happens when it does get fire adapted now at fireadapted. Org are looking at now, she died on the scene, three other victims are still fighting for their lives right now, hundreds came towing sunday night in the school gym shedding tears offering comfort to one another, very needed in a situation like this and more details are worried about the shooters motive. Why this happened and there is information about a teacher who helped stop the bloodshed moments before the teenager was able to take his own life. So she at least tried. Shes also the author of something thats very relevant for this discussion today. Screen smart parenting. Thats how to find balance and benefit iffure childs use of social media apps and digital devices, is this an area we parents dont know about social media, kids are two steps ahead. We dont have the time the inclination or the fear, very key to this story. Well take a step back there seems to be a profile. This kid was isolated. They were upset. Peep knew it. They didnt know what to do. He was mentally ill. He wasnt treated, he had access to a weapon he shouldnt have. Then this hammond. This is not this kid. How so . I dont think of this being a Typical School shooting. To me this seems like a targeted shooting that happened to happen at a school. Thats a distinction with a difference . Y. Because we seen a profile of School Shooting, the Typical School shooter is angry andal yen nated. This child was very successful if high school. He was a Football Player and a homecoming prince he was angry and pissed off at his friends. I think it sound like he wassal yen nated and angry and acted impulsively. Thats not normal. He was above normal when you look at it. Public esteem, how he was perceived, how he perceives himself, objectively, doing well, had Community Around him, people who loved him. So how about that. Im mad at my friends, the guys i thought of loved me the most, hurt me the most. To this. Its hard to wrap your mind around it. This is a lot about teenagers and impulsive behaviors. It sound like he was betrayed and couldnt pod late his emotions. People reached out to him. But obviously he was rageful. He is only 14 or 15yearsold, he had access to a gun. When the uninitiated here, only 14, 15, this is not a way for a 14 and 15yearold to think to behave. Thats because we dont understand the development of the mind as well as we should. Its not an excuse, you are saying its science, where is the head of a kid that age . He was 14 or 15 his intran not as developed, his ability to have executive planning, to think ahead, to be thoughtful, is not the same as an adult. Its not an exexcuse you be its a window and understanding. That takes it into an area of your particular expertise the social pedia, when you go back and look, it was more than just it wont last, it will never last. Thats supposedly the last woke from the shooter. Thats kind of vague, but you say few had been on the social medio of this kid and tracking it you would have seen things, how so . I think you would have seen things, i dont think there is anyone to blame or warning signs, usually we can see the manifestos, through their twitter or facebook. I wouldnt say thats completely true. I think we saw a week or so his behavior changed a bit. It was a reflectedhis twitter feeds. Im not sure anything he posted would have caused a huge alarm. It wasnt a call to arms. It sound like he was hurt and betrayed and angry. The one ting we try to respect the victims and we try to figure out how to do it better. This is a hard one he did reach out to twitter. I think we have to take from this, his take, portrayal and emotion seriously, as parents, when you see a change in behavior, especially a boy has been hurt or portrayed in a relationship, he has to take it serio seriously. You should check out social medi media. The point is the kids know better these days tan the parents. Thats why parents back off. Its very strong out if washington right now to help the people who need it most. I think its maybe the flu dont go forward. I think the teenagers should listen to what they see online. Dont pretend to be somebody else. If you are hurting and need help and you post it on twitter and facebook, i hope your friends and family will take it seriously. One of the hardest things in life is be honestant yourself. Thank you very much. Its a horrible experience to learn from. Thank you so much for having me. Back to another top story, new york eases its mandatory ebola quarantine policy saying Health Care Workers can now quarantine at home. But in new jersey, a quarantine nurse is still being kept in an isolation tent. She says her human ritz are being violated. We will talk more about that controversy and the giants a win away from making it three titles in five years remember dont count out kc. Details ahead in our bleacher report. Your fidelity green line and youll see just how much it has to offer, especially if youre thinking of moving an old 401 k to a fidelity ira. It gives you a wide range of investment options. And the free help you need to make sure your investments fit your goals and what youre really investing for. Tap into the full power of your fidelity green line. Call today and well make it easy to move that old 401 k to a fidelity rollover ira. Chevrolet is merging the physical freedom of the car, with the virtual freedom of wifi. Chevrolet, the first and only car company to bring builtin 4g lte wifi to cars, trucks and crossovers. Hi mom. You made it its the new independence. I won this 55 inch tv for less than 30 on dealdash. Com. Visit dealdash. Com for great deals. And start bidding today . New york state is stopping its policy for Health Care Workers returning from the socalled ebola hot zones, they can be quarantined at home. New jerseys governor, meanwhile, is sticking by his decision to keep nurse Casey Hickock in a hospital isolation tent. She calls her treatment inhumane and plans to sue to end her quarantine. Changing the ga ready in afghanistan, the last u. S. Marine and his troops are officially entered camps to afghan control. The american and british flags were lowered, pulled up for the last time, marking the military milestone. The Vice President exiting polls are proof of his path to europe. He says the parliamentary elections showed support for his peace plan, millions in separatist controlled areas were not able to vote, leaving 27 of the 450 seats in parliament vacant. The First Official results are expected as early as today. I got to show you crazy video, a group of people take down a man who taunted and attacked a fellow passenger. He had been shouting expletives for wearing a pink shirt. Other passengers jumped, intervened, quickly followed by airport police. When asked why he attacked the passenger the pan said, quote, these are his words, not mine, because this is america. In america, we dont kick like a punk in a situation like that either. We dont treat our fellow americans leak that. Everything he did was ugly in that situation. I think he was reading the constitution. He didnt read it is where the problem is. Other people, better people stepped in. The San Francisco giants beat the royals 50 just one win away from the third world series tile in the past five years. Andy schols here with this mornings broocher report. What do you think . Its hard to beat the giants. One in 2010, now theyre up 32. Royals are headed home for game six. They will not have to face this guy, madison bumgarner, he was great last fight again dominant during a fourhit shutout. In his career, he is 4 and 0 with a. 29 e. Rchl a. That makes him statistically the best pitcher ever in the world series. You got to have this they want to force a winner take all game seven. Its sad news to report to you this morning. 22yearold cardinals outfielder died yesterday in his home country. His 18yearold girlfriend was in the car. She died as well. She made his debut before the season, he was the third ranked prospect in all of baseball. Very sad news. All right. To the nfl, you probably had a good day yesterday, for example, drew brees threw for 311 yards, three touchdowns. The saints continue their dominance at home. They beat the packers 4423 on sunday fight football. If in pittsburgh, Ben Roethlisberger threw a year high touchdown. Hes the first quarterback ever to have two 500 yard passing games. The steelers crushed the colts 5124. One of the ugliest uniforms ever. Ever. Last but not least, tom brady, vintage brady against the bears. He dominated 51 to have 23. A lot of high scores yesterday. My favorite stack was brady, he threw five touchdowns, he had five incomplete passes, nearly perfect on the day. I just only have envious watching those great quarterbacks, we have to deal wi with. At least you are in the hunt for that first pick. We need to end on a high note. Before we go, show andys socks. There with is a side to this kid you just den know. Greatest center in history. On his foots. Love it. Thank you very much. I appreciate. So we will tell you this morning. We got to get into these concerns about ebola. The white house says quarantine teens, a mistake, a trend. New york now says we will modify our quarantine, you can do it at home. The question is, will quarantines hurt or help the situation . Thats next. Helps you find a whole range of coverages. No one else gives you options like that. [voice echoing] no one at all no one at all no one. Wake up [gasp] oh you okay, buddy . I just had a dream that progressive had this thing called. The name your price tool. It isnt a dream, is it . Nope. Sorry you know that thing freaks me out. He can hear you. He didnt mean that, kevin. Kevin yes, he did keeping our competitors up at night. Now, thats progressive. Creeping up on you. Fight back with relief so smooth. Its fast. Tums smoothies starts dissolving the instant it touches your tongue. And neutralizes stomach acid at the source. Tum, tum tum tum. Smoothies only from tums. An Unprecedented Program arting busithat partners businesses with universities across the state. For better access to talent, cutting edge research, and state of the art facilities. And you pay no taxes for ten years. From biotech in brooklyn, to next gen energy in binghamton, to manufacturing in buffalo. Startupny has new businesses popping up across the state. See how startupny can help your business grow at startup. Ny. Gov a single ember that escapes from a wildfire can travel more than a mile. That single ember can ignite and destroy your home or even your community you cant control where that ember will land only what happens when it does get fire adapted now at fireadapted. Org Marie Callenders knows, a golden flaky crust, fresh fuji apples, and brown sugar streusel, make for the best dutch apple pie. Marie callenders. Welcome back to new day. New york and new jersey are now enforceing quarantines for Health Care Workers returning from west africa. Although, new york says they can be quarantined at home. The federal government says the could actually hurt the fight against ebola. It wants the quarantines scaled back. So the bottom line, will quarantineing Health Care Workers be effective or harmful . Joining us via skype is shawn hoffman. He has been training healthcare workers. Good to see you. Good to see you, alisyn. We are know you are coming to us from dubai, you are helping people contain Infectious Diseases, including ebola. What do you think of these mandatory quarantines that we are now seeing here in the u. S. . Well, its a good thing that im not a part of these mandatory quarantines, because i wouldnt be able to continue to dopy job, with i is actually training folks to work with ebola. I dont like them. I think they are a danger. I think, you know the battle against ebola has to occur in west africa. If we develop policies that prevents us from fighting that battle if west affect, it could come to the United States. What you are referring to, two weeks ago, you were in liberia, you were working with patients with ebola, why arent you self quarantining right now . Well, its funny. Look, anybody who comes from the front line has to take preventative measures, which means we have to assess ourselves we have to behave in an appropriate manner and we have to communicate. The reality is i am assessing myself. Im doing everything i can to make sure that if something does go wrong, i will be able to self isolate, keep myself away from people responsibly and continue to live my life but live my life responsibly, i think everybody that dedicates their life to this mission does the same. Governor christie disagrees with you, people were supposed to be self quarantineing, they ended up going out to restaurants or getting on the subway or going to bowl or whatever, granted, they were asymptomatic at the time. But it makes people nervous. Let me play for what you governor christie said people cant be trusted to do what you are suggesting. The fact of the matter is that we, i dont believe when you are dealing with something as serious as this that we can count on a voluntary system. This is governments job, if anything else the governments job is to protect the safety and health of our sids. So weve taken this action and i absolutely have for the second thoughts about it. Shawn, the voluntary system doesnt seem to work in every case what do you say to that . Well, look, these folks that are coming back to the United States should not be treated in my opinion like dogs. Here is a nurse who has dedicated her life carrying and offering compassion to patients in west africa to fight the battle overseas. She comes back and is put in a tent next to a hospital for 21 days. I dont think its ridiculous. I dont think governor christie is leading, i think hes imaging. He is doing a poor job at that. Hes not using science, he is simply using fear and trying to get folks to rally up against it, which i agree in the long run will end up hurting this battle against ebola. The reason you think it will hurt, if the kwoorn teen is too draconian as we see with Casey Hickock. She says she was hungry, confused, tired, they were interrogateing her him so you think that will be a disincentive for people to go to liberia or to places like dubai where you are . Alisyn, absolutely. Look, if i have to spend time overseas in a high stressful situation, then when i come home, i will be treated like this im not going again. Im not going to spend my time overseas and spend three weeks in a quarantine in a Foreign Place by myself. Its not going to happen. I dont think anybody that has any type of family will allow that to happen as well. Look, when we come home, we should be treated like heroes. We can do better than whats done in new york and new jersey. I hope the leadership chooses to do Something Better as well. How about quarantine at home rather than in an isolation tent . Where does it end, alisyn, does that mane we can be around our kid and our wives . Does that mean when we go home, we have to move them out so they dont have contact with us, so we dont interact with the public. We have to use science, science should be our guiding force, not fear, not perception and certainly not public opinion. Science real science. Shawn hoffman, you are on the front lines there, thanks so much for giving us the perspective from a healthcare worker. We appreciate it. Thank you. Boy, its about science its also about politics now, thats just the fact. Who would have guessed the hot button issue for midterm elections coming down to the wire would be ebola. Even with an exotic issue the politics are the same. Is the leadership there, now urging states to focus on science, not fear. Remember, a nurse under mandatory quarantine is the one caught in the middle of all this in new jersey. The question is too much caution better than not enough . Creeping up on you. Fight back with relief so smooth. Its fast. Tums smoothies starts dissolving the instant it touches your tongue. And neutralizes stomach acid at the source. Tum, tum tum tum. Smoothies only from tums. New york is allowing people to self quarantine, they can do it at home. Thats not water going on in new jersey. There was a nurse there treating ebola patients in west africa. Now shes really kind of held hostage in this hospital. She told us that she feels the treatment is inhumane. Are these state imposed measures necessary or is this as the nurse called it kneejerk reaction by politicians playing politics with public sentiment. Lets bring in the editor of the day lot beast and market hoover, cnn political commentator and republican consultant. Good morning. Good morning. There is a naked political play. People are afraid. You are doing what you think assuages the peoples will, you are not following science, you are victimizing people doing the work. West africa, shame on you. Look at you. Taking a strong line. Look, i think Public Health and personal liberty are often intentioned in the course of the country. Right now people are panicking. So you have local officials trying to overreact to restrain that panic. When the doctor came home from west africa and came down a week later with ebola. That has ripple effects. Its a kind of an imposition of putting people in the hospital. In the case of this nurse in new jersey, clearly a part of the problem is a lack of communication. She is angry. Thats one of the things motivating the lawsuit. We have to find balance. We are dealing with precedent. This is pr. She doesnt have symptoms. She is completely symptomfree. So for pr reasons, politicians are saying, but we have to hold her to make the, quell the public anxiety. I dont know its exactly pr. I dont take Chris Christie as a blatant political hack trying to gain points in an Election Year doing this. He clearly has a responsibility for securing a state and securing a state from panic, frankly. I think you have two side of the spectrum here. You could have pure panic or you could, truly, if you have two sides, panic or a strong armed governme government. The balance is somewhere in between. Frankly, the Obama Administration wasnt out in front of this in august when the first patient came here. There wasnt guidance from the cdc or clear communication. Sometimes i think the white house isnt leading thing and thats playing politics, but here, confidence is consistency, john, and weve gone from 21 days quarantine, but we know when in 21 you can get it. Its actually 40 days. Oh, its okay for them to come back. Wait, its here now, its a big problem. There are mixed messages. It leaves people scared. Look. No czar. Thats a fair point. You have to change your approach to facts oak. This is a place where the white house is messaging especially from the cdc where the goal posts keep moving, i think has undercut confidence. You cant replay that. What we need to do is realize we are in an unprecedented situation. I think the white house and government needs to get involved and set clear standards. Its a part of water baked into our system. The big thing is, eight days from election, trying to politicalize a pandemic on any side is truly foolish and dangerous. Lets talk about the midterms for a second, ebola is not local, all politics is local. Does it play into the midterms . Well, you have really tight senate races where the senate hangs in the balance, it isnt local. There is no senate race in texas, new jersey or new york. There arent senate races in arkansas. So you know, only to the extent that maybe the next maybe wasnt fast enough. But you are right. Its not a local issue in the key states. So i dont see a massive politicalization of this. My governor is the brother of fork state. Im the one pointing fingers about this policy because if you had, my brother would disagree with this, hes a democrat. He could say, no, no, this isnt about the white house and their policies. How is the not about leadership from the top that is making states now go rogue and come up with their own policies and doesnt that reflect on the midterm to kind of that collective psychology of whether the democrats are really in control and doing what they need to do for the people of this country. The world is going to hell, its a lack of leadership on the part of the president doing it. You know most Public Safety measures are matters for local and state governments. If we want to federalize a pandemic, that moves the ball a lot more towards that no, what does the department of Homeland Security does . They absolutely does work on pandemic and the cdc. You do federalize the response. Thats the point. The reason narratives get traction is because there is some kind of truth to them. We have seen we know in the Obama Administration a lack of response to many crises or a lack of Quick Response so the crises has gotten out of the way or out of the hand of those in administration. You saw it as early as the oil spill. It drives you crazy. Fair point. That was tough to concede right now. I cant believe. Now i dont know meyiwa to do. I dont know what to do. John, great to see you guys. Look, what we do about ebola is big. Its local. Its national. Its international. We will have to keep talking about it to physical out. We clearly dont have the solution yet. One big story we are following, big fuse as well, so lets get right to you. Backlash from Health Workers on the front lean of the ebola fight. I feel like my basic human rights have been violated. My first and foremost obligation is to protect the Public Health and the people of new jersey. We have to be very careful about letting politicians make medical and Public Health decisions. The quarantine controversy rages on. It is totally in the states authority to implement what that state thinks is appropriate. You have got to make your decisions and your policy based on the scientific data. Its a time for everyone to get on the same page and protect our people. Good morning, everyone, welcome back to new day. Alisyn come rot to along side questions cuomo. Overnight, we are responding to an uproar, new york state is scaleing back its boll la quarantine policy, Health Care Workers returning from west africa who will be able to do their own mandatory 21day period at home. It has a lot of people raising questions, well, can we trust self monitoring . Thats why new jersey, governor Chris Christie, has a different take. Hes standing by his ebola rule despite coming under attack to be the first one to isolate a nurse coming back from treating people with ebola. Now the nurse is slamming his policy saying she is completely healthy. She has no sign of ebola. She should be free to leave the new jersey hospital. But she isnt. We need complete cover annual of this. We have it. We will give you the ebola story like nobody can. Lets begin with senior medical correspondent elizabeth cohen. Good morning. Good morning. Chris, one side says the quarantines protect the public, but the other side says the quarantines could actually lead to more cases of ebola. This morning the governors of fork and new jersey offering clarification on their days old policy of ebola quarantining. Under guidelines, Health Care Workers returning from treating ebola patients in west africa will remain quarantined for a mandatory 21 days, residents of the state can stay inside their homes. In addition, those traveling from ebola hot zones that havent come into contact will be actively monitored for nurse casey kaci hickox, the new policy has been a nightmare. I dont think most people understand what its like to be alone in a tent and to know that there is nothing wrong with you and that decisions are being made that dont make sense. Reporter hickox was quarantined, se currently shows no symptoms and tested negative for ebola twice. My first and foremost obligation is to protect the Public Health and safety of new jersey. Good afternoon, everyone. Reporter the mayor of fork city blasted the decision, which some say deters Health Care Workers to contain the fight from taking ebola abroad. This hero coming back from the front, having done the right thing, was treated with disrespect. Reporter her lawyers are fighting for her immediate release. We believe that policy infringes on the constitutional liberty interests. Reporter currently officials are quarantining three states, new york, new jersey and illinois. The policy was abruptly implemented friday, just one day after a new york doctor Craig Spencer who treated patients in guinea was diagnosed with ebola. Some people are say we are being too cautious. Ill take that criticism. Reporter a federal official says the cdc was surprised but acknowledges state and local officials have the progresstive to set tighter policies. Now, critics of these quarantines say they are unclear, too broad and unnecessary, if are you not sick, you cant spread the virus. It is complicated. Thanks so much for breaking it down. We will talk to you again in the show. White house officials enacting quarantine policies based on science, not fear. They are expressing concerns medical volunteers may not go to ebola hot zones to help if they have to face three weeks of confinement when they get back. Consider the case of nurse casey kaci hickox. She finds herself under legal quarantine. She is pursuing legal action now to get out. Michelle co zin ski joins us more on the politics of ebomb la. Lets say you are a health care worker, you are moved to fight ebola, to care for patient patients there. Is it go to go prevent you from going at all . It hasnt been clear that would be a deterrent or why to doing something thats already a pretty difficult thing to do. Thats what the white house has cited we petedly as its own fear in this. Its interesting, of the five states going above and beyond what the cdc is doing, three of them have democratic governors. New york Governor Cuomo said he has not been pressured by the white house to change course. The white house did make its displeasure very clear in a statement saying it is letting governors know it has concerns about the unintended consequences of policies that quote are not grounded in science. But now the white house says that its working on coming up with its own new guidelines for returning Health Care Workers. Clearly, it wont go as far as some of these states have gone. It also indicates the white house doesnt think the new restrictions going into effect today requiring Health Care Workers to monitoring their own temperatures for 21 days might not be enough. So once again, well see the federal response to ebola change. Alisyn. All right. Michelle, thank you for breaking that down for us from the white house. Lets talk to somebody who knows about ebola all too well. He is a doctor who went to treat ebola patients. He became a patient, himself. His firsthand knowledge, in fact, he is still fighting it. He joins us to lend his perspectives. Checking in with us on skype. I hope the connection holds up, most importantly, how are you feeling . We know its not over until it is completely over. There are different steps to recovery. You had some trouble lately. Give us the latest. I am feeling pretty good. I am getting my strength back gradually. Really feeling better. You understand the fear thats out there, doc. A lot is ignorance and inconsistency. What is your take . Well, you know, any time there is a new or unknown infection that hits us, we have this experience. We saw it with polio. We saw it when hiv came out in the 80s. There was a lot of fear, a lot of stigma. I think we are seeing the same thing. In each of those other cases, americans overcame that disease and really were able to get it under control through, you know, through following what the science says through aggressively gathering information and then developing interventions that work, according to science. I think thats what we need to do again with ebola. I think we can. We just need to Pay Attention to the science, the fact and that, you know, let that guide us through. The fact is that these people who are being quarantined who are not ill are not at risk. When you dont have symptoms, you are not a risk. Its simple to say. I get it. I know its simple to understand for you. You are a doctor, you get the science. I know you dont want to wade into political waters. You are a champion and a survivor from the virus. We have tremendous respect from what you have done. You know that there are questions about this self monitoring. You know, can we trust people to do it . Will they really be that aware . Maybe we should take a further step, because you dont know when you will get it. 21 days, there are so many variables. Is there a middle ground . Please dont say 40 days. There is no data to suggest a 40day window. You know why i say that, right . You know somebody came out with a study and said that 21 days is from the 1970s and now it could be longer than. That thats where the number comes from. That was based on mathematical modeling, not on clinical data. They dont have cases that came out 40 days later. Okay. It was a mathematical model they were using on the computer. Okay. Let stick with the 21 days. What do you think about these governors . My brother is the government of new york. He came out and said i will quarantine them. Then he started getting questioned about it. He said, all right, well let them quarantine at home. Chris christie across the river says, no, no, no, this nurse is in the hospital. Thats the safest way, everybody counts more than she does for temporary inconvenience. Is one of those solutions better than the other or are they both bad . Lets keep this in mind. We want, you know, Governor Cuomo said he wasnt comfortable with an honor system when he made the initial announcement. Lets keep in mind, these Health Care Workers are coming back in through an airport and being asked what activities were you involved in in west africa. Thats an honor system right there. They are being asked to self report their activities, what were they doing . Were they in touch with ebola patients . Thats Self Reporting and thats an honor system right there. So you have to have a system that encourages more communication of better relationship between those Health Care Workers and their local health authorities. I think when you put in place a more burdensome quarantine, you are going to start having people not want to be quite so free about communicating the truth about what they were doing. So lets appeal to the honor of these amazing self sacrificeing Health Care Workers and let them, you know, let them have a role in monitoring their own condition instead of dock it like a police state approach. A point well taken. Lets end on this before we end this interview. I hope we get to talk to you again. I want to make sure we stay in up the. Were so parochial about ebola right now. It only really matters in the u. S. Because we have seen it in the u. S. Will you speak to the fact that the ebola scare is not over. That its just really starting. Its about how much and how aggressively we attack it in africa and as as it starts to move in other continents, thats really the focus. Thats right this past week we had the first case of mollie, the borders in west africa are porous. This can move across africa or a passenger can get on a plane in westing africa and land in india or somewhere in asia with it. We need to contain it and get it under control where it is now in those three major countries in west africa. We need to do everything we can to facilitate getting people on the ground to bring that under control and to help the people of liberia and guinea and sierra leone. Thank you for the good work you did abroad. Thank god you have gotten over the virus, stay in up the. We want to foe you get back to 100 . Thank you for being with us on new day and understanding the situation a little better. Thank you. Great to see you looking so healthy. Lets give you a look at your headlines, breaking overnight, another student has died following a student at a Washington State high school. Three other victims are still fighting for their lives. In the meantime, details are emerging of what happened during that attack. One student says they went up to a table of student and opened fire a. Teacher stopped the teen by running umm to him, grabbing his arm before he took his own life. A Syrian Monitoring Group says at least 800 people have been killed in the last 40 days in the battle for control of kobani along the syrianturkey border. Most of the dead are syrian and kurdish fighters. U. S. Military are hammering isis targets in syria and iraq over the weekend. In hong kong now, protest leaders suspended a vote to determine the next step if a pro democracy movement. Organizers cancelled the vote because they could not agree on a method of voting. This move will have confusion weeks after the protesters occupied the streets in the Financial Hub and election reforms. You could call this robbers remorse a. Guy held up a station and returned later to give up the. And apologize. He told officers he needed the cash to leave town and make a fresh start. He had second thoughts, though, called the whole thing off. Now, despite the change of heart, watson was still arrested. I hope the judge has some leniency on that. Well within their discretion to do so. Well stay on that and update you when we get it. Thousands of u. S. Troops lost in battle against ebola. They are building clinics to try to stop the virus in its tracks. How will quarantine rules affect them when they come back . As im sure you will know the race to see who will control the senate is as tight as two coats of paint. We will tell you what you need to know in fees final days. Stay with us. train horn vo wherever our trains go, the economy comes to life. Norfolk southern. One line, infinite possibilities. So right now if you get the 15 gig plan, well double the data and make it 30 gigs for the same price. 30 gigs . Wow thats a lot. You dont have to do that for me. Oh, thats ok. interrupting seriously, i wouldnt want you to get in trouble. Its the same plan for everyone. Families. Businesses. Whoever. Riiiiight. yelling no celebrity treatment here yelling there really isnt any celebrity treatment. Just a normal guy, getting a great deal. Were just saying it loudly for some reason. Now get 30 gigs of data to share with family or your business. For a limited time, starting at 160 dollars a month. Do you guys have Identity Theft protection . [ male voice ] im sorry, did you say identity distribution . No. Protection. Identity theft protection. You have selected identity distribution. Your identity will now be shared with everyone. Thank you. No, no, no [ click, dial tone ] [ female announcer ] not all Credit Report sites are equal. [ male voice ] were good in here, howie. Yeah, have a good night, brother. Experian. Com members get personalized help plus Identity Theft protection. Join now at experian. Com. With enrollment in experian credit tracker. Join now at experian. Com. Means keeping seven billion ctransactions flowing. G, and when weather hits, its data mayhem. But airlines running hp endtoend solutions are always calm during a storm. So if your business deals with the unexpected, hp big data and Cloud Solutions make sure you always know whats coming and are ready for it. Make it matter. Thousands of u. S. Soldiers are a part of the American Mission to fight ebola in west africa. Theyre constructing field hospitals and labs to try to slow the epidemic. So how could these state mandated quarantines obviously their deployment . Lets bring in retired colonel and Affairs Analyst james reese. Good morning, alisyn. Good morning. Soon there will be troops in west africa helping to contain the virus. Down they are vulnerable to contracting the virus . You know, alisyn, everyone is velnerable. Lets be honest. But the way that the military does predeployment the ppe, personal protective equipment the military will have for these soldiers over there and the postdeployment and all the medical providers that the military has to observe and watch their own soldiers, i think that the chances of them contracting ebola are very slim heres what we have been told, they will not be treating patients. They will be building clinics, training personnel and they will be testing the blood of patients with ebola. So that sounds like a possible point of exposure. So you are confident that theyre doing everything that they need to be doing to stay safe. What happens now when they need to come home, do you think they should also be subject to these quarantines . Well, you know, alisyn, you got to remember, the military is a self contained unit. The commander over there right now that i know very well the guy is a stud. He has his own team that will advise him. They will literally lead this crisis down the road. When they have soldiers that are going back, they already have a plan. Theyll have a postdeployment plan, how to monitor, how to check soldiers and to insure that theyre are squared away, the other beauty is the military has some of the best equipment in the world, if there is a soldier that does get infected, they will be able quarantine them back at Fort Campbell, fort hood, wherever they are. I think its a low risk. If there is a soldier affected, the military will take care of it quickly and square it away. Absolutely t. Military knows how to do this. They are the best in the world at doing this. Given whats happened this weekend with new jersey and illinois saying anybody that returns from these west african countries should be quarantined for 21 days. It sound like these 4,000 troops should also be. Again, keep in mind, lets say tomorrow the 1,500 troops from Fort Campbell 101st Airborne Division return. Lets fast forward. They will land in Fort Campbell, couple. Those commanders have the ability to keep people on their own base, on their own post and do their own self quarantine. The pentagon will be working with local officials to make sure these aspects are chained away. They help things along so you dont have individuals doing great work on the public side coming back, then you get the friction points between our individuals, the military brings it own self containment to barbi barbie. Ba progress have they been eight make . In there we see people challengying is the military doing this . First off, this is a core military task. As a former commander, this is one operation id rather do tan have to go into combat operations. You know, the military brings a plethora and cross aspect of civilian life. You know, theres leaders, theres medical people. Theres construction individuals. Theres people that know how to do the medical piece, the medical professionals, blood, the blood folks, so what theyll do is tail bring in the key engineers, the cbs in the navy, from spain, theyll set up these camps, theyll also bring if great equipment that can be used for all of the Public Health people coming in, the other doctors the civilian doctors and nurses that will come in. Theyll just be able to backside them. The other great thing for the military in this aspect is the military is in a supporting role this time, supporting the usaid. Again the military are great at crisis leadership. They will be able to coach, teach and mentor the aid workers coming in, really be a great backbone for what we got to do with ebola in west affect. Thats wonderful. Thanks for spelling it all out for us. It must be a great comfort for us to have at least 900 of our military there. Its great to see you this morning. You too, alisyn, have a great day. Lets go over to chris. We will be talking about the bush family. They have been a dominant push in politics for decades. Now there are new signs that the man on your screen, jeb bush, may be eyeing the white house. Will he run in 2016 . People have been asking a little on the side, now hes in focus. John king will take him on, a u. S. Army vet so outraged by isis brutal. He left everything hoo ind to fight against the terror group. We have his incredible story later this hour. Youll want to see it. Test. A single ember that escapes from a wildfire can travel more than a mile. That single ember can ignite and destroy your home or even your community you cant control where that ember will land only what happens when it does get fire adapted now at fireadapted. Org glad to have you back with us here on new day. We begin with breaking news, prosecutors overseas want the Death Penalty for the ferry that capsized in april, killing 300 people. He faces homicide charges for abandoning the ship. Prosecutors want life sentencings for the other three people for their roles. The president is staying in power in brazil by the slimmest of margins. She won by 51 of the vote following a bitter campaign, coasting the opposition candidate in a runoff. The tightest race brazil has seen since it returned to democracy some three decades ago. Thousands gathering in hungaries budapest in the first known demonstration of its kind, demonstrators held up their devices, illuminated and threw old computer parts at the gates of the ruling partys headquarters, if it passes, they would pay about 60 cents a gigabyte. Lawmakers promised to put a cap on that tax. I have said this more than once, singing the National Anthem is not easy. When you mess up, oh, millions get to watch you on tv. It is not pretty. Take a look. Oh so proudly we hailed were so gallantly streaming whose broad stripes and bright stars. Country singer aaron lewis jumped the gun, he sang were so gallantly streaming. The words come later. Lewis was later very apom jettic saying in a statement quote all i can say is i am sorry and ask for the nations forgives in. We forgive him. We forgive you. Yes. Oh, except for him. I forgive him. I feel horrible. I feel bad we had to play it. I really feel badly for the guy. They feed a teleprompter. Thats what they need. You need to have the lyrics right in front of you. I dont blame them for that. You got to be nice. Give them the forgiveness. Speaking of forgiveness. Midterm elects are coming up. Lets get inside politics. Do you think the voters will see forgiveness for what is raging down there in d. C. . Is turnout going to be the same as the occupation of our set right now. I think democrats are down. They are working the early voting. We will see what happens. Its a big question. One full week of campaigning left. One full week of campaigning left. Im sewing you the battle for the control for the United States senate. Let focus there as we go inside politics there. This is the state of flight, ladies and gentlemen, 55 democratic seats, including the two independents, 45 republicans, heres whats up this year, there are three dozen senate races, the ones in gold are yellow, those are the races we are watching closely. I will play you out a scenario. This is a hypothetical scenario of how republicans think they are close to the six seats they need. I just gave the republicans for the sake of this argument democrats say theyre at play in arkansas. There could be a surprise, will its go here. What does that leave you . Eight races, colorado, kansas, i, what kentucky, lousiana, georgia, forth carolina and New Hampshire, all of them right now within single digits. Lets take a look at new polling. These are nbc polls released over the weekend. Look at the polls. You go through the key battlegrounds, 1point races, 2point races. Republicans think thats trending their way. Play out a scenario. Look at these races, what happens, in colorado, the republicans think theyre in the lead. Just for the fun of it, i will say the democrats hold on to this blue state here, there is a hypothetical. Iowa, we will lay this out. Republicans think they will win this one too. Lets assume that democrats hold on to the state of new hampshir. Then youd have six left at 47, 47. Republicans would have to hold their own. Lets play this out. Lets say pat roberts holds on in kansas. There is an independent candidate there. I will give the republicans their own. This is a very tight race. Im headed to kentucky tomorrow to get an eye on this one, then where are we in 49, 47, one, two, three, four left. Jonathan martin. I want you at this point, you have to say the odds are with the republicans. If they win half of the races, it looks like they get the majority. But so many so close. Thats right, john. I think this is why so Many Democrats are concerned. They have no margin for error at all. If you include the three states you mentioned widely seated at gop pickups, west virginia, south dakota, john, and im missing one more, i think its going to be hard for democrats to hold on because of the fact that it places like iowa, which for a long time democrats not to come back are looking tougher. Colorado still very close, looking for democrats, then you go to the south, places like arkansas and louisiana seem really tough with obama in the white house. They do. I la ied this out while jonathan was talking. I gave democrats all the blue states, colorado, i, what famp, forth clone, a lot of frub republicans say that will not happen. I did it to make a point. If all the races break late and go the republicans way, republicans get as high as 55. Margaret, look at this scenario, i can get you 49 to 49, two states with runoff. Georgia david purdue vs. Michelle nun, a lot of people think you need 50 plus 1 in these states. Lousiana is december. Georgia would be january. What if we had this scenario, 49 and 49 with two runoffs after election day to divide controls the senate. Isnt that amazing . It made georgia a fascinating to watch. In the near term just because of what it would mean the sort of cliff hangar going down to the wire if january, how you would mobilize anything to boat a runoff then. I think if you get those two runoff, the president then, does he become a factor . Hes been a pariah layout the campaign. That would be key in the runoff. This week he is playing. He is out on the road. He is not playing anywhere that matters in control of the senate. Se going to wisconsin. That is a big race. That matters. Michigan, the democrats are winning. He is going up into new england. Why, jonathan, still a pariah in the Democratic Party when it comes to the big senate race. A lot of the democratic campaigns have determined, john, there is more risk. They have president obama come out there and at this late stage in the campaign, they dont want to give their opponents the opportunity to make the race about president obama. By the way, i forgot, montana. Yes. And the president s leadership is at issue. We started this year thinking about obamacare. We thought it would be more about economy. We end on ebola. The president , the white house is in a battle with states, saying dont go further than the federal government. You had new york, new jersey, spoke up with a tougher quarantine policy. New york is listen to Chris Christie the new jersey governor, saying no, i dont think the federal government is being tough enough. Im not going to being down. As we saw with what happened with some of the healthcare workers in texas with the cdc shifting property coltprotocols had people infected. We cant have that in the new jersey area. Now you see they agree in chicago as well. I think this is a policy that will become a National Policy southeastern rather than later. You have a feud over a subject thats anxiety ridden as ebola in terms of the politics of it. How does the prediction come out here . Christie, his biggest problem is hes too friendly with president obama. He gave him tbro hug. At least this is a way to distinguish himself. What are you saying . Im sorry for this nurse, i got to protect people. John the democrats have not concocted a more unwelcome scenario, the final weeks of the election will be played out with a viral disease coming to american shores from africa. Its the last thing they need. You mentioned jeb bush. His dad is jeb bush the former governor. There is a big question whether mom, barbara bush is on board, jeb bushs wife is on board. Listen to george p. Sort of get a green light. Is your dad going to run for president . I think hes still assessing it. Do you think its more than 50 , less than 50 . I think its more than likely he is giving this a serious thought and moving forward. That hell run. That hell run. Look, hes a young guy, george p. , relatively new, he is not saying things like that loose lipped, is he . Hes got to mean it . No, he does mean it. He knows jeb bush would like to run for president. My colleague has a great story in the times george w. Bush is the family cheerleader pushing jeb on here. It seems like with the exception of barbara bush, most of the family is on board, especially the two georges. Jeb bush . Yes . I mean. Thats god. I like that. I think its entirely possible. You continue to look at the republican field. If you are jeb bush, you are thinking, you know what, why not . As we get back to new new york, it makes debate on immigration issues, if you get jeb bush versus the other guys, fascinating debates. That republican race would be a lot of fun. It does sound like that. It seems like hes leaning in that direction. John, thanks, so much. Grit to see you. All right, new yorks first ebola patient fighting for his life. How is dr. Craig spencer coming along . We will speak with the ceo of the hospital treatment treating him. Is it better to be overly cautious . The nurse under quarantine says no it is not as does the white house. Will it chaening the mind of state officials . New day returns in just a moment. Decay. Its the opposite of evolution. The absence of improvement. And the enemy of perfection. Which is why you can never stop moving forward. Never stop inventing. Introducing the mercedesbenz gla. A breakthrough in design, aerodynamics and engineering. Because the only way to triumph over decay. Is to leave it in its own dust. Just take a closer look. It works how you want to work. With a Fidelity Investment professional. Or managing your investments on your own. Helping you find new ways to plan for retirement. And save on taxes where you can. So you can invest in the life that you want today. Tap into the full power of your fidelity greenline. Call or come in today for a free oneonone review. Ring ring progresso i cant believe im eating bacon and rich creamy cheese before my sisters wedding well its only 100 calories, so youll be ready for that dress uhhuh. You dont love the dress . I love my sister. 40 flavors. 100 calories or less. Creeping up on you. Fight back with relief so smooth. Its fast. Tums smoothies starts dissolving the instant it touches your tongue. And neutralizes stomach acid at the source. Tum, tum tum tum. Smoothies only from tums. Good to have you back with us on new day. Andrew cuomo is adjusting the 21day quarantine for doctors and nurses returning from africa. They are quarantine at home as long as they are symptom free. Dr. Spencer continues to fight for his life. How is he proceeding . Is the fear of ebola good for quarantines. The president and ceo of fork city health and hospitals corporation, which overseas Bellevue Hospital where dr. Craig spencer is being treated. First of all, we are getting word that the daily fuse is reporting a fiveyearold child is being treated at bellevue, apparently returning from his family from west africa with a 103 fever, can you tell us if that child is at the hospital and what is being done . We are working with people with a travel history and fever at Bellevue Hospital together with the department of health and Mental Hygiene of new york city. We will be probably making sticks. Observations or being tested . We dont know yet. Obvations are still going on. How long will that last . A couple hours. Can we turn to dr. Spencer . We know he received treatment from nancy writebol, ebola survivor, can you update on his condition . He is in a serious condition but stable. He is going through the phase of the disease, which is completely anticipated. We continue to closely mon core him at our specialize lalgs unit at Bellevue Hospital. I got a question. When you are evaluating, why wouldnt you take his blood right away and test to see if he has the virus . Is that a part of the evaluation . A part of the eraugs is the history of the travel and the contact. Is there any contact they had with any patient with ebola in west africa when the kid was there. The question is you are the household contacts doing, also, evaluating the kid for symptoms of ebola. So they will make a decision with the department of mental health. Why not test them right away . If i locate them with a low risk. There is no travel history. There is a travel history. There is a travel history. No contact history yet. So they havent been able to establish where the child was specifically . Yes. So, doctor, how confident are you that all your Health Workers are being protected and not being exposed. We saw what happened in dallas. They were conversation they were not exposed. Low and behold two came down with ebola. I dont know if you saw 60 minutes. Some of the nurses were on. They had a such a heart rendering story how they knew they might be at rick, but they wanted to do their job and do it well. Let me play for you when the nurse first saw the patient thomas duncan. I put on my protective wear. I went in and introduced myself to him and let him know i would be the nurse helping him tonight. I was very frightened. I was. But i just dried my tears, rolled down my sleeves so to speak and went on about my night. She has such a compelling story. She says she was very frightened. Do you think Health Care Workers in your field feel the same way . In there we all learned a lot from dallas. We have strong, really played it over twoandahalf months to putting this on and protecting our nurses and doctors and Health Care Providers helping ebola patients. We are preparing it for a while. We have tested our system we have a buddy system if plates. When the nurse comes out of the room, he or she does not take the gear off, somebody is there. Now you remove the clothes, it is all done in a very very sistered way of ta structured way of taking it off. I am sure we will have much better results tan what we had in dallas is there we are hearing reports some of the staff at bellevue are betting pushed back in their own communities, some people say i know you work at bellevue, i dont want to serve you. I dont want you to come into my store. Is this what you are hearing . How do you counteract is that . Weve talked about the science and the perception . The man was very effective yesterday in the first conference. He actually compared the Health Care Workers to the people who come back, return from a Foreign Military duty. So we need to treat them leak this this is the war the health care. So we treat them like that, like heroes. They are not discriminating against them. They are working bellevue patie patients who are sec you need to say this is something you do not catch. It is absolutely important that all of us have a lot of things to do to make the public feel saf safe. Thank you, its comforting to hear from you. Thank you. Please keep us informed about the fiveyearold. We will. An army vet quit his job, left his family behind to fight on the front lines. Now he wants you to do the same. We have his story next. Youre driving along, having a perfectly nice day, when out of nowhere a pickup truck slams into your brand new car. One second it wasnt there and the next second. Boom youve had your first accident. Now you have to make your first claim. So you talk to your Insurance Company and. Boom youre blindsided for a second time. They wont give you enough money to replace your brand new car. Dont those people know youre already shaken up . Liberty mutuals new car replacement will pay for the entire value of your car plus depreciation. Call and for drivers with accident forgiveness, Liberty Mutual wont raise your rates due to your first accident. Switch to Liberty Mutual insurance and you could save up to 423 dollars. Call Liberty Mutual for a free quote today at see Car Insurance in a whole new light. Liberty mutual insurance. So you may say youre against isis. Its pretty easy, right . What a are you going to do about it . An American Army veteran felt the same and went to fight side by side with Kurdish Forces in syria to destroy isis. Hes jouts raoutraged by the br. He quit his job, left behind loved ones and volunteered on the front lines in the battle against terror. Now hes recruiting other westerners in the fight. Ivan watson is live in iraq with that story. Ivan . Reporter chris, theres been so much attention on westerner who is have joined isis, but the fact is the Syrian Civil War has attracted westerners to other fighting in other simultaneous civil wars tearing syria apart. We traveled into kurdish controlled Northern Syria and met this American Veteran soldier who decided to join the kurds. Armed men are a common sight. One of the gunmen in this truck is not like the others. How do people react to you when they see and realize youre from the u. S. . They ask if i will come over for dinner and stay at their house. Hes a 28yearold former u. S. Army soldier from wisconsin. For the last month, hes also been a volunteer fighter in the Kurdish Militia known here as the wpg. I got in contact with the ypg on facebook, soul searched and said is this what i want to do . Eventually you know, decided to do it. Soon after arriving here in syria, he says he ended up in a battle against isis. The second day in i got hit by a mortar. While recovering from shrapnel wounds, he went to work online recruiting foreigners to help the ypg fight against isis. Ive had ex military from eastern europe, western europe, canada, United States, australia. He lives in places like this former restaurant converted into a militia camp. What are the pictures . All men who have died fighting against isis. The ypg are very lightly armed gorillas. Is this a flak jacket . No. This is a vest to carry ammunition. Basically people are running into battle without armor . Yes. And wearing sneakers half the time . Yes. Combat adidas is. U. S. Law enforcement officers say its illegal for an american to join a syrian militia. He says being here fighting along side the kurds is a dream come true. All my life i wanted to be a soldier. Im at peace being here. Matson says hes at peace in a war zone. He also says there are at least three other americans there fighting along side the kurds in Northern Syria. Ive covered a lot of conflicts around the world. If theres one common thing ive seen, its that they tend to act as magnets, attract adventurers, mercenaries, idealists and mistmi misfits. This is no exception. What a story. Thanks so much for telling us his story. Great stuff. Meanwhile, concerns over ebola spiked this morning. Word of 5yearold monitored in new york city. This has states quarantine implements come under fire. One nurse calls her treatment inhumane. Well tell you what she says shes enduring. From fashion retailers to healthcare providers, jewelers to Sporting Good stores, we provide Financing Solutions for all sorts of businesses. Banking. Loyalty. Analytics. Synchrony financial. Engage with us. [ female announcer ] we love our smartphones. And now telcos using hp Big Data Solutions are feeling the love, too. By offering things like onthespot data upgrades an idea that reduced overcharge complaints by 98 . No matter how fast your Business Needs to adapt, if hp Big Data Solutions can keep wireless customers smiling, imagine what they can do for yours. Make it matter. Ima receptionist can do Gunderman Group is growing. Getting in a groove. Growth is gratifying. Goal is to grow. Gotta get greater growth. I just talked to ups. They got expert advise, special discounts, new technologies. Like smart pick ups. Theyll only show up when you print a label and its automatic. We save time and money. Time . Money . Time and money. Awesome. Awesome awesome awesome awesome all awesome i love logistics. Big day . Ah, the usual. Moved some new cars. Hauled a bunch of steel. Kept the supermarket shelves stocked. Made sure everyone got their latest gadgets. Whats up for the next shift . Ah, nothing much. Just keeping the lights on. laugh nice. Doing the big things that move an economy. See you tomorrow, mac. See you tomorrow, sam. Just another day at norfolk southern. I found a better deal on prescriptions. We found lower copays. And a free wellness visit. New plan. Same doctor. Im happy. Its medicare open enrollment. Have you compared plans yet . Its easy at medicare. Gov. Or you can call 1800medicare. Medicare open enrollment. Youll never know unless you go. I did it. You can too. Visit tripadvisor rome. With millions of reviews, tripadvisor makes any destination better. So visit tripadvisor. Com now. Quarantine fall out, fear driving policy. Officials in several states under pressure to reassess policies for Health Care Workers returning from west africa. Now a nurse quarantined in new jersey pull nothing punches about her prison like conditions. Are her rights being violated . Is this overreaction . The white house urging state as not to go too far. Theyre concerned it may hurt effort tops send medical staff to west african nations forcing new york to make a change. Another student has died from injuries from friday School Shooting in Washington State. New details emerging about the chaotic scene inside as shots rang out. Were going to tell you of one teacher that put herself at risk trying to stop the carnage in the cafeteria. Your new day continues right now. Good morning. Welcome back to new day. Its monday, october 27, a about 8 00 in the east. Chris cuomo joined by alisyn camerota. Not another health care returning, this is a kid 5 years old. He is just back with his family from guinea we believe. Hes now at a designated ebola center evaluated, not tested. They have to check, to see his symptoms, see if he was near anyone who had ebola in the first place before they take that step. This comes as concerns about the virus coming in more volume in the United States as politicians push for mandatory quarantines. New jersey is clarifying the strict quarantine process under fire from a nurse who has been kept in isolation since arriving back from sierra leone. She says shes not sick, has no signs of ebola and wants out of that tent. Shes telling cnn her basic human rights are being violated. Our coverage begins with cnn elizabeth cochecohen. You cant blame the nurse. Shes not allowed to go home. Shes not sick. Shes tested negative twice now. Folks that advocate for quarantines say theyll protect the public. Folks that criticize say look, they could lead to more cases of ebola. This morning governors of new york and new jersey offering policy ises. Under the guidelines, Health Care Workers returning from treating ebola patients in west africa will remain quarantined 21 days. Residents of the state can stay inside their hopes. In addition, those traveling from hot zones who havent come in contact with ebola patients, theyll be actively monitored. For the nurse, the poll say has been a nightmare. I spoke to casey on the phone. I dont think most people understand what its like to be alone in a tent and you know nothing is wrong with you. It doesnt make sense. She was quarantined inside this tent after she arrived from treating ebola patients in sierra leone. She currently shows no symptoms of the virus and tested negative for ebola twice. My first and foremost obligation is protect Public Health and safety of people of new jersey. The mayor of new york city blasted the decision which some say deters Health Care Workers from taking part in the fight to detain ebola abroad. This hero coming back from having done the right thing was treated with disrespect. Her lawyers are fighting for her immediate release. We believe that policy enfringes on the constitutional liberty interests. Currently three states, new york, new jersey and illinois have the policy. It was abruptly implemented friday after dr. Spencer was diagnosed with ebola. Some people will say were being too cautious. Ill take that criticism. A federal official says the cdc was surprised by the mandate but acknowledges state officials have the prerogative to set policies. Critics of quarantines say theyre too broad, unclear and unnecessary. If youre not sick, you cant spread the disease. Were going to debate all of that in a moment. Then you go on the other side. They say 21 days, you have to wait the full to know if someone is sick. We have to deal with that as well. Lets get back to kaci , the nurse under mandatory quarantine in j new jersey. Hes not a criminal. She is a champion that went to do the one thing to keep ebola from coming to the u. S. , fighting it in africa. After her evaluation sunday, her Infectious Disease doctor did not recommend she get tested again today. Shes gone public with harsh words for Chris Christie and the system preparing legal papers for her to get out. Take a look. Once i got to the hospital, they of course tested my blood and confirmed it was negative. There are report of the me having a fever in the airport. I truly believe that it was an instrument error. When i arrived in in the isolation unit, they took my temperature orally and it was completely normal. Does it remain completely normal . Yes, it has also been completely normal. I heard from my mother last night who called me concerned and said governor christie just said in an interview that you were quote, unquote, obviously ill. This is frustrating to me. First of all, i dont think hes a doctor and secondly hes never laid eyes on me. Thirdly, i have been a symptomatic since ive been here. I feel completely strong and emotionally exhausted. I have not been implemented a clear plan. Even to this day, no one has told me what it means. This to me is just completely unacceptable. Do you understand the need of governors from new jersey, new yo york, illinois to say we need to make sure theyre in isolation until we know theyre past the danger zone. Do you understand that . I completely dont understand it. We have to be careful letting politicians make public and health decisions. I understand people feel they have a risk. I think we can have a conversation about what further measures might look like. I think this is an extreme that is really unacceptable. I feel like my basic human rights have been violated. All right. Lets figure out if this is extreme. Lets continue the conversation with dr. Kent, infectious kz specialist and contributor for the daily beast. And robin, cnn analyst and commentator. Doctor, does this woman need to be in the isolation tent for the next 21 days . Certainly not. Ic Public Health authorities would not have put her there. The danger of this is we might need mandatory quarantine in a different scenario. Its going to be hard to get us back to making that acceptable. Whats is scenario . It is as follows. You can have a false negative ebola test if you have symptoms for up to three days. In other words, if she had fever and was negative on day one, we would want to keep her with fever, which she did not have. We would keep her quarantined up to three days. There might be a need going forward. I think this is going to make it very hard for mandatory quarantine to happen at all. She does not need it. She has no fever, no symptoms. She feels she is just being punished because she went to west africa. She is 100 correct. Were talking about an issue alisyn where its Public Health concerns versus individual liberties. The law is clear. In matters of stopping the spread of any kind of disease like the this, particularly around border patrol. Federal and state governments have tremendous powers that are given to them to fight this kind of infection. However, you still as a citizen of the United States and even to somebody visiting the United States, you have individual liberties. What shes being robbed of is due process. They have put forward this quarantine alisyn which in myids ridiculous. More are going to die from the flu, probably thousands more people are going to. I dont see a quarantine or matter like this from stopping the spread of it. Let me play why. G governors cuomo and christie have to justify this. Ive always aired on the side of caution. Expect the best but prepare for the worst. Our job is protect the safety and health of our citizens. Weve take than action. I have no second thoughts about it. See doctor, the problem is you cant always rely on people to selfquarantine. We saw with dr. Nancy snyderman case from nbc. She was supposed to be in quarantine in her home but went out driving around, going to meet a friend at a restaurant. Dr. Craig spencer was selfmonitoring but going bowling and on the subway. It makes people feel better if anyone with possible exposure is kept in isolation for 21 days. I understand that entirely. I think though theres a need for us to get the message across about what does constitute true risks and what does not. I think the governors have a lot to worry about. I dont envy their job at all. I think by moving us away from a Scientific Evidence based approach to these decisions and toward, well everyone is nervous, lets make them less nervous, i think thats a big mistake. Its giving in to unjustified panic. I 100 agree. Theres alternatives here. You could take anybody coming back thats had direct contact, been working with ebola patients like kaci and put her in quarantine. Give her a specific caseworker from the cdc. Give her selfmonitoring. Theres longer monitoring period than a day. I completely agree with what doctors say. It feeds into irrational panic on the part of the public. For governors to come out and say were being super cautious here. Theres a 21 day incubation period. The only people that contracted this here in the United States have had direct contact, typically caring for patients. All of them except for mr. Duncan have been cured. Let me read you kacis experience. She wrote a letter this weekend. She says this when first coming to the airport. I was tired, hungry and confused. I tried to remain calm. My temperature was taken using a forehead scanner. No one would tell me what was going on or what would happen to me. Eight police cars were there. Sirens blared, lights flashed. I wonder had i had done wrong. She does not have terms in getting damages. Her course is to say theres been no due process. Theres no hearing, no chance to appeal this, no court system to go to. Thats part of the problem. You create policies based on public fear and dont provide the corresponding protection for an individual now in lock down. Maybe she can be sent home to maine in an ambulance today. With eight cars escorting her and sirens blaring. Thanks for coming in with the information. We appreciate it. Lets go to michaela. Thanks so much. Here are headlines now. The final u. S. Marines and british troops have ended operations in afghanistan. They transferred control to afghans. The flags were put up the last time marking that military milestone. Residents in the eastern part of hawaii are on alert, high alert as flowing lava races towards the town. Officials in the region of the big island say lava from the volcano is moving 15 yards per hour. Residents are repairing to evacuate. That occurred in june but picked up speed in the last few days. Well keep watching that. An ohio man held captive in north korea for months arrived home. He is seen shaking hands at church in ohio. He said its good to be free and prayed for quick return of two of americans held there, miller and bay. A new Study Suggests a natural compound found in cocoa can reverse memory loss. The study found it can improve connectivity in part of the brain that works with memory. Naturally researchers warn the compound exists only in minuscule amounts. Overeating chocolate to help your memory is probably not the wisest. Oddly, i do not remember the last part of what she said. I remember eat more chocolate. Especially with the weekend coming up. Got a pregame going this weekend. Did you say the weekend coming up . Its like five days away. Im not trying to halloween lover. Dont kill the dream. Hes excited for halloween. We got it going this past weekend. Whats your favorite . Costume . Candy. Get over the costumes. New mentality, cant go with nuts. Its up there with ebola in terms of parents fearing. Twix strong. Ill go with almond joy. Sometimes i feel like a nut, sometimes i dont. He was a popular freshman and homecoming prince with a bright future. What prompted him to open fire killing two classmates injuring two more . The key is to know why so we can see signs in others before it happens. Were going to speak to one of the victims friends obviously hurting very much right now. Dovisit tripadvisor new york. This is the life. With millions of reviews, tripadvisor makes any destination better. To dan simon live in marysville with the developments. Reporter school is closed for the entire week. When students return, its not clear if theyll ever eat in the cafeteria again where the shooting took place. No shooting makes sense, but this is more perplexing because he targeted friends and cousins. Over night, gia soriano died from injuries. Her family releasing this statement. Gia is our beautiful daughter. Words cannot express how much well miss her. An emotional tribal song to mourn for the community trying to heal. Looking for answers, answers that might not exist for us. Reporter many still asking why the popular teen would want to target his best friends and own a family. It was friday morning when freshman Jaylen Fryberg entered the cafeteria, walked up to a table where two cousins were sitting with friends and opened fire with a. 40 caliber handgun. He came up from behind and fired about six bullets into the backs of them. Reporter three others remain hospitalized in intensive care. Shaylee chuckulnaskit and cousins. Zoe galasso was the first to be killed. We all loved her so much. The first year social studies teacher ran towards gunfire and confronted the shooter. She grabbed his arm, hand on hand. It happened in seconds. Reporter moments later, fryberg is dead from apparent suicide. Exactly why this happened is unclear. The New York Daily News reporting that students say jaylen targeted the group after he was spurned by a Love Interest who chose one of his cousins over him. A friend of zoe galasso tells cnn that the victim was dating one of the victims friends. He snapped for no reason. Recently elected homecoming prince, he was a well liked student. On twitter he had a darker personality. I know i seem like im sweating it off but im not. And i will never be able to. It wont last. It will never last. We need to know why this happened, how to heal and how to help others. We have a family friend of zoe galasso, the first victim in the shooting. We have the pastor at the church in washington. Gentlemen, thank you for joining us. I wish it was under different circumstances. We have learned overnight gia soriano has lost her life. How are you this morning . Im doing fine. Im just really feeling the weight of the entire circumstances that are going on, especially on behalf of my friend and their family. Pastor, for all of the flowers behind you, each one represents a gesture and also one person whos very confused and hurt about how this could ever happen. What are you telling congregants . Its day by day, moment by moment. Whether its grief thats expressed or grief you dont feel right away. Were going to get through this together. Its okay however you feel. Were going to navigate this day by day. Its not about the event. The media gets caught up in the details. Its about the people involved not just the shooter. Corey, tell us about zoe. Well im really familiar with the parents. Didnt get a great opportunity to be close to zoe. Knowing the parents, its a clear representation of the type of person zoe is. The outpouring thats happened simply in the short amount of time speaks to the type of people that they were in the community which is why we are doing everything we can both spiritually and tangibly for the family. Why, the most important question and most frightening thing to consider. It takes you closer to what happened. What are they coming up with . Why their daughter . I know theres a lot of tears. I had a chance to spend time with the family, and its a thick feeling there. Its just sad. There is a lot of just holding and crying together. I dont know if theyve really reached the why question yet. Theyre just trying to hold it together. Thats very understandable. Pastor, when these happen and they happen too often we see a pretty distinct formula. This kid was troubled, maybe mentally ill. He was ignored, an outcast, supposed to get treatment. He was getting it and didnt take it seriously. He didnt take plmeds, angry. He had access to weapons and then the tragic event. This situation seems to check none of those boxes. I think its a mystery that we sit here and get into the why and what. Im sure as people continue to dig, theyre going to come up with theories and ideas and thoughts. I dont know where he was at as far as processing life. I dont know what stories come out of this that become clear heart ache was so heavy or burden he bared was so terrible. I dont know. Were all different as individuals. Its hard to see how everybody processes everything all the time. I dont think its a stereo type or way to put a person in a box. I dont think we can do that at this time. From what youre hearing, was this kids reputation consistent with what weve been reporting that he was seen as a good kid, seen as somebody who had things going for him . Yeah. You have a guy whos part of the tribe, young leader in his tribe. That was evident from people that did know him and recognized this guy has gifts and talents to be a real leader. Thats a pretty incredible thing to have said. As well as students he played football with and mingled with. Thats part of the shock of the situation. On one hand with the stereo types, you could say we could see this coming. With this here, this is one of those you go, this is a kid were not sure exactly what he was processing. Thats tough about the whole thing. We know other kids hit by him in this are still struggling. Couple are stable, one in serious condition. We have to keep prayers and thoughts going for them. Well monitor the situation going forth. Corey, you set up a go fund me page for zoes family. Obviously a lot of what theyre dealing with is emotional. Theres no price to pay to get past that. What is the need now people should know about . I dont even know if the family can wrap their mind around what their needs are. I just know that so many of us in the peer group and around the community were looking for a way to really help in a way that could be present. If you couldnt be there to wrap your arms around them and hold them, that was the only other thing a lot of people were looking to do. I know they will be experiencing things much long after the cameras are gone. They really, really need some support to make sure they can see it through. Corey, i think that is a point that really will bear repeating in the days, weeks, months ahead. Corey, pastor, thank you for joining us. As somebody whos experienced too many of these from the outside, it begins when the media part ends. Theyre going to need you there for them much more in days ahead. I know you will. Its a tight community. Let us know what we can do. Thank you for joining us. Thank you. Theres another headline weve been following this morning. A developing story. A 5yearold boy in new york city is being monitored for symptoms of ebola. He is not being tested yet. Hes evaluated. Theyre watching his symptoms. On top of this is the fight about quarantines, fear of what happens when somebody has the virus. Which are right decisions and which are wrong . Well discuss it. Foreign markets. Asian debt that recognizes the shift in the global economy. You know, the kind that capitalizes on diversity across the credit spectrum and gets exposure to frontier and emerging markets. If you convert 4quarter p e of the s p 500, its yield is doing a lot better. If youve had to become your own investment expert, maybe its time for bny mellon, a different kind of wealth manager. And black swans are unpredictable. Wouldnt it be great if hiring plumbers, shopping online is as easy as it gets. Carpenters and even piano tuners were just as simple . Thanks to angies list, now it is. Start shopping online from a list of toprated providers. Visit angieslist. Com today. Just take a closer look. It works how you want to work. With a Fidelity Investment professional. Or managing your investments on your own. Helping you find new ways to plan for retirement. And save on taxes where you can. So you can invest in the life that you want today. Tap into the full power of your fidelity greenline. Call or come in today for a free oneonone review. What if we finally had that would be amazing. Hey, what if we took down this wall . What if this was my art studio . What if we were preapproved . Shut up from finding to financing, howd you do that . Zillow. All right. Here we go with five things you need to know for your five day. At number one. A 5yearold boy is monitored for ebola symptoms at Bellevue Hospital as new york state revises the the quarantine policy so people without symptoms can stay home three weeks and selfmonitor instead of doing that within a hospital. A second student has died after freshman opened fire inside a Washington State high school. Three students including two of the gunmans cousin remain hospitalized. In the meantime, a vigil was held sunday night. U. S. Marines and british troops have officially ended combat operations in afghanistan transferring camp leather neck to afghan control. Brazils president celebrating reelection after winning an incredibly tight race. She beat the opposition candidate to win. Speaking of winning, just one away. The giants shut out royals 50. Tuesday game six in kc. We always update the five things to know. Always visit cnn. Com for the latest. Its cnn money time. Christine romans with whats going on with stocks today. This is usually a rhetorical question. Last week was one of the best for stocks in almost two yoears. Dow climbed 2. 6 in one week. S p 500, 4 last week. Thats why you dont bail when things get rough. You miss the big moves. Talking about retailers declining apple pay. Cvs stores no longer taking apple pay following rite aids lead. There could be a mobile pay fight. Watch this. Gas prices plunging. The average price for a regular gallon of gas 3. 03 dollars. Thats the low nest almost four years, down 30 cents from a month ago, 60 cents from the prices over the summer. Why oil prices are plunging because we are producing a heck of a lot of energy in the country. You make me feel like driving somewhere. Youre getting an extra couple of a week. Its a tax break for consumers. If it lasts, we could see more in economic numbers. People have a little more money to spend. Youll spend less on heating bills this winter too. Thanks so much. Adjusting quarantine orders just a week before Voters Decide which politicians can keep their jobs. Is the ebola battle fought on political grounds . Well debate. E financial noise financial noise financial noise financial noise creeping up on you. Fight back with relief so smooth. Its fast. Tums smoothies starts dissolving the instant it touches your tongue. And neutralizes stomach acid at the source. Tum, tum tum tum. Smoothies only from tums. Are the largest targets in the world, for every hacker, crook and nuisance in the world. But systems policed by hps Cyber Security team are constantly monitored for threats. Outside and in. Thats why hp reports and helps neutralize more intrusions than anyone. In the world. If Hp Security Solutions can help keep the Worlds Largest organizations safe, they can keep yours safe, too. Make it matter. Maestro of project management. Baron of the buildout. You need a permit. To be this awesome. And you. Rent from national. Because only national lets you choose any car in the aisle. And go. You can even take a fullsize or above, and still pay the midsize price. aaron purrrfect. vo meeeow, business pro. Meeeow. Go national. Go like a pro. For most people, earning cash back ends here, at the purchase. But theres a new card in town. Introducing the citi® double cash card. It lets you earn cash back when you buy and again as you pay. Thats cash back twice. Its cash back with a side of cash back. The citi double cash card. The only card that lets you earn cash back twice on every purchase with 1 when you buy and 1 as you pay. With two ways to earn, it makes a lot of other cards seem onesided. What if we finally had that would be amazing. Hey, what if we took down this wall . What if this was my art studio . What if we were preapproved . Shut up from finding to financing, howd you do that . Zillow. You need to see this. Show em the curve. Do you know what this means . The greater the curvature, the bigger the difference. [scifi tractor beam sound]. Sucked me right in. Its beautiful. Gotta admit one thing. Cant beat the view. Introducing the worlds first curved Ultra High Definition Television from samsung. Good to have you back with us on new day. Were getting word a 5yearold boy is monitored for ebola symptoms here in new york city. All of this has new york state adjusts mandatory 21 day quarantine. Four Health Care Workers returning from the ebola hot zone in west africa. New york allowing quarantines to be served at home. Is this all about Public Health or has it deteriorated into a political postering . Joining me political commentator and anchor. Good morning to you. Good morning. Im sure youre watching this with a keen eye. Youre a new yorker, concerned about Public Health here. Do you view all of this going on with governors of new jersey and new york being politically motivated . Always. Its not a bad thing. Theyre supposed to be responding to public, aware of what they want. They do indeed adjust positions in order to appeal to public. Big election coming up in new york next week. Its no secret Chris Christie wants to be considered for president. A lot going on. To that end, we know now theres the potential case in new york, a 5yearold boy returning with his family from guinea. Tested with a 103 degrees fever at bellevue now being monitored and observed. They havent tested him yet. Theyre going to go off on their checklist until they decide when theyre going to test. Makes you wonder, are you potentially going to see Governor Cuomo reverse decisions or pivot again . One would hope everybody would be most concerned about a 5yearold with a 103 temperature. Whether the flu or anything else, got to feel for the family and kid. I think what were going to find is the governor has acknowledged by actions he may have jumped out too quickly. He sat next to the governor of new jersey. They announced this quarantine. Absolutely no details that were included with it. It led to this nurse being basically imprisoned. Now legal issues are flowing from it. The governor of new york walked it back and said were not doing the tent thing. Were going to let people go to their homes, try to allow a protocol so they can be with families and not overreact. Clearly result of political pressure. The fact is, this is somewhat unchartered territory. Is there a case to be made for an overabundance of caution . There is and isnt. If you go back and look at what happened with the aids scare. It was an absolute panic in new york. Came through here in the 1980s. People had to invent protocols and figure what to do. The public played a big role. Gray and lesbian took the lead in preventing protocols, creating selfhelp and selfcare possibilities in the community that helped us through what was in the end a tragic time with a lot of lives lost. Theres absolutely no excuse to say we dont know. Lets do whatever we feel like or whatever the latest poll suggests would be popular. Thats what weve seen in texas. A little bit in new york and a lot in new jersey. New york is reasonably prepared. Weve seen for example a few weeks ago theyre sending actors to er units. There were drills being done, preparations. Weve had medical professionals here. It didnt catch them completely by surprise. Thats always going to be a debate. New york city has extraordinary resources. We have 11 public hospitals. Its unique in the city. I interviewed ron. He said we have a certain amount of swagger. Were ready for this. Mary basser spent 13 years Running Health systems in tanzania. She admitted yesterday its going to be a long fight. Why not give her a call . She was not contacted before the quarantines popped up in her backyards. Too many eyes on the midterm elections and not enough on whats happening here . Too many eyes on the midterm elections and 2016 elections. Too many eyes on trying to outmaneuver other people, whos in charge and who can show charge and leadership and not enough time doing what politics say theyre going to do. This fight is going to have to take place in africa. Weve got to get workers over there. The World Health Organization has said at the end of the year, if this isnt stepped, there could be 10,000 new cases per week. That will overwhelm everyones systems. Theres no quarantine anywhere in the world going to contain that. Great to have you as always. Thanks so much. Chris . Heres one you may not have heard of. Democrats say they have an amazing woman who could have president. The big question is, is she going to run . Im not talking about hillary. Im talking about senator Elizabeth Warren on the road in dema demand. We have an interview with the candid senator next. Its a must watch. Tum, tum tu. Smoothies only from tums. You know how fast you were going . About 55. Where you headed at such an appropriate speed . Across the country to enhance the nations most reliable 4g lte network. Hows it working for ya . Better than ever. Howd you do it . Added cell sites. Increased capacity. And your point is. So you can download music, games, and directions for the road when you need them. Whos this guy . Oh thats charlie. You ever put pepper spray on your burrito . I like it spicy but not like uggggh spicy. He always like this . You have no idea. At t. The nations most reliable 4g lte network. receptionist Gunderman Group is growing. Getting in a groove. Growth is gratifying. Goal is to grow. Gotta get greater growth. I just talked to ups. They got expert advise, special discounts, new technologies. Like smart pick ups. Theyll only show up when you print a label and its automatic. We save time and money. Time . Money . Time and money. Awesome. Awesome awesome awesome awesome all awesome i love logistics. Having a perfectly nice day, when out of nowhere a pickup truck slams into your brand new car. One second it wasnt there and the next second. Boom youve had your first accident. Now you have to make your first claim. So you talk to your Insurance Company and. Boom youre blindsided for a second time. They wont give you enough money to replace your brand new car. Dont those people know youre already shaken up . Liberty mutuals new car replacement will pay for the entire value of your car plus depreciation. Call and for drivers with accident forgiveness, Liberty Mutual wont raise your rates due to your first accident. Switch to Liberty Mutual insurance and you could save up to 423 dollars. Call Liberty Mutual for a free quote today at see Car Insurance in a whole new light. Liberty mutual insurance. Well, she said out right shes not interested this the white house in 2016. Thats not stopping massachusetts senator Elizabeth Warren from upping her National Profile ahead of midterms and help democrats keep the senate. Even with popularity, warren remains a renegade in her party. We spent time with warren on the campaign trail. She joins us. Hi. How you doing . Shes an interesting person Elizabeth Warren. Her latest Campaign Stop was this weekend for New Hampshire democratic senator. While everyone else is whispering about her future, warren made it clear to me for now shes just working on 2014, trying to keep democrats in control of the senate. But the more shes out there and out there a lot alisyn, the more speculation there is about 2016. Shes a democrat in demand on the campaign trail. Its about making sure nobody steals your purse on main street or pension on wall street. Thats what we believe. Rallying the party base in states where the president and his dismal Approval Rating are not welcome. As in colorado with endangered senator. You mark me all of us. Thats how were going to build the future. Warren is an unusual nomination. A soldier and inside agitator, a party star that takes on her own party. What democrats have to do is be willing to stand up and fight. I just think we could use a little more of that. We could use a little more of standing up and saying this is what its about. Im willing to do it. Shes willing all right. Always has been. Complicating her relationship with president obama whom she manages to praise just before slinging arrows his way. If president obama had not been in the white house, then we wouldnt have a Consumer Financial Protection Bureau today. This is an agency that has forced biggest banks in the country to return 4 billion directly to people they cheated. Thats been in just three years. I hear a but coming. Of course theres a but coming. Theres another half to this. They also chose an Economic Team. When the going got tough, the Economic Team chose wall street. They protected wall street over american families. Thats just something that i think is fundamentally wrong. Youve also said in the past that Hillary Clinton is somebody who has likewise protected wall street. Do you think shes still too close to wall street . I have said i worry about everyone who is too close to wall street. When i described what this race is about and its about who does government work for, i worry everywhere. Not exactly a ringing endorsement of clinton although warren encourages her to run. Today warren is all about selling her own populist message. On the road she comes a loud and clear. When conservatives talk about opportunity, they mean opportunity for rich to get richer and powerful to get more powerful. Shes become the liberals anti hillary. Planted his feet and stood firm. There are some who say you energize republicans as much as you do democrats because youre so left wing liberal, populist whoa, whoa. Wait, wait. I believe we should have a higher minimum wage. Because i believe women should have access to birth control. Because i believe the United States government should not be tens and billions off backs of kids on Student Loans because i believe Social Security shouldnt be private xizeded. Thats what im fighting for. Does that have appeal in a red state . You bet. It has an appeal anywhere there are working people. She says thats the winning democratic agenda for this year and beyond. You think if Hillary Clinton is a nominee, she can make that case . What i care about now is focus in 2014. This is the key election. 2014, right if in front of us. We shouldnt take our eye off the ball on that. I didnt get a yes or no to that. I want to be clear, this is about the 2014 race. She is determined not to look beyond. While her supporters want the 2016 door open, warren wants everyone to stop talking about it. Really, stop. Why not think about running . Im not running for president. I am not running for president. I am not running for president. But if hillary didnt run, you might give it a shot . I am not running for president. She is on the run. Off to minnesota. To her next state, 16 in all, campaigning for other democrats, at least for now. Interesting profile gloria. We understand on friday, both Elizabeth Warren and Hillary Clinton appeared at Campaign Event in massachusetts. Something unusual happened. It was a warm, public embrace from Hillary Clinton. The two women chatted backstage apparently about being grandmothers. Hillary went on stage, warm public embrace. Their relationships have been complicated as we pointed out in the piece. Elizabeth warren gave no such warm public embrace to hillary, just welcomed her. It was clear hillary was reaching out to her, talking about how important the things that Elizabeth Warren stands for are to the Democratic Party. Nothing like that from Elizabeth Warren which of course raises all red flags. Everybody whispering about, maybe Elizabeth Warren would take her on sooner rather than later. We dont know. Hard to read. Thanks so much. Sure. Hard unless you listen to her that says im not running. Sometimes the people asking the questions, not those answering it. She said it four times. Shell say it 50 more. Take a picture of this. Why so cute and cuddly . Theres a story to that. Its really about the watch on my wrist. Look at me. Hes cute and cuddly. I look scary. Itd be bigger. dad theres nothing i cant reach in my subaru. vo introducing the allnew subaru outback. Love. Its what makes a subaru,a subaru. Ugh. Heartburn. Did someone say burn . Try alka seltzer reliefchews. They work just as fast and are proven to taste better than tums smoothies assorted fruit. Mmm. Amazing. Yeah, i get that a lot. Alka seltzer heartburn reliefchews. Enjoy the relief. Time is on my side. Yes, it is. We often time for a good cause. This is mikes personal watch. I told him i liked hit when he was here earlier. He rolled eyes and gave it to me. I said listen mike, id rather give it away than wear it. Thats what we did. We put the watch up for sale. It goes for the mike rowe foundation. The winning bid 4,050. The winning bidder said she bought it for her 9yearold son. Thats good stuff. He gave it away for a better kauchltz he cause. He had been wearing that watch. Fantastic. I love that story. One for both wrists. Time for more news in the newsroom with carol costello. Thanks a lot. Have a great day. Newsroom starts now. Happening now in the newsroom, quarantine night. Shes contained to a tent, no shower, no flushable toilet. Is a 21 day quarantine breaking her Constitutional Rights . Plus heart break in washington. A teen injured in the shooting has died from her injuries. This as we hear tales of heroism. The teacher rushing the gunman in the