extra credit that it received from the italian government. and joining us now from frankfurt is yvonne back he's the head of the nominees commission that's an independent group which advises the german government on competition questions thank you very much for being with us today now and if council has put in for paul said on italia some say it's already been allowed to simply pick the best bits at the end do you agree with that assessment. your loved ones as taken part of the million but the twin cities that it's the largest ally and company in germany buying the second largest so there are a lot of competition issues arising saw what you mention is the best part they have to take as it only takes those parts where no competition issues come up well what advice did your panel give to the german government regarding the case and do you feel that they took your advice on board that it was a fair that is acting in