a clear message to the german industry in the context that the chemical giant buyer is about to strike a deal with monsanto which uses clive as it so it would be a huge market with a location in germany and obviously the conservatives in the acting government very keen not to miss that opportunity catherine as you point out germany voting in favor neighboring france against can we expect president mccall to accept this defeat. well the president the french president has a very clear position on glaive. they wanted really a ban on life aside and he already announced that he will try to get it down to three years and by the way in legal terms this is totally possible national a member states can restrict the use of twice as old if they want to only for their