Evan Peters' American Horror Story Characters Ranked Worst To Best Evan Peters' American Horror Story Characters Ranked Worst To Best By Tyler Pisapia/Feb. 24, 2021 1:42 pm EDT American Horror Story ( AHS) creator Ryan Murphy has his go-to list of favorite actors who often find their way into the tangled, sprawling narratives that make up his anthology series. Some are personal friends, others are Hollywood legends, and a select few are truly remarkable talents who help elevate the show by balancing its campy nature with the menacing subtlety that makes the horror genre great. Such is the case with Evan Peters. In 2011, he was a young actor with enough accomplishments at his back to know he would be successful, but he was still looking for his big break. Peters found his home on