Reply The Graeter's location on the corner of Green Bay Road and Gage Street was the top pick among more than half of respondents to an unscientific survey of Winnetka-Glencoe Patch readers. (Google Maps) WINNETKA, IL — The results are in from last week's poll of Winnetka-Glencoe Patch readers. Ahead of National Ice Cream Day, readers were asked to recommend the best ice cream shop in the area, and one local creamery came out on top as the undisputed favorite. Graeter's, which four years ago opened a Hubbard Woods location at 940 Green Bay Road, was recommended by more than half of the the dozens of respondents to the unscientific poll.