unusual they would go out over water, if you're routing particularly since when you look at the route, look where they were they would have been on a straight in to dusseldorf. that doesn't concern me i don't think that was necessarily an indication they had strayed from their flight path. >> we're getting a statement here now from airbus the makers of the a-320. that was involved in this crash. we know that the aircraft the specific one was 24 years old. the statement from airbus which is based in southwestern france near toulouse as david soucie was telling us the quote is we are aware of the media reports, all efforts are going towards assessing the situation. and you've been talking about the fact that this airline has a good safety record air bus, what is the safety record of airbus what can you tell us? >> it's good. typically speaking if you look for recent crash specifics, the