Will the Supreme Court Botch Trump's Immunity Case Too?
Special counsel Jack Smith has made it as easy as possible for the justices to rule against Trump. But we’ve seen this movie before.
Stay updated with breaking news from Impeachment Judgment. Get real-time updates on events, politics, business, and more. Visit us for reliable news and exclusive interviews.
Special counsel Jack Smith has made it as easy as possible for the justices to rule against Trump. But we’ve seen this movie before.
According to Vance, the key SCOTUS-aimed passage in the decision -- the one that straightens the arrow -- is this.
Interpretation of the impeachment judgment clause? that is, if he's correct, then that the impeachment judgment clause includes this impeachment first rule, then he wins? and if he's wrong, if we think the impeachment judgment clause does not contain impeachment first oral, then he loses? >> article one section three of the u.s. constitution says, judgment in cases of impeachment shall not extend further than to removal from office and disqualification to hold and enjoy any office of honor, trust, for profit under united states, but the party convicted shall nevertheless be liable and subject ...
Trump argument, comes down to nothing but the impeachment clause. let's listen to this. >> it just seems to me that if once you concede that presidents can be prosecuted under some circumstances, your separation of powers argument falls away, and the issues before us are narrowed to, are you correct in your interpretation of the impeachment judgment clause? does the impeachment judgment clause actually say what you say it says? that's all that we really need to decide. >> andrew, that's the whole case. >> absolutely. she was just laser focused. and to your point about why the defense lawyer is...
Job to hold trump accountable. that's what prosecutors and courts are for. >> president trump is still liable for everything he did while he was in office. didn't get away with anything, yet. we have a criminal justice system in this country. we have civil litigation. and former presidents are not immune from being accountable by either one. >> lisa rubin is a former litigator, known msnbc legal analyst. charles colbert prosecuted civil cases on behalf of -- the government. he's now a civil rights defense attorney. they both join me now, free to have you here. first, give me your first read on...