things. first of all he wants the united states to be able to outcompete the world on the wrong basis. we want to be able to compete by being able to outpollute everybody. the we want to be the most pollution as opposed to the best solutions. he is already- he is already wrong in terms how he wants us to show up. then endoesn't look at his own krep. look at california. california already has a more carbon constraint set of policies than anything in paris. andia is now the sixth largest economy in the world growing better than anything in the united states. look at your own country. where the economic performance? it's when you actually have strong environmental performance you're seeing strong economic performance. facts don't matter the country doesn't mar where the industries is don't matter growth is happening doesn't marry. you want to play the game of throwing something to the base. the base doesn't need sound bites they can't eat sound bites he the base needs jobs and the