path with syria and nicaragua, doesn't that make you feel great again? >> i want to bring in -- >> let me jump in on this, because i think what steven is saying is totally wrong and i think steven you're using old talk points. solar and wind are cheaper than coal and natural gas now, unsubsidized. from the lazar report in december, the fact that these countries want to have access to wind and solar as one option -- by the way india and china have cancelled their coal plants because coal is more expensive for their citizens than solar. let me just say, the president said this was an economic decision. there are 3.1 million people in america who are working in this clean energy industry. in pennsylvania, you had the mayor of pittsburgh on, in pennsylvania there are 57,000