business, jobs american kpee. he said it over and again today. he said the reason that the president has pulled out is because in deal has come at the expense of the american economy. >> there is absolutely no evidence of that. in fact the reverse is really true. there have been probably ten times the number of jobs maybe i think the number is actually like 8 times of number of jobs created in renewables compared to what's lost in the fossle fuel industry. >> michael bloom burm afternoon amanpour with the panel. governor grant whom we didn't speak to you. to you is it reasonable to ask the president whether or not he still believes climate change is a hoax. >> of course. you started out the show with the guy who co-authored the mit study that president trump cited incorrectly. and i just -- let me try out this metaphor and you anderson if you go to get a second opinion on a cancerous tumor you