your earlier point. let me ask this, because i know that some of the work has been on this, and i would be interested parly in a libb libertarian perspective around this. if the president is going to run on the the health of the economy and you have a republican party saying that the government cannot create jobs and only the private sector can create jobs s this fully a question for americans about tax policy or something that the president is meant to be doing despite the fact that government does not create jobs? this is a serious empirical and serious challenge for me. how do you make that claim? >> let me totally agree with you here. what is fascinating is that the president has continued to frame the jobs outlook as the understandably growth in private sector jobs. one reason that the african-american unemployment rate is so high because in a time of the 1950s and 1960s when it was hard for black people to break into the private sector