from political economy. the total retreat. you look at these ads, and they'll be and not about socialism, i saw rick scott try to get up and try to demagogue an inflation, i thought that's a sort of like endearingly old school normal politics. the cost of milk is, up and too much government money. i thought yeah that's fine you can make that argument. that's in the boundaries of normal politics right? there's no traction there, nothing, you can see that it does, nothing you can see that that's not with the based cares about. anything having to do with the broad spectrum, of the state, and the market, and all this stuff that used to make up, nothing, zero. nothing. >> that used to be the entire ball, game was arguments about the proper role of government. and should this to be done at the federal level. or perhaps would be better at the state. that's all gone now. it's now all about fermenting grievance, and the sense of vic defines a shun.