Transcripts For WHUT Worldfocus 20091126 : vimarsana.com
WHUT Worldfocus November 26, 2009
tonight on worldfocus israel s prime minister proposes a ten-month freeze on west bank settlement construction in an attempt to jump-start the mideast peace process. will it work? three days that shocked the world. mumbai, india, prepares to mark anniversary of the terror attacks that killed 166 people. tonight a new look at how the horror happened. cancer controversy. in britain, a drug that has shown promise for extending the lives of some cancer victims is deemed too costly and won t be covered by national insurance. so what are the dying to do? and it was once the diet for healthy living. now the famed mediterranean diet is dying, even in the mediterranean. tonight, a look at what s taking its place on the menu. from the world s leading reporters and analysts, here s what s happening from around the world. this is worldcus. major support has been provided by rosalind p. walter and the peter g. petern foundation, dedicated to promoting fiscal responsibility and addressing key economic challenges facing america s future. and additional funding is provided by the following supporters good evening. i m martin savidge. thank you for joining us. could this be the breakthrough in the middle east peace process that the americans have been waiting for? that s what some people are asking tonight following an announcement by israeli prime minister benjamin netanyahu that israel will freeze the building of settlements on the west bank for the next ten months. a move that was praised by the obama administration. the palestinians had demanded a moratorium on the construction of israeli settlements on the west bank as a precondition of peace talks. the obama administration, too, once backed that position, although it recently softened its stance on the issue. in making his announcement netanyahu says the freeze shows israel is very serious in its intention to advance peace. but there are conditions to the planned freeze, conditions that have already raised the ire of palestinian officials. netanyahu s settlement proposal only applies to new construction permits. the construction of some 3,000 homes already approved would not be affected. the freeze would also not apply to construion in arab east jerusalem, which palestinians would like to one day see as their capital. for more about prime minister netanyahu s proposal to freeze israeli settlements on the west bank, we re joined tonight by one of our rulars. he s ghassan shabaneh, a palestinian american who is a professor at marymount college here in new york. good to see you again. thank you. thank you for having me. what do you think prompted this proposal to come forward from the prime minister and why now? i believe pressure from washington and pressure from many european countries. wherever the prime minister goes, he hears that settlements ought to stop or ought to be frozen for the palestinians to come back to the negotiation table. so the palestinians are now winning diplomatically around the globe because everyone is basically asking what they are desiring. do you ths was possibly an effort on the part of the israelis to prop up palestinian lead mahmoud abbas? because abbas has threatened to resign due to lack of progress. i believe if that was the intention, i believe they have failed miserably in doing that. why? because if east jerusalem is not included into this deal, president abbas cannot come back to the negotiation table because east jerusalem is a core issue for not only the palestinians but also for arabs around the globe. anything that basically pushes east jerusalem out of the picture is unacceptable and short of where the palesnians would like to see a future state cong. so freezing settlements on the west bank alone is not enough for the palestinians? is not enough. and also it is in direct contradiction with the road map where it stated very clearly in two or three to push the peace process forwarhe stated or he issued the road map where it s stated very clearly that the palestinians and the israelis each has to take steps. one of the steps that the israelis were asked to take was to freeze settlements, natural growth and east jerusalem was included. if east jerusalem is not included in this freeze, that is also a violation of the road map, which is an american-framed road map. that is why you think the palestinians were so quick to respond in a negative way to this? he responded to this proposal by saying he would not accept it. i believe that president abbas would do the same and the majority of the palestinian people would do the same because it falls short of the desired future palestinian state. east jerusalem in 1967 was 60 square kilometers. now east jerusalem is 72 square kilo and this huge explosion of size of east jerusalem all added settlements to the regular or natural size of east jerusalem. so the palestinians really have a lot of difficulty in absorbing what the israelis are doing at this stage. so what happens next? if the israelis will not compromise on east jerusalem, i believe psident abbas will resign. and if abbas resigns, we ll see more chaos in the region, and i don t see that any palestinian leader in the near future is capable of sitting with the israelis and doing the compromise that the old guards have been able to do, which is arafat and abbas. ghassan shabaneh. thank you very much. thank you. president obama held the first state dinner of his administration last night. the event was in honor of indian prime minister manmohan singh and was widely viewed as an effort to patch up rocky relations with that country. however, it was michelle obama and her gold strapless dress that were the talk of the town. the dress was a little bit of its own diplomacy, made by the indian-born designer naeem khan. known for dressing some of hollywood s most glamorous women. and in another nod to india, the first lady sported a collection of traditional indian bangles on her left arm. tomorrow the residents of mumbai, india, will observe a sad anniversary. it will be one year since a group of terrorists went on a city-wide killing spree there which left 166 people dead. the terrorist plot was long believed to have been hatched in pakistan. and today, pakistani officials charged seven men in pakistan with planning that attack. dan nolan of al jazeera english remembers the day in the following report, which includes surveillance camera video of the early moments of the attack. reporter: it was three days of violence that engulfed india s most populous city and gripped the attention of the world. only recently released to the public, this security camera vision shows the horrifying reality of just one chapter of the mumbai attacks. 31 of the 166 people victims died here at the luxury taj mahal hotel. the video shows gunmen going room to room, kicking in doors, looking for hostages. while also discussing how to light the fires that raged while the world s media watched from outside. the mumbai attacks began around sunset on november 26th, when ten gunmen landed in inflatable boats. it took little more than an hour for them to fan across the city, plunging it into chaos. [ sirens ] their targets included a jewish outreach center at nariman house. popular tourist spot, leopold s cafe. the luxury hotels, the taj mahal and the oberoi trident across the peninsula, the cama hospital and thehatrapati shivaji railway station. armed with automatic rifles and grenades, the gunmen fired indiscriminately along the way, setting off bombs and holding hostages for up to 60 hours. commandos smoked out the last gunman on november 28th, freeing some of the hostages, while others died in the final gun battle. the incident frayed already tense ties between nuclear-armed neighbors india and pakistan. pakistan has acknowledged that the mumbai attacks were plotted and partly launched from its soil and has put seven suspects on trial. ajmal kasab is the only gunman to have been captured alive. charged with waging war against india, his trial is under way in mumbai and could end in a death sentence. while indians await the results, many still question how such a shocking and large scale attack could have ever been allowed to happen in the first place. dan nolan, al jazeera. by the way, pbs commemorates the first anniversary of the mumbai attacks with this week s broadcast of secrets of the dead. the program is a unique look inside the attacks featuring closed circuit footage and firsthand accounts from survivors, some of whom came face-to-face with the killers. here s an excerpt. at first we laughed. you know, we thought, oh, it s a i don t know, it s an argument or something. then when it kept going, it sort of got more and more chilling. and before we knew it, gunshot had just erupted, automatic weapon fire through the front door of where we were. if they would just turn and glance over their shoulder, they would have seen my whole crew standing there around the coffee table absolutely point blank. they just backed off and went into the next restaurant. we could hear them sort of spread out on that first floor. this restaurant manager had worked at the taj since he was 17. he knew a quick way out. at that point of time, i just kicked open the door. the door broke, and then i got up, i came back. i fell down on the steps out of the restaurant. let me be honest, i opened the door and fell out, i did take off and run. instead ahmad returned to the hotel. i just wouldn t have left my guests. on the other side of the peninsula, another attack on a major hotel. the five-star trident oberoi. from up in the rooms, it sounded like someone was setting off firecrackers in the lobby. at that point, i saw two guards with machine guns and backpacks walking through the lobby. then i saw them disappear into the lobby cafe. and immediately, the moment i saw lost sight of them, i heard probably 30 or 40 rounds of gunfire. we n into the kitchen, and we hid behind the counter in the kitchen. we were just crouched down behind this counter and just sort of looking at the door. you know, things change significantly when the door opened and the gunman actually came in. i started getting dressed. got my safe open, got my passport out, got my wallet and my mobile phone and got ready to really take some steps. i really didn t know what they were. and then my mobile phone rang, and it was my colleague drew. i said, look, just stay there. i ll try and get down to you. and we ll get through this thing together. by the time drew arrived, debra s room, like the rest of the hotel, was filling with smoke. so we read the evacuation plan, and there was an exit stairwell not too far from my room. so i picked up my room key and we made our way along the corridor to the stairs. the power of a gun is something i had never imagined. he didn t each have to say anything. he just gestured for us to move to the back of the kitchen where there was a door that we found out failed the fire test. the gunmen were marching their hostages up the same smoky stairs that drew dixon and debra baine were blindly making their way down. that s secrets of the dead. to find out where it airs in your town, go to pbs.org/secrets, or check your local listings. today in saudi arabia, muslims from around the world gathered in preparation for the annual hajj pilgrimage between mecca and medinah. it begins tomorrow. the hajj is the most sacred rite in islam and is required by all able-bodied muslims at least once in their life. it is expected to attract 3 million muslims from 160 countries. this year with concerns running high over swine flu, many were seen wearing masks. there were new swine flu fears coming out of china today. chinese officials say they ve detected eight cases of a mutated form of the swine flu. scientists have long worried that the h1n1 virus could mutate to a more dangerous form. chinese officials did not say whether the new form was linked to any deaths in their country, but the world health organization is looking into two deaths in norway it believes might have been caused by a mutated form of swine flu. in other health news, a controversy is brewing in britain. that country s national health service has decided it will not pay for a popular drug used to treat bowel, or, as we call it, colon cancer. it says the drug is not, quote, cost effective. the drug avastin can extend the life of colon cancer patients by a few months, but it s not a cure for the often fatal disease. that decision has patient groups up in arms who believe cost should not be an issue. jenny wivell of itn reports. reporter: avast could extend the lives of around 6,000 people, but it s been rejected as a treatment for bowel cancer by n.i.c.e., the national institute for clinical excellence, on monetary grounds. if approved it would cost the nhs between £6 million and 12 million a year. although it s not cure, it can extend life by several months. extension of life is very important because there s nothing more precious than that. so we re always calling on n.i.c.e. and the government to look at it in those terms and think about it how it would be if it was you and you were only given a few weeks to live and you were given an extra lease on life to spend christmas with your family this time of year. reporter: avastin works by attacking the blood cells around a tumor and helping to starve it. when combined with chemotherapy, it has been shown to shrink 78% of cancers, sometimes enough to allow surgeons to operate. no one was available for interview from n.i.c.e., but in a statement it says that although it recognizes there are some benefits to avastin, the high cost of bevacizumab, avastin, relative to the benefits it brings means that it is not a cost effective use of nhs resources for the treatment of metastatic colorectal cancer. britain is one of only five european countries not to offer avastin on its health service. it is available in 33 other countrs around the world, including australia and canada. jenny wivell of itn. just how much medical care should be made available to patients at the end of their lives? for more on that debate we re joined by henry aaron, a senior fellow and noted health care expert from the brookings institution in washington, d.c. welcome to worldfocus. thank you. we just saw a report about how the british health care system will no longer provide an expensive cancer medication to patients deemed to be near death. are such decisions likely to become more commonplace here? not any time soon. the brits spend about 40% as much as we do on health care. the sorts of decisions we need to confront are what methods of care work best, not which methods to deny people altogether. just how much money is spent on providing health care to patients, say, in the last months of their lives? that s a hard question to answer because the objective of medical care is to prevent those months from being the last months. all of those who survive by definition are not in the last months of their lives. that said, we spend billions and billions of dollars of care on patients who are palpably and obviously very near to death. some of that care is probably are probably services those people would have chosen not to have had had they had an opportunity to discuss what the options would be in the event that we all will face of terminal illness. is trying to limit the amount of money spent on terminally ill patients really an appropriate way to try to bring down the cost of health care? i don t think the objective should be to try to spend less money, per se, on the terminally ill. the objective that we should face in the united states is how to provide information to individuals and physicians so that they can make fully informed decisions about the kinds of care that they want to have. a system such as great britain s where expenditures are a small fraction of what we spend here need to face those kinds of questions. we are light-years away from having to confront that sort of question here in the united states. we only have a few seconds left, but there s more to this than just economics. there s a moral debate aspect, isn t there? yes. very much so. we re all going to die at some point. we want to have our treatment at such times be consistent with our values, our comfort. we want to spend time with our families and friends. medical care should facilitate that, not stand in the way of it. henry aaron, thank you very much for being on the program. thank you very much for having me. now, let s get your thoughts, because brings us to tonight s how you see it question. in an effort to bring down health care costs, should the u.s. government limit payment for cancer-fighting drugs that only extend life by a few months? you can tell us what you think by going to our how you see it section of our website, and that s at worldfocus.org. finally, it s time for tonight s signature story. on this thanksgiving eve, we wanted to bring you some food for thought. it s a story about how in one country bad food and big portions are creating an epidemic of obesity. and we re not talking about the united states. it s happening in, of all aces, greece, the birthplace of the superhealthy mediterranean diet. now a government campaign is urging greeks to get back in the kitchen and back to their roots. worldfocus special correspondent lynn sherr recently traveled to the greek island of crete for a taste of the good life. reporter: in western crete, this harbors rich traditions, history that stretches from minoan palaces to venetian forts. rugged mountains cascade to an endless sea. and mountains of food. this island, smack in the middle of the mediterranean sea, is also the home of the mediterranean dietlong recognized as one of the most healthful on the planet. based on fresh vegetables, whole grains and olive oil. lots and lots of olive oil. in this land of the olive tree, the heart-friendly nectar of the gnarled groves infuses every meal. a monosaturated fat that lowers so-called bad cholesterol. it is, these local residents assured me, a time tested recipe for life. it is statistically proved that we live longer. my grandmother died 96. my grandfather 97. my other grandmother 90. reporter: but centuries of healthy eating and living here in crete are now threatened by a new reality. and it s one with grave consequences for this nation known in ancient times as a model of moderation. greeks are getting fat and fatter. so much that in a recent world health organization obesity study, greek men were ranked first among european union nations. greek women came in third. experts say the biggest weight gain was among young people. some 10% of them are overweight. more than half of that number are considered obese.
Related Keywords
Norway, New York, United States, Jerusalem, Israel General, Israel, West Bank, Canada, Australia, China, Washington, District Of Columbia, Pakistan, United Kingdom, India, Mumbai, Maharashtra, Marymount College, California, Hollywood, Saudi Arabia, Mecca, Makkah, Mediterranean Sea, Oceans General, Oceans, Greece, Taj Mahal, Punjab, Britain, Americans, America, Israelis, Chinese, Greeks, British, Israeli, Palestinian, Greek, American, Pakistani, Mahmoud Abbas, Henry Aaron, Dan Nolan, Debra Baine, Manmohan Singh, Naeem Khan, Michelle Obama, Rosalind P Walter, Ajmal Kasab, Benjamin Netanyahu,