Transcripts For CSPAN Q A 20090706 : vimarsana.com

the first months of the obama presidency. . . i wrote an essay about three years ago at my time at princeton. we are not very honest in this country at fault when students are shipped off to the wonderful fairy land called college. i had a real hard time with it. i was lost in many ways and what i thought about what the system was that had lost me. it was this the advancement model that underlies the american education. if you are six previous books had been fiction. this is non-fiction. why? i have noticed in some of the reviews that they find some of the stories that i tell him plausible. that is unfortunate, because the book does happen to be all true unlike all other unlike other memoirs that have come out recently. this is about a real place, princeton university. it really experience it, might education. i did not know that it would have much relevance to people unless they were assured that it actually happened. if you say up front that this is a work of memory concerning events from more than 25 years ago. it tends to be truthful in its narrative. there are, i suspect, a number of inaccuracies. a number of people s identities had been changed in disguise. and will admiral. uncle admiral. key was a retired admiral whose job had been to survey the coast of alaska and southern california. she at four-years old babysit me constantly when my mother was in school and my mother was and my father was in school. he ab set me constantly when my father was in school. i think it was the last time i truly learned, until like that at a princeton. i suspect someone might question how do you remember quotes from that admiral. do you remember before-years old? well, when you write a book is non-fiction. when you put in story form, recalling conversations and events that you do not recall photographically, you reconstruct them as best as you can, giving your memory of house people spoke and how certain spots of time which work especially vivid. and there is no pre-tenths to anything being tape-recorded, but these are the interactions that i remember. there are no pretense to anything being tape-recorder. the iraqis said that he knew great riding when debt theod ore retky, the poet, said he knew a great riding when he the hair on his back stood up. i know it when i see it. who is the finest writer you have ever known? personally? yes. personally, the finest writer i was ever given the chance to meet was the great, the legendary argentinian master novelist and short story writer. i met him at oxford after i went to princeton. i met day becket to. i met daniel beckett, too. the finest writer now that i have met is robert stone. he is someone i admire a great deal. what is it that, when do you conclude that they are great writers? i conclude they are great writers when they leave me to make associations, connections, leaps in my mind that i do not feel i could have made otherwise. which once i made an they felt inevitable somehow. who do you think rates today in this society, could, non- fiction political writing? i am a fan of a lot of writers. i let christopher hichens. i love christopher hichens. it is not important for me to agree with political writers, it is important for me to carry along with their argument so i can entertain their points at youthfully. other political writers? there are people at the atlantic like james fallin. as far as columnists type writers, i like frank rich. it is hard to go through it all. to go where do you lived in rye? i ve lived in livingston, montana. i live in the livingston, montana. i live in a loft. i do almost all of my riding there. i found it necessary at an early stage in my career, about 20 years ago, to remove myself from metropolitan life in order to observe america, and i think it is serving meat great. through the years i have worked through times of magazines and they were always willing to feed me everything west of the hudson river and east of los angeles. it has worked out. let s go quickly to the places where you have lived. i was born in akron, ohio. i grew up in a little town in minnesota. from there i went to princeton university. this is the subject of this book. princeton could not have been more different from minnesota. i went to oxford university on scholarship. i lived in london for a year. came back to new york city and worked for a magazine. one day on an assignment in montana, i saw my opportunity. you can imagine what the end of the world has an effect on real- estate prices. houses were very cheap in livingston, montana, and this was a big call. i got a price at a fire sale price. what year was that? 1990. i was covering a call called the church universal and triumphant. at that time it was about 300,000 strong. people were literally selling their house is in preparation for going underground and writing out a nuclear holocaust. and riding out a nuclear holocaust. so you got a good deal? i got a good deal. this is no aspin. it is a rare road town. a lot of hit the, intellectual artist settled their hippie, intellectual artists settled there. through the years it has attracted several movie stars. tom brokaw has a ranch nearby. jeff bridges, michael keaton. they do not affect the society of the town, because like a lot of places out west, they come in on their private jets, take a car to their splendid ranch, and get out. that is not true of brokaw. he mixes and ankles, but some other folks you will never see their face. he mixes and mingles. your ex-wife was of margaow kiddo s ex-wife? daughter? i had known the novelist for many years. we have two kids. we are now divorced. where are they now? they are in livingston. they live in livingston. charlie is in the hospital for having broken arm. i feel sad for him. go back to the story of your father, and being kind of lost. and where you lived in where you went and what it was like. my father ended up going to princeton, but afterward and before she was not what you might call princeton material. he he wawas not what you migt call princeton material. he did not know the difference between princeton material and non-princeton material. they gave him the best deal. he studied something practical in case his athletic career did not work out. people go to princeton on athletic scholarships and do not end up playing pro. after he left, he moved to washington and became a patent attorney. we added some how badly to corporate life and his ivy league education, such that he moved our family to a tiny little farm, not on the outskirts of the city but will be on the outskirts where we armed with horses and i went to a public school, with no real idea of at the places that he had been or the kind of places that i was going to end up. how did the mormon is some mormonism king come into your life? when i was 12-years old my father went to a difficult thing, the loss of his father, and a job loss. living where? phoenix, ariz., of all places. we let the midwest in a career. the family when desert the family was under great stress. the mormon missionaries came to the door and knocked and they had a rare success with a converted a family in not too many weeks. i became a mormon as a teenager. for how long? until i was 17. and as five years, how did it change your life? in several ways. being a mormon in the midwest where they were not a majority religion gave me a real feeling of being an outsider. you know, mormonism demonstrated in the last election is still a religion looked upon somewhat dubiously by mainstream society. it gave me a feeling of being marginalized and outside the mainstream. it also allowed me, because there is no paid clergy, to do a lot of public speaking and sunday meetings. i think that experience allowed me to hone a grimness that serve me increased at a site attentive to get into princeton and then survive princeton. what does it look like inside the mormon church looking out, versus those who have not been inside it? what goes on in a mormon church that we do not see when you are not a member? the churches themselves are open to the public. it is the temples that are not. really what goes on are lessons on the book of mormon and the various mormon scriptures, which the everyday person would have very little understanding of. moral expectations of a very typical kind. what is important to realize is that mormonism is not the same as evangelical christianity. there is a totally different history. it is still attempting to win at mainstream respectability. the mormons really really great radicals when they started out because of their pro- abolitionist use and other radical opinions at the time they were moved from place to place when they ended up in the desert in salt lake, city. they have tried to come back and close themselves and establish, and no one looks more establishment garbage then it romney. they still cannot track crack the mainstream barriers against them. why did you leave them? morning males are expected to go on missions at that age and as in july anti evangelize. and evangelize? . where did religion take you for the rest of your life? i can confess without any apology to be a religious person, probably a christian to some description. it took me to the place where you remain a permanent skepticism of a rationalism, but cannot be completely compelled by the claims of dr. and either. i guess i exist in a kind of netherworld of belief and nothing a belief in something, but a disbelief in secular values. what hours of the day you find yourself there? all hours. it is my privilege to command my own space and have no nabors so that i can work it is my privilege to command my own space and have no neighbors. i do depend a little bit on the spirits for inspiration that it can take me at any time. when would we normally see do working? you can reliably see me working at 2:00 a.m. you can sometimes see me working at 2:00 p.m. when you are writing, what kind of materials do you use? a computer? i used legal pads. i was an attorney and i find that it frees me in no way that a computer does not. also, for a constant self editing that i do not think is conducive to free thought is on the computer. once i have finished eighth three drafts on the legal pad, i move it to the computer to straighten it out. do you put your own words on the computer? i do it with my own fingers. to cook this book was written in livingston, montana? it was finished at the university of chicago last fall. i taught and a fellowship at the university of chicago. i taught a non-fiction writing seminar. the very last part of it was written in an academic setting. having not taught in my life, had not been an academic setting since princeton, so that made for an odd day job as a finished the book. you said in your book that you did not think you were a very good teacher. i do not know that i am a good teacher, chiefly because i do not believe in those things that are crucial to good writing can really be taught. you know, knock on collateral has a book at about how people succeed. malcolm gladwell has a book out about how to succeed. as a teacher, all i do is they do not give up and try to expose them to good examples. how many students in your seminar? 12. ok, i am in your seminar right now and i have been writing a lot. i say to you, walter kirn, give me three things that you know about writing that might help me do a better job on non-fiction writing. what would you say? number one, i would tell you that the most important act is to establish short as 42 rights in the first place. #one, i would tell you that the most important act is for you to establish a voice in the first place. you need to establish or intimacy with the subject. where did you do that in this book? i think i do that in this book by saying in the very first pages of it, might authority is that of a bewildered young man who ends up at princeton. it is written all over the book that i actually attended princeton, so i have the authority to speak of it, but i have the authority to speak of it as an outsider, by having come from a very small town. i conjure up a life in a small town before i take you to oz. how much of this paragraph that i am about to read is part of establishing authority? it is to the humane and dedicated educators who helped me find my way when i could barely see the path. the first name on there is joyce carol oates. those are some big names. yes, some of them are. it is my lot in life that these groups of people that were very helpful to me in a difficult time should include such wonderful thing occurs, educators, and writers. education to me is often presented as the system, a set of schools and institutions. what it really comes down is to a set of contacts with individual teachers. i had a great teacher at the very beginning of my life, uncle admiral. the book is about the system itself. these people actually, to me, were the exceptions that proves the rule. they picked me at that very difficult times, because the machine or the system itself was very hard on me. why neil rudenstein? k.i.a. appeared at of know where one day. he taught me on my shoulder at the end of my senior year when i had no idea where i was going in took me out to lunch, and said we have nominated you for the scholarship. it is a very discreet scholarship to oxford. i have no idea how that process had occurred, what they had picked me, but it really saved me. was this after you have lost the rhodes scholarship? after. losing that rhodes scholarship contest had what kind of an impact on you? well, i was the kind of kid who went from competition to competition, a blue ribbon to blue ribbon, a trophy to a trophy, thinking it was going to be a yellow brick road ending in the stars. the rhodes scholarship was the first tournament of merit that i resoundingly failed at. i thought, i have come up again something i cannot do. i did not enter the next round and i was bewildered. why did you mentione joyce carol oates? i took an academic class with her. she was also a great friend. she used to have any bartend at her house when she threw a party. it was by letting me into her home and showing me her office and showing me the books on herself, that i thought this is a job done by people, not by people in the sky. that trust and simple friendship boosted my morale hugely. how about james region 6? james richardson? key west might created adviser. i decided i wanted to be a public. he was a creative adviser. i had no ideas, nor did i had any interest in political advisement. he was my thesis adviser. we will talk about romantic poetry. it was this confidence in me, confidence that i did that and myself that made him valuable. you mentioned smoking cigarettes, and it brings to light when i read in your book. there is a lot of reference to taking drugs. are you a drug user? i would not say big user because that took money and i never had any. there were a lot of drugs floating around princeton university in 1980. where they floated, i often floated with them. what kind of a drug s? marijuana,lsd. it was almost like 1980 s was the end of the 1960 s. people listen to the grateful dead. it was a hippie culture. that was the drug use that i was exposed to. how extensive was it? fairly extensive. this has come out of little bit with sonya sotomayor. that place had only recently admitted women. i happen to know about the history of ivy league submission and had only started letting in students that were not born into at about 15 years ago. we had a college and campus that was still dominated by what you might call the blue-blood, upper-class america. into it were coming people were coming in who had done very well on tests and had different ethnic backgrounds. there was a lot of alienation at princeton. when there is unhappiness there is a lot of drug usage. did you ever get caught using drugs? no. then again, princeton was a very large late unpoliced island. princeton was a very large, and policed by land. unpoliced island. they brought all these kids in and let us lose. i was not aware of supervision, even from a far. did you win this? i did win the case before the ship. kasbee fellowship. it was a very of the other ship. very odd fellowship. when i got to the interviews that were held in a law firm in philadelphia, there was a different kind of merit. it was the young gentleman. they ask me, did i like to take walks? i said yes. they asked me if i had gotten d s on my spanish tests. i said yes because i was strong. they all laughed. i said yes because i was drunk. i sit the bill because i was an incredible young man. who made the decision? it was only open to students who had gone to a few, select universities. each of these universities selected a few candidates. they selected me and a quarterback of the football team to be nominees for this. i never thought that i would peak at the quarterback of the football team, but that is what happens. let me go back and reconstruct dates. the year you graduated from high school? i did not graduate from high school. i took the s.a.t. test and was offered because of the high score an immediate admission to st. paul. i transferred to princeton in 1980. how close to 1600 did you get? this is an honest answer. my editor enemy over and over to finite s.a.t. results and some help put them in the front of the rboook. and then put them in the front of the book. i could not find them, but i think it was around 15. when you ended up at princeton how old were you? i was 18. i went to mcallister barely 17. what year were you in princeton? i was a sophomore. they asked me to start again as a freshman, and i said i would rather not go if i had to be pushed back a year. they relented. what year did you graduate from princeton? 1983. what year did you have the fellowship? 1985. your first full-time job? my first full-time job was a teacher of english as a second language at a low-class, business school in the old times square in new york where for $10 an hour i helped ever wonder i helped everyone learn english. at princeton classmate solly living hand to mouth in new york city a year later and she worked at a magazine and said what are you doing? you are worth so much more than this. come on over to the vanity fair and we will give you a job. she did. what did you do there? bragh bagels and coffee to the superior editors, and brought headlines for stories. when did you first really bright for a living? > when did you first really write for a living? i interviewed for the bbc radio back in england. in new york i interviewed american book editors. i interviewed a man who main raymond carver a great name. he said at the end of the interview must have a great short story or book. i did not that i set a course. i went back and wrote a story. i wrote a short story and and about a week i brought it later brought it back and he liked it. i said can i have a contract? he said you have a contract. i wrote my first book of short stories. kept at it. what did you get paid? $3,000. all politics is local, and that does for us here. we were first introduced to you by someone i had never heard of you in my life. actually the producer of the showed a drop this magazine article on my desk, and she was someone incensed by what she read. i had a different reaction, but i want to read it back to you. i remember writing it and i remember the sentiments, but i do not remember the sentences. i want you to tell me where you think the world has gone. the headline is ram tv. it television is a plug in drug, then c-span is the antidote the network to watch when you want to come down. the programs are shot in color, but might as well be in black and white. there are no commercials. the almost total lack of editing and super sluggish camerawork create a world as flat and in art as a mid-level bureaucrats desktop. this sets, and sets argues, arnon sets. are nonsets. the polyester hosts make brokaw seemed like flynn. and the classical music played during breaks reminds you of this entire entitled cassettes tapes. what comes around goes around. exactly. what got you there? i turned on c-span my job was to comment on the media in a monthly fashion for this magazine. it is now a dead and gone fashion magazine. i turned on c-span i turned and cable television and as i ran through the channel there was only one which visually did not resemble the others, and that was c-span. it went slow. they spoke loudly, it spoke softly. it fascinated me. it was like coming across a buddhist at a holy-roller church service. here was c-span sitting quietly, deliberately, doing its own thing in the middle of cable television. it was fascinating. you also wrote, for everyone besides the target audience of policy nerds in traction patients, the result was like watching the watergate hearings- the scandal that made them interesting. it was a dead some on the dial. i am referring to congress. i understand. i do not know that before c- span had regular televised exposure to our legislative and collaborative processes. once we did, i think we found they are both less dramatic than we might imagine. i could not believe however day the chambers of congress usually are, for example. the reason i bring it up is to ask you it is always fun to hear feedback. you were watching this from livingston at the time? yes. what has happened to television since 1992 in your opinion? one of the things that happened is that c-span has evolved in a way that i think is sincere. it is a tribute to its mission. a lot of things have come and gone, but these programs and these camera angles and the settings that would not have appeared to be likely to hold the nation s attention have gone on and on. a lot has happened. we are not the network that makes money, and we do not have to deliver oddballs to advertisers. eyeball tls to advertisers. it has grown progressively less serious, less nourishing intellectually. it has grown in a linear fashion more superficial. it really does not take a genius to identify the trajectory of american television, which is you are somewhat more realistic straight down. i never thought that i would watch network news or serious cable newscasts and see 75% of them are taken up with britney spears mothering or a woman who had eight kids and whether or not she is a good person when a writer said that visionary, satire news she had no ideas that he would be raised and double raised 5 reality. that is exactly what has happened. if you have written six of fiction books. yes. give me a sentence on each one of them so we have an idea of what they were about. the unbinding is about the way in which the internet, things like facebook, myspace.com wet weather, have separated people and their identities. the unbinding is about the way in which the internet, things like facebook, myspace, and twitter have confuse our social relationships. this is about a religious cult. it manifest many at the ideals of america, which i pretend has survived unscathed in the mountains of montana. then we send out missionaries to look at the america of 2005. any religion in mind? it was christian science, mormonism. they are appalled by how poorly we eat. the book called up in the air. it will be in a movie this fall costarring george clooney. this specializes in firing people in the corporate world. he has only one preoccupation, which is collecting frequent flyer miles. where did you get that idea? i met a guy on a plane and i asked him where he was from. he said this seat. i said what do you mean? he said i am from seat 3. he said i stay in hotels for eight months at a time. all of my stuff is in storage. i live in airplanes and mary its. did you get a license nice, long conversation before it was over? yes. i met a guy who i think it exemplifies a lot of the trends of the times of the disconnected motion. had you ever seen him again? does he know you read a book about him? no. thumbsucker. this is about growing up in the 1980 s. i had a terrible, unbreakable than sucking have it. it caused me great emotional pain. it is a true story of a boy like that in the 1980 s in minnesota. how long did you suck your thumb? until i was 17 years old. how did you break it? a general shame and modification over the thought of girls i liked seeing me do it. and sucking in the book is a metaphor for all kinds of things that make us feel different or outside. i had a lot of day fans gay fans who thought it was a metaphor for being gay. just checking on a couple of things. mom and dad, are they still a lot? they are both still alive. mom is in the town i grew up in in minnesota. >dass lives near where i live. he retired to a place in the montana mountains. my dad lives in near where i live. i use my life quite frankly, even in my fiction and here in my 9-fiction, i had used it literally. how old are your parents? my dad is 70 and my mom is 69. r.v. still working? my dad is retired. my mom, who was a nurse in minnesota, is retired, to. the next novel is shee needed me. that is about abortion. is this about the time you are trashing c-span? i think i turned it around. it was a very senior humorous page. at least i spelled your name right. this was an anti-abortion community. it was about a right to life young man trying to convince a young woman not to have an abortion. it would now be about the culture wars. this was the first book. the theme was mormonism, this crisis in rural life. all really sexy topics guaranteed to draw thousands of books. which one of all of these was the biggest seller? i think up in the air. it was really a book that was trying to grapple with a society that was starting to become witinfatuated with mobile phones and technology. it was set in airplanes and had the misfortune of being published about two months before 9/11 happened. it did very well until 9/11. it covers it s cover shows a bunch of men flying an airplane and crashing. it did not sit well, given what happened. it crashed, too. going back to your mom. well-known drug treatment center that she worked at. any irony of that your drug use, and how did your mom deal with it? did she even know you were using drugs? i was away at princeton. she had no idea. there is irony. there is even greater irony by the fact that i was born in a hospital where alcoholics anonymous was born. i guess it shows that anything can happen to anyone, anywhere. plenty of i.n.d.. in your book, you also have a couple of minutes of threats up front where you a couple of people. the first one is john ashbery. what is this? it is a poem. i tell myself it all seems like fun and will work out in the end. i expect i will be asked a question i can answer and then be handed a big prize. that to me that quote to me manifest a thought which i always had as a young student, at the end of this kidding golden stars getting golden stars, but there was going to be a celebration of walter kirn. i had the generic need for approval. that little expert excerpt speaks to that. were you an only child? i had a brother. he works as a paralegal for a financial firm. you quote . f. scott fitzgerald. i see now that this has been a story of the west. f. scott fitzgerald lived peake in a house not far from mcallister college. lived in a house not far from mcallister college. i was very aware of him. we had these great identities. in an attempt to fit in in the american classis, that was up corporate to my book because my experience in going to princeton was similarly disastrous and ran along similar themes. i wanted desperately to be accepted by what i perceive to be for the first time a real american hierarchy and establishment to which i did not have the keys, and two s acceptance i craved, but whose presence and power i also presented, and that made for a very difficult psychological state while i was at princeton. it was about learning the american the layout of the american land socially. what is the feel you have when you are on the campus? princeton is an island of squirrels and overly manicured grass. it is in suburban new jersey. it is a a society unto itself. it is not like yale or harvard. it is a kind of a monastic institutions where students live at an allegedly idealistic existence. they lounge around and drink on the weekends and party, growing into what princeton thinks of as a well-grounded american comers. they tend to go out into finance, government, business, and so on. princeton is a small campus for the ivy league s. it does not have big graduate schools, law schools. it is chiefly an undergraduate institution. it is a place where you are supposed to be happy all the time and go to football games. and you are supposed to shut up if you are not happy. i could not shut up for my whole life, but i had to at the time. what did your education cost to? it is hard to say. i had a national merit scholarship. there was some other loans and so on, but my parents paid for a lot of it. i think at the time it was 20,000 something per year. i have no idea what it cost now. i have become an advocate on this subject. i cannot understand with these these places with the endowment s should be so expensive and so influence still. i think princeton s whole philosophy schedules should be on the web. i think these islands of talent and well should be opened up to the larger society, and not kept separate, which they still are, and i cannot understand why. i want to redo a paragraph from your book. read you put a paragraph from your book. put i grew to suspect that certain professors or onto less, and i wondered if they, too, were fakes. i felt these teachers were unsuited to the new attitude of an attntic thinking. i knew little of that great literature and had every reason to agree with them. in the land of non readability, and on reader was king, it seems. break that paragraph down. when i was at princeton, the art study was something called deconstruction is some deconstructionism, which taught that words and great masterpieces of writing were released were really these instruments of their ruling class of men to keep people in all of traditional institutions, women subjugated by men, and their content, they re supposed , but had been alleged to be their greatness, was really dubious and something to be resisted. here i was coming from a little public school in minnesota thinking i was going to come read the classics, and i got there only to find out that the classics were unjustly a revered and positively malignant in some political sense some people felt. so, you know, i guess somewhere in the book i went straight from ignorance to revisionism. what kind of a breakdown did you really have? i had a breakdown, which is described in the book, and people said, and do you exaggerates? i was sitting in a lecture one day in between the drugs and fatigue, trying to keep up socially, intellectually, and academically, i just lost the ability to process information. words became nonsense that i cannot understand. i could not understand what was being talked about. i ve lost the ability to read. i lost the ability to read. every essay that i had to write became a crossword puzzle i could not complete. it really was a matter of months after this break down before i could carry on as a student. in the meantime, i made up my way through and hit and dodged. and hid and dodged my way through. how long before you recover? i got a job restocking books. we had a break every half hour, and we could sit down and read for five minutes. between reading the dictionary, put the abc dictionary reading that we sometimes joke about and reading in this library over the summer, i got traction again mentally. it was a big slide. in the end, how did you finish one york/ finish in your class? i grant you dated graduated summa cum laude. that designation was based on my performance in my senior thesis, which is a collection of 13 poems. it was exactly 13 pages long. i remember a teacher saying it is a bit slim, is it not? because those poems were getting good grades, i got him a very high designation as a graduate. i prevailed in the end, and i think i always knew that i would because i was so desperate to, but the knocks along the way worker found. have you been back? i was back once about two years ago as i was finishing the book. it was an astonishing experience. in a year since princeton they have received massive debts gifts. a guy named peter the west has given 100 million or more dollars to the arts center. they have built, without having any more students, these massive buildings in praise of these donors. the campus is that much more splendid and imposing, yet there are the still yet there is still the same amount as students. i am a little appalled by the nature of princeton s physical plan, compared to the ongoing nature of of its academic mission, which is at somewhat the same level. these places remind me of modern cathedrals. they are getting larger and larger, but their presence in society and their virtues that they are adding to our society has not grown in proportion. our guest has been walter kirn. thank you for joining us. thank you very much. for a dvd copy call the number listed below. for free transcripts is this s visit put us on the web. visit us on the web. this is c-span. up next, prime minister s question. gordon brown talks about government spending and unemployment. another look at president obama s first months as president. later, the president s fourth of july remarks. tomorrow on washington journal, david drucker looks at the congressional week ahead. california congressman henry waxman talks about his book. washington journal live at 7:00 a.m. eastern on c-span. how is c-span funded? big u.s. government. i do not know. i think some of it is government raised. the public funding. probably donations. i am going to say from me, from my tax dollars. how is c-span funded? 30 years ago. it is created by cable companies. no government money. i am sure many have showed my deep disappointment. disappointment in the manner of which legitimate demonstrations are being suppressed. disappointment that the iranian government has expelled several of our diplomats. this action is unjustified and unacceptable.